International Skeptics Forum

International Skeptics Forum (https://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/forumindex.php)
-   Social Issues & Current Events (https://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=82)
-   -   (Ed) OR Professor objects to white students being excluded from campus for Day of Absence (https://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=320133)

Emily's Cat 1st June 2017 02:02 PM

OR Professor objects to white students being excluded from campus for Day of Absence
 
I'm a bit surprised this hasn't already shown up on ISF, so I'll go ahead and contribute.

Here's the scenario: A professor at Evergreen University in Oregon protested a policy shift for the campus' annual "Day of Absence". Historically, the Day of Absence has seen minority students and faculty voluntarily absent themselves from campus on that day, in order to demonstrate the value of their contributions and presence at school. This year, however, it was proposed that instead of people of color choosing to stay home... they should instead insist that white people shouldn't be allowed to come to school. The professor, Bret Weinstein, protested this proposal as a move in the wrong direction:

Quote:

"There is a huge difference between a group or coalition deciding to voluntarily absent themselves from a shared space in order to highlight their vital and underappreciated roles (the theme of the Douglas Turner Ward play Day of Absence, as well as the recent Women's Day walkout), and a group encouraging another group to go away," Weinstein wrote. "The first is a forceful call to consciousness, which is, of course, crippling to the logic of oppression. The second is a show of force, and an act of oppression in and of itself."
As a result of his email, Professor Weinstein has since been subjected to verbal abuse and threats. Police have suggested that he refrain from coming to campus at present, as they cannot guarantee his safety.

Article:
https://www.insidehighered.com/news/...ring-professor

Video of the student objection outside of Professor Weinstein's office:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qCZNCmMFwcI

Personally, I agree with Professor Weinstein. I am fully supportive of a day of absence, and if it were deemed appropriate by those involved I would happily absent myself in order to show support for that message. But I would be very offended if it were suggested that I not be allowed to come to campus on that day because of my skin color.

I am also struck by the complete lack of discourse being demonstrated by college students.

Ziggurat 1st June 2017 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Emily's Cat (Post 11864563)
Personally, I agree with Professor Weinstein. I am fully supportive of a day of absence,

I wouldn't be "fully supportive". I find such public demonstrations pretty pointless, regardless of the cause. But I wouldn't oppose or try to stop it either. But if I were a professor there, I wouldn't change my class schedule to accommodate it.

Quote:

I am also struck by the complete lack of discourse being demonstrated by college students.
I note you didn't say "surprised". You are right not to be.

applecorped 1st June 2017 02:18 PM

triggered

Emily's Cat 1st June 2017 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ziggurat (Post 11864594)
I wouldn't be "fully supportive". I find such public demonstrations pretty pointless, regardless of the cause. But I wouldn't oppose or try to stop it either. But if I were a professor there, I wouldn't change my class schedule to accommodate it.

I would be supportive, in part because I support the message, but also because I think this is an effective way to get that message conveyed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ziggurat (Post 11864594)
I note you didn't say "surprised". You are right not to be.

I would have been surprised several months ago. Today, not so much. I'm still appalled and saddened, but I'm not surprised anymore. Which is sad in and of itself.

madurobob 1st June 2017 02:44 PM

Isn't evergreen that hippy school with no grades and no real curriculum?

Imagine my surprise.

bytewizard 1st June 2017 02:49 PM

And the professor is a self proclaimed progressive. Ah, the progressive teacher/student relationship comes full circle.

Giz 1st June 2017 03:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Emily's Cat (Post 11864563)
I am also struck by the complete lack of discourse being demonstrated by college students.

Putting it mildly.

The students at Evergreen State sound as if they'd be happier at a Seminary than at an institution of rationalism and higher learning.

Shepherd 1st June 2017 03:14 PM

Ouch. Do you suppose someone finally realized that our minority "Day of Absence" was actually our secret white person "Day of Celebration"? I told you this couldn't last! ...and that even one of these slow minority types would eventually figure it out!

bytewizard 1st June 2017 03:15 PM

Almost all of the protesters were white and most of those look like they take full advantage of the college's lunch program. Put down the fork and learn to read. What was racist in the Professor's letter?

Jodie 1st June 2017 03:17 PM

I'ld enjoy the day off and go soak in a hot spring somewhere.

TragicMonkey 1st June 2017 03:45 PM

Exclusion from a day of absence? How many people are going to show up by mistake just because of the confusion surrounding a double negative?

mgidm86 1st June 2017 03:45 PM

I'm sure the school could never survive without multiculturalism. The whole idea is stupid - A Day Of Absence, A Day Without Mexicans. How about a day without preachy asswipes? Just one day.

Oh thank you great school for showing me the errors of my ways! We would not be able to survive without your incredible progressive wisdom! Your moral superiority is inspiring! Now blow me.

Joe Random 1st June 2017 04:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bytewizard (Post 11864691)
Almost all of the protesters were white and most of those look like they take full advantage of the college's lunch program. Put down the fork and learn to read. What was racist in the Professor's letter?

There's a pic of the letter in this article : https://mic.com/articles/178730/ever...nce#.9Mpr2sRzy

Graham2001 1st June 2017 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bytewizard (Post 11864691)
What was racist in the Professor's letter?

The Oregonian newspaper has published the full set of emails, they can be read in PDF form in this article:

Quote:

The News Tribune and The Olympian have obtained copies of emails written by an Evergreen State College professor who sparked a campus backlash and wider debate by criticizing a race-based event at the school.

Some students at the liberal college called for Bret Weinstein to be fired after he questioned the tactics of the people promoting the school’s annual Day of Absence.

http://www.theolympian.com/news/poli...153826004.html


The rest of their coverage is well worth reading as well.

Ziggurat 1st June 2017 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shepherd (Post 11864690)
Ouch. Do you suppose someone finally realized that our minority "Day of Absence" was actually our secret white person "Day of Celebration"? I told you this couldn't last! ...and that even one of these slow minority types would eventually figure it out!

Eddie Murphy figured it out years ago.

YouTube Video This video is not hosted by the ISF. The ISF can not be held responsible for the suitability or legality of this material. By clicking the link below you agree to view content from an external website.
I AGREE

baron 2nd June 2017 01:55 AM

Anybody giving credence to any of this needs their head examined. A Day of Absence! **** off. If the world had an Eternity of Absence from these PC idiots it would be a better place.

Graham2001 2nd June 2017 05:26 AM

For anyone who is interested, this video comes from one of the Alt-Right channels I keep an eye on, it includes a video from the students protest. Presented to show how the story is playing amongst the Alt-Right.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amvwQptFwXM

uke2se 2nd June 2017 06:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham2001 (Post 11865575)
For anyone who is interested, this video comes from one of the Alt-Right channels I keep an eye on, it includes a video from the students protest. Presented to show how the story is playing amongst the Alt-Right.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amvwQptFwXM

Why would anyone want to watch that? Could you summarize it in your own words instead?

baron 2nd June 2017 06:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham2001 (Post 11865575)
For anyone who is interested, this video comes from one of the Alt-Right channels I keep an eye on, it includes a video from the students protest. Presented to show how the story is playing amongst the Alt-Right.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amvwQptFwXM

Are those two alt-right? Everything they said is not only common sense, it's anti-racist.

BStrong 2nd June 2017 06:52 AM

Between right wing idiots that believe any issue can be decided in their favor by using military force and the goof balls on that campus, we may well be doomed.

Bogative 2nd June 2017 07:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by baron (Post 11865645)
Are those two alt-right? Everything they said is not only common sense, it's anti-racist.


Anti-racism is the new racism.

Ziggurat 2nd June 2017 07:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Emily's Cat (Post 11864608)
I would be supportive, in part because I support the message, but also because I think this is an effective way to get that message conveyed.

I suspect we don't agree on what their message is. I believe the real message of the protests is not the nominal message, and their attempts to get this professor fired are not simply overzealous efforts in the cause of the nominal message but an integral part of the real message.

Quote:

I would have been surprised several months ago. Today, not so much. I'm still appalled and saddened, but I'm not surprised anymore. Which is sad in and of itself.
The movement in this direction has been going on a lot longer than several months. Remember Prof. Click from Missouri? That was well over a year ago.

Newtons Bit 2nd June 2017 08:26 AM

I tend to have sympathy for the professor in this story. But I can't seem to muster it this time. This insane ideology was shaped and molded by Weinstein and his fellow professors at Evergreen. They taught this ideology. Their students listened and believed it. This is a monster co-created by him. That it has turned on him now isn't sad, it's poetic justice.

Jodie 2nd June 2017 08:27 AM

Baron & Bogative- Do me a favor and post why you think that alt right video that was linked was either racist or anti-racist.

baron 2nd June 2017 08:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jodie (Post 11865825)
Baron & Bogative- Do me a favor and post why you think that alt right video that was linked was either racist or anti-racist.

It wasn't racist, it was anti-racist, and it was so because it criticised racism and divisiveness. Indeed, how else could it have come by the definition?

Chris_Halkides 2nd June 2017 08:30 AM

FIREing Weinstein
 
The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) has a thoughtful article on this incident. "Whatever you think of the content of Weinstein’s now infamous email, threatening a professor’s safety, driving his class off campus, and demanding his firing because of his protected speech should trouble anyone who cares about the free exchange of ideas. All the more troubling should be the fact that this isn’t the first time something like this has happened on campus, and, given the environment right now, it might not be the last."

If the students get ride of Professor Weinstein, do they plan to teach themselves biology? Do they want someone with less experience than he has teaching them?

Jodie 2nd June 2017 08:31 AM

I think something that people forget about is the legacy of PTSD that slavery leaves on a society or culture. Some of the things the guys said in the alt right video were accurate, some not. The college students protesting may have a point but shouting black power isn't appropriate. True anti-racism is people power. I see wrong on both sides.

Jodie 2nd June 2017 08:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by baron (Post 11865828)
It wasn't racist, it was anti-racist, and it was so because it criticized racism and divisiveness. Indeed, how else could it have come by the definition?

Because they stated that these children did not deserve an education because they were inciting racism based on something that happened to their ancestors. They completely ignored the cultural and psychological ramifications that slavery can induce. That's anti-people.

Jodie 2nd June 2017 08:41 AM

Here is an article that cites research or perspectives on the long term damages of slavery, specifically in the United States:

https://newrepublic.com/article/1223...lack-americans

Belz... 2nd June 2017 09:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Emily's Cat (Post 11864563)
I'm a bit surprised this hasn't already shown up on ISF, so I'll go ahead and contribute.

Here's the scenario: A professor at Evergreen University in Oregon protested a policy shift for the campus' annual "Day of Absence". Historically, the Day of Absence has seen minority students and faculty voluntarily absent themselves from campus on that day, in order to demonstrate the value of their contributions and presence at school.

Wow, what a bunch of drama queens.

Quote:

This year, however, it was proposed that instead of people of color choosing to stay home... they should instead insist that white people shouldn't be allowed to come to school.
In order to demonstrate the worthlessness of their contributions, I'm sure.

Quote:

As a result of his email, Professor Weinstein has since been subjected to verbal abuse and threats.
Of course he has. There's no justice in social justice.

Belz... 2nd June 2017 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jodie (Post 11865834)
I think something that people forget about is the legacy of PTSD that slavery leaves on a society or culture.

What in the blue hell are you babbling about? PTSD on society?

baron 2nd June 2017 09:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jodie (Post 11865845)
Because they stated that these children did not deserve an education because they were inciting racism based on something that happened to their ancestors. They completely ignored the cultural and psychological ramifications that slavery can induce. That's anti-people.

Slavery. Give me a break. These students are amongst the global top 1% in terms of privilege and opportunity, it's difficult to imagine a more privileged group, and what do they do with their advantage? Whine about how they're downtrodden because they can't exclude white people from their college, march around chanting racist slogans, vilify their very own teachers for no reason and attempt to destroy their careers, and generally act like the spoiled brats that they are. So yes, every one of them should be expelled and their university places given to deserving people of whatever ethnicity who would appreciate a thousand times over the opportunity to study in their place. The only downside is we'd have to listen to all the apologists claiming that the reason they were 'on the streets' is not because of their disgusting behaviour, but on account of all us nasty white racists who wouldn't give them a chance. Pass the tissues, it's all so sad.

Pterodactyl 2nd June 2017 09:28 AM

Just my opinion, but crap like this is exactly how middle class whites in America get driven to supporting conservatives (or even Trump) when they would otherwise have no inkling to do so.

Belz... 2nd June 2017 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pterodactyl (Post 11865949)
Just my opinion, but crap like this is exactly how middle class whites in America get driven to supporting conservatives (or even Trump) when they would otherwise have no inkling to do so.

BS. White middle-class Americans tend to support the GOP anyway. Do you have any evidence that this sort of nonsense, frustrating as it is, somehow converted them from one party to the other in large numbers?

Pterodactyl 2nd June 2017 09:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Argumemnon (Post 11865952)
BS. White middle-class Americans tend to support the GOP anyway. Do you have any evidence that this sort of nonsense, frustrating as it is, somehow converted them from one party to the other in large numbers?

No.
But I think this type of divisiveness has effects, and I dont know what otherwise could be the result. People who feel alienated tend to align themselves with people who, you know, don't alienate them.

Dr. Keith 2nd June 2017 09:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mgidm86 (Post 11864747)
I'm sure the school could never survive without multiculturalism. The whole idea is stupid - A Day Of Absence, A Day Without Mexicans. How about a day without preachy asswipes? Just one day.

Oh thank you great school for showing me the errors of my ways! We would not be able to survive without your incredible progressive wisdom! Your moral superiority is inspiring! Now blow me.

Moist?

If you can remember this other word for me, please let me know, but in a different thread.

Jodie 2nd June 2017 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Argumemnon (Post 11865924)
What in the blue hell are you babbling about? PTSD on society?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transgenerational_trauma

Repeated generational trauma, regardless of the cause, whether it's genocide or slavery, or even both, has lasting affects on a culture or race that isn't easily undone by signing an emancipation proclamation. This trauma was never addressed in the African American society so any problems with racism will never be resolved until that is addressed in treatment programs.


Now how this relates to the topic, the percentage of African Americans living in Washington state is small. The reason this whole situation happened was due to cultural insensitivity under the guise of a good cause. The last thing you want to ever do is accuse a hippy of being a hypocrite although they so often are. Nobody had a problem with this until they asked the white people to leave. I'm guessing Rashida is African American and it looks like it was her idea....LOLOLOL.

If they really want to stop racism, it stops with the assumptions that you make about people in general. You incorporate that into your everyday life, not set aside a day to think about it with like kind.

BStrong 2nd June 2017 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jodie (Post 11865834)
I think something that people forget about is the legacy of PTSD that slavery leaves on a society or culture. Some of the things the guys said in the alt right video were accurate, some not. The college students protesting may have a point but shouting black power isn't appropriate. True anti-racism is people power. I see wrong on both sides.

I have PTSD.

What you are referencing isn't PTSD.

What you describe is either a general sense of collective guilt for immoral actions and practices committed by our predecessors and the anger of individuals that feel their anger is properly directed at the ancestors of the individuals and society that committed those acts.

Point of fact.

The worst incident of lynching/mob violence based on race was committed on My predecessors, Sicilians in New Orleans:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/March_14,_1891_lynchings

The March 14, 1891 lynchings were a series of lynchings of eleven Italian Americans in New Orleans, Louisiana, for their alleged role in the murder of police chief David Hennessy. It was the largest mass lynching in U.S. history.[1][2][note 1]

The lynching took place the day after the trial of nine of the nineteen men indicted in the murder. Six of these defendants had been acquitted, and a mistrial had been declared for the remaining three because the jury failed to agree on their verdicts. Believing the jury had been bribed, a mob broke into the jail where the men were being held and killed eleven of them. The mob numbered in the thousands and included some of the city's most prominent citizens. American press coverage of the event was largely congratulatory, and those responsible for the lynching were never charged.

The incident had serious national repercussions. Italy cut off diplomatic relations with the United States, sparking rumors of war. Increased anti-Italian sentiment led to calls for restrictions on immigration. The word "Mafia" entered the American lexicon, and the stereotype of the Italian-American mafioso was firmly established in the popular imagination.


I heard about it often as a kid.

Beelzebuddy 2nd June 2017 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pterodactyl (Post 11865949)
Just my opinion, but crap like this is exactly how middle class whites in America get driven to supporting conservatives (or even Trump) when they would otherwise have no inkling to do so.

What exactly do you refer to with "crap?"

I don't disagree with you in theory, assuming that "crap like this" means "covering the stupid antics of one of the most insular liberal arts colleges as if it was the slightest bit representative of the nation as a whole." It's typical right-wing bias, where anything objectionable on the right is downplayed, but anything on the left is cause for mass hysteria.

Jodie 2nd June 2017 10:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by baron (Post 11865933)
Slavery. Give me a break. These students are amongst the global top 1% in terms of privilege and opportunity, it's difficult to imagine a more privileged group, and what do they do with their advantage? Whine about how they're downtrodden because they can't exclude white people from their college, march around chanting racist slogans, vilify their very own teachers for no reason and attempt to destroy their careers, and generally act like the spoiled brats that they are. So yes, every one of them should be expelled and their university places given to deserving people of whatever ethnicity who would appreciate a thousand times over the opportunity to study in their place. The only downside is we'd have to listen to all the apologists claiming that the reason they were 'on the streets' is not because of their disgusting behaviour, but on account of all us nasty white racists who wouldn't give them a chance. Pass the tissues, it's all so sad.

What these young people are doing is wrong but transgenerational trauma or multigeneraltional PTSD related to persecution of a culture crosses all socioeconomic classes. They aren't acting like spoiled brats, they are venting rage that never had a voice before because we are told to get over it, stiff upper lip, and move on. There is a better way to do that, Martin Luther King had it right. So it wasn't a problem to ask all of the brown people to take a day of absence but when white people were asked to leave it caused a problem, see the hypocrisy? It works both ways.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 07:51 PM.

Powered by vBulletin. Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
© 2015-24, TribeTech AB. All Rights Reserved.