I just now answered your question in that thread.
Thanks. Rather than splitting discussion across two threads, I'll reply to both your posts here.
If he was assistant manager at a Baskin-Robbins I would consider him an authority on ice cream. I might ask him for suggestions on a good flavor, but I would not consider him an expert on engineering topics.
Reasonable enough. Similarly, I do not consider you an expert on engineering, physics, or firefighting topics - all domains on which you have rendered opinions in this forum.
If he was an engineer, I would consider him an authority on topics related to engineering. I might ask him for his opinions on engineering topics. If he gave his opinion, and it clearly contradicted basic physics
See below; you're assuming that you understand and appropriately apply "basic physics" to the issue.
... and the opinions of other engineers,
But,
generally speaking, his opinions
are in line with the consensus of the engineering community. What you're saying here is that his opinions contradict a relatively small number of engineers with whom
you agree. But your agreement rests on implicit assumptions of your own ability to gauge the validity of "your" engineers. That's what I'm poking at - again, see below.
...I would still consider him an authority but his opinions would have no credibility. I would not ask him for future opinions. I would also consider his presence on a forum such as this highly suspect.
Then, as I've asked before, what is the point of asking him for his credentials? If he says that WTC buildings collapsed as a result of impact and fire damage, will his credentials have any effect whatsoever on your assessment of his position?
To beat you to your next post - I already said I am not an expert. You should not consider me an authority on engineering issues.
I can assure you, that is not a mistake I am likely to make.
What you should do is pay attention to credible engineers, and use your own judgement and understanding of basic physics to know who is right.
... Which brings us back to the problem of how you establish who is "credible", and how you know you understand
and correctly apply "basic physics".
Although I am not an expert, my educational background supports my claim that I understand basic physics...
...Your next question is, what is my educational background. Answer: It's more than enough to understand basic physics.
I wasn't going to ask what your educational background in physics is. I'm guessing high school, tops, but that's not really the point. How did you
verify that you "understand basic physics"? I'm not talking QM or electrodynamics or thermodynamics or even college-level mechanics. Just basic kinematics and dynamics.
My understanding of basic physics is enough to draw accurate conclusions based on what I can see during the collapses of WTC1, 2 and 7.
Exactly how did you
validate the assumptions implicit in your claim? In other words, how do you know that applying your "understand[ing] of basic physics" to your viewing of collapse imagery is done correctly, or even appropriately? How did you
validate that you really understand what you're seeing?
You can take a grade-school science class and understand Newton's laws of motion. I know you going to argue against this, because you must argue against everything I say. That does not mean you are right, or that I am wrong.
Of course not. The problem is, how do you know that "understand[ing] Newton's laws of motion" is sufficient for you to understand the failure mechanisms under discussion? Especially for you to dismiss the technical consensus of domain experts?
And, given your remarks about "credible" authority, I ask again - why does it matter to you at all whether he is a domain expert or not? Let me flip it around for you. If he
was assistant manager at Baskin-Robbins, but he agreed with everything you said, would you then find him a "credible" layman who understood "basic physics" and had "common sense"?