Bigfoot: The Patterson Gimlin Film - Part 5

Bigfoot is debunked by your wit? You haven't even debunked Santa. Absence of evidence fallacy, etc.

Absence of evidence is a lack of evidence. In the case of footie, that means an absolute lack of any scientific evidence. When Sagan (and others) claim "absence of evidence does not mean evidence of absence," they are trotting out an aphorism.

Bigfoot has been debunked daily for over 15,000 years. It's not getting any more real.
 
Remember the main lesson Greg Long taught us: nobody's even looking. Especially not the 'footers themselves.

It is contrary to their interests. BLAARGing 101 is to make loud noises pretending to be investigating. You have to distance yourself from DeAtley because he is all bad news for bigfoot.

He was as frank as you can be with Greg DeLong without stating "I committed fraud". He's a wealthy guy, involved in wines now. I have no idea about his personality other than he's been a successful businessman for half a century and he was good-humored in DeLong's interviews. He isn't going to do anything flaky. This is a person of substance.

Wallace's offspring were pretty proud of the old man for his stompers and his key role in the bigfoot phenomenon. It doesn't matter if DeAtley comes out with it in his lifetime. The descendants probably will, and one of the reasons for not coming out with it sooner is that between the two of them it is a one-two punch knockout of bigfoot: Wallace then DeAtley, ie the PGF.

The tracks that led Roger Patterson there and the suit Bob Heironimus wore - this is the underpinning of bigfoot in the USA. DeAtley has done the 'footers a great service by keeping quiet. He has done himself a great favor too. If he had come out after Roger died or something, then bigfoot would not be where it is now. The PGF is the top claim to evidence. By laying low and holding on to his investment it has grown in value, not just in money but legacy. This can go down as one of the greatest hoaxes of all time.
 
This can go down as one of the greatest hoaxes of all time.
The greatest hoax of all time that hardly anybody actually believed. America was (and still is) craving an animal myth. Bigfoot is it. Scotland has the Loch Ness Monster and we have Bigfoot. It makes no difference whatsoever that few people have ever believed the PGF to be authentic. No difference at all.
 
Well there is a certain genius in having the right hoax to back, the timing, how you tie it in to it's predecessors - it isn't the technical wizardry. Shake the camera at distance. Modified ape suit with diaper butt. *yawn*

Getting people up to Yakima right away and never having to defend the site - that's pretty cagey. He's the man for the times in what you are calling a craving for an animal myth. I agree to that, sure.
 
Not very good investigating on your part. Roger had almost 2 days to set up the film. Do you not think DeAtley could have made that happen?

What are you on about? The fact that it was obviously processed somehow and somewhere by somebody is irrelevant. Patterson LIED about how he shipped the film and how it was processed. The story is simply not true. That proves the fraud and the hoax.

Rubbish. Even Bob H's stories contradict themselves. And why would Bob G contradict Roger? Besides, you know perfectly well that testimony never proves anything.

What??? Testimony is very much an integral part of examining a fraud. Major contradictions each time a principle opens their mouths is indicative of lying. If the story cannot be ascertained with any sort of consistency by listening to the two principles - you certainly have a lie on your hands. It's not rocket science.

And yes - Gimlin contradicts himself and Patterson within a short time of the event. This has been pointed out many, many times.

BTW - who said anything about Bob H.>:rolleyes:


Yes. Facts. Please do your research.
 
Last edited:
I've always found the whole "shipping/mailing/courier" angle to be rather suspicious on it's own. If I had just shot such stunning and important film footage, of an actual real Yeti... there's no way that I'm letting that gold out of my hands for a second. I'd be on top of it every step of the way.

"Yeah, I just shot the footage of the century... just gonna pop it in the mail."

Sure you would, Roger. Totally.
 
Ah! The right person this time.

Any response to this, OS?

Garrette said:
I've seen it. They were looking at how closely a human can match the gait seen in the Patterson film. They found out that most aspects of her walk can be closely replicated. Meldrum was surprised at how closely it was replicated because he was expecting it to be very different from a human gait.

A more accurate experiment done at a human biomechanics lab has shown that a person can't walk exactly like what we see in the film

OntarioSquatch, what follow up have you done on this? Is this edited video from a television show the extent of your research into it or have you gone to the source?
 
OntarioSquatch, what follow up have you done on this? Is this edited video from a television show the extent of your research into it or have you gone to the source?

I've looked at a variety of sources and one thing I've noticed is that all of them report the same characteristics even though their opinion on whether or not the gait could be replicated differs. The problem appears to be that the amount of difference required to exist between the gait of a regular person and the gait of the PGF subject varies. In other words, whether or not the walk can be replicated depends on how much room you leave for difference. The data itself isn't a problem.
 
That is not an answer to the question. You posted that edited video from a television special as evidence for your position. What checking did you do on it?
 
I've looked at a variety of sources and one thing I've noticed is that all of them report the same characteristics even though their opinion on whether or not the gait could be replicated differs. The problem appears to be that the amount of difference required to exist between the gait of a regular person and the gait of the PGF subject varies. In other words, whether or not the walk can be replicated depends on how much room you leave for difference. The data itself isn't a problem.

The gait was replicated much to Meldrum's dismay as well as your own.

It must be time for mid-terms.
 
Ah, OS, you're back again.

Perhaps you could deal with the foot-size claim now please. Can you back up your claim that Patty's foot was "near normal" for us, so that we can move on to something more interesting. Thank you.
 
The discussion of credentials was off topic and was therefore moved to AAH. Please return to the topic at hand.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
I've always found the whole "shipping/mailing/courier" angle to be rather suspicious on it's own. If I had just shot such stunning and important film footage, of an actual real Yeti... there's no way that I'm letting that gold out of my hands for a second.

I suppose so, and it fits in with the whole pattern of everything they're doing being inconsistent with what they're saying.

Never go back to find what you filmed. Go directly to Bangkok. Do not pass Go, move directly to exotic showgirl bars.

It's the one redeeming thing about the whole PGF. Roger was dying, he had pulled off the big con, and he partied like tomorrow wasn't coming because for him, it wasn't. It's a Cinderella Story for guys that "live by their wits" as he called it.

Most here couldn't pull a con job because it would bother their conscience. But these guys are wired differently. Pouring garbage cans of money on themselves in a string of hotel rooms. Must have been something.
 
I suppose so, and it fits in with the whole pattern of everything they're doing being inconsistent with what they're saying.

Never go back to find what you filmed. Go directly to Bangkok. Do not pass Go, move directly to exotic showgirl bars.

It's the one redeeming thing about the whole PGF. Roger was dying, he had pulled off the big con, and he partied like tomorrow wasn't coming because for him, it wasn't. It's a Cinderella Story for guys that "live by their wits" as he called it.

Most here couldn't pull a con job because it would bother their conscience. But these guys are wired differently. Pouring garbage cans of money on themselves in a string of hotel rooms. Must have been something.


The "mailing" angle, lie that it is, makes no damn sense... unless it's a hoax. All the blather about the whys and wherefores of that piece of the story are just ridiculous. Patterson supposedly just caught world shattering footage and does what? Puts it in "the mail"? What the hell for?

He wants to have it ready to show asap? This is monumental stuff. It wouldn't matter how many days later you could show it. He's going to risk "Oooops, sorry, lost it" just to show it to some footers early? I don't think so.

He wants to make sure it's viable footage, so mails it off and heads back down to Bluff Creek to try to get more, just in case? What? It's gonna take days to find out. In which case you've got nothing more, or you've scored some more footage. So, why mail it off at all? Just hang onto it, stick around and try to get some more. He's going to risk losing it, striking out on getting more and ending up with nothing? Sorry, not buying it.

If it were real, Patterson's got a golden ticket to the big time. Forget the footers and whatnot. High tail it back to big smoke, can in hand and never let it out of your sight. If it doesn't turn out well... then go back and try to get more. Or, keep it in your hot little hands, try to get more straight away, if that's a bust... then, high tail it back to the big smoke, can in hand.

This is bigger than the Hindenburg film. You don't get cavalier with it and stick it in the post, no matter what the outcome of a print might be like. Just go and get it developed yourself, or hang onto it while you're trying to get safety shots. It doesn't matter who he was supposed to send it to, he's gonna risk having them say... "The package? Didn't get it, Roger."???

It makes no sense for what he says he had. It only makes sense as part of a ************ story.
 
Last edited:
It's a Cinderella Story for guys that "live by their wits" as he called it.

Most here couldn't pull a con job because it would bother their conscience. But these guys are wired differently.

It's weirdly funny. You observe these cons, the ones footers fall over themselves to fall for, and you think maybe, maybe they deserve it.
http://bigfootforums.com/index.php/topic/52821-sasquatchmeldrums-skeleton-model/page-5
CowboyHatGuy said:
Its simple. If you dont like his work? Dont follow it! Whatever happened to "caveat emptor"? Are Randiites going to save the world from our own selves? If people want to believe in Bigfoot and pay money to watch Meldrum speak???? Who cares?

He's correct: I don't care what he believes when he drags his mules off into the High Lonesome in hopeless pursuit of a nonexistent monkey. The problem is the wish-thinking, and lack of critical thinking that this odd enthusiasm fosters.
 
I think we have to look at what their problem at hand was, Captain. They have a hoax film already cut, ready to market. They come out with the big announcement, but if people scrutinize the scene, the trackways won't match the story.

They are not in possession of the film at 6:30 pm when they reach Al Hodgsen's store because the developed film was already mounted on a projector in Al DeAtley's Yakima home.

Dahinden was at Hodgsen's store by noon the next day with another "researcher". Patterson had already cleared out North, and called in to Hodgen's store to tell them about the great flood of Noah developing at Bluff Creek, about having to flee for their lives. Don't go to Bluff Creek, seven dead by drowning already.

If the film is in their possession then it hasn't been shipped yet to a developer. It can't be shipped until they arrive, which is a 14 hour drive. The next day is Sunday so that would leave plenty of time for people to crawl all over the site. Their story is that the film was shipped Friday and it is going to be developed in time to show Sunday.

They really shot their mouths off on Friday the 20th, and the tracks can't back what they claimed. Roger's horse falling down for example - sure, just point that out, Roger.

So this mailing of the film is important to them in getting people up to Yakima right away, drawing them away from the hoax site. Roger can't be there to answer people's questions with tracks in front of him.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom