Why Liberal Suck at Understanding Conservatives and Why it Matters

Emily's Cat vs plague311 is the same basic argument I get stuck in.

I can't demand any contribution from all able members of the community for a charitable cause anyway, and if I try to do so without first contributing everything I possibly could myself, I'm a hypocrite too.

If there's a million people in the community and a tenth of them need help I don't want one thousand people contributing everything to help them, I want half a million people contributing a little to help them.

Too many people feel like they're being played for a chump or can't make a difference if they give charitably, and so don't, for me to feel comfortable relying on optional charity only for all social programs. I feel like social assistance is infrastructure, full stop.

Similarly I can't understand why there's opposition to opt-out rather than opt-in organ donation status. Most people just won't take the time or consideration to go and opt in.

Absolutely. Which, to me, is pretty much a false dichotomy or at least some fallacy.
 
It has nothing to do with the discussion at hand and everything to do with past discussions in another thread. I grew tired of the constant attacks there so I don't post there anymore. Seems as though some still crave confrontation and followed me here. Typical of the Liberal ideology.....Chris B.
Nope, just pointing out the inconsistencies and contradictions in your posts. By the way, if I have an ideology, it's independent.
 
Why would universal healthcare in the USA cause some kids to go without food? You've not joined the dots.

Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today. That would require either a reduction in other government spending or increased taxes, or some combination thereof. I suppose it's technically possible that the US government could cut spending from some program that doesn't somehow directly affect any actual people... but I'm not going to hang my hat on that assumption.

My best guess is that Universal Healthcare would be accomplished through raising taxes. And for at least some people, that increase in taxes will result in lower take-home pay, with enough marginal impact to affect other necessities. In this case, the example being a reduction in food spend for that family.
 
Because america is far to poor to care for all its children, so it needs to choose which ones to sacrifice. We just need to be more open about it and use some kind of lottery system.

Children of cannibals will have less corpses to dine on.

Such charitable, considerate, and respectful viewpoint couldn't possibly lead to a cessation of discussion, could it? :rolleyes:
 
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today. That would require either a reduction in other government spending or increased taxes, or some combination thereof. I suppose it's technically possible that the US government could cut spending from some program that doesn't somehow directly affect any actual people... but I'm not going to hang my hat on that assumption.

Cut military spending, increase healthcare.

Boom.
 
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today

Not necessarily. The US spends as much as a percentage of GDP as any other nation on socialized healthcare just to cover a small percentage of the entire population instead of the whole thing. So conceivably it could be done with out raising more tax revenue. It would just result in much less income for some sectors of the economy and a loss of jobs in there.

It depends on if the system is determined to keep up profits for companies like the one that makes the Epipen, who's big complaint was that as it is classified as to not be covered by insurance consumers could see how they were jacking up the price.
 
Such charitable, considerate, and respectful viewpoint couldn't possibly lead to a cessation of discussion, could it? :rolleyes:

It is a summation of your claim. We can't afford universal health care with out things like life time maximums of coverage. As many other nations do that clearly if we can not afford it we are terribly poor.
 
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today. That would require either a reduction in other government spending or increased taxes, or some combination thereof. I suppose it's technically possible that the US government could cut spending from some program that doesn't somehow directly affect any actual people... but I'm not going to hang my hat on that assumption.

My best guess is that Universal Healthcare would be accomplished through raising taxes. And for at least some people, that increase in taxes will result in lower take-home pay, with enough marginal impact to affect other necessities. In this case, the example being a reduction in food spend for that family.
Why? Just tax those making more than 200 000. Plenty to tax there. The CEO of blue cross blue shield, a nonprofit, makes 30 million a year. We should tax 80%.
 
Why? Just tax those making more than 200 000.
Or $500k - whatever. It doesn't matter that wealthy people pay more in absolute taxes than middle class and poor people, what matters is what percentage of their vital operating expenses those taxes consume. You could tax a rich guy at a really high rate before he has to buy off-brand peanut butter to make ends meet.
 
Why? Just tax those making more than 200 000. Plenty to tax there. The CEO of blue cross blue shield, a nonprofit, makes 30 million a year. We should tax 80%.
Why 80%? Why not 99%?

We'll see if you can figure out why your idea would be a disaster.
 
Just a heads-up on my posting schedule: I will not likely be able to post anything for the rest of today, 12/15/2016. I will try to post responses to things on Friday. But, the weekend is looking thin on posting opportunities, as well.
So, depending on the number of responses, you might not necessarily hear much from me until Monday.

Just saying this so no one thinks I am abandoning this thread, or anything. I want this to go on, and I have more new content in the planning, to post. But, it seems I happen to have some sort of life outside of this Forum, right now.

No its no weird its observstion of fact. You might want to reflect on itb. I mean feel free to disagree but at least have an argument.
I know. I was being facetious.

If had spent more time writing a proper thread, I would have tried to make it appeal more internationally. (In fact, Haidt found his foundations do work across cultures, though each one give different names to each side.) Since this was based on a U.S. SkeptiCamp presentation, it ended up very U.S. oriented.

But, while that problem applies to the parent post, we CAN make the discussion below more generic, I suppose. (Even though I posted this under the USA Politics sub-forum.)

How do conservatives who favour stricter gun laws fit into this?
The Care/Harm foundation is so much stronger in Liberals (guns being a tool designed specifically to cause harm), that they do not see how other values, such as Liberty (in the ironically-non-Liberal-in-this-context sense) and Authority, etc., could have other things to say on the matter.

In other words, what in political science is called "negative freedom", favoured by Classical Liberals.
Yeah, it looks that way.

Perhaps then the term is too narrowly defined, just to exclude them. Or the definition of "liberal" is wrong.
Perhaps it might be best to look beyond the words used, and to look at the basic idea, that there are differing moral value foundations between groups of people. There are only 2 or 3 discernably large groups, though there are certainly people who will not fit so well into any of them.

And, more to the point, these differences are causing people on one part of the line to feel alien to people on another.

For convenience, we can label each of the 2 largest sides something: It could be "liberal" and "conservative", or it could be "big-endians" and "little-endians" for all the difference it actually makes to the theory. The larger message is the basics of the theory.


I am not convinced this is true.
Do you see any harm in some of us putting it into practice, to find out?

Are those papers accessible somewhere?
There is a References section in the back of the book, but I have not had time to try to dig any of them up, yet, to find out.

You chose to present the theory here. I think you could do more to explain it.
And, I shall! Over the course of this thread, I hope.

Though, I am not exactly the world's foremost expert on this subject matter, and information is not quite as readily available as other subjects I like to debate about (such as Evolutionary Theory). So, I am going to end up lacking on the complicating details.

I think that if one plans to put this theory to use, in an informal environment, they can at least get started with what was outlined in the book. And, anyone planning to make an actual political career out of it can read the fine-print papers (or have their advisors read the papers).

I don't think understanding political movements is helped by stubbornly holding on to a liberal/conservative dichotomy. Especially since those are not even opposites; there are political movements that are liberal and conservative at the same time without necessarily being centrist.
Stubborn is not quite the right word. We can acknowledge that there is a wide spectrum of political beliefs, and sometimes that may become important in communicating with people (as a professional politician might find).

For MOST informal purposes, it is sufficient to SUMMARIZE the landscape of political beliefs into a small number of groups. It is better to understand people in those terms, than to assume there are no such groups at all, and that everyone should think the same exact way.

Maybe it is because some people just don't believe in miracles :p
I will have to find a way to better explain the 'Markets Are Miraculous' point, I guess. (Maybe when it is not 2AM in the morning, for me.)

The differences are so vast between Conservatives and Liberals. The 2nd Amendment and gun control are a small part of the differing views.
I agree that the differences are vast enough, that it causes such heated arguments! Thus, the point of this thread.

Though, underneath it all, they also might find that they have a surprising amount in common. Care for others is actually strong enough to make a difference on all sides of the aisle, for one thing.

One big thing that we will never agree on is abortion. I don't believe it should be legal. Why? Simple, killing is wrong. Taking life is wrong, no matter what the reason is.
For the record, my own stance is that abortion should be avoided; except in cases of rape, incest, or the life of the mother is threatened.
But, I consider myself a moderate, and cannot speak properly for liberals. And, as usual, you do not need to agree with me on that.

I doubt anyone, other than psychopaths, would disagree that killing is wrong. So, the debate seems to center around whether a fetus counts as a live human or not. I know science tries to resolve that issue, but it seems there are values beyond what it has to say on the matter.

While liberals and conservatives may disagree with each other over this for a long time, I think liberals CAN take a crack at understanding the conservative side. This article I found identifies several relevant value differences that can be better understood by liberals: https://pages.shanti.virginia.edu/PPOL_3260_Blog/2012/11/20/the-morality-of-abortion/
Sanctity/Degradation might be the main one, followed by Loyalty/Betrayal and even a touch of Authority/Subversion.
(Sometimes the names of the foundations will differ from what I had in my posts. Sometimes they will be pairs of opposites, like this.)


Unfortunately, this very topic might be one of the most challenging for one side to come up with compelling arguments for the other. But, that does NOT mean understanding each other cannot be constructive in some way.

Perhaps you could put this discussion on a more pragmatic footing by an example. Can you take a liberal policy position such as marriage equality and use your understanding of conservatism to phrase a supporting argument that would appeal to conservatives? (If you don't like that topic, pick another.) We have some conservatives here that you can try it out on.
This is a very good exercise! One I would like to expand on, in future posts!

For the case of marriage equality, there are a couple approaches one could take, though I don't know which would be the most effective for this topic.

1. There are other types of purity and sanctity to consider: Gay marriage would make everyone more virtuous, and less promiscuous. They will be allowed to enjoy the relationships they desire, rather than being forced into a lifetime of something they do not.

2. It should NOT the role of government to determine the course of individual lives, when it comes to marriage.

With more time, we can develop these lines of arguments more fully. And, there may be others we can come up with.

As noted above, the subject of abortion might be one of the most difficult topics to develop effective appeals using this approach.

Seriously, can we table the gun discussion now?
I agree that the actual debate on gun control belongs in a different thread.

But, if anyone has anything to say that is relevant to the VALUES at play, within the debate, those comments can stay.

Or, if someone offers a compelling alternative theory for our differences in understanding, they can feel free to use the subject of gun control to illustrate that one, if they wish.

xjx388's response wasn't directed at you. It was a response to Travis.
Sorry. He did not use quote tags, so I got confused.


I feel Skepticism has ignored the actual fundamentals of learning, and merely resorted to repeating facts. It's not working, it's obviously not working

You make some very good points! I think I will pick up that book!

The problem isn't a lack of understanding by Liberals, it's that they've given up trying to advance any alternative to the mean spirited and self-centred philosophy that's become the mainstream.
I think the more fundamental problem is that most liberals are not using the right kind of "translation software" (so to speak). The mean-spirited stuff comes out of frustration, but a reboot with better "software" can avoid that.

By the way, Diplomacy Matters! In order to converse persuasively with the other side, just knowing about these moral value differences, alone, won't do the trick. Being respectful and diplomatic are also important ingredients.

I did not mention diplomacy much in this thread, before, because the focus was more foundational than that. But, it bears a mention at least once, I suppose!

Liberals need to understand working class, rustbelt independents who could go either way. Not conservatives.
I agree that the political spectrum is much broader than conservatives and liberals (as Earthborn likes to point out). But, understanding conservatives is still part of a comprehensive understanding of everyone, including those who might swing from side to side.

If you want greater understanding, spend less time making declarative statements (especially hostile ones) and more time making queries.
Hear, hear!

It may take some time, but with practice, we can get there.

There are some issue like abortion where I find both sides equally glued to a polarized absolute ideological position, but off the top of my head I can’t really think of any major issue where Democrats take and absolutist position while Republicans are more open to a pragmatic discussion.
...and the reasons could be because of differences in moral foundations.

Whether that is correct or not, studying the fundamental reasons why these observations occur could change the habits of those doing the talking. There could be ways for liberals to more effectively sell their ideas, by using non-pragmatic arguments that appeal to conservatives, based on whatever those fundamental reasons turn out to be.

Part of what is missing in the discussion is that fiscal / government minimalizing conservatives may be approaching their view from one of valuing efficiency as a means of sustainability of civilization. Government inefficiency, ever growing, cannot be sustained as the best way to distribute resources. Of course, unrestrained capitalism also leads to inefficiencies, so some regulatory controls or incentives also need to be in place. I don't want to debate this point in this thread, just add it for understanding.
I agree there needs to be balance in regulations. One could debate how to do that in another thread, yes.

But, if you would like, we could delve into why different groups of people have different interpretations of what "small government" means. Both seem to want it, to a certain degree. But, argue over which services are essential and which are wasteful.
 
Last edited:
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today. That would require either a reduction in other government spending or increased taxes, or some combination thereof. I suppose it's technically possible that the US government could cut spending from some program that doesn't somehow directly affect any actual people... but I'm not going to hang my hat on that assumption.

My best guess is that Universal Healthcare would be accomplished through raising taxes. And for at least some people, that increase in taxes will result in lower take-home pay, with enough marginal impact to affect other necessities. In this case, the example being a reduction in food spend for that family.

On the other hand, if it brought our per-capita health care costs down to that of other OECD countries, then the taxes paid would be offset by the drop in personal expenditures meaning a rise in disposable income and an increase in cyclical consumption in other areas which itself would result in increased revenues collected through taxes.

If you want to look at the economy as a comprehensive, integrated system, that is. Totally crazy, I know!
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, if it brought our per-capita health care costs down to that of other OECD countries, then the taxes paid would be offset by the drop in personal expenditures meaning a rise in disposable income and an increase in cyclical consumption in other areas which itself would result in increased revenues collected through taxes.

If you want to look at the economy as a comprehensive, integrated system, that is. Totally crazy, I know!

Does it bring costs down though?

It would be interesting to see how much bang for the buck the VA gets compared to the private sector.
 
During the Eisenhower era, when America was the great nation your President to be wants to make it again, tax on the richest in the country (who were, compared to today's 1% were not so rich) was at about that level. So it seems, taxing the rich at an appropriate rate can produce a successful and rich country. And really, if you are earning $200 million a year, you are saying you couldn't get by on about $40 million, which is what an 80% tax rate would leave you with? Really high taxes would only be aimed at the super rich btw, with a progressive scale of taxation at other levels. That is what all sensible nations round the world tried to do in the past before the super rich bought our democracies.
 
Universal healthcare in the US would necessitate increased government expenditures relative to what is spent today. That would require either a reduction in other government spending or increased taxes, or some combination thereof. I suppose it's technically possible that the US government could cut spending from some program that doesn't somehow directly affect any actual people... but I'm not going to hang my hat on that assumption.

My best guess is that Universal Healthcare would be accomplished through raising taxes. And for at least some people, that increase in taxes will result in lower take-home pay, with enough marginal impact to affect other necessities. In this case, the example being a reduction in food spend for that family.
Why would it require the USA government to spend more?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom