So is the Stock Market BS or what?

Is the Stock Market just a crapshoot, or a form of legalized gambling?

Neither.

Gambling is a zero-sum game. The stock market is not. It's quite easy to make money in the stock market, because the average market return has historically been quite good. The trick is 1) it takes time, 2) it's not risk-free, especially in the short term, and 3) while matching the market return is easy (index funds), beating the market is hard, and you can loose a whole lot of money trying.
 
There’s a secret to the market. Here it is; buy low, sell high.

[ALI G]Is it always a good idea to sell high?

Because this one time, when me was high, I sold me car for, like, 24 chicken nuggets.[/ALI G]
 
Gambling is a zero-sum game. The stock market is not. It's quite easy to make money in the stock market, because the average market return has historically been quite good. The trick is 1) it takes time, 2) it's not risk-free, especially in the short term, and 3) while matching the market return is easy (index funds), beating the market is hard, and you can loose a whole lot of money trying.

Agreed. Day trading is economic suicide but I believe that if you take any 10 year period since 1945 the return on common stock is 10% a year, which is excellent compared to simple bank savings.
 
No more than money is. Money has no intrinsic value. It's little pieces of paper or metal, or sometimes even just bits in a computer somewhere. We put a value on it, by accepting some amount for work we do, and paying some amount for some item or service we want. I see no intrinsic difference between that and financing the debt of some corporation that wants to have more money to develop their business by accepting a small portion of ownership as collateral for it. If the company does well, it will be worth more later, if not, it may become worthless and the money I paid for it will be gone. Most companies that are competently run do OK in the medium long term, so by and large it's a good investment.
 
Neither, although many people treat it as one, or the other, or both. Also, it doesn't behave the way it ought to, by which I mean the buy and sell decisions of the stockholders is not based on sound economic principles, although it could be.

For years, I read books with titles like "How to Buy Stocks" and "How to Make Money in the Stock Market". The stuff in them made no sense whatsoever to me, and I avoided the market except for checking "stocks" in one of my options in a 401k plan.

Then, I read a new book. It was about Corporate Finance. (I think it was the Barron's simplified version, widely available in bookstores.) Corporate Finance books talk about the stock market from the perspective of people who issue stock, i.e. the company that puts its stock up for sale.

Suddenly, it all made sense. I got into the market and although I'm not rich, I've been buying and selling since 1998, and I have beaten the S&P 500 by 1.5 percentage points annually, which puts me ahead of almost all mutual fund managers.

ETA: For those who aren't willing to stomach books on corporate finance, I think Smart Money is the best of the mass market advice periodicals available. Unlike others, in 2000 it was saying that the market was out of control and certainly going to dive. It was also saying that mutual fund managers were ripping off investors, and corporate CEO pay was ridiculous, and suggested stockholders avoid shoveling money into companies that were just going to hand it over to an overpaid CEO and his BOD cronies.
 
Last edited:
Yes, of course the stock market is a form of gambling. It involves putting money into a 'machine' which increases or decreases the amount of money in a stochastic fashion.

That doesn't mean you can't make money from it. As Ziggurat said, it is not a zero-sum game (but I disagree that that means it isn't gambling. The zero-sum concept is not AFAIK part of the definition of the word 'gambling'). And as others have pointed out, the stock market tends to offer a return of about 10% per year, over the loooong term (ie averaged over several years, encompassing all the various booms and busts). So it's a very smart form of gambling.

(well the 'investing' rather than 'trading' form, as was also pointed out)
 
And as others have pointed out, the stock market tends to offer a return of about 10% per year, over the loooong term (ie averaged over several years, encompassing all the various booms and busts).

The "stock market" doesn't return 10% annually. The DJIA does. (actually, I think it's a bit closer to 12%, but I could be wrong)
 
Actually, the market as a whole averages about 3%. Check the "Whilshire Index", which is the list of all 7,000 stocks listed in America. Oh, everybody has heard of most of the stocks in the Dow Jones, but that is only 100 of the largest companies.

What drives the constant upwards spiral? Pension funds. Everyday, the millions of American workers give money to their pension funds. It HAS to be invested. Plus forign investers- Saudi oil money? The US market does better than anybody. Where else can you put billions of dollars? So that demand drives the prices up- constantly. So everybody else puts thier money in the market too. It keeps going up, like home prices. Good investment, in what is basically a Ponzi scheme with no particular Ponzi.

My guess is that an upsurge in retirement will end the market growth, as would a permanent lessening of the work force.

Of course, the current housing market set back will bring more dollars to the stock market, because where else can we put our billions of investment capital?

Personally, I keep my fortune buried in a coffee can in the garden.
 
It's simple. When you buy a stock, you are buying a piece of a company. If the company does well, so will your stock (over time). There is all kinds of irrational behavior over the short term, so price at any given moment may not be an indicator of the business' intrinsic value.

So, to take casebro's objection. If stock prices are currently high compared to the business' intrinsic worth, certainly prices will fall if retirement money falls off. But then prices will fall, prices will become attractive, and that will attract foreign investment.

If you are buying either to try to ride a short term gain, or because you think you can predict the stock market (no one has ever shown any evidence of being able to do either), then you are gambling. If you are buying high quality companies at a fair price with the intention of owning them for years to decades, then it is not a gamble. The latter is called Value investing - look in to Graham and Dodd, Warren Buffett, Searle, etc.

Are prices high or low right now? I won't tell you, but I suggest looking at the P/E ratio of the stock market (use a broad index, not DJIA) and dividends, and decide whether you would buy a single company with those numbers, assuming it is fundamentally sound. If your answer is yes, go ahead and put your money in some index funds. If your answer is no, look to other methods to invest than index funds.


ETA: my post implies I am unfamiliar with Efficient Market Theory and/or Malkiel's random walk theory. I am familiar with both, I just don't buy them. If you are seriously interested in this topic, you owe it to yourself to study both and come to your own conclusions.
 
Last edited:
ETA: my post implies I am unfamiliar with Efficient Market Theory and/or Malkiel's random walk theory. I am familiar with both, I just don't buy them. If you are seriously interested in this topic, you owe it to yourself to study both and come to your own conclusions.

Or better yet, buy a share of Berkshire and pay a visit to Omaha. (as I will be doing in 2 weeks)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom