does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

At least at one point, Tony's conspiracy theory was that someone either leaned on NIST to fudge the results, or someone within NIST took it upon themselves to fudge them. Tony's crusade was to restore the good name of NIST.

I've re-read the NIST WTC7 report, and while I'm not going to pretend I get the engineering, I grasp their recommendations, which stem from the collapse (same is true with their report on WTC1 & 2). Had someone fudged the information then it follows that their suggested changes would not make sense in places...yet they do.

The new WTC7 and WTC1 were built using the NIST changes, and in some cases exceeding them.

My business got a warning from the city fire marshal for not having insulation around the drain and water pipes between the floors. When we asked them why the change we were told this came out of 9-11.

I interpret NIST's work on WTC7 as going out of their way not to point fingers at design flaws stemming from questionable code changes made by the city to allow the Port Authority to build #7 as designed to avoid inflicting a string of lawsuits on the city. I can't say if this lead to fuzzy interpretations of the engineering, but it may explain why debate about the actual trigger for the collapse still goes on.

I doubt we will ever get a solid answer for that, but nobody was killed in or around #7, and the NIST recommendations seem to have been added to building codes around the country meaning the ultimate goal for the report was achieved.
 
As I see it, the CD debate is already over because fire and impact evidence has been presented and such evidence is clear and undeniable whereas video and audio evidence in conjunction with seismic data and lack of CD hardware at WTC ground zero has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that no CD evidence ever existed.

15 years and counting and still, no CD evidence to present in a debate.

No one ever said it was going to be a long debate :D
 
I've re-read the NIST WTC7 report, and while I'm not going to pretend I get the engineering, I grasp their recommendations, which stem from the collapse (same is true with their report on WTC1 & 2). Had someone fudged the information then it follows that their suggested changes would not make sense in places...yet they do.

The new WTC7 and WTC1 were built using the NIST changes, and in some cases exceeding them.

My business got a warning from the city fire marshal for not having insulation around the drain and water pipes between the floors. When we asked them why the change we were told this came out of 9-11.

I interpret NIST's work on WTC7 as going out of their way not to point fingers at design flaws stemming from questionable code changes made by the city to allow the Port Authority to build #7 as designed to avoid inflicting a string of lawsuits on the city. I can't say if this lead to fuzzy interpretations of the engineering, but it may explain why debate about the actual trigger for the collapse still goes on.

I doubt we will ever get a solid answer for that, but nobody was killed in or around #7, and the NIST recommendations seem to have been added to building codes around the country meaning the ultimate goal for the report was achieved.

Most of the NIST recommendations stemming from their work on the WTC collapses were not adopted by the IBC. See https://digwithin.net/2012/09/07/are-tall-buildings-safer/
 
As I see it, the CD debate is already over because fire and impact evidence has been presented and such evidence is clear and undeniable whereas video and audio evidence in conjunction with seismic data and lack of CD hardware at WTC ground zero has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that no CD evidence ever existed.

15 years and counting and still, no CD evidence to present in a debate.
No one ever said it was going to be a long debate :D
It would be even shorter if members did not fall for the trap of "debating" the technical issues.

The foundation premises are false and take them out Tony has NOTHING to discuss.

Most of Tony's "Twin Towers" claims arise out of - depend on TWO related sets of errors. First in time was his misrepresentation of Bazant to support "Missing Jolt". Second and more important is the broader context for that which is that Tony does not understand the "initiation and transition to progression" mechanisms - the first two stages of Twin Towers three stages of collapse).

But it would be easer - and allow Tony far less "wriggle room " ;) - to once again show that he is wrong on MJ AND Then move to the more complicate stuff - that he doesn't understand the real mechanism. Rebut both those and ALL of Tony Szamboti's Twin Towers claims are falsified.

UNLESS the debater is into "troll feeding"and wants to continue going round in circles discussing technical detail which is of zero significance when it has no foundation of logic in T Sz's "arguments". AKA unsupported bare assertions based on personal incredulity. "I don't understand so ...."

On WTC7 - simply pull the plug on Tony's "false dichotomy" which says "Nordenson et al" are wrong THEREFORE I, Tony, am right!" Blatant nonsense. There is no need to even discuss whether or not Nordenson, Weidlinger et al were right or wrong. Tony's argument is falsified in foundation (lack of foundation???) logic. If he finds 100 professionals who are wrong his own claim remains unproven until he makes and supports an affirmative claim.

Tony has been playing and winning with the same trick since 2007 when I identified it in my first Internet post:

me-on another forum said:
The paper ...by Tony Szamboti is typical of many which look impressive in detail... The complex calculations may even be correct but the base premises are faulty and the resulting conclusions can readily be demonstrated to be totally wrong.
 
Last edited:
Most of the NIST recommendations stemming from their work on the WTC collapses were not adopted by the IBC. See https://digwithin.net/2012/09/07/are-tall-buildings-safer/

You linked to a Truther site?

How about one professional firefighters read instead:

http://www.sustainable-design.ie/fire/structdesfire.htm#service

Their take on NIST:

http://www.cjwalsh.ie/2011/10/nists-recommendations-on-the-9-11-wtc-building-collapses/

Or the NFPA:

http://www.nfpa.org/news-and-resear...-october-2011/features/a-decade-of-difference

Then there is this:

http://www.cleveland.com/science/index.ssf/2011/08/a_decade_after_the_911_attacks.html

This:

http://www.campussafetymagazine.com/article/9-11-Prompts-New-Building-and-Fire-Codes-to-Emerge

This:

https://www.nibs.org/news/100420/How-Building-Sciences-Have-Changed-Since-911.htm

And I could keep going but I'll stop with the elevator folks:

http://www.elevatorworld.com/magazi...craper-safety-improvements-advance-after-911/

Couple of points:

I would argue that corners were cut in the construction of WTC7, just as they are in many big-scale construction projects. NIST hints at this.

I would also argue that fire protection and suppression technologies on 9/11/2001 were clearly lagging behind the engineering that was making buildings taller, but just as there weren't enough life-boats on the Titanic, nobody wanted to spend the money on research and upgrades.

The WTC did receive added fire-resistant foam after the 1993 attacks, but as of today I have never seen a comprehensive inspection report from the FDNY which looked at every floor. I would bet money that the focus was on the lower floors to prevent fire from another truck bomb.

The foam insulation was clearly knocked clean from the steel from the impacts of the jets, and the collapse of both towers may have been enough to degrade the insulation of WTC7.

Whatever mysteries behind the collapse of 7 may be, their root causes are fire, and structural damage
 
I knew Oystein would run from such a fair debate, but who would have expected such speed.

Indeed, his acceleration is impressive these days. But has his efficiency at producing a flood of comments with excuses and diversions improved as well? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11542138&postcount=2562

An interesting ISF forum development is apparent...

In early 2015, Oystein and other "debunkers" here were all very sure of themselves in their failed arguments defending the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC7, to the point of making utter fools of themselves in their desperation to defend NIST, as perfectly exemplified by one "skeptic" called WilliamSeger http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10521740&postcount=4469 :

Before completely discounting the walk-off hypothesis (and pardon me for rehashing for the umpteenth time), what about the eastward displacement of column 79, or the induced torsion found in the Chapter 8 simulation? And if we still can't find enough reason to believe the girder was pushed off its seat, what about being pulled off the seat by thermal contraction, or just a general floor structure collapse, as suggested by the CTBUH?

...But now by the end of 2016, these same people refuse to enter a one-on-one debate where they would be expected to defend the NIST report, and the excuses are blatantly pathetic. Suddenly, people that have spent years on this forum and other forums defending the NIST report claim there is no point debating whether or not the NIST report was erroneous. Obviously they failed to "find enough reason to believe" and want to change the subject. And, it should be noted that the NIST explanations for the Twin Towers have been given the same classification of irrelevance as well. Although some people still find it hard to admit it in public, it has become obvious to everyone that has really looked into the NIST reports that they are bunkum.

JM Talboo, March 2, 2015:
Ziggi Zugam is testing the remnants of the disgraced forum that once belonged to JREF, to see if anyone there can provide scientific support for NIST´s collapse initation theory for Building 7. The frontman of this forum, Skeptic Magazine writer Reverend Chris Mohr has been notified and encouraged to carefully observe the behavior and alleged knowledge of his forum buddies.

Interested readers are encouraged to observe this debate, and see if NIST´s story is as utterly unscientific and wrong as suspected. In addition, it should be interesting for "people on the fence" to discover how little scrutiny NIST´s story has received on this supposed forum of hard-core skeptics, or in other words, see how pseudo-skeptics have managed to bury the problems under the rug for more than 6 years. Yes, NIST´s final report on Building 7 was published in 2008.

It has been predicted that the prominent defenders of NIST on this forum will find excuses to avoid the discussion, and that their troll friends will attempt to bury the discussion with BS, in an effort to divert attention. http://911debunkers.blogspot.is/2015/03/a-disgraced-forum-tested-one-last-time.html
 
You linked to a Truther site?
From that link
Despite its grandiose claims, NIST knows that the building community has ignored the WTC investigation findings.
More than adequately demonstrated as a damn lie by your short list


It might have been more accurate to say that many of NIST's recommendations have been ignored not by the "building community", but by political organizations.
 
Last edited:
The foam insulation was clearly knocked clean from the steel from the impacts of the jets, and the collapse of both towers may have been enough to degrade the insulation of WTC7.


I agree! Take a look at these WTC fire-resistive coating inspection photos and notice how poorly fire-resistive coatings were applied.

"FIREPROOFING" AT THE WTC TOWERS

th_111463.jpg


th_111459.jpg


th_111465.jpg


http://www.fireengineering.com/arti...e-rebirth/fireproofing-at-the-wtc-towers.html
 
.................
An interesting ISF forum development is apparent...

.......
...But now by the end of 2016, these same people refuse to enter a one-on-one debate where they would be expected to defend the NIST report, and the excuses are blatantly pathetic.

1) How will one on one debates further your desire for a new investigation? What is it's purpose?

2) All studies of WTC7's collapse converge on fire induced multifloor collapses that are the first step in progressive collapse that leads to global involvement.

3) As I recall it, most if not all debunkers here did not so much defend NIST's initiating event as point out that it was described as a "most probable" first event but that many other factors would have been in play such as column spreading, stresses induced due to loss of SW corner and other impact damage, and stresses due to fires on other floors.

4) WRT the towers, many here distinctly describe collapse and include how jolt could not happen and how internal collapse led perimeter peel, and core destruction.

5) NIST was not alone in studying any if these three buildings. There are numerous professional engineering organizations that have, and exactly none have deduced that anything other than impact and fire was responsible for the demise of theee buildings. A point made numerous times in this forum's pages.


OTOH, the extreme paucity of any engineering study from those who deny the commonly accepted history of the events of 9/11, has been pointed out. The fact that the leading "9/11truth" group, while loudly touting support of 2000+ engineers and architects, has chosen to spend funds raised not on engineering, but to concentrate on sending Gage and a few others on speaking tours for the general public. Little effort has been made to ellicit support from recognized professional organizations.

Lately Tony Sz. has declared that the steel temperatures used in the WAI report are ridiculoys despite not having any research to back his declaration up ( since neither he or any other professional at AE911T has been bothered to produce a fire spread/intensity study) , nor bothering to try to find the fire engineering study that is cited by Abboud.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, his acceleration is impressive these days. But has his efficiency at producing a flood of comments with excuses and diversions improved as well?

Let's take a look to see how long it took WTC 7 to fully collapse.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrIBOTfRFXo

...But now by the end of 2016, these same people refuse to enter a one-on-one debate where they would be expected to defend the NIST report, and the excuses are blatantly pathetic.

Tony want's to debate in order to prove the collapse of WTC 7 was the result of CD and do so without a shred of evidence. Had explosives been used, the evidence would have been clearly heard on various videos and yet, not one single video depicts the sound of demolition explosions as WTC 7 collapsed and the same can be said in regards to WTC 1 and WTC 2. To properly rig the WTC buildings with explosives in secret would have been impossible.
 
Last edited:
Indeed, his acceleration is impressive these days. But has his efficiency at producing a flood of comments with excuses and diversions improved as well?


Let's take a look to see how long it took WTC 7 to fully collapse.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrIBOTfRFXo


Tony want's to debate in order to prove the collapse of WTC 7 was the result of CD and do so without a shred of evidence. Had explosives been used, the evidence would have been clearly heard on various videos and yet, not one single video depicts the sound of demolition explosions as WTC 7 collapsed and the same can be said in regards to WTC 1 and WTC 2. To properly rig the WTC buildings with explosives in secret would have been impossible.
Without direct and undeniable CD evidence, time would be better spent counting vehicles on an interstate highway rather than wasting time debating CD on WTC for which no evidence exist.
 
Indeed, his acceleration is impressive these days. But has his efficiency at producing a flood of comments with excuses and diversions improved as well? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11542138&postcount=2562

An interesting ISF forum development is apparent...

In early 2015, Oystein and other "debunkers" here were all very sure of themselves in their failed arguments defending the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC7, to the point of making utter fools of themselves in their desperation to defend NIST, as perfectly exemplified by one "skeptic" called WilliamSeger http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10521740&postcount=4469 :



...But now by the end of 2016, these same people refuse to enter a one-on-one debate where they would be expected to defend the NIST report, and the excuses are blatantly pathetic. Suddenly, people that have spent years on this forum and other forums defending the NIST report claim there is no point debating whether or not the NIST report was erroneous. Obviously they failed to "find enough reason to believe" and want to change the subject. And, it should be noted that the NIST explanations for the Twin Towers have been given the same classification of irrelevance as well. Although some people still find it hard to admit it in public, it has become obvious to everyone that has really looked into the NIST reports that they are bunkum.

JM Talboo, March 2, 2015:
Come one, come all, a debate of fantasy; by 9/11 truth.

15 years of weak personal attacks based on the no evidence CD fantasy.

Go post on the debunking the debunkers web site of woo, proof 9/11 truth is based on lies, fantasy, and zero knowledge of science. Where is the evidence for CD, locked up in a fantasy world of lies, named "truth". A name out of 1984 and NAZI like, calling idiotic lies the "truth".
 
Last edited:
3. Each starting post will be considered a topic. Discussion of a topic consists of a maximum of 4 posts. Person A will start a post on a specific issue/topic. Person B then replies, Person A counters, then Person B counters, and that topic is closed. Person B then leads off the next sequence.

4. Individual posts are limited to 1,000 words.

As usual, the proposed terms of the debate are designed to set up a false equivalence by limiting discussion of the mountain of evidence in favour of what actually happened on 9/11 to a maximum of 2,000 words per topic, in the knowledge that it only takes less than ten to say "I don't believe this, therefore it's wrong."

Dave
 
Indeed, his acceleration is impressive these days. But has his efficiency at producing a flood of comments with excuses and diversions improved as well? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11542138&postcount=2562

An interesting ISF forum development is apparent...

In early 2015, Oystein and other "debunkers" here were all very sure of themselves in their failed arguments defending the NIST explanation for the collapse of WTC7, to the point of making utter fools of themselves in their desperation to defend NIST, as perfectly exemplified by one "skeptic" called WilliamSeger http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=10521740&postcount=4469 :



...But now by the end of 2016, these same people refuse to enter a one-on-one debate where they would be expected to defend the NIST report, and the excuses are blatantly pathetic. Suddenly, people that have spent years on this forum and other forums defending the NIST report claim there is no point debating whether or not the NIST report was erroneous. Obviously they failed to "find enough reason to believe" and want to change the subject. And, it should be noted that the NIST explanations for the Twin Towers have been given the same classification of irrelevance as well. Although some people still find it hard to admit it in public, it has become obvious to everyone that has really looked into the NIST reports that they are bunkum.

JM Talboo, March 2, 2015:

That's a great rant coming from the author of the Mark Basile Fraud.

Just what bank, account, or trust fund, did you say that $5000USD was deposited in?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom