If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, my mistake: I thought you weren't responding to it because you were at least aware that you didn't understand it. Now I see that you didn't understand it well enough to realize that you weren't responding to it. Seriously: Try reading it again without all the defensive willful ignorance.
I did, and I gave my example. I am willing to revisit this one more time if you post a link to the original post in question.
 
What graph?

I am pretty sure I didn't post any graphs.

Sure you did, and more than once. Here's an example:

You're also talking about average acceleration. Average acceleration is a meaningless number. The issues are constant acceleration and how long it was observed.

Well, I'll save whether 'average acceleration' is a meaningless number for another time. The issue is, indeed, constant acceleration. You have provided no evidence of constant acceleration. All the claims you have made based on a constant acceleration premise are baseless.
 
Well, I'll save whether 'average acceleration' is a meaningless number for another time. The issue is, indeed, constant acceleration. You have provided no evidence of constant acceleration. All the claims you have made based on a constant acceleration premise are baseless.

I don't agree. How did NIST determine constant acceleration for WTC7? Well, you don't have to speculate because the answer is here: http://www.nist.gov/public_affairs/factsheet/wtc_qa_082108.cfm

Here are some facts:
1. NIST used a video to calculate acceleration.
2. NIST determined that freefall acceleration occurred for 2.25 seconds.
3. David Chandler used a video to determine that freefall acceleration occurred for approximately the same amount of time.
4. Both NIST and David Chandler came to the conclusions that WTC accelerated for about 2.25 seconds at freefall.

Conclusions:
If David Chandler can perform an experiment that matches the results of NIST, it must prove he knows what he's doing. If NIST can use a video, so can David Chandler. If the videos of the WTC7 collapse of can be used to determine acceleration, then the videos of WTC1 and WTC2 can be used to determine acceleration.

I have provided evidence of constant acceleration. You just refuse to accept it by hiding behind insignificant minutia. Defects in the quality of the video are not enough to affect the measurement of acceleration.

Next...
 
Last edited:
Except that both NIST's and Chandler's data indicate that acceleration was not constant fir any length of time including the near g portion. In addition the work done by femr2 indicated that during that 2.25s period, acceleration momentarily exceeded g which definitively demonstrates that simple Newtonian motion is not the whole story and that another effect is in play. Likely a transfer of energy from earlier moving parts of the structure to those that began moving later.
 
Right now we are talking about Newton's first law of motion.

I will answer your question, only in regards to Newton's first law of motion. When we get to Newton's third law of motion, I will expand on my answer.

If the cart is at rest, it will only move when an unbalanced force is applied. Again, I am only going to discuss this example in terms of Newton's first law of motion. Bring this up again when we get to Newton's third law of motion.
The horse and cart ARE demonstrating first law of motion. If the horse is pulling the cart at a steady velocity all forces are balanced. ONE special case of v=0 also has all forces balanced. As long as acceleration=0 all forces are balanced but a=0 does not require v=0.
In the case of the constant velocity horse and cart , the force provided by the horse is equal to friction forces acting in the opposite direction.
 
I did, and I gave my example. I am willing to revisit this one more time if you post a link to the original post in question.
.
OK:
FalseFlag said:
The floors should have exerted an opposite and equal force on the falling mass.
This is false.

"Equal and opposite" applies to matched pairs of forces between the same two objects, not to any two simultaneous forces you happen to name.

The force of the gravitational attraction between the earth and the falling mass acts upon the falling mass, pulling it downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the earth, pulling it upward. (The earth, being rather large, does not move very much as a result of that pull. F = ma means a = F/m.)

Simultaneously, the force of the impact between the falling mass and a floor acts upon the floor, breaking it and accelerating the floor material downward. An equal and opposite force therefore acts upon the falling mass. That force might decelerate the falling mass, but only if that force exceeds the force of gravity pulling the falling mass down.

There is no physical law requiring the upward force of impact of the floor upon the falling mass to be equal in magnitude to the downward force of gravity acting upon the falling mass. And there is no reason to expect they would be equal. They are two different forces. As long as the latter is greater, there will be no deceleration. As the latter was in fact greater, there was no deceleration.
.
I see that later you quoted one line from that post then accused Myriad of not understanding that a collision involves equal and opposite forces. As I said, you didn't understand his point well enough to understand that you weren't responding to it. I tried restating it in my own words with the apparently futile hope that it might help you see the point he was actually making, because it's important, and your only response was that we're both wrong. I seriously doubt that the situation is going to improve, but if you'd like to try rereading it and responding on point, go for it. But pretending that you understand it won't do: Please start by restating in your own words what you think the issue is and then clearly state what you think is wrong with it.
 
AClark said:
That's all very well and mathy, but it makes some very glaring omissions. Primarily the trigonometry of the situation. If you are going to have pieces toppling, then you are going to need pivot points, and enough geometry for your javelin.
You are Moving the Goal Posts.

You had declared:
AClark said:
The amount of energy required to eject steel sections a considerable distance is very large...
So I asked:
Can you quantify this "very large" energy required?

There are basically two theories on the table that would explain the source of that energy:
  • Gravity (GPE - Gravitational Potential Energy)
  • Explosives (ChE - Chemical Energy)
I quantified the requirement for the first theory - that GPE is the energy source: Drop height of 10 to 40 floors - easily available for collapses starting 78+ floors above ground.

Remember: You made a claim about the quantity of energy.

Now you:
How much explosives (equivalent to chemical energy, ChE) does it take, per mass unit of steel to propel a steel section to 60 mph?
That calculation is much less straightforward.
I have done it.
Have you?
Can you guess?
 
The horse and cart ARE demonstrating first law of motion. If the horse is pulling the cart at a steady velocity all forces are balanced. ONE special case of v=0 also has all forces balanced. As long as acceleration=0 all forces are balanced but a=0 does not require v=0.
In the case of the constant velocity horse and cart , the force provided by the horse is equal to friction forces acting in the opposite direction.

I found this page on the horse & cart problem, and it clearly states the points that FalseFlag just can't comprehend:

  • Newton's third law action/reaction forces act on different bodies.
  • Forces that contribute to the net force on a body act on that body, not on different bodies.

So, while the impact force of the upper block on the lower equals that of the lower block upon the upper (those are the different bodies), one must consider all the forces on the upper block in order to calculate its acceleration.

These forces include gravity.
 
FalseFlag,

This will be short. Just a demo.
You’re scorching case of Dunning-Kruger has earned you “don’t bother” status.

Your challenge is meaningless.
Newton’s Laws are not broken by anything that NIST analyzed or concluded.

Your understanding of Newton’s laws, on the other hand, is virtually non-existent.

The fundamental question here is “Is scaling a crucial concern in structural modeling?”

The correct application of Newton’s laws is, in fact, crucial to that discussion.
Unfortunately, your lack of understanding of “How to apply Newton’s laws” prevents you from seeing how that comes to pass.

So I’ll have to simply give you a “demonstration by example”.

Here is your textbook:
Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques, Second Edition
By Harry G. Harris
http://tinyurl.com/gra8ejf

You can read the 1st chapter with Google’s “Look Inside” feature.
In order to even be in this conversation, you need to understand:
1.2.1 Model classification (The collapse model is FAR MORE difficult than the hardest model listed here: The Dynamic Model. Dynamic models are rarely pushed to failure, and the results after failure are never cited as reliable.)
1.3 Historical Perspective (optional, but valuable)
1.6 Choice of Geometric Scale
1.7 The Modeling Process. Especially the 9 step study plan.
1.8 Advantages and Limitations of Model Analysis
1.9 Accuracy of Structural models

Then you should just peruse
1.10 Case studies To see the size of the effort that real engineers put into creating real engineering models.

Once you’ve read the above ...

Here is the Lecture Notes for a Laboratory in “Modeling in Structures” class
http://civil.eng.buffalo.edu/cie616...nd Scaling/Slides 2 Modeling and Scaling.pdf

Read pages 1 thru 21.
No, Seriously. Read them.

The math will be beyond you. Don’t worry about that.

Here are the salient points.
1. This is exactly the sort of analysis that must be done in order for your model to mean anything.

Under Remarks (pg 21)
1. "Elastic behavior" means small deflections, where there is no residual deformation after the loads are removed. This analysis is (comparatively) easy, once you know all the engineering listed above.

2. “Plastic behavior” means the stresses get higher, and permanent deformations to some components happen. This analysis is “non-linear” and is much, much harder than the linear elastic one.

We aren’t CLOSE to the difficulty of a collapse model yet.

3. Note this comment carefully:
"Design of models and their construction requires extreme care. Small variations can be critical for interpretation of results."
Pay attention to the words “extreme care” & “Small variations”.

4. "Non-linear structures can be studied using analytical models that are validated by scaled models.”

In other words, in a Non-Linear Dynamics model, do NOT plan on having your scaled model be GLOBALLY accurate. Break the problem down into small pieces, and IF you model the small pieces CAREFULLY & RIGOROUSLY, you may be able to use these results to inform small limited aspect of your mathematical (i.e., “analytical”) model.

The Collapse Model, that Cole claims to be producing, is far more complex than the most complex dynamics model described here.

Next step: Walk thru the Example starting on page 22.

A Prototype Bridge.

An incredibly SIMPLE structure.
An incredibly SIMPLE model.
A scale factor of 1:2.

Once again, read thru the text, and try to appreciate the various math required to get meaningful results.

In the text, “λ” means “scaling factor”.

λl = linear scaling factor = 2
λA = area scaling factor = 4
λI = moment of inertia s.f. = 16
λw = force s.f. = 4

The math for the 1:2 scale model of a simply supported bridge is complicated. Nothing that an engineering student can’t handle, but complex.

The care, the rigor, the math for a non-linear, dynamic model that is going to be “pushed to failure” is orders of magnitude more complex. And the results are orders of magnitude less reliable.
__

The scale factor for Cole’s collapse model was about 1:120

That means:
λl = linear scaling factor = 120
λA = area scaling factor = 14,400
λI = moment of inertia s.f. = 207,000,000
λw = force s.f. = 14,400

Meanwhile, he paid zero attention to ANY of the concepts described above.

His model is a joke.

Your understanding of structural models is the same.
__

Now, the saving grace of any effort to model the collapse of the towers is that “it doesn’t have to be accurate”.

Nobody is going to die if the analysis is wrong.
No building or bridge is going to collapse.

But the other side of that coin is that you are not going to get a model that accurately replicates the collapse of any real skyscraper.

And this is true whether you do it with a physical model, or with an analytic (math) model. Or even if you attempt to build a full sized mode (say of WTC7), try to emulate every single thing that happened, and watch to see if it fails in the same way.

The chances a fully rebuilt WTC7, with all the equipment & furnishings inside, damaged as accurately as possible, set on fire as accurately as possible, collapses are very high.

The chances that it collapses exactly the same manner are in distinguishable from 0.

Do you know what the really annoying thing about this whole fiasco is, FF?

That, after putting in 8 years getting your BS, MS & PhD, after spending decades more honing your skills on building models, performing this type of analysis, studying buildings that did & did not collapse …

… which is exactly what they NIST structural engineers did …

… when you get done with a first-rate analysis, done to the highest professional standards …

… you get to look forward to a bunch of know-nothing clueless amateurs critiquing your work, suggesting that you falsified your data, suggesting that you’re part of some giant conspiracy to hide treason & mass murder, out of evil intent, politics or cowardice …

… because your simulation “had a twist to it that the actual building did not.”

LMAO.
 
Last edited:
No. Here is a definition of uniform motion:


Thanks for the definition of uniform motion.

Now can you give us a real world example of an object in uniform motion?

Give us a perfect example of an object maintaining constant speed and direction as described in Newtons first law.
 
Here's where your explanation fails. It would be impossible for the chaotic and random micro-jolts to allow a constant acceleration for any length of time, even if that acceleration was considerably less than 9.8m/s/s.

Bare assertion fallacy; sorry, but you don't get to make up your facts. The average structural resistance is determined by the collapse mode and the structural strength of the lower structure, and these result in a more or less constant figure for the average acceleration, with small variations. These small variations are the micro-jolts we were talking about.

I absolutely agree with you, in theory, that micro-jolts would be nearly impossible to detect using the video and film footage that exists.

Wrong. They have been observed.

Dave

ETA: Actually, strike paragraph 1 above. Who said the acceleration was constant? It wasn't. We see micro-jolts all over the place; these are changes in acceleration. We see WTC7 accelerating slowly, then increasing up to freefall, then dropping as it starts to contact less damages parts of the structure below. We see all kinds of variations in acceleration, on both long and short timescales, exactly as you'd expect from a collection of random impacts. So your objection is rejected; it doesn't fit the facts.
 
Last edited:
Right now we are talking about Newton's first law of motion.

I will answer your question, only in regards to Newton's first law of motion. When we get to Newton's third law of motion, I will expand on my answer.

If the cart is at rest, it will only move when an unbalanced force is applied. Again, I am only going to discuss this example in terms of Newton's first law of motion. Bring this up again when we get to Newton's third law of motion.

We were on the third law a few days ago. You switched to this 'game' with the first law because you were getting thrashed on the third.
 
By the way:

I have already conceded that you can have magical steel, and a magical building structure,

In effect, you haven't conceded magical steel; you've insisted on it. The only way a collapse could cause a jolt large enough to cause actual deceleration is if a section of supports of constant length is completely removed simultaneously by a carefully controlled process, because it requires a single impact on a structure at least strong enough to bear the static weight of the falling section. Hence we see actual deceleration in verinage demolitions, where the collapse initiation is carefully and precisely controlled, and we might also see a similar deceleration in a top-down controlled demolition of the type truthers surmise may have happened. In a chaotically initiated collapse we expect the impacts to be distributed, giving no overall deceleration because no single impulse is strong enough. In reality, the absence of jolts greater than 1g is evidence against, not for, controlled demolition.

Dave
 
We were on the third law a few days ago. You switched to this 'game' with the first law because you were getting thrashed on the third.

It might appear that way right now. More than 24 hours have passed and no one completed any of challenges I put forth on Monday. Later today I will create another set of challenges discussing Newton's second law of motion. It should be pretty obvious then that challenges involving Newton's third law of motion will come after that.
 
You're also talking about average acceleration. Average acceleration is a meaningless number. The issues are constant acceleration and how long it was observed.

Since constant acceleration is now crucial to your argument, please post evidence that it was observed at any time in the collapse.

You may find this difficult.

Dave
 
By the way:



In effect, you haven't conceded magical steel; you've insisted on it. The only way a collapse could cause a jolt large enough to cause actual deceleration is if a section of supports of constant length is completely removed simultaneously by a carefully controlled process, because it requires a single impact on a structure at least strong enough to bear the static weight of the falling section. Hence we see actual deceleration in verinage demolitions, where the collapse initiation is carefully and precisely controlled, and we might also see a similar deceleration in a top-down controlled demolition of the type truthers surmise may have happened. In a chaotically initiated collapse we expect the impacts to be distributed, giving no overall deceleration because no single impulse is strong enough. In reality, the absence of jolts greater than 1g is evidence against, not for, controlled demolition.

Dave

No, I conceded magical steel to remove arguments about steel and structure in order to focus this discussion solely on Newton's three laws of motion. I have insisted on nothing.

You have also made a mistake I did not expect you to make.

In your post yesterday you said
The bit after the last comma is simply wrong, but the rest is in principle OK; every time part of the top section hits part of the bottom section, there is an impulse.
Then, to summarize, you claim there are numerous small impacts which lead to numerous small impulses.

You admit there are impulses of resistance in the opposite direction. This, by the very definition of an impulse of resistance in the one direction, would prevent constant acceleration in the opposite direction. This is your mistake.

You are trying to claim the impulses are so numerous and small that they combine to create a constant acceleration in the opposite force exerted by acceleration due to gravity. This is not going to happen.

You also claim in your original post that.
And that's exactly what we saw in all the WTC collapses, and it's also exactly what the best measurements of all the collapses show; lots of micro-jolts from small impulses when part of the structure collides with another part of the structure.
Please post supporting documentation of this.
 
I think you should answer that question yourself.

I'm asking YOU.

And no, the 'experts' aren't the colledge drop-out with no jobs and an axe to grind against the government. Real physics, the one you seem refering to, does not and cannot support the insane theories that 9/11 truthers spout about that event.

So, again: wouldn't you prefer to conclude from real data and real expertise rather than conspiracy nutjobs who are trying to sell you something?
 
Since constant acceleration is now crucial to your argument, please post evidence that it was observed at any time in the collapse.

You may find this difficult.

Dave

I have posted this repeatedly. I have posted proof that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of WTC 1, and I have posted proof that constant acceleration was observed during the collapse of WTC 7. NIST has also confirmed a constant acceleration of 9.8m/s/s for approximately 2.25 seconds during the collapse of WTC 7.

The fact that constant acceleration occurred is not open for debate; It happened.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom