Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

This is the first of several separate posts I will be putting out in response to Cosmic Cat’s Challenge thread. I’m going to roll them out slowly so as to try to justice to all reasonable responses.

Thanks

Jake Steele
InterGalactic Repo Man™



Cognitive dissonance​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance

In psychology, cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

A good way to explain cognitive dissonance is to use this movie as an example:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0140352/?ref_=fn_tt_tt_1

It stars Russell Crowe as a research chemist who is making a good living for himself and his family. However, he begins to have a crisis of conscientious when he began to question the motives and actions of B&W.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Insider_(film)

Bergman visits Wigand's house and vigorously denies revealing anything to B&W. Wigand, reassured, talks to Bergman about tobacco companies, and how the "Seven Dwarves" (the seven CEOs of the Big Tobacco companies) perjured themselves when they testified to Congress that they did not believe nicotine to be addictive. Wigand contrasts them with what he sees as the more conscientious healthcare companies he previously worked for, and concedes he feels hypocritical for believing he could maintain scientific ideals while working for a tobacco company. Although apparently possessing very damaging information about B&W, Wigand hesitates to do anything that might threaten his family's medical coverage.

That is a really good example of conscious cognitive dissonance; a person caught between his conscientious and his actions. He resolves that cognitive dissonance by going public. He now feels that he is doing the right thing that is in alignment with his ethics, morals and scruples. This is a resolution to his cognitive dissonance achieved by taking a firm moral and ethical stance.

An important point to keep in mind is that cognitive dissonance is not necessarily a conscious phenomenon. It often occurs subliminally below an individual's threshold of conscious perception. Regardless, an individual seeks out ways or means to achieve cognitive closure.

On this site atheism, materialism and the mechanistic universe are ways to resolve the existential crisis one experiences during one's life where the individual questions whether life has any meaning, purpose, or value.

People seek comforting answers to the King of Questions™(who are we, why are we, what are, is there a God(s) or is there not, etc.) In this sense Atheism is no different that any type of theism; they are both answers to the Big Questions. Neither one is intrinsically the ‘right’ one or the ‘better’ one. Atheism and theism are like an *******, everybody’s got one and everybody thinks everybody else’s stinks.

Also, the materialism and mechanistic philosophies are also in this same class. They are simply reality tunnels through which individuals view reality. These reality tunnels eliminate the uncertainty and uneasiness that some people feel when pondering Life, The Universe and Everything.

And that brings us to the Need for Closure Scale
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closure_(psychology)#Need_for_Closure_Scale

A person with a high need for closure prefers order and predictability, is decisive and closed-minded, and is uncomfortable with ambiguity.[3]

Someone rating low on need for closure will express more ideational fluidity and creative acts.[5] Items on the scale include statements such as "I think that having clear rules and order at work is essential to success," and "I do not like situations that are uncertain." Items such as "Even after I've made up my mind about something, I am always eager to consider a different opinion," and "I like to have friends who are unpredictable" are reverse scored.

The majority of people on this site have a high need for closure, hence, the reality tunnels of atheistic, materialistic and mechanistic world views; black and white, all or nothing. Every sound, every movement must be accounted for. There can be no uncertainty, no doubt no unsettling ambiguities. No nothing but nuts and bolts; reality boiled down to its most simplistic Lego building blocks later to be assembled into a whole unit.

There, enough on that for now. Stay tuned; same Bat time, same Bat channel.
 
I don't think I made any attempt to conceal the fact that this thread is aimed at you, OS and bubba, among others. It just took you rather longer than I expected to realise it.....

:rolleyes:

I venture to disagree. OS kept bringing it back to Bigfoot. Other posters objected. I saw an easy solution, which was to create a separate thread in which you, OS and others of your persuasion could post specific examples of the kind of behaviour you keep insisting is rampant on this forum.



No. You are not going to hijack another thread with your pet obsession. As has been said by others, if you want to start a psychology thread, by all means do so. This thread was created so you, OS, bubba and anyone else can post specific examples of the specific behaviour I outlined in my OP. I note that you have the time to try to steer us OT, but somehow not enough to post examples of what I was asking for.
So, if you want to wax poetical about the kinds of metaphorical walls you envisage me as, do it in another thread. My stance is unchanged from my OP: show the posts you object to, so we can see where you're coming from. If it is real, as I said in my OP (which you should probably re-read), I will change my approach if I am doing what you and others are claiming I am doing. Others may well follow suit, though I cannot claim to speak for anyone other than myself. Conversely, if you continue to twist and turn like a ....twisty turny thing, either ignoring or excusing your inability to furnish such posts, then you really should stop with the accusations. This is not a brick wall, nor indeed a wall of any sort: this is your opportunity, and OS's and anyone else's, to prove your point about the behaviour you keep complaining about.



Post your evidence or not. I can't say I'll lose any sleep over it. It will be your loss: here's your chance to do this without being accused of going OT. Take it or leave it, as you wish.
Good luck!

You didn't answer my two questions which I said were a litmus test of sorts and it would, in large part, determine my further interactions with you. As I said, and Adimintuim wallls.

Toodles, ta ta and goodbye.
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.

- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.

- Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.

- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.
And still no evidence that any of them are shills.
 
jakesteele,

I am quoting from the first post in this thread, started by CosmicYak
I would like to see actual examples of the following, as alleged, repeatedly, by certain members here:

Blind obedience to an "Official Story".
A refusal to accept evidence for a non-conventional idea or assertion.
Cognitive dissonance and/or anxiety caused by a subconscious acceptance of such ideas, coupled by a public disavowal of same.
Insulting, aggressive posts that attack the arguer, not the argument. (Probably best to exclude Beachnut from this, really.... )
Pseudo-skepticism.
Unqualified, uncritical support for governments, police forces and other establishment organisations.
Shilling for corporations or security forces.

This is the first of several separate posts I will be putting out in response to Cosmic Cat’s Challenge thread. I’m going to roll them out slowly so as to try to justice to all reasonable responses.

Thanks

Why are you posting yet another definition for cognitive dissonance?
Where is the evidence for cognitive dissonance on the ISF from the posters here?

How do you apply the movie The Insider to the International Skeptics Forum?

On this site atheism, materialism and the mechanistic universe are ways to resolve the existential crisis one experiences during one's life where the individual questions whether life has any meaning, purpose, or value.

Evidence for this amazing assertion, please.
With specific posts from specific posters from this forum.

The majority of people on this site have a high need for closure, hence, the reality tunnels of atheistic, materialistic and mechanistic world views; black and white, all or nothing. Every sound, every movement must be accounted for. There can be no uncertainty, no doubt no unsettling ambiguities. No nothing but nuts and bolts; reality boiled down to its most simplistic Lego building blocks later to be assembled into a whole unit.

I do not see any evidence in this sweeping and grand generalization that you
have the insight or the ability to make about posters from all
over the world and from many different walks of life.

I think you, sir, are the one with the tunnel vision that turns every
poster* on this forum from thinking individuals with varied opinions into
this mass closure-needing, cognitively dissonant group.

With not one example for evidence yet.

*Except the ones who agree with you.

Kid Eager

Here's some additional information that puts the claim in jakesteele's post in context:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closur..._Closure_Scale

And here's an online survey that one can do regarding need for closure:

http://www.psyctherapy.com/Enrolled/...orClosure.aspx

Perhaps if we get enough data from the surveys we can move from assertion to examination of evidence.

Excellent, I will do it.
Thanks KE.
 
The thread title is incorrect. It should've been "The Mentality of Pseudoskeptics" for accuracy, but since nearly everyone who claims to be a hardcore skeptic fits the profile of a pseudo, I'm not so sure if it's incorrect from a non-technical point of view. In the end, "Skeptic" is just a highly subjective label. Everyone uses skepticism to some extent in their life.

And now, in addition to the other evidence you've been asked for, you could kindly post evidence for someone here claiming to be a "hardcore skeptic." Thanks in advance! :thumbsup:
 
Here's some additional information that puts the claim in jakesteele's post in context:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closure_%28psychology%29#Need_for_Closure_Scale

And here's an online survey that one can do regarding need for closure:

http://www.psyctherapy.com/Enrolled/Activities/NeedForClosure.aspx

Perhaps if we get enough data from the surveys we can move from assertion to examination of evidence.

I'm not going to take that test, but I've done the Myers-Briggs device several times, and my comfort with uncertainty, lack of closure and ambiguity is well documented.
 
This is the first of several separate posts I will be putting out in response to Cosmic Cat’s Challenge thread. I’m going to roll them out slowly so as to try to justice to all reasonable responses.

Thanks

Jake Steele
InterGalactic Repo Man™



Cognitive dissonance​

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance

In psychology, cognitive dissonance is the mental stress or discomfort experienced by an individual who holds two or more contradictory beliefs, ideas, or values at the same time, performs an action that is contradictory to one or more beliefs, ideas or values, or is confronted by new information that conflicts with existing beliefs, ideas, or values.

A good way to explain cognitive dissonance is to use this movie as an example:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0140352/?ref_=fn_tt_tt_1

It stars Russell Crowe as a research chemist who is making a good living for himself and his family. However, he begins to have a crisis of conscientious when he began to question the motives and actions of B&W.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Insider_(film)

Bergman visits Wigand's house and vigorously denies revealing anything to B&W. Wigand, reassured, talks to Bergman about tobacco companies, and how the "Seven Dwarves" (the seven CEOs of the Big Tobacco companies) perjured themselves when they testified to Congress that they did not believe nicotine to be addictive. Wigand contrasts them with what he sees as the more conscientious healthcare companies he previously worked for, and concedes he feels hypocritical for believing he could maintain scientific ideals while working for a tobacco company. Although apparently possessing very damaging information about B&W, Wigand hesitates to do anything that might threaten his family's medical coverage.

That is a really good example of conscious cognitive dissonance; a person caught between his conscientious and his actions. He resolves that cognitive dissonance by going public. He now feels that he is doing the right thing that is in alignment with his ethics, morals and scruples. This is a resolution to his cognitive dissonance achieved by taking a firm moral and ethical stance.

An important point to keep in mind is that cognitive dissonance is not necessarily a conscious phenomenon. It often occurs subliminally below an individual's threshold of conscious perception. Regardless, an individual seeks out ways or means to achieve cognitive closure.

On this site atheism, materialism and the mechanistic universe are ways to resolve the existential crisis one experiences during one's life where the individual questions whether life has any meaning, purpose, or value.

People seek comforting answers to the King of Questions™(who are we, why are we, what are, is there a God(s) or is there not, etc.) In this sense Atheism is no different that any type of theism; they are both answers to the Big Questions. Neither one is intrinsically the ‘right’ one or the ‘better’ one. Atheism and theism are like an *******, everybody’s got one and everybody thinks everybody else’s stinks.

Also, the materialism and mechanistic philosophies are also in this same class. They are simply reality tunnels through which individuals view reality. These reality tunnels eliminate the uncertainty and uneasiness that some people feel when pondering Life, The Universe and Everything.

And that brings us to the Need for Closure Scale
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Closure_(psychology)#Need_for_Closure_Scale

A person with a high need for closure prefers order and predictability, is decisive and closed-minded, and is uncomfortable with ambiguity.[3]

Someone rating low on need for closure will express more ideational fluidity and creative acts.[5] Items on the scale include statements such as "I think that having clear rules and order at work is essential to success," and "I do not like situations that are uncertain." Items such as "Even after I've made up my mind about something, I am always eager to consider a different opinion," and "I like to have friends who are unpredictable" are reverse scored.

The majority of people on this site have a high need for closure, hence, the reality tunnels of atheistic, materialistic and mechanistic world views; black and white, all or nothing. Every sound, every movement must be accounted for. There can be no uncertainty, no doubt no unsettling ambiguities. No nothing but nuts and bolts; reality boiled down to its most simplistic Lego building blocks later to be assembled into a whole unit.

There, enough on that for now. Stay tuned; same Bat time, same Bat channel.

Your King of Questions amounts to no more than a child's cry in the night for their mommy and daddy.

The rest of your post is pure projection.
 
I'm not going to take that test, but I've done the Myers-Briggs device several times, and my comfort with uncertainty, lack of closure and ambiguity is well documented.

I have been married for 49 years and I submit that as evidence for my comfort with uncertainty, lack of closure and ambiguity.
 
I am still waiting for one piece of evidence of the Loch Ness monster, just one that is neither totally disproved, or involving a trip to the pub. then you will have convinced me and I shall have to return all my shill cheques and my dogs will starve... I may have to feed then to the cats...
 
I'm not going to take that test, but I've done the Myers-Briggs device several times, and my comfort with uncertainty, lack of closure and ambiguity is well documented.

so you say... (hmmmm.... refuses to try new experiences... hmmmmm :p )
 
examples

- If someone claims to have encountered a UFO or a ghost, the pseudo-skeptic will try hard to dismiss it as a misidentification. If that doesn't work to their satisfaction, they'll accuse the witness of lying or hallucinating.
Perhaps, but what I see on this forum is this: Someone posts with "100% irrefutable proof of aliens/ ghosts". Alternative explanations are offered, explanations that do not rely on unevidenced speculation, but rather fit the observed facts of the event. The OP dismisses all alternative explanations and continues to insist, still without offering any positive evidence, that it really really is aliens or ghosts.
This is skepticism in action. Offer concrete evidence, rather than anecdotal speculation, and I will be the first to accept the existence of either.
I know you're trying, but you're still not quite there. Please try to quote actual posts, especially ones where accusations of hallucinations or lying have been made.
- A pseudoskeptic will tell you that psychic phenomenon doesn't exist because no one has ever proven it exists.
The fact that you think this is a problem speaks volumes about you.


-
Pseudoskeptics consider all "woo" to be the same. They'll argue that the Loch Ness Monster and Sasquatch are no more plausible than Santa Claus.
Evidence, old bean. Evidence. You know, that thing that's lacking in every thread about BF so far. Nessie is a known fraud, which some basic research on the subject would have revealed. Hence these phenomena are tarred with the same brush, until something is presented which would change that stance.
Guess what that might be?
Evidence.


- They'll attempt to make fun of you for suggesting that there could be a conspiracy.
That depends on the conspiracy. There is a thread about conspiracies that turned out to be true. P2/ Opus Dei is one example that came up. No-one laughed.
On the other hand, suggesting that the Vatican used GMOs stuffed inside a Knight of Malta to bring down the WTC, or whatever it is that pappamundi is claiming, is worthy of ridicule. Unevidenced paranoid streams of consciousness get all they deserve. My point is that conspiracy is not immediately and automatically dismissed: each, at least from where I'm sitting, gets individual and considered attention. Look at the Charlie Hebdo thread if you want an example.

- They ask for studies published in scientific journals, but when you show it to them, they'll raise the bar or come up with whatever excuse they can to dismiss it.
I would love to see some evidence of this. I would have thought that anyone dismissing published scientific evidence as you assert would get quite a roasting here. Must be pages of it. Link?

- Anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by pseudoskeptics. Footprints, audio, film/video, geographical patterns across reports and hair samples are all dismissed as not being evidence because none of it has ever been proven.
No, anything that falls short of proof is dismissed by skeptics, and again, the fact that you have a problem with this says a lot about the foundation of your beliefs.
Again, links please. Where has all this evidence been presented? Specifically hair samples. Hair samples would be good. Nice bit of Bigfoot DNA to silence those pesky critics. Link, please. Pretty please.
 
jakesteele,

I am quoting from the first post in this thread, started by CosmicYak




Why are you posting yet another definition for cognitive dissonance?
Where is the evidence for cognitive dissonance on the ISF from the posters here?

How do you apply the movie The Insider to the International Skeptics Forum?



Evidence for this amazing assertion, please.
With specific posts from specific posters from this forum.



I do not see any evidence in this sweeping and grand generalization that you
have the insight or the ability to make about posters from all
over the world and from many different walks of life.

I think you, sir, are the one with the tunnel vision that turns every
poster* on this forum from thinking individuals with varied opinions into
this mass closure-needing, cognitively dissonant group.

With not one example for evidence yet.

*Except the ones who agree with you.

^ ^
This.
:thumbsup::)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom