Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.
 
Last edited:
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.

Okay, so those are what you think pseudo-skeptics do. Now, what mentality of skeptics were you then referencing in the other thread?
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

Given the millions of claims of sightings, of which zero have any evidence to support them, it's not pseudo-skeptical to dismiss.

Remember: that which can be claimed without evidence, can be dismissed without evidence.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

You're definitely struggling with the prefix "pseudo" because that's nonsense. Anyone with half a brain can tell you psychic phenomena don't exist for the very simple reason that despite millions of dollars of prize money being available, no psychic has even come close to displaying an actual psychic skill. Every psychic is a fraud and every example of psychic phenomena is bunkum.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

Nothing pseudo there.

I agree entirely with the idea that all irrational subjects are the same and I'm not even a skeptic, let alone a pseudo-skeptic. Bigfoot, Nessie, Allah, Jehovah, Vishnu and the Yowie - they are all equally pathetic and irrational.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

Rubbish, of course there are conspiracies.

Just an awful lot fewer than David Icke or Alex Jones claim.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

Maybe you simply don't quite get the idea of what a scientific journal is. Infowars is not one.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.

Nah, I'd say most of it is dismissed because it's laughably stupid or simply faked.
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.

Let me repeat my question to you, OntarioSquatch, who are these SkeptiBunkersTM, the skeptics or the pseudo-skeptics?
In this thread you appear to mean the pseudo-skeptics but in the other thread they appear to be the skeptics.

Which one are the SkeptiBunkersTM, OntarioSquatch?
 
- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

Quite correct. True skeptics will dismiss this nonsense out of hand, because no, you didn't see a ghost. Or aliens. Or Bigfoot. And yes, you are either lying or mistaken in some manner, because those things do not exist. The matter has long since been settled. Trying to tell people that they aren't "true skeptics" for dealing with the facts as they stand isn't rational or skeptical. It's just silly.

Now, if someone were to bring actual evidence forward, that would change things. But you do not have evidence. No one who claims to have experienced these things ever has evidence.

Because, again, they don't exist.
 
Last edited:
Let me repeat my question to you, OntarioSquatch, who are these SkeptiBunkersTM, the skeptics or the pseudo-skeptics?
In this thread you appear to mean the pseudo-skeptics but in the other thread they appear to be the skeptics.

Which one are the SkeptiBunkersTM, OntarioSquatch?

The thread title is incorrect. It should've been "The Mentality of Pseudoskeptics" for accuracy, but since nearly everyone who claims to be a hardcore skeptic fits the profile of a pseudo, I'm not so sure if it's incorrect from a non-technical point of view. In the end, "Skeptic" is just a highly subjective label. Everyone uses skepticism to some extent in their life.
 
Last edited:
The thread title is incorrect. It should've been "The Mentality of Pseudoskeptics" for accuracy, but since nearly everyone who claims to be a hardcore skeptic fits the profile of a pseudo, I'm not so sure if it's incorrect from a non-technical point of view. In the end, "Skeptic" is just a highly subjective label. Everyone uses skepticism to some extent in their life.

However, pseudo-skepticism is when you cloak your existing irrational belief(s) or irrational mindset in skeptically sounding rhetoric.
Which irrational belief/mindset do your pseudo-skeptics have?
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.
Heffalumps and Woozles are very confusal.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.
If it can't be demonstrated, what do you expect?
- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.
I disagree; Santy Claus is more plausible than those other things you listed.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.
There's a difference between actual conspiracies and things folks make up as an excuse for lack of credible evidence.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.
Do you have a concrete example?

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.
None of it passes inspection; if any of these examples were compelling, there'd be actual professional, well-credentialed scientists looking for . . . whatever thing it is you're talking about here.
 
Last edited:
However, pseudo-skepticism is when you cloak your existing irrational belief(s) or irrational mindset in skeptically sounding rhetoric.
Which irrational belief/mindset do your pseudo-skeptics have?

They're wired in a way that they can't handle even the slightest amount of cognitive dissonance. Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.

Cognitive dissonance refers to a situation involving conflicting attitudes, beliefs or behaviors.

This produces a feeling of discomfort leading to an alteration in one of the attitudes, beliefs or behaviors to reduce the discomfort and restore balance etc.

For example, when people smoke (behavior) and they know that smoking causes cancer (cognition).

Festinger's (1957) cognitive dissonance theory suggests that we have an inner drive to hold all our attitudes and beliefs in harmony and avoid disharmony (or dissonance).

attitude change cognitive dissonance cartoon

Attitudes may change because of factors within the person. An important factor here is the principle of cognitive consistency, the focus of Festinger's (1957) theory of cognitive dissonance. This theory starts from the idea that we seek consistency in our beliefs and attitudes in any situation where two cognitions are inconsistent.

Leon Festinger (1957) proposed cognitive dissonance theory, which states that a powerful motive to maintain cognitive consistency can give rise to irrational and sometimes maladaptive behavior.


According to Festinger, we hold many cognitions about the world and ourselves; when they clash, a discrepancy is evoked, resulting in a state of tension known as cognitive dissonance. As the experience of dissonance is unpleasant, we are motivated to reduce or eliminate it, and achieve consonance (i.e. agreement).

http://www.simplypsychology.org/cognitive-dissonance.html
 
There is no denial of evidence because there is no evidence. Anecdotes don't count. I realize it may be difficult to understand at first, but make a *********** effort.
 
They're wired in a way that they can't handle even the slightest amount of cognitive dissonance. Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.

Do you ever intend to put forth the slightest bit of evidence of anyone here acting in a way that supports your conjectures?
 
Do you ever intend to put forth the slightest bit of evidence of anyone here acting in a way that supports your conjectures?

I'd like to see evidence that the poster has the slightest clue as to the meanings of the terms he uses.
 
They're wired in a way that they can't handle even the slightest amount of cognitive dissonance. Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.

Complete lack of evidence for your armchair psychology aside, none of the things that you have used as examples have ever had actual evidence put forth in their favor.
 
... Denial of evidence and biased thinking are the tactics used to restore consistency in their minds.
...
Could you successfully point to the dissonance in that?

The best you did was identify disagreement, you haven't shown the irrational belief/mindset your pseudo-skeptics supposedly have.

What quality evidence is denied according to you?
Proper evidence which establishes the existence of bigfoot or poor evidence which only indicates belief but not the actual existence of bigfoot?
 
Do you ever intend to put forth the slightest bit of evidence of anyone here acting in a way that supports your conjectures?
No. The game is to get us to respond to those conjectures. The last thing he'd want to do is provide any kind of evidence that could be objectively evaluated because it would end the game.
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.



Gamer's gotta game!
 
Last edited:
- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

It's usually not just the claim, but the follow-on bovine scatology which follows the claim that gets jumped on.

Example: I'm 52 years old, I have seen 4 ghosts in my lifetime. Where my claim differs from the "believers" is that my reaction becomes WHY DID I SEE THEM? Not, "I saw a ghost, therefore there is life after death!" To me the more intellectually satisfying thing is to search for the real answers instead of buying into silliness, and worse - spreading it here. I've learned a lot about how light works inside of your eyeball, and how your brain processed raw visual information, and a whole bunch of other cool FACTS that I wouldn't have known had I just stopped at : I saw a ghost.

The first time I saw a Gray Fox I thought it was a mountain lion. Why? Because I didn't know we had them here, and I didn't know how big they are, and I learned that often the first time you see an animal it will appear bigger than it really is. I think there's even a neurological name for this reaction too.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

How is this intellectually inconsistent?

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

They have the same thing in common. In Santa's case, he was based on St. Nicolas, a Greek Bishop. Over time he evolved into the "Christmas Spirit", and in the mid-20th century Coca Cola re-framed him as the fat man in the red suit.

The Loch Ness Monster was largely a hoax, having roots in religious history, and combined with a large, and very deep body of water between two tectonic plates (the north side of the lake is on the North American Plate).

Bigfoot is a late 20th century fabrication. The initial began in the late 1940s and early 1950s with footprints found crossing logging roads in Oregon. Those prints came from a local logging foreman with a sense of humor and a skill-saw. From there, like Santa Claus and Nessie, people began to back-date events from history to tie them to Bigfoot. The problem is that as the Bigfoot mythology grew it spread into UFOs, inter-dimensional beings and portals, and the creature seems to have a presence in over 20 states.

Bigfooters like to compare their creation to the Mountain Gorilla, a large primate that had gone "undiscovered" until late in the game. But where they differ is profound. The Gorilla's fact base had not changed much from the initial observations, and while our knowledge has certainly increased it needs to be pointed out the Gorillas have not added special mind-control powers, nor can they psychoanalytically turn off remote trail cameras, or are seen reporting back to gray aliens.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

You need to be able to site independent sources, not site sources from conspiracy websites and talkshow hosts.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

Not always. It depends on what the poster is trying to do with the science. Often these reports are cherry-picked without the poster understanding what the report said.

Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.

There hasn't been good video evidence, certainly not definitive evidence. Not of bigfoot, not of the Loch Ness Monster, and not of a ghost.

You mention geographical patterns, but you don't understand that it is the geographical evidence that ultimately sinks Bigfoot into Hoaxville. If you can track Bigfoot through sighting reports then YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO TRACK HIM DOWN. There is no reason to believe that Bigfoot is the only animal or being on earth that cannot be tracked.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom