does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Tony Szamboti

Illuminator
Joined
Jun 2, 2007
Messages
4,976
I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the conclusions of the NIST reports, for the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that these NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.

The debate would take place on the 911 free forum, like the one I did with tfk, and the rules would be the same as those for that debate shown below.

1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.

2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) explaining what they believe caused the collapse of WTC 7 and briefly stating what they believe are the (approximately) 3 strongest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition" is the heart of the debate.

3. tfk will go first after both participants make an opening statement on June 21, 2016.

4. Each person shall make no more than one post per day and cannot make another until it is responded to.

5. If a post is not responded to within a week the person not responding is considered to have forfeited his turn & the other person will proceed with his next statement.

6. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words. If it is deemed necessary to exceed that limit, justification shall be provided by the person wanting to exceed it and agreement to by the other participant received prior to doing so. This should be done by private messaging, so as not to interrupt the flow of the debate, and should be the exception rather than the rule.

7. Each post will discuss one principle topic. Each topic consists of 4 posts. Person A will state a topic post, Person B replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

8. Every point that either person brings up must be addressed in some manner by the other. Both parties will do their best to stay focused on the original topic point.

9. There shall be no name calling, denigration, or defamatory language used. Each person shall bring only technical arguments to the debate. If any derogatory comments are used they shall be addressed to arguments only, not to individuals.

10. The debate will end after a maximum of 50 total posts, or earlier if the participants mutually agree to an earlier termination, or whenever either participant decides to stop responding.
 
Last edited:
There is nothing to debate IMO. It is futile. The few "truther" left can be left to their belief, they will be like those who STILL believe we did not land on the moon, or like holocaust denier. It does not matter how many evidence provided to them, they will deny it.

At this point the controlled demolition dank meme is just a belief so deep anchored it will only end when the person die of natural death.
 
There is nothing to debate IMO. It is futile. The few "truther" left can be left to their belief, they will be like those who STILL believe we did not land on the moon, or like holocaust denier. It does not matter how many evidence provided to them, they will deny it.

At this point the controlled demolition dank meme is just a belief so deep anchored it will only end when the person die of natural death.

You can't be taken seriously here, as you provide zero basis for your claim/opinion that there is nothing to debate.

Debates are what we use to move past opinions into what withstands scrutiny as reality based fact.
 
Last edited:
You can't be taken seriously here, as you provide zero basis for your claim/opinion that there is nothing to debate.

Debates are what we use to move past opinions into what withstands scrutiny as reality based fact.

Look, I am guessing you are a believer. Keep your belief. The world has moved on. History book have been written. People barely born at that time are now adult. It has been 15 years. If there was really something to that CT, it would have been known by now. But all that it is people dis-beliving the explanation of the plane hitting and killing the building.

Debate all you want. The world does not care. ETA: I have seen enough Cont dem in my summer of 20 and 21 to know what it entails. Did you ? That is a rhetoric question. No need to answer.

/thread
 
Last edited:
You can't be taken seriously here, as you provide zero basis for your claim/opinion that there is nothing to debate.

Debates are what we use to move past opinions into what withstands scrutiny as reality based fact.

As factual as that video you said you saw?
 
I have some time right now and am wondering if anyone here who supports the conclusions of the NIST reports, for the three high-rise collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001, would want to debate me one-on-one as I contend that these NIST reports have been shown to be non-explanatory and incorrect.

Why not take it up with NIST, since it's their conclusions you have issues with? All you can possibly get here is the opinions of a third party without access to the background data and results NIST worked from or obtained, which will be no more than an alternative interpretation to yours which can be debated endlessly with no possibility of resolution since both you and your interlocutor will be working with the same incomplete set of data.

Dave
 
What's to debate? the same debunked nonsense?
After sixteen years it gets wearisome.
Fact isn't up for debate, NIST reports, despite what some may think aren't theological texts.
 
I fully understand your need for attention Tony, however I have no desire to give attention to an over simplified protagonists.
The towers were coming apart inside before the top block fell, and your last FEA used multiple springs to dissipate to much energy from the girder, ignoring totally the leverage effects a second hinge would produce.
You treated the girder as if its heating and stiffness were uniform real steel in fire doesn't act that way.
 
Oh, and one other thing: As has been repeatedly stated by numerous posters here on many occasions, and answering what I have no doubt is your unstated agenda here, Tony, there is a crucial difference between finding faults with the NIST model - which is intended to determine the most probable collapse sequence with a view to proposing modifications to building codes that will alleviate the damage in future occurrences - and establishing any doubt that the collapse was due entirely to the damage sustained by the building due to debris impact from other collapses and fires within the building. The latter would require either that any possible debris and fire related collapse sequence, rather than the specific sequence outlined by NIST, be shown to be at the very least highly implausible, or that specific and credible evidence be produced of some other cause of collapse; this does not include quote mining, vague, ambiguous or unverified eyewitness accounts, or speculation. In short, even if someone were foolish enough to take up this challenge and fail at it, it would not produce the result you want it to.

Dave
 
2. Each person shall make an opening statement (of no more than 500 words) explaining what they believe caused the collapse of WTC 7 and briefly stating what they believe are the (approximately) 3 strongest pieces of verifiable evidence for/against Controlled Demolition, as "Controlled Demolition vs. No Controlled Demolition" is the heart of the debate.

Beyond "It looks like CD", "mumble, mumble freefall mumble" and "ITS OWN FOOTPRINT!!!!!", has this ever actually been done?
After 15 years, AFAIK, we have
  • No trace of explosives in the debris.
  • No sound of explosives.
  • No witnesses who saw the buildings being prepped for demolition.
  • No whistleblowers who were involved, and who have now come forward.
  • No coherent explanation of how both thermite and explosives were used.
  • No explanation of how the thermite, explosives and all the associated fuses etc. survived 7 hours of being in an uncontrolled fire.
Tony, did I miss something? What evidence do you have for CD? I'm serious: I'd really like to know.
 
Beyond "It looks like CD", "mumble, mumble freefall mumble" and "ITS OWN FOOTPRINT!!!!!", has this ever actually been done?
After 15 years, AFAIK, we have
  • No trace of explosives in the debris.
  • No sound of explosives.
  • No witnesses who saw the buildings being prepped for demolition.
  • No whistleblowers who were involved, and who have now come forward.
  • No coherent explanation of how both thermite and explosives were used.
  • No explanation of how the thermite, explosives and all the associated fuses etc. survived 7 hours of being in an uncontrolled fire.
Tony, did I miss something? What evidence do you have for CD? I'm serious: I'd really like to know.

You forgot, no mushroomed steel, from thermite-thermate cutting.
 
You can't be taken seriously here, as you provide zero basis for your claim/opinion that there is nothing to debate.

Oh, I disagree. The thing's been debated to death, and no amount of evidence or reasoning will change the true believers' beliefs. If you want to believe in a conspiracy, you will.
 
Oh, I disagree. The thing's been debated to death, and no amount of evidence or reasoning will change the true believers' beliefs. If you want to believe in a conspiracy, you will.

I would debate if I could use experimential evidence to show fraudulent behavior of AE/9/11 truth, and by said evidence that Tony has no moral quams about himself supporting a fraudulent organization.
 
1. The debate is restricted to the collapses of WTC 1, 2 & 7 in NYC on September 11, 2001, the NIST reports on these events, and any additional objectively verifiable information and analyses in the public domain about them.



In other words you lack the courage to discuss 9/11 as a whole.

Before any more useless debates can happen, you have to be prepared to tie all four plane crashes together in a manner that better explains them than reality.

Absent that, your pathetic little movement is just a joke.
 
In other words you lack the courage to discuss 9/11 as a whole.

Before any more useless debates can happen, you have to be prepared to tie all four plane crashes together in a manner that better explains them than reality.

Absent that, your pathetic little movement is just a joke.

Now, Now Tony's movement isn't a Joke, at this point it is pure unadulterated fraud.

It was always a fraud and always will be a fraud, with hoaxed experiments, that prove that PT Barnum's statement that, "A sucker is born everyday." was one hundred percent accurate
Except the internet has made it a sucker born per second.
 
Given that not only NIST but the CTBUH, the AIA, the ASCE, Purdue University, Nordenson and Associates, and other recognized professional organizations ALL unequivocally agree that impact and fire induced damage caused the collapses of the three WTC structures, then I feel it is with these organizations with which you should debate.

OTOH, I am quite sure that all or most of them would feel it beneath them to engage in a debate on a web forum on such a fringe issue. What would you debate? AE911T's full study and report on the collapses? No, of course not. AE911T has NEVER engaged in such a report despite supposedly having a cadre of 2000+ professionals in the field whose expertise might be put to such use.
 
Last edited:
So, Tony, as for the value of debating on the internet:
The entire rason d'etre, it appears, of AE911T, is education about the events of 9/11.

EXACTLY how has the cause been advanced by having tfk withdraw from an internet forum debate?

EXACTLY how has tfk withdrawing from debate increased the technical veracity of the claims?

EXACTLY how would debating a different internet poster further the cause of AE911T, or increase the veracity of the claims that AE911T make?
 
Given that not only NIST but the CTBUH, the AIA, the ASCE, Purdue University, Nordenson and Associates, and other recognized professional organizations ALL unequivocally agree that impact and fire induced damage caused the collapses of the three WTC structures, then I feel it is with these organizations with which you should debate.

OTOH, I am quite sure that all or most of them would feel it beneath them to engage in a debate on a web forum on such a fringe issue. What would you debate? AE911T's full study and report on the collapses? No, of course not. AE911T has NEVER engaged in such a report despite supposedly having a cadre of 2000+ professionals in the field whose expertise might be put to such use.

It goes back further than that to Tony's mentor, Steven E. Jones

Does anyone think such worthless experiments as this Molten Aluminum Experiment: Molten Aluminum Experiment: http://youtu.be/SQdkyaO56OY could ever duplicate a large molt of Aluminum reacting with nitrogen fire retardants in plastics?

You see I can point to the actual fraudulent behavior of all the experimenters, and show how and why they are frauds all the way back to Jones.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom