Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

Bob001

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Dec 21, 2006
Messages
16,613
Location
US of A
The previous thread was getting slow and generating duplicates, so here is a continuation. As is usual the split point was arbitrary and participants can copy and paste from the previous thread to address points raised therein.
Posted By: Agatha







The Times has outlined the winners of the wealthcare bill.

I don't understand the GOP's intense desire to pass this bill since the voters they added to win in November are going to be harmed the most by it.

You're kidding, right? Their goal is to reduce taxes. They are against the basic idea of providing government services, and they will cut as much as they can wherever they can. Ryan wants to cut Medicare and Social Security, which have long been considered practically sacrosanct.

And if poor whites get hurt, they will blame blacks, immigrants, "welfare," "foreign aid," etc., never Trump or the Repubs.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For clarity : are the AHA and the expansion of Medicare separate issues? I get that impression from Stacko's post



I had assumed they were a package.

Let's just note that the subject is Medicaid, not Medicare. The ACA (Obamacare) expanded Medicaid in the states that chose to accept it; the AHCA wants to reduce funding and eligibility.
 
An interesting concept, it's not OK to fine you for not carrying health insurance, as an incentive.

But it is OK to threaten you with not being able to get insurance for 6 months as an incentive.

I’m also not clear on implementation. When does the waiting period start? If you don’t have insurance for 2 years does that count as the waiting period, if so I don’t see how it helps solve the problem of people not buying insurance until they are already sick.

Is it a case of you having to buy insurance but not be eligible to avail yourself of it for 6 months? That could be more helpful, or maybe not if it means your condition advances and becomes more expensive to treat while you sit on an un-triaged waiting list. Also, how much does requiring people to pay for insurance they are not allowed to use different than a tax on people who opt out of insurance?
 
I’m also not clear on implementation. When does the waiting period start? If you don’t have insurance for 2 years does that count as the waiting period, if so I don’t see how it helps solve the problem of people not buying insurance until they are already sick.

Is it a case of you having to buy insurance but not be eligible to avail yourself of it for 6 months? That could be more helpful, or maybe not if it means your condition advances and becomes more expensive to treat while you sit on an un-triaged waiting list. Also, how much does requiring people to pay for insurance they are not allowed to use different than a tax on people who opt out of insurance?

The GOP just handed the Dems their "death panel". They should start referring to the GOP plan as the Affordable Death Care Act.
 
I’m also not clear on implementation. When does the waiting period start? If you don’t have insurance for 2 years does that count as the waiting period, if so I don’t see how it helps solve the problem of people not buying insurance until they are already sick.

Is it a case of you having to buy insurance but not be eligible to avail yourself of it for 6 months? That could be more helpful, or maybe not if it means your condition advances and becomes more expensive to treat while you sit on an un-triaged waiting list. Also, how much does requiring people to pay for insurance they are not allowed to use different than a tax on people who opt out of insurance?

The wording for the amendment hasn't been released yet that I can find. It sounds like it starts when you start looking for insurance. Something along the lines of, "Insurers can impose a six-month waiting period on those who cannot demonstrate 12 months of continuous creditable coverage."
 
The belief that corporations will act in the best long term interest of the corporation is common. Reality is that corporations are controlled by insiders who are human. Science has shown us that humans value short term gains over long term gains and personal gains over the welfare of a group. In short they will make decisions that create short term personal profits even if these decisions are bad for the long term survival of a corporation. What happened to Lehman Brothers is a good example.

AKA the Principle-Agent problem.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal–agent_problem
People who actually controlee corporations are not, ultimately, motivated by the long term best interest of the company but by their own best interests which are invariably driven by short term incentives. CEO’s can make a lot of money by doing things that have short term benefits but cost the company enormously in the long run. E.g. many of the problems IBM is suffering from came about exactly this way.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2014/05/30/why-ibm-is-in-decline/#62182f993e48
 
People who actually control corporations are not, ultimately, motivated by the long term best interest of the company but by their own best interests
How can that be a problem? It's a core principle of Capitalism!

Corporations only exist so that those who run them can make money. If that goal is met by destroying the corporation then it has served its purpose. And healthy Capitalism requires that poorly performing businesses fail. That's why we like it!
 
Nope, you can't use the individual market so it's employer insurance or if you qualify Medicaid. They would be barred for six months from purchasing a plan for themselves.
Wow. That's restraint of trade, which is a fundamental evil for the right, but they go there anyway.
 
Wow. That's restraint of trade, which is a fundamental evil for the right, but they go there anyway.
Well yeah, anytime you can screw over the little guy in favor of a big corporation, the GOP is all in.
 
CBO score says 22 million more uninsured by 2026.

So one million more stay insured than the House bill? :rolleyes:

I've yet to see the Democrats, however, address the GOP talking point, are these indeed simply the people who chose not to buy health insurance?

I doubt they are. Rather, it's going to be mostly people who cannot afford the insurance due to withdrawal of a large chunk of the ACA funding in favor of tax breaks for the rich.
 
So one million more stay insured than the House bill? :rolleyes:

I've yet to see the Democrats, however, address the GOP talking point, are these indeed simply the people who chose not to buy health insurance?

I doubt they are. Rather, it's going to be mostly people who cannot afford the insurance due to withdrawal of a large chunk of the ACA funding in favor of tax breaks for the rich.
Out of pocket expenses are higher. Just what everyone was looking for in an ACA replacement: less coverage combined with higher copays and deductibles.
 
Out of pocket expenses are higher. Just what everyone was looking for in an ACA replacement: less coverage combined with higher copays and deductibles.
Hard to imagine Trump signing off on that. He promised something very different.

I kid, of course. I doubt this'll be his first veto if it passes Congress. That said, if it is, remember you heard it here first. :cool:
 
CBO is predicting 15 million more uninsured next year under this bill. 4 million lose Medicaid, 4 million lose employer insurance and 7 million lose individual market insurance. That's a bad move for an election year.
 
CBO is predicting 15 million more uninsured next year under this bill. 4 million lose Medicaid, 4 million lose employer insurance and 7 million lose individual market insurance. That's a bad move for an election year.
Also, premiums 20% higher next year.
 
Congress seems to have understood that the penalty for not having insurance would be more effective if it was larger. The lower penalties were part of the compromises needed to get the bill passed. As I understand it families with incomes between FPL and 133% of FPL are allowed to buy policies from the exchange. This has helped some of the working poor that live in states that rejected Medicaid expansion.

Republicans in Congress could have proposed some of these changes or done other things to fix the known problems with the ACA. But that would assume they were actually interested in anything but tax cuts for rich people and hating Obama.


I know people that are in this situation, between 100% and 133% so not eligible for Obamacare and can't get insurance, so this bit is an improvement. Can't say I hope the bill will pass though, I don't.

ETA- Top two paragraphs quoted from Kestrel in the old thread
user_offline.gif
link.gif
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom