Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

You. Seem to be only able to understand things by trying to control the conversation. The clown car comment isn't usually associated with honesty. Its usually intended as a simple insult. Which is why I posted "with total control"

Yes, Trumpians are in total control. Of a clown car.
[/QUOTE]
 
You. Seem [sic] to be only able to understand things by trying to control the conversation.

If you think that preventing you from changing the topic is "controlling the conversation" then you have no idea how conversations work.

The clown car comment isn't usually associated with honesty. Its usually intended as a simple insult. Which is why I posted "with total control"

That doesn't follow. How would "total control" somehow address an insult?

I feel like I have to spoon feed you through all these posts.

That's hilarious, since you can't even be bothered to understand the subjects you are discussing or even to follow the thread of the conversation.

You understand why your posting with others ALWAYS ends up in confusion?

Now you're just lying.
 
Hard to imagine a thread about 'understanding' the other side has gone like this, what with the auspicious beginning that the title sets the tone for.

If you want greater understanding, spend less time making declarative statements (especially hostile ones) and more time making queries.

This applies to both all sides.

Fair enough; let's see what I can do during break time. For conservatives or liberals, one cannot help but use broad stereotypes, but here goes. I would agree that the world that I understand many conservatives would like to see is one in which ethical behavior becomes more of a norm. I like the mental picture of hard-working people taking care of family and providing health, wealth (in measure), and security for those under their remit. I like the idea of less crime, less fear, and more mutual respect.

Where we part ways is in this:
  • I believe values are not values at all until turned into virtues. This involves "walking the talk" even when, especially when, it runs directly counter to self-interest.
  • I believe there is indeed a cultural tradition in the West, mostly Christian inspired, that as a secular humanist I can relate to in terms of many ethics, as summarized in the traditional virtues.
  • The poor ethical results in practice, apart from not walking the talk, come from having forgotten the other list: vices. To tout virtues alone is to praise Jekyll, but ignore Hyde.
Values translate into virtues by first turning them into basic principles as guidelines. An example might be: Value: all humans are "created" equal; Principle: the laws and means for ordering daily life should be applied in same and equal measure to all adults. Principles are the operating guidelines for creating social institutions, including government and private enterprise. Following the example, ideally, would lead to "blind" justice and "blind" decision-making in all walks of life, including laws, constitutions, and private enterprise/corporate charters.

In theory and on paper, over the course of US history to take as example, we can see there are swings in the support for, and basic walk required, to turn laudable principles into action and behavior. The maxims thought to best govern private enterprise have varied from focused corporate charters to get, say, a local electrical dam built, to value-neutral financial operations, and finally to nearly unrestricted behavior tethered only begrudgingly by force. Corporate ethics, today, is the elbow-dig joke course in all MBA programs.

***

We've heard much of values. What does the old list of virtues and vices look like?
Virtues:
Greeks: temperance, wisdom, justice, and courage
Christian: chastity*, temperance, charity, diligence, patience, kindness, and humility (*not just "keep it in your pants")

Vices:
Christian: pride, greed, lust, envy, gluttony, wrath, and sloth
Also expressed as deadly sins:

1. A proud (vain) look
2. A lying tongue
3. Hands that shed innocent blood
4. A heart that deviseth wicked acts
5. Feet that be swift in running to mischief
6. A false witness that speaketh lies
7. He that soweth discord among brethren

I leave off the easy pot shot that last list provides. However, I would invite those identifying as conservative, especially but not limited to Christians, to give pause and consider the above. How is charity practiced without encouraging sloth, but without abandoning all acts of kindness? How does one live the American Dream without falling into pride and gluttony, yet still be a responsible adult?

Why not agree on a short list?:
Honor the truth.
Meet commitments.
Celebrate differences.
Wait on understanding before acting.

If that is somehow threatening, I wonder if there is any recourse left to us to reach meaningful mutual accommodation.
 
Lol

There is nothing more polarizing than liberal politics... Your side wrote the book on pitting one group against the other.

Is this the anger stage. ;)

By insisting that both groups should have the same rights?

Your "conservative" mask is slipping.
 
I would think most enjoy others and being apart of something, especially something they agree with.

I have difficulty understanding why someone enjoy being part of a set of political policies. I don’t chose my position on policy based on political party, I choose my political party based on it it’s alignment with my views on a number of individual policies. As such I have no particularly affiliation or connection to the political party, it’s there to server my wishes not dictate them.

IMO single issue voters aside, there is a general tendency in US politics “Conservatives” to choose their stand on issues based on their political affiliation while Liberals chose their political affiliation based on their stance on the issues. This probably has more to do with the “Liberal” political parties being more centrist and “Conservatives” trending more towards the extreme and extremists in general tilt more towards ideological purity. The Conservative tendency towards favoring Authoritarianism could play a role as well, as could the strict party line discipline developed when Republicans were in a minority position in Congress.
 
I have difficulty understanding why someone enjoy being part of a set of political policies. I don’t chose my position on policy based on political party, I choose my political party based on it it’s alignment with my views on a number of individual policies. As such I have no particularly affiliation or connection to the political party, it’s there to server my wishes not dictate them.

Same here. Each election, I look up the parties with a shot at winning in my district and at the provincial or federal level, and vote for the ones that represent my interests best. Political parties do change over time, at least up here.
 
I think you are right. But I will say this. Though it might not apply so much in the US as it does here in Canada, when I argue a conservative view point, most of the time, the person I'm arguing has never even heard argument before. My own example is minimum wage. I remember being around 20 (like 18 years ago) and reading on the internet arguments against minimum wage, like no minimum wage, by hugely influential economists. Now I don't want to start an argument on minimum wage (I don't mind it myself), but I say it just to point out I was stunned that the argument existed. Same goes with the wage gap (the right leaning economists view vs say the left wing liberals view). Popular culture, what most people are exposed to, would only ever point to the more left leaning side of most arguments.


It exists on the other side to. Conservatives usually don't get a liberals argument on the legalization of drugs, or maybe why tough on crime policies might backfire, stuff like that. But for the most part people are mostly exposed to liberal view points.

Getting back to something I wrote, and took some heat for earlier in this thread. There are benefits and disbenefits to a minimum wage, furthermore the disbenefits grow the higher you set it. The real debate should be about where the crossover point is, and the answer isn’t the same everywhere. In some cases that crossover point may even be zero, but that can still be a possibility in a debate over how high.

What we see in conservative rhetoric is typically “minimum wage is bad” while Liberal rhetoric typically something like “minimum wage in X(city, state, country) should be higher”. The latter comes closest to the actual discussion that should be taking place.

On a whole range of topics Republcian/Conservative voters almost always go with the simple ideological idealistic argument. Eg
“taxes are bad so we always oppose taxes” even though other real debate should be weighting taxes vs services.
“Military is good so we always support more military spending” even though the real debate should be centered on how much military is required and weighing that against the taxation required to support it.
“Drugs are bad so we always oppose legalization” even though legalization can be a better approach to dealing with the problems drugs create.
“Teen sex is bad so we oppose sex education” even though the practical consideration is that sex education doesn’t change the rate of teen sex and reduces the associated problems
“Free markets are good therefore we always oppose regulation” even though regulation is essential in keeping a free market functioning because it’s the most practical way to deal market failures. The real discussion needs to be about how aggressively you attack market failures because there are some cases where the cure is worse than the original problem.

There are some issue like abortion where I find both sides equally glued to a polarized absolute ideological position, but off the top of my head I can’t really think of any major issue where Democrats take and absolutist position while Republicans are more open to a pragmatic discussion.
 
. . . but off the top of my head I can’t really think of any major issue where Democrats take and absolutist position while Republicans are more open to a pragmatic discussion.

This is my take, too. I'm quite willing to be disavowed of this impression, however, if there are some who can speak to this on behalf of US conservatives/Republicans.

I have no political party affiliation, no preconceived notion of the relative size or power of federal vs. state governments, no opinion as to what corporate tax rates should be, etc. I support Roe v. Wade and the 2nd Amendment, but I'm open to regulations that modify both. I want to see greater investment in wind and solar power but I think we're going about it in entirely the wrong way. I'm strongly pro-nuclear power, pro-equal rights under the law, pro-1st Amendment, and support efforts to reduce the influence of money and religion on government policy. I think economic models based on growth are ultimately unsustainable and wish we could figure out how to thrive under a steady-state model. I don't know how big our military needs to be but I do know that we need to do much more to care for our veterans. I agree that we need to do a better job to secure our borders but I'm a lot more concerned about the employers who hire illegal immigrants than I am about the people they hire.

That's a mixed bag of positions that is well to the left and the right of what most folks would consider "liberal" in the US. My sense is that this is not too unusual for left-leaning folks. Is nuance like this on multiple issues common in right-leaning folks?
 
Part of what is missing in the discussion is that fiscal / government minimalizing conservatives may be approaching their view from one of valuing efficiency as a means of sustainability of civilization. Government inefficiency, ever growing, cannot be sustained as the best way to distribute resources. Of course, unrestrained capitalism also leads to inefficiencies, so some regulatory controls or incentives also need to be in place. I don't want to debate this point in this thread, just add it for understanding.
 
You seem to be assuming that the expenditure wouldn't increase? I'm not following why you think it would be the same amount spent, but now everyone gets covered? I'm sure there's a simple piece I'm missing :)

Why would universal healthcare in the USA cause some kids to go without food? You've not joined the dots.
 
Why would universal healthcare in the USA cause some kids to go without food? You've not joined the dots.

Because america is far to poor to care for all its children, so it needs to choose which ones to sacrifice. We just need to be more open about it and use some kind of lottery system.
 
Chris B, why are these two so hostile to you? You seem to engage them with clear thought, honest answers and civility. What gives?

It has nothing to do with the discussion at hand and everything to do with past discussions in another thread. I grew tired of the constant attacks there so I don't post there anymore. Seems as though some still crave confrontation and followed me here. Typical of the Liberal ideology.....Chris B.
 
Emily's Cat vs plague311 is the same basic argument I get stuck in.

I can't demand any contribution from all able members of the community for a charitable cause anyway, and if I try to do so without first contributing everything I possibly could myself, I'm a hypocrite too.

If there's a million people in the community and a tenth of them need help I don't want one thousand people contributing everything to help them, I want half a million people contributing a little to help them.

Too many people feel like they're being played for a chump or can't make a difference if they give charitably, and so don't, for me to feel comfortable relying on optional charity only for all social programs. I feel like social assistance is infrastructure, full stop.

Similarly I can't understand why there's opposition to opt-out rather than opt-in organ donation status. Most people just won't take the time or consideration to go and opt in.
 
Last edited:
It has nothing to do with the discussion at hand and everything to do with past discussions in another thread. I grew tired of the constant attacks there so I don't post there anymore. Seems as though some still crave confrontation and followed me here. Typical of the Liberal ideology.....Chris B.

I assume you're talking about the Bigfoot thread. Can't remember last time I was there.

You made a big show of stating you would never shoot anything live. But then you had said you had brought your gun while out looking for bigfoot. Then you claim the gun is only to scare away said bigfeet. It appears you are using a gun as just a noisemaker. That is not the purpose of a gun and it shouldn't be used as such from a gun safety point of view.

So where does Liberal ideology fit into all that?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom