What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

El Greco

Summer worshipper
Joined
Nov 11, 2003
Messages
17,760
As we grow older and leave adolescence far behind [sad], we also inevitably adopt a more skeptic view towards love. We will usually not fall in love anymore with a girl at first sight, or at least will not fantasize too hard about her ;) Women will look for a little more in a man than beautiful blue eyes (could it be a beautiful black wallet ?)

But I have noticed that many people never completely escape love woo-woo-ism, even if they are fully rational in every other aspect of their lives. Why do we love the ones we love ? Why are we attracted to certain people ? What exactly is "love" ? Why do so many people fail to understand the underlying mechanisms of love and treat it almost like magic ?

While I can't provide positive answers to the above questions, I think that the following factors affect our "loving" brain cells:

  • The Looks. Duh. Beautiful men and women will find love more easily. It's really easier to be loved if you look like Brad Pitt than if you look like a Hobbit. Duh. Sometimes, especially for women, good looks is all they need to attract almost any man they fancy. We all want beautiful people around us. We also like beautiful cars, furniture, clothes etc. It's a matter of aesthetics.
  • Money, power and stuff like that. Men and women alike, are impressed by the prospect of a luxurious life. It is also very hard to isolate the person we love from his/her belongings, since the stuff we own immensely affects our own character; our self-confidence, our attitude, our anxiety levels etc.
  • Similarity. People tend to like others if they are alike them. Similar interests, common ways of expressing, similar language and body language, socio- cultural- economic level... when we find a match for all these, we tend to look at the other person as our own extension, as an acknowledgement of our own qualities.
  • Insecurities. IMO, the number 1 reason people stay together and sometimes "fake" love. It can be emotional insecurity (I need to love and be loved), social insecurity (all my friends are married), financial insecurity (s/he makes more money than I do), gene insecurity (I want to have children and raise them in a family), sexual insecurity (duh), fear of the unknown (what will happen if I have a divorce ? will I find a better one ?)

So, do you think there really is any "chemistry" or anything "magical" in love ? Don't tell me about exceptions that just corroborate the rules. Do you think it is possible for a beautiful, healthy, adorable, rich, clever male to love a disfigured, sick, poor and apish vixen ?

And, if you agree with the above, do you also share my observation that many people tend to find "magic" in love and consider "unexplained" many things that are actually perfectly explainable ? Are you able to discern the mechanisms that make you fall in love or are you a good skeptic only as far as the others are concerned ?
 
El Greco said:

So, do you think there really is any "chemistry" or anything "magical" in love ? Don't tell me about exceptions that just corroborate the rules. Do you think it is possible for a beautiful, healthy, adorable, rich, clever male to love a disfigured, sick, poor and apish vixen ?
Chemistry? You bet. Her's a thread on Love and Dopamine.

You know what they say; "Love is a many-splintered thong. Or at least some times it feels that painful."
 
I think love is the one thing that should remain firmly in the realm of the woo-woo.

I dont want science taking away the magic of romance.
 
Love is something that cannot be scientifically quantified or qualified. It's purely subjective, like happiness. Since no scientific explanations work, I suppose the only ones left are "woo-woo".
 
"Science cannot possibly explain X".
" I do not want science to explain X".

Sorry guys, but you're coming across as woowoos. Just because science can explain X does not mean that X is no longer wonderful and amazing.

Fill in the X.
 
arcticpenguin said:
"Science cannot possibly explain X".
" I do not want science to explain X".

Sorry guys, but you're coming across as woowoos. Just because science can explain X does not mean that X is no longer wonderful and amazing.

Fill in the X.

I don't think it has anything to do with wanting science to explain love; it just can't - or hasn't been able to yet, anyway. Oh sure, science can record the physiological effects of this or that emotion, but emotions themselves seem to be complete mysteries.

In point of fact, if science came out and said "People fall in love for this reason", I don't think it would detract from the all-around coolness of love.
 
When I saw the thread title for a moment I believed that Kenneth returned :)

Even if love is mere chemistry I do not care. It's still a great thing.

Do you think it is possible for a beautiful, healthy, adorable, rich, clever male to love a disfigured, sick, poor and apish vixen ?

Yes. Because the vixen as described above might have something that this beautiful, healthy bla bla bla male desperately wants but he can't find anywhere else but in her.
 
El Greco said:
As we grow older and leave adolescence far behind [sad], we also inevitably adopt a more skeptic view towards love. We will usually not fall in love anymore with a girl at first sight, or at least will not fantasize too hard about her ;) Women will look for a little more in a man than beautiful blue eyes (could it be a beautiful black wallet ?)

But I have noticed that many people never completely escape love woo-woo-ism, even if they are fully rational in every other aspect of their lives. Why do we love the ones we love ? Why are we attracted to certain people ? What exactly is "love" ? Why do so many people fail to understand the underlying mechanisms of love and treat it almost like magic ?

While I can't provide positive answers to the above questions, I think that the following factors affect our "loving" brain cells:

  • The Looks. Duh. Beautiful men and women will find love more easily. It's really easier to be loved if you look like Brad Pitt than if you look like a Hobbit. Duh. Sometimes, especially for women, good looks is all they need to attract almost any man they fancy. We all want beautiful people around us. We also like beautiful cars, furniture, clothes etc. It's a matter of aesthetics.
  • Money, power and stuff like that. Men and women alike, are impressed by the prospect of a luxurious life. It is also very hard to isolate the person we love from his/her belongings, since the stuff we own immensely affects our own character; our self-confidence, our attitude, our anxiety levels etc.
  • Similarity. People tend to like others if they are alike them. Similar interests, common ways of expressing, similar language and body language, socio- cultural- economic level... when we find a match for all these, we tend to look at the other person as our own extension, as an acknowledgement of our own qualities.
  • Insecurities. IMO, the number 1 reason people stay together and sometimes "fake" love. It can be emotional insecurity (I need to love and be loved), social insecurity (all my friends are married), financial insecurity (s/he makes more money than I do), gene insecurity (I want to have children and raise them in a family), sexual insecurity (duh), fear of the unknown (what will happen if I have a divorce ? will I find a better one ?)

So, do you think there really is any "chemistry" or anything "magical" in love ? Don't tell me about exceptions that just corroborate the rules. Do you think it is possible for a beautiful, healthy, adorable, rich, clever male to love a disfigured, sick, poor and apish vixen ?

And, if you agree with the above, do you also share my observation that many people tend to find "magic" in love and consider "unexplained" many things that are actually perfectly explainable ? Are you able to discern the mechanisms that make you fall in love or are you a good skeptic only as far as the others are concerned ?

First of all there is only one type of love. I do not distinguish "romantic love" from other types of love.

Secondly, love has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with chemistry, or indeed any physical process. Such physical processes merely inhibit or allow the feeling of love.

Thirdly, love is not an illusion.

True love is a complete and total identification with another person. A complete empathy with their very being. An infinite appreciation of their intrinsic essence. A melding of 2 minds into one.
 
Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Interesting Ian said:


First of all there is only one type of love. I do not distinguish "romantic love" from other types of love.

You don't recognize "filial love" as being any different?
 
Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Joshua Korosi said:


You don't recognize "filial love" as being any different?

Not if you understand what the word love means.
 
Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Interesting Ian said:


First of all there is only one type of love. I do not distinguish "romantic love" from other types of love.

I wouldn't agree with that. I love my children, I love my grandmother, I love my best friend. None of these are the same thing. I wouldn't consider having sex with any of them, for example. I don't feel for them the same way I feel for my wife or even each other. They really do feel to me like very different emotions taht all get lumped together under the name "love"

Secondly, love has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with chemistry, or indeed any physical process. Such physical processes merely inhibit or allow the feeling of love.

I guess that would depend on whether you are a materialist or not;) However I am a materialist and knowing that my love for my wife is the product of chemical reactions in my brain doesn't diminish my feelings for her one bit, nor does it lessen my enjoyment of them.

Thirdly, love is not an illusion.

True love is a complete and total identification with another person. A complete empathy with their very being. An infinite appreciation of their intrinsic essence. A melding of 2 minds into one.

That is a fine concept for a poet. But if you want to look at love in a scientific light it doesn't work, primarally because it means nothing in a scientific sense.
 
Joshua Korosi said:
Love is something that cannot be scientifically quantified or qualified. It's purely subjective, like happiness. Since no scientific explanations work, I suppose the only ones left are "woo-woo".
Love, just as everything else we experience, is pure brain chemistry.
 
Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Nyarlathotep said:
First of all there is only one type of love. I do not distinguish "romantic love" from other types of love.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



I wouldn't agree with that. I love my children, I love my grandmother, I love my best friend. None of these are the same thing. I wouldn't consider having sex with any of them, for example.

Sexual attraction does not constitute part of the essence of love. One can be sexually attracted to someone without loving them, and obviously love someone and not be sexually attracted towards them. But of course they can occur together as in romantic love where they supplement and complement each other.

I don't feel for them the same way I feel for my wife

Well, I expect you have some sexual attraction for your wife.

or even each other. They really do feel to me like very different emotions taht all get lumped together under the name "love"

I agree that even if the word love is not poorly defined, a lot of people simply just use the word to describe any sort of sexual attraction. I don't, and I think that love is incredibly rare. People like each other, appreciate each other, care about each other, but love involves more than that (and no I'm not talking about sexual attraction! LOL).

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Secondly, love has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with chemistry, or indeed any physical process. Such physical processes merely inhibit or allow the feeling of love.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



I guess that would depend on whether you are a materialist or not However I am a materialist and knowing that my love for my wife is the product of chemical reactions in my brain doesn't diminish my feelings for her one bit, nor does it lessen my enjoyment of them.


quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thirdly, love is not an illusion.

True love is a complete and total identification with another person. A complete empathy with their very being. An infinite appreciation of their intrinsic essence. A melding of 2 minds into one.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



That is a fine concept for a poet.

Are you saying my definition is incorrect?

But if you want to look at love in a scientific light it doesn't work, primarally because it means nothing in a scientific sense.

Whether we want to or not, we can't look at love in a scientific sense anymore than any other aspect of consciousness. And I care less than nothing at all that it means nothing in a scientific sense.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Interesting Ian said:

Are you saying my definition is incorrect?


I am not saying it is incorrect as much I am saying it is imprecise. I think love is a very hard thing to define because it invariably means different things to different people. It also means different things in different contexts. so defining it is rather like trying to catch a buzzing fly with a pair of chopsticks, it's not impossible, but it's incredibly difficult and the target keeps moving.

Your definition is fine, I think, for MOST situations and people. However I took the discussion to boil down to: Is love "woo-woo" (original posters words, not mine, I don't like the term) concept or not. In my opinion, I think it requires a more....concrete definition than you gave.
 
Talk to newlyweds and they will tell you how in love they are. Talk to a couple who have been married for 30+ years and they'll tell you how they've merely put up with each other.

Love is a silly, temporary, fickle thing. Its basis in biology is undeniable.

Romance is a lie. Because romance is about what life isn't like. Romance is pretending, for a time, that your partner is perfect, and that all is well with the world.

In reality, it is no different from a male seahorse vibrating in front of the female, or the bright plumage and strange noises and dances of various birds. That is romance. Nothing more than an attempt at getting an interest to mate with you.

To quote Callisto, "Love is nature's trick to get you to reproduce."

Strangely enough, I'm a romantic. I just acknowledge it as a lie. As smoke and mirrors. But oh, what a pleasurable lie it is...
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Interesting Ian:
Sexual attraction does not constitute part of the essence of love.
Of course it does. The probleming, dear Ian, is that the term "love" is overloaded. In one definition, that between two mates, sexual desire is obviously a large component.
One can be sexually attracted to someone without loving them, and obviously love someone and not be sexually attracted towards them. But of course they can occur together as in romantic love where they supplement and complement each other.
See above.
I agree that even if the word love is not poorly defined, a lot of people simply just use the word to describe any sort of sexual attraction. I don't, and I think that love is incredibly rare. People like each other, appreciate each other, care about each other, but love involves more than that (and no I'm not talking about sexual attraction! LOL).
The term "love" has two major branches. One branch very much includes sexual attraction, the other doesn't.
Are you saying my definition is incorrect?
Not so much incorrect, just limited. In the English language, "love" means many things.
Whether we want to or not, we can't look at love in a scientific sense anymore than any other aspect of consciousness. And I care less than nothing at all that it means nothing in a scientific sense.
Of course we can look at love in the scientific sense. Love is pure science.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Nyarlathotep said:
However I took the discussion to boil down to: Is love "woo-woo" (original posters words, not mine, I don't like the term)

Original poster's words were completely different: I spoke about woo-woo around love, surrounding love, I didn't say that love itself is woo-woo.

...and original poster's observations seem to get confirmed:

It looks like the "whys" and "hows" of our love are a taboo even for this forum!

Is it only me who (at last) can (more or less) identify my motives, reasons, insecurities etc behind my love for a woman ?

These things I read here remind me of a religious forum! "Love" is magic, "love" is inexplicable, "love" is mysterious! Beware skeptics - stay away from "love"! And some of you may be insinuating that dissecting "love" means that "I feel less" ??? The same way that theists look down on atheists as less moral ?

Also, the original question didn't have the meaning of whether love is a hormonal or chemical function. Of course it is, although perhaps we will never be able to understand it fully at the molecular level. I just meant that an outer observer can use pure common sense in order to justify why we love the people we love. But many people dispute this, and seem to believe that there is indeed something "magical" about it.

Ok, how many of you can you prove me wrong ? How many have completely ignored the factors I presented above and loved a person of the opposite sex just for his/her character and "aura" ignoring any possible objective criteria that would deem this match doomed ?

Some of you say that love is inexplicable, but I bet I wouldn't be surprised at all by your selection of mate...

(But such posts could be justified if your other halves are over your shoulder while you are reading this :D)
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

El Greco said:


Original poster's words were completely different: I spoke about woo-woo around love, surrounding love, I didn't say that love itself is woo-woo.

...and original poster's observations seem to get confirmed:

It looks like the "whys" and "hows" of our love are a taboo even for this forum!

Is it only me who (at last) can (more or less) identify my motives, reasons, insecurities etc behind my love for a woman ?

These things I read here remind me of a religious forum! "Love" is magic, "love" is inexplicable, "love" is mysterious! Beware skeptics - stay away from "love"! And some of you may be insinuating that dissecting "love" means that "I feel less" ??? The same way that theists look down on atheists as less moral ?

Also, the original question didn't have the meaning of whether love is a hormonal or chemical function. Of course it is, although perhaps we will never be able to understand it fully at the molecular level. I just meant that an outer observer can use pure common sense in order to justify why we love the people we love. But many people dispute this, and seem to believe that there is indeed something "magical" about it.

Ok, how many of you can you prove me wrong ? How many have completely ignored the factors I presented above and loved a person of the opposite sex just for his/her character and "aura" ignoring any possible objective criteria that would deem this match doomed ?

Some of you say that love is inexplicable, but I bet I wouldn't be surprised at all by your selection of mate...

(But such posts could be justified if your other halves are over your shoulder while you are reading this :D)

Sorry, misunderstood you. That is what I get for trying to read the forum and monitor something else at work at the same time.

As for love being inexplicable, I don't know if you werer referring to my comment, but that's not exactly what I said either. I said that it means different things to different people. Even if you eliminate all of the other forms of love (love of family, love of friends, love of country, etc.) and concentrate only on love between "significant others", that still covers a lot of ground. Some will define it along the lines of pure sexual attraction, some on intellectual compatability. Most will pick something somewhere between those two. I don't think it means the same thing to any two people.

I think your list is broad enough that it
does cover most of the reasons people get together, my point is that every single person will attach a different weight to each of those factors. They might not realize it but then again it is very difficult, maybe even impossible, to be objective about any situation (good or bad) that one is personally involved in. That include ones romantic life.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What is "Love" and why is there so much woo-woo around it ?

Nyarlathotep said:



I am not saying it is incorrect as much I am saying it is imprecise.



I think my definition is vastly more accurate then yours and other peoples.

I think love is a very hard thing to define because it invariably means different things to different people.
This was the point of my other post. I said it ought not to.

It also means different things in different contexts.

As I say it is unfortunate that people use it so loosely. That doesn't mean to say the concept itself has an indefinite meaning! :eek:

so defining it is rather like trying to catch a buzzing fly with a pair of chopsticks, it's not impossible, but it's incredibly difficult and the target keeps moving.

I see nothing particularly wrong with my definition.

Your definition is fine, I think, for MOST situations and people. However I took the discussion to boil down to: Is love "woo-woo" (original posters words, not mine, I don't like the term) concept or not. In my opinion, I think it requires a more....concrete definition than you gave.

Well why don't you give one then?
 
Hand Bent Spoon said:
Talk to newlyweds and they will tell you how in love they are. Talk to a couple who have been married for 30+ years and they'll tell you how they've merely put up with each other.



It doesn't really matter what they say, they are mistaken.

Love is a silly, temporary, fickle thing. Its basis in biology is undeniable.

It has absolutely nothing to do with the physical world. How could it?

Romance is a lie. Because romance is about what life isn't like. Romance is pretending, for a time, that your partner is perfect, and that all is well with the world.

In reality, it is no different from a male seahorse vibrating in front of the female, or the bright plumage and strange noises and dances of various birds. That is romance. Nothing more than an attempt at getting an interest to mate with you.

To quote Callisto, "Love is nature's trick to get you to reproduce."

And you and him confuse love with romance.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom