JayUtah
Penultimate Amazing
And since I think every one of us can point to at least one detail Tony has got wrong,...
I certainly did, but that's years ago. The debate has moved on since then.
But I have to agree with you. The question that's important to me is what happened on 9/11. I don't think any one study is universally comprehensive and accurate, but I think there's enough in aggregation to build up a general picture that confirms the conventional narrative as the most plausible explanation. That said, I think the mark of a rational person is being open to hearing alternative theories. In other words, the general goal of open-mindedness is met by not dismissing claims on their face but rather by hearing them waiting to judge them on their merits. We've done that for Tony, and have ample reasons to reject his claim on the merits.
But what we get from Tony et al. is not so much an alternative theory for the events of 9/11 as it is a fairly narrowly-tailored "NIST is bad" theory. This is similar to the most common practice among JFK conspiracy theorists: it's a "Warren Commission was wrong" theory, not so much a "who killed Kennedy?" theory. And here as there, the conspiracy theorist always wants the debate to look like someone stepping up to be the proxy for his designated enemy. And more importantly, he wants the proxy to have the burden of proof to defend the designee. (I believe this is usually because the designated enemy generally won't give conspiracy theorists the time of day.)
So it becomes a quest for personal validation, which most of us seem unwilling to satisfy. That manifests itself in the paradoxical approach of expressing disdain for critics for their unwillingness to debate, insinuating it's because they know they'll lose as opposed to their having seen through the ploy. The other side of the paradox is the implied value of such a debate as the sine qua non of the issue. The claimant needs to believe his interlocutor is a credible proxy. But he also needs to believe we're a bunch of irrelevant low-lifes for not wanting to engage on his terms.
