Skeptibunkers and Anxious Sheeple: A Challenge.

Subjectivity and unfair standards isn't the real issue here. The core problem is that people can deny any evidence that opposes a fragile belief. When comes to an opposing belief, anything that falls short of proof will be dismissed if the person can't handle the cognitive dissonance that's created by good arguments existing on both sides.

And any time you feel up to substantiating this with actual quotes from this forum, just go ahead.
 
Is it really?


You forgot to include this part: "In other words, put up or shut up."
I did indeed. Someone commented that they found it unnecessarily aggressive, so to err on the side of caution I didn't repost it.


http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=145251&highlight=shamless+nickell
Start at post 13 and see an ongoing back and forth on pilots vs. A. astronomers between me and a guy called Astrophotographer. I had already posted this thread in the Mentality thread regarding the Law of the Implausible Plausible™ with an example of Shameless Joe Nickel's absurd debunking of the Flying Friar regarding human levitation. You already read this. Stop asking for that which has already been asked and answered.

I read the first 100 or so posts, as you asked. The only hyping of amateur astronomers that I could see was your repeated claims that they were being hyped. Astrophotographer stated explicitly that both pilots and amateur astronomers make mistakes. You appeared then, as now, to be arguing against strawmen.
 
I did not post them before, I've seen others post them. There's nothing "easy-peasy" about finding those again.
Upon rereading, I realise I was in error. My apologies.




For but one example, read this thread. Specifically note the complete lack of evidence provided in the OP, it's just a story in a newspaper, and the lack of anyone in that thread even bothered by such lack of evidence. At the end of page 3 you can see me try to ask for evidence, and you will see what the usual response to such requests then is.

By 'complete lack of evidence', you presumably mean the interviews with former employees, the leaked emails, the links to documentation and the sources for the trolling pictures, and the confirmation from Russian media sources as well.
Yup. Totally unevidenced.
:rolleyes:
 
I have already told you where to find it, you are free to check it. You will easily see that unevidenced claims by Western governments/media are considered as a priori true, where evidence is required so as to not be considered true, whereas equally unevidenced claims by non-Western governments/media are considered as a priori false, where evidence is required so as to consider them true.

I've been thinking about this point, and I can see where you're coming from on this one. I think it is natural to trust sources from your own country or culture, and distrust ones that are not.
That said, I do think you are conflating two things that are not necessarily connected. The press in the west is free: it is not owned by governments, and so is at liberty to criticise government policies and actions. Another beneficial feature of a free press is that the various channels are in competition with each other: if one publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it. Finally, there is, in the UK at least, a Press Complaints Commission, which deals with accusations of untrue or otherwise unacceptable articles. Whilst some newspapers, for example, follow one party, they are balanced by those on the other side. Those papers that are slavishly uncritical of one party or other are frequently and loudly mocked (I'm thinking specifically of the Daily Mail here, but there are others as well).
On the other hand, channels such as Press TV and Russia Today are owned by their respective governments. Journalists from those companies have complained about having to publish government propaganda they know is untrue, and many of the stories are obviously biased and laughably false. As far as I am aware, no-one has left the Guardian or the Telegraph making similar accusations.
To say, then, that accepting a priori stories in the western press is tantamount to toeing the government line is, I believe, unjustified, whereas citing Press TV or RT as legitimate sources of information is to lend support to the agendas of the Iranian or Russian governments.
I would like to say though, and I mean this with sincerity and respect, that you have come closer than either OntarioSquatch or jakesteele in making a valid point about bias. I don't entirely agree with you, for the reasons I have listed above, but I do think it is a fair point. It is always good to examine whether one has unconscious biases, and I thank you for making me think about it.
 
By 'complete lack of evidence', you presumably mean the interviews with former employees

I know this person Dave who formerly worked at Area 51 and will tell you whole stories about how they're holding alien prisoners there. Of course there is no documentation that Dave actually ever worked there, you see it was all "unofficial" and such. By your standards you should believe Dave.

the leaked emails, the links to documentation and the sources for the trolling pictures, and the confirmation from Russian media sources as well.
Yup. Totally unevidenced.
:rolleyes:

You mean the complete lack of any actual source for one of those supposed "trolling posts on social media"? Interesting you notice that too.
 
If I was pretending, I'd be claiming that I do go out and look for evidence and that I did have a sighting. It seems anything that a proponent of "woo" does will in your mind be indicative of "gaming" due to the extreme bias and denial that's present.

The best part about all of this is that you yourself are guilty of nearly everything you've falsely accused myself and others of. You want to see some gaming? Just look for the guy who claims to have hunted leopards in the Amazon.
The jig has been up for a long time, OS, and you fool no one, not even your fellow gamers -- though they will allow you to play.

You won't answer the question about the highly edited video I keep remind you of because you know it condemns you either way. If you didn't research it, then you are not the great researcher you claim with all your vast knowledge, which makes all your posts here lies. If you did research it, then you know that scientist who headed up that study considers it at best inconclusive and never published a paper on it, which makes all your posts here lies.

ABP isn't perfect, but he's a heck of a lot closer to the credible, believable, and trustworthy end of the spectrum than you will ever be.
 
I know this person Dave who formerly worked at Area 51 and will tell you whole stories about how they're holding alien prisoners there. Of course there is no documentation that Dave actually ever worked there, you see it was all "unofficial" and such. By your standards you should believe Dave.

Did you actually read the article? You know, the one with the names of the people they interviewed? The ones that were later substantiated by other, Russian media sources?
There is a significant difference between "anecdote" and "interview", one that you should try to grasp.
 
The press in the west is free

:rolleyes:

it is not owned by governments, and so is at liberty to criticise government policies and actions.

Here is just one of many examples of the "free press which criticizes government policies and actions."

Another beneficial feature of a free press is that the various channels are in competition with each other

Ah yes, the illusion of competition. Actually 95% of the media in the US is owned by 5 corporations.

if one publishes a story that is, for example, untrue, unevidenced or slavishly pro-government, the papers and channels of other political persuasions can, and will, attack it.

Do you have any evidence for these beliefs?

Finally, there is, in the UK at least, a Press Complaints Commission, which deals with accusations of untrue or otherwise unacceptable articles. Whilst some newspapers, for example, follow one party, they are balanced by those on the other side. Those papers that are slavishly uncritical of one party or other are frequently and loudly mocked (I'm thinking specifically of the Daily Mail here, but there are others as well).

Funny how you immediately must go back to "one party vs the other", it's almost as if you can't parse the criticism about shared assumptions among the marginally different political persuasions represented in mainstream media.

On the other hand, channels such as Press TV and Russia Today are owned by their respective governments. Journalists from those companies have complained about having to publish government propaganda they know is untrue

Can you give some examples?

and many of the stories are obviously biased and laughably false.

Do you have evidence for this or is this just your gut-feeling based on all those laughably fake stories that appear in your "free press"?
 
Did you actually read the article? You know, the one with the names of the people they interviewed? The ones that were later substantiated by other, Russian media sources?
There is a significant difference between "anecdote" and "interview", one that you should try to grasp.

Well yes, I'll interview Dave for you and my buddy Bob will also claim that Dave worked at Area 51. Do you or do you not have any form of documentation that any of these people actually worked where they claim? Can you or can you not show any such "social media posts" that they purportedly created?

So, in short, there is no evidence presented whatsoever other than mere claims by a Guardian reporter. The Guardian claims that its comments section is being "run over by these Kremlin trolls" yet there exist plenty of screenshots showing that the comments that are being deleted are nothing but simple comments pointing out all the lies written in the articles.

So we have on the one hand actual screenshots of the comments that are being removed, and on the other hand a delusional conspiracy theory with not a smidgen of hard evidence behind it trying to justify removal of those comments.

Which position would a self-declared skeptic on ISF take? We have our answer.
 
Last edited:
Of course not, if you agree with it then it's not a conspiracy theory. QED

Wrong.

The conspiracy by Brutus and others to assassinate Julius Caesar is recorded in what are generally regarded as reliable (ancient) historical sources. The identity of the assassins is simply not in dispute by any reasonable person. Nor are the circumstances of Caesar's death.

The hallmark of a conspiracy theory is that it is a claim that does not rest on credible evidence; the claim is either invented from nothing whatsoever, or deduced from unreliable, tenuous, indirect or bogus sources.
 
Wrong.

The conspiracy by Brutus and others to assassinate Julius Caesar is recorded in what are generally regarded as reliable (ancient) historical sources. The identity of the assassins is simply not in dispute by any reasonable person. Nor are the circumstances of Caesar's death.

The hallmark of a conspiracy theory is that it is a claim that does not rest on credible evidence; the claim is either invented from nothing whatsoever, or deduced from unreliable, tenuous, indirect or bogus sources.

First you say "wrong" and then you explain why I'm right. The set of designated authority figures agrees with the claim, therefor it is not a conspiracy theory. You do understand that merely giving reasons why this set of authority figures agrees with the claim does not contradict what I said? On the contrary.
 
Last edited:
It looked like only a very short shot to me. A claim is designated as a "conspiracy theory" based on whether there is agreement with the claim or not.
No, not remotely (discarding the fringe elements you can find on any topic and on all sides of any topic).

A claim is designated a conspiracy theory if it involves a conspiracy. From there, however, proceeds confusion, and I suspect you are deliberately helping sow it. I say this because you are obviously highly intelligent and capable of deep analytical thought yet you do not apply it here.

Not everything that is a conspiracy theory is bunkum; there have been legitimate conspiracies, both successful and not.

Some conspiracy theories are indeed bunkum. The 9/11 inside jobbers and the moon landing hoaxers are examples.

What you have done in this conversation is assume that the use of "conspiracy theory" is identically applied by skeptics to all cases when in fact it is quite obvious in context which subset of all CTs JayUtah and others were referring to.
 
First you say "wrong" and then you explain why I'm right. The set of designated authority figures agrees with the claim, therefor it is not a conspiracy theory. You do understand that merely giving reasons why this set of authority figures agrees with the claim does not contradict what I said? On the contrary.

You missed the crucial step - the evidencing of the conspiracy to assassinate Caesar in sources.

Quite a few conspiracy theories are conjured up on the basis of no real evidence whatsoever - pretty much any terrorist event or major upset will generate conspiracy claims within hours these days, long before a sufficient amount of sources are available. When sources (video footage, whatever) do become available, the conspiracy theorists go over them with a fine tooth-comb looking for anomalies, ignoring any contrary evidence.

Ancient historians examining the life of Caesar agree on the assessment of the sources for his death. They are experts in the relevant language (Latin) and know the source material and context. Since nobody really seems to gain by doubting this, then there is universal acceptance. But this is underpinned by demonstrable expertise.

Rank amateurs can of course set themselves up as arbiters and interpreters of sources and different types of evidence, but they will need to demonstrate genuine, reliable expertise. That's certainly possible in fields like ancient history, since one does not need a PhD to interpret these sources. It is much harder with some other forms of scientific evidence, though.

LOL at the idea of my colleagues in classics and ancient history down the corridor as 'authority figures'.
 
Jay Utah's self-serving definition of "conspiracy theory" which boils down to "if I don't agree with it then it's a conspiracy theory" rather than being an objective definition based on the claims made, ie "a theory which proposes a conspiracy as an explanation for something" or something like that.

Your summary isn't even close.

The statement to which you refer doesn't attempt to define a conspiracy theory. Nor does it invoke in any way, shape, or form a comparison with what I may or may not agree with. What it does is outline the method by which proponents of fringe theories present and defend their cases. I'll say here that this method is applied by others besides conspiracy theorists.

It is a given that a fringe claimant disagrees with the mainstream. That is a statement of fact, not a value judgment. The process I outlined merely states that the rejection of the mainstream and the expostulation of the fringe claim employ different standards of proof, necessitating two stages of presentation.
 
A claim is designated a conspiracy theory if it involves a conspiracy.{...}

Not everything that is a conspiracy theory is bunkum; there have been legitimate conspiracies, both successful and not.

Some conspiracy theories are indeed bunkum. The 9/11 inside jobbers and the moon landing hoaxers are examples.

Yes, you'd think that would be the obvious, simple and objective definition of the term "conspiracy theory". Yet you are the first person I've encountered here who would agree upon it.

What you have done in this conversation is assume that the use of "conspiracy theory" is identically applied by skeptics to all cases when in fact it is quite obvious in context which subset of all CTs JayUtah and others were referring to.

Only Jay Utah himself can clarify this, however the quote was taken from the thread "How does the Skeptic Community (tm) define what is a Conspiracy Theory?" in direct response to a request for a consensus definition.
 
Your summary isn't even close.

The statement to which you refer doesn't attempt to define a conspiracy theory. Nor does it invoke in any way, shape, or form a comparison with what I may or may not agree with. What it does is outline the method by which proponents of fringe theories present and defend their cases. I'll say here that this method is applied by others besides conspiracy theorists.

It is a given that a fringe claimant disagrees with the mainstream. That is a statement of fact, not a value judgment. The process I outlined merely states that the rejection of the mainstream and the expostulation of the fringe claim employ different standards of proof, necessitating two stages of presentation.

Just let me ask you this first: is the theory that Brutus et al conspired to kill Caesar a conspiracy theory to you? If yes, how does this fit your statement that "a conspiracy theory invariably involves ...". If no, what is your definition of "conspiracy theory"?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom