Asolepius
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Jul 5, 2004
- Messages
- 1,150
I just saw this new study. Can anyone comment on whether it's sound?
I just saw this new study. Can anyone comment on whether it's sound?
Wayne Jonas committed professional suicide a long time ago. You can read about some of it hereOh, I am accessing it from work, and my company has a licence. Well it's a valid reporting channel, and of course you cannot really rule out fraud, but in these circles, fraud is professional suicide, and in many countries punishable by law.
Hans
I don't know about the six others, but this one seems to merit the label well-designed. Whether it holds up to closer scrutiny is another matter.
It was not a large study, 100 rats, but enough to provide statistical significance. Blinding appears to be OK, assessment methods clear and objective. They made a number of initial studies on smaller groups and where blinding was questionable, but the final study seems OK.
Hans
I just saw this new study. Can anyone comment on whether it's sound?
Yes, Linda, that is among least informative abstracts I have ever seen. I also wonder about the choice of journal. If any homeopathy shows a quantitative effect, it should be in Nature (or another top publication) because it would overthrow known physical principles.There is no description of the control group. There is no description of how the rats were assigned to treatment or control. There is no description of what is meant by "homeopathic treatment". There is no mention of blinding. There is no description of how the various parameters were assessed. There is no description of how many comparisons in total were made and what adjustments were made to the level of significance to account for multiple comparisons.
Unless these issues are addressed, one cannot assume the study is sound. If you or anyone has access to the full text, then an assessment can be made.
Linda
I was actually surprised that there were so few, but there could always be more out there that the cite simply didn't know about. At least one of the studies were the diarrhea studies. I know some people have argued that the blinding procedures were too loose, but you probably know more about that than I do.
There is no description of the control group. There is no description of how the rats were assigned to treatment or control.
There is no description of what is meant by "homeopathic treatment".
There is no mention of blinding.
There is no description of how the various parameters were assessed.
There is no description of how many comparisons in total were made and what adjustments were made to the level of significance to account for multiple comparisons.
Controls were treated with blank water potentized to the same level as the remedies. 100 rats were randomized into two groups (so I assume appr. 50 in each).Thank you. Since you have access, can you answer some other questions?
How were the controls treated and how were they assigned (i.e. the randomization method)? What was the homeopathic treatment (including the degree of dilution)? How many comparison were made (they list seven in vivo outcomes)? And who was blinded (e.g. was a placebo used)?
ETA: I forgot to ask. Were the percentages given relative or absolute reductions?
Linda
Ouch!Wayne Jonas committed professional suicide a long time ago. You can read about some of it here
http://www.quackwatch.org/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/Hearing/gorski2.html