Your thoughts on the “Flight 93” smoke plume photo

What are your thoughts on the “Flight 93” smoke plume photo?

  • It’s real and shows a plume from UA 93 crashing that grew 700yd wide*, drifted 250yd* w/out dissip

    Votes: 39 86.7%
  • It’s real and originated from/near the crater, but wasn’t caused by UA 93 or a 757 crashing.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • It’s real, but wasn’t caused by UA 93 or a 757 crashing and originated far from the crater.

    Votes: 3 6.7%
  • It’s fake.

    Votes: 3 6.7%

  • Total voters
    45

Killtown

Banned
Joined
Aug 11, 2006
Messages
1,393
*If you disagree with these descriptions in this poll choice, please state how long the photo was taken after UA 93 allegedly crashed, how wide you think the plume was, how far it drifted if at all, and whether you think it dissipating much at the time the photo was taken.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

(Note, this thread is not about whether Flight 93 crashed in Shanksville, or not. It's is solely about this smoke plume photo.)


What are your thoughts about the famous "End of Serenity" photo that allegedly shows the smoke plume from Flight 93 crashing in Shanksville?





Before voting, please read the story behind this photo along with my analysis of this photo in which I’ve concluded that the smoke plume in this photo:


1) Did not come from a Boeing 757 (with approx. 5,500 gal of jet fuel on board at the time of impact) that was said to have crashed here:

crater_pl3.jpg

crater_stahl.jpg



but had to have originated closer to where the photo was taken. (See here because analysis contains copyrighted photo.)



2) The photo is fake.




.
 
Last edited:
I voted #1. I ignored all of the leading, opinonated part you added to option #1 to make it seem less credible, as I know your intention.

TAM:):):)
 
I'm asking the mods to combine this with Killtown's other thread with a poll about flight 93's smoke.

Please do not encourage Killtown's disgraceful behavior.
 
Yep, that's from the crash, no doubt at all. Oh, but maybe the federales pre-positioned a smoke bomb right where they'd crash the plane, right?
 
I voted #1. I ignored all of the leading, opinonated part you added to option #1 to make it seem less credible, as I know your intention.

I moved this to the top of the page because apparantely you missed it:

*If you disagree with these descriptions in this poll choice, please state how long the photo was taken after UA 93 allegedly crashed, how wide you think the plume was, how far it drifted if at all, and whether you think it dissipating much at the time the photo was taken.
 
EDIT: Apologies to Lisa S.

Please keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not resort to insults.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited:
I choose not to address the part of you rpost after the poll. The poll itself did not mention this. Your poll is misleading. Like any person voting, i have the right to vote which ever way I wish, without justifying my choice.

TAM
 
I choose not to address the part of you rpost after the poll. The poll itself did not mention this.
Yes it did, it was there. you just didn't read my post throughly (a problem if find with JREFers). But I moved it up to the top so it will be harder for you guys to say "well, I didn't notice it".

Btw, when you see a *, it means there is further description to that point which usually is mentioned of the same page.
 
Wow, I've heard of false dichotomies before, but this is the first false quadrology I've ever seen.

Now, let's just take one little look at one of your pieces of "evidence", shall we?

plume-drift.gif


Now let's go to Google Maps, and search on her address, 107 Osage Path Stoystown, PA, that you've so conviently provided.

Scale the sattelite image to the correct level, and look for the not-quite pie shaped bit of forrest (the bit underlined in your image). this is off to the left of her house, on my screen at least. I'll leave it as an exercise for the student to lay a piece of paper on their screen, to line up with her house and where the image was taken.

I see it as pretty well perfectly aligned with where you say the crash site was. No drifting or anything. So your "analysis" is complete crap.

Pretty much everything else I read was the same old "Let's question everything without using our brain and make up coincidences" crap you usually spew. Just as an example:

It's unclear when she came back home, but she never walked up the road beyond the horizon to see what she allegedly photographed. Instead, she just heard the sirens and went into the kitchen and put on a barbecue for the rescue crews as if she was anticipating the events. How was she able to cook for the crews with her electricity knocked out? Did it come back on by then? Did she just cook on a charcoal BBQ outside**? How did she even think to start cooking for the rescue crews and how did the crews know she was even cooking for them? Did she bring the food down to the rescuers, or did they stop by her house? Wouldn't some official group, such as the Red-Cross, come and feed the crews instead?

From this it's clear you've never actually met anyone from a small town, particularly during any sort of crisis. These people don't just sit around waiting for others to get things done, they pitch in and do it themselves. Just as a pro-Canadian, anti-bozo slap in the face, consider what the people of Gander, Newfoundland did on that day.

Now piss off, will you?

**BTW, yes, some sort of BBQ, which you'd know if you'd ever read your own fricken page!
 
ok, whatever you say. I still have the right to answer the poll as I wish, without justifying my answer.

Your poll might as well read:

It’s real and shows a plume from UA 93 crashing, but the plume does not look like what I think it should look like, so there is something wrong with it.

It’s real and originated from/near the crater, but wasn’t caused by UA 93 or a 757 crashing.

It’s real, but wasn’t caused by UA 93 or a 757 crashing and originated far from the crater.

It’s fake.

TAM
 



I know, i know it, i know what the plume is!

Since my daily job is to work with Photoshop
and 3d-Software i´m pretty sure it was a
huge Giant doing this:

whacky103.gif


​

​

​
 
We've already established that Killtown's argument essentially is based on assuming a plane crash at 450mph acts approximately equal to an egg dropping and breaking.

He honestly believes that's a reasonable comparison to make.

That's all that needs to be said, really.
 
We've already established that Killtown's argument essentially is based on assuming a plane crash at 450mph acts approximately equal to an egg dropping and breaking.

He honestly believes that's a reasonable comparison to make.

That's all that needs to be said, really.

Yeah, but those bits I explained just stood out as so dumb I had to say something. Bad habit, I know :)
 
1) her address, 107 Osage Path Stoystown, PA, that you've so conviently provided.

2) Scale the sattelite image to the correct level, and look for the not-quite pie shaped bit of forrest (the bit underlined in your image). this is off to the left of her house, on my screen at least. I'll leave it as an exercise for the student to lay a piece of paper on their screen, to line up with her house and where the image was taken.

I see it as pretty well perfectly aligned with where you say the crash site was. No drifting or anything. So your "analysis" is complete crap.
1) Thanks, glad some one appreciates that I make things convienent for people.

2) If I recall correctly, lost of JREFers think it drifted.

Why don't you draw up your analysis so we can compare?
 
Isn't there a thread for this fake photo BS theory already?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom