does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

Visitors with open minds can better see both sides of each issue. Wading through mountains of ‘cut ’n paste’ garbage and rant posts tends to keep visitors away.

You could argue that the first bird that flew into WTC7 was “the first step in a ‘progressive collapse’. The term is really quite meaningless.

What "bird" flew into 7 WTC?

CD describes well what was observed.

Except for the lack of deafening noise, blast effects, windows shattered for blocks in every direction, lethal high velocity ejecta, blast damaged steel, and any physical evidence whatsoever for the presence of malicious pre-planted devices you are totally correct.

Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.

So much deliberate dishonesty, so little time.

A colourful ability to describe one’s chosen hypothesis that fails to be supported by engineering science has zero credibility.

And how much engineering science supports CD at the WTC? Just curious.

The problem is a lazy, acceptance of history as it is published by the mainstream media.

As opposed to,.... Youtube?

Lie much?

Do you (see above)?

Dr. Hulsey and his team, as part of their ongoing study, have declared unequivocally that fire was not the cause of WTC7’s collapse.

Yeah, and Husley reached that conclusion before publishing any data.

How would you react if a quasi "official" agency - lets call it NIST - reached a conclusion without publishing any data? Would it be OK as long as they reached the conclusion you want?
 
What "bird" flew into 7 WTC?
Have to admit I have never heard the "pigeons did it theory" before. :rolleyes:

Except for the lack of deafening noise, blast effects, windows shattered for blocks in every direction, lethal high velocity ejecta, blast damaged steel, and any physical evidence whatsoever for the presence of malicious pre-planted devices you are totally correct.

Or any actual CD sequence. Instead, truthers simply make it up as they go along, like a really bad movie.

So much deliberate dishonesty, so little time.
Cubicle- attempt at minimalizing fires that would be classed as severe on not one or two floors but several
Sudden- ignores all but 2.25 seconds of a 20 second collapse
Desperately clinging- projection

And how much engineering science supports CD at the WTC? Just curious.

Oh, oh pick me, pick me. The answer is exactly none.

As opposed to,.... Youtube?

As opposed to actually understanding what I wrote, or deliberately ignoring it.

Do you (see above)?
Either that or a really bad case of insufficient reading comprehesion.


Yeah, and Husley reached that conclusion before publishing any data.

How would you react if a quasi "official" agency - lets call it NIST - reached a conclusion without publishing any data? Would it be OK as long as they reached the conclusion you want?
He and his compadres would be apoplectic.
 
Does your alter ego Oystein feel incapable of defending his views on this subject?

Here's thing, ozeco41 and Oystein tend to answer questions, honest questions not trolling questions, all the time. Since I have been posting here both have been happy to answer my questions, guide me to credible sources where I can learn more about this subject, and have politely corrected me when I'm wrong about key facts.

In short they're grownups.

They're also professionals, and like the others who post here who are professionals in their fields they are happy to help educate others because that's what professionals do. They have never dodged a legitimate question since I've been here.

Tony's not asking legitimate questions, and is trying to rig a "debate" in his favor. Over the years there have been legitimate debates on this board about WTC7, which can take the time to read and learn from, where it is clear there are a few of unanswered question about the collapse. Not one centers around CD. The idea that one cannot get a fair hearing here is bullocks. If you have real independent evidence you can present it and defend it here...we're still waiting...:thumbsup:
 
TS sure I would debate you one-on-one. I am particularly busy these days with architectural projects. I only have time on weekends and it’s going to take me a few weeks to review the new additional studies. I can begin the 3 rd week of February.
Of course, the other two posters pgimeno and another one (?) take precedence If they wish. What do you say, are you game for February.
 
CD describes well what was observed.


Absolutely false, and I might add that CD is not supported by demolition and seismic experts nor by the majority of structural engineers.

Brent Blanchard: Demolition Expert

Brent Blanchard, a leading professional and writer in the controlled demolition industry, publishes a 12-page report that says it refutes claims that the World Trade Center was destroyed with explosives.

Brent Blanchard devotes section 4 of his paper to the issue of seismic recordings on 9/11. Blanchard is Senior Editor of ImplosionWorld, a website which posts details of explosive demolitions, and also Director of Field Operations at Protec Documentation Services, Inc. Protec works in the field of vibration monitoring and structure inspection, a key service to both the construction and demolition industries.

Vibration monitoring performed by independent experts has long been considered crucial for companies carrying out explosive demolition, because owners of nearby buildings are keen to sue if any cracks or other structural damage appears.

The field seismographs used by Protec and others provide the key scientific evidence for disturbances that may have caused damage, and there were a number of such seismographs operated by Protec on 9/11 in the vicinity of Ground Zero, for monitoring construction sites. Blanchard tells us that data from these machines and seismographs operated elsewhere, all confirm single vibration events recording the collapse. None of them record the tell-tale 'spikes' that would indicate explosive detonations prior to collapse.
This evidence makes a compelling argument against explosive demolition. The laws of physics dictate that any detonation powerful enough to defeat steel columns would have transferred excess energy through those same columns into the ground, and would certainly have been detected by at least one of the monitors that were sensitive enough to record the structural collapses.


WTC Seismic Spikes

Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory of Columbia University

"There is no scientific basis for the conclusion that explosions brought down the towers," Lerner-Lam tells PM. "That representation of our work is categorically incorrect and not in context."

The report issued by Lamont-Doherty includes various graphs showing the seismic readings produced by the planes crashing into the two towers as well as the later collapse of both buildings. WhatReallyHappened.com chooses to display only one graph (Graph 1), which shows the readings over a 30-minute time span.

On that graph, the 8- and 10-second collapses appear—misleadingly—as a pair of sudden spikes. Lamont-Doherty's 40-second plot of the same data (Graph 2) gives a much more detailed picture: The seismic waves—blue for the South Tower, red for the North Tower—start small and then escalate as the buildings rumble to the ground. Translation: no bombs.
http://www.implosionworld.com/Article-WTC STUDY 8-06 w clarif as of 9-8-06 .pdf
 
Criteria;1163717 Do you not believe that any of those “2 said:
Let's take at the real numbers.

There are 123,000 members of ASCE(American Society of Civil Engineers) who do not question the NIST Report. There are also 80,000 members of AIA(American Institute of Architects) who do not question the NIST Report.

There are 120,000 members of ASME(American Society of Mechanical Engineers) who do not question the NIST report. There are also 370,000 members of IEEE(Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers) who do not question the NIST report.

There are also 40,000 members of AIChE(American Institute of Chemical Engineers) who do not question the NIST Report. There are also 35,000 members of AIAA (American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics) who do not question the NIST report.

http://911-engineers.blogspot.com/


As you can see, the overwhelming number of experts do not support WTC conspiracy theorist


On the investigation side, Dr. Hulsey’s study is being funded by AE911T.


Let's take at look at AE911T and Richard Gage

ARCHITECT Magazine
The Magzine of the American Institute of Architects

All of Gage’s so-called evidence has been rebutted in peer-reviewed papers, by the Federal Emergency Management Agency, by the National Institute for Standards and Technology, by the American Society of Civil Engineers, by the 9/11 Commission Report, and, perhaps most memorably, by the 110-year-old engineering journal Popular Mechanics.


WTC 7 Collapse Full - Do you hear explosives?


​
 
Last edited:
TS sure I would debate you one-on-one. I am particularly busy these days with architectural projects. I only have time on weekends and it’s going to take me a few weeks to review the new additional studies. I can begin the 3 rd week of February.
Of course, the other two posters pgimeno and another one (?) take precedence If they wish. What do you say, are you game for February.

Basque, that is fine. I can wait.

You will need to join the 911 Free Forum if you aren't already a member there. You can then PM me from there when you are ready, as their PMs go to one's e-mail. Thus I will know relatively quickly without having to constantly check where I could also miss it.
 
Last edited:
Office cubicle fires heating fire-proofed structural steel to the point of sudden global collapse was only observed by the minds of those who desperately cling to the NIST hypothesis.

I have had a brainwave.

We do not need another pointless debate. No sir, what we need is a winner-take-all game show. It will be a simple format, multiple choice and the first one to get it right wins... everything.

Q. Which of these images best represents a mere office cubicle fire?


A.
office-on-fire.jpg



B.
cubicle-decorating-warm-and-cozy.jpg.838x0_q80.jpg


Or

C.
WTC7_Fires_DoD02_Still.jpg
 
That's a great rant coming from the author of the Mark Basile Fraud.

Just what bank, account, or trust fund, did you say that $5000USD was deposited in?

Since there's never been any accounting, nobody really knows how much money was collected. It may have been many times that amount. Considering that the fundraising went on for over 5 years, this does not appear unlikely.

What we do know for sure is that no results have ever been published on what would have been a simple, cheap, and quick series of tests. Draw your own conclusions.
 
TS sure I would debate you one-on-one. I am particularly busy these days with architectural projects. I only have time on weekends and it’s going to take me a few weeks to review the new additional studies. I can begin the 3 rd week of February.
Of course, the other two posters pgimeno and another one (?) take precedence If they wish. What do you say, are you game for February.

Why "debate" someone so clearly dishonest?
 
I have had a brainwave.

We do not need another pointless debate. No sir, what we need is a winner-take-all game show. It will be a simple format, multiple choice and the first one to get it right wins... everything.

Q. Which of these images best represents a mere office cubicle fire?


A. [qimg]http://cdn.bleedingcool.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/office-on-fire.jpg[/qimg]


B. [qimg]http://media.mnn.com/assets/images/2015/12/cubicle-decorating-warm-and-cozy.jpg.838x0_q80.jpg[/qimg]

Or

C. [qimg]http://911myths.com/images/b/b4/WTC7_Fires_DoD02_Still.jpg[/qimg]


A of course.
 
I have had a brainwave.

We do not need another pointless debate. No sir, what we need is a winner-take-all game show. It will be a simple format, multiple choice and the first one to get it right wins... everything.

Q. Which of these images best represents a mere office cubicle fire?


A. [qimg]http://cdn.bleedingcool.net/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/office-on-fire.jpg[/qimg]


B. [qimg]http://media.mnn.com/assets/images/2015/12/cubicle-decorating-warm-and-cozy.jpg.838x0_q80.jpg[/qimg]

Or

C. [qimg]http://911myths.com/images/b/b4/WTC7_Fires_DoD02_Still.jpg[/qimg]

This is like those Facebook quizzes that state " Only 30% of people get these questions right". You click on them and go through 10 questions in 20 seconds, done and correct.
 
This is like those Facebook quizzes that state " Only 30% of people get these questions right". You click on them and go through 10 questions in 20 seconds, done and correct.

I never said it was going to be difficult.
 
...Oystein and other "debunkers" here ...
Does your alter ego Oystein feel incapable of defending his views on this subject?

Hehe.

Ziggi and Criteria hate me like the plague.
Why?
I ask them questions sometimes. Straight, relevant questions.
I ask them to provide straight, honest answers.
Every single time, they fail to provide straight, honest answers.
Ziggi has by now gone to the low of pretending he doesn't read my questions any longer.
Criteria still exposes himself time and time again by not aswering my questions.

Ziggi and Criteria are both many dozends of straight, honest answers behind.
It bugs them no end.

So they try to yank my chain.


I wear your angry, malicious call-outs as a badge of honour.
I got to y'all
:cool:
 
I have lost count of the number of times I have had to post, pointing out that Criteria et al, while quoting me, have utterly failed to address what they quote me posting.

ETA: (this happens with others quoted by the same posters as well)

It has gone beyond credible that these are all mistakes, and misreading, and would instead imply deliberate misrepresentation and obfuscation.

This has always been Criteria's SOP: Quote, fudge with the quotes in strange ways (like add quote marks in addition to QUOTE tags; insert INDENT tags that enclose nothing...), but he totally, systematically fails to address the content of the quotes.
For example, if he quotes a question, he fails to answer it.

Another, secondary tactic is to quote only the most irrelevant bit of longer posts and respond to them, while not using ellipses to indicate that, and where, parts of the quoted post were left out.


All this editing and fudging seems to me to be proof of the deliberate nature of his non-answers and evasions.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom