does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

We may be talking past each other here, CC
In design, we work really hard to not be so close to the edge, as it were, that we have to worry about ductile vs brittle (static vs impact) loading on fasteners. This is especially true in commercial use, where a number of factors are beyond our control, such as maintenance and field repair, not to mention field assembly.
Using threaded fasteners, we generally design so that the holes are tightly toleranced and then torque to a pretty high preload (typically 75-90% of yield, with the upper end being "Do not reuse this fastener" if you ever take it apart), to avoid slop and impact loading. We also design for Bearing Failure (the parent material around the hole yields) which tends to equalize the loads on fasteners in a pattern. That way we can go to zero margin at ultimate load.
If a joint is shear critical (Shear margin< Bearing Margin), we always allow a 15% margin (Margin is (allowable/actual)-Safety Factor) and we use the Minimum Allowable spec for that fastener

I was on a crew that assembled a few smaller (100 foot) transmission towers and the material that came with it dictated that the fasteners NEVER be re-used, and that only grade 5 fasteners be used to replace bolts and nuts during routine maintenance(which we also carried out yearly)
 
I was on a crew that assembled a few smaller (100 foot) transmission towers and the material that came with it dictated that the fasteners NEVER be re-used, and that only grade 5 fasteners be used to replace bolts and nuts during routine maintenance(which we also carried out yearly)
Unfortunately, there are those who disregard such instructions. That's one of the reasons we have such high safety factors on stuff. Field folks often "use what they got". Aircraft maint. folks tend to be more highly trained and informed, plus there is a paperwork trail on every step...
So, you are at a complete loss as to what concept Mick was demonstrating? Here's a hint though,,,, it has absolutely nothing at all to do with the post of Crazy Chainsaw's that you quoted.

Perhaps you should take it up with him at Metabunk.org rather than discussing it here then.
 
We may be talking past each other here, CC
In design, we work really hard to not be so close to the edge, as it were, that we have to worry about ductile vs brittle (static vs impact) loading on fasteners. This is especially true in commercial use, where a number of factors are beyond our control, such as maintenance and field repair, not to mention field assembly.
Using threaded fasteners, we generally design so that the holes are tightly toleranced and then torque to a pretty high preload (typically 75-90% of yield, with the upper end being "Do not reuse this fastener" if you ever take it apart), to avoid slop and impact loading. We also design for Bearing Failure (the parent material around the hole yields) which tends to equalize the loads on fasteners in a pattern. That way we can go to zero margin at ultimate load.
If a joint is shear critical (Shear margin< Bearing Margin), we always allow a 15% margin (Margin is (allowable/actual)-Safety Factor) and we use the Minimum Allowable spec for that fastener

I agree I was not referring to design, I was referring to the science of forensic engineering determining failure modes in structure, Tony is trying to use a design tool to disprove a forensic engineering study, and doesn't understand why it doesn't work that way.

I have 385 experimental studies, none supports his Opinion that is why I asked for one that does.

Thank you I value your engineering and design skills but this has to be looked at though Forensic engineering studies to gain any insite.
 
Unfortunately, there are those who disregard such instructions. That's one of the reasons we have such high safety factors on stuff. Field folks often "use what they got". Aircraft maint. folks tend to be more highly trained and informed, plus there is a paperwork trail on every step...

Well, we were the guys having to climb the towers. It was bad enough that on inspection a year later, some small nuts on cross arms would back off due to wind vibrations, (despite the lock washers) occasionally even coming right off. (grabbing a cross arm that then pivots around the bolt of the other end while 60 feet off the ground is,,,, puckering) We preferred to use the components instructed.
 
Remember heat transfers from hot to cold, so the only time that should be considered is when the object transferring the heat to another object is actually hotter than it.

How many minutes are the Cardington gas temperatures above the temperature that the WAI report claims the steel on floors 9 and 10 got to?

You're dodging the question and so I can only assume you do understand how utterly incorrect Korol's approach is but you are incapable of having a reasoned discussion about it. But go ahead and post something that actially supports Korol's 25 min-only heating times and prove me wrong. Your analysis here is ludicrous--as if only a "max temperature" fire (and Korol's max temperature does not actually even match the experimental Cardington or NIST results) would heat a building element. I can only image how you'd react if Bailey or Beyler used a method as transparently incorrect as Korol.

In Tony's world, fires magically teleport from place to place at a "maximum" temperature (100 C lower than their experimentally observed maximum temperature) for no more than 25 min at a time. Obviously these magical teleporting fires could not destroy wtc 7, so we need a new investigation!
 
Last edited:
I agree I was not referring to design, I was referring to the science of forensic engineering determining failure modes in structure, Tony is trying to use a design tool to disprove a forensic engineering study, and doesn't understand why it doesn't work that way.

I have 385 experimental studies, none supports his Opinion that is why I asked for one that does.

Thank you I value your engineering and design skills but this has to be looked at though Forensic engineering studies to gain any insite.
That's why I said "Talking past each other"
Tony is using a FEM in a non-FEM-appropriate application, it would appear.
In the analysis end of things, for design, nearly everything gets analyzed to steady-state static, or transient dynamics. Occasionally, a random vibration (my particular claim to fame) analysis is required/performed. But you leave plenty of "wiggle room" in there, and your models tend to have joints that are not particularly detailed, and even when detailed, the FEA will not truly treat them appropriately for anything other than a quasi-static loading.
You do separate joint analysis, using the "Grid Point Force" (NASTRAN) or equivalent output to perform that analysis. Restraints/constraints/grounds tend to be rigid, and most FEMs over-constrain the boundarys and joints (90% of FEA problems come from the boundary conditions)
In forensic analysis, damn near every fastener needs to be rigid, or very stiff. Rigid is better because excessive stiffness changes ill-condition the [K] (stiffness matrix) leading to the problem of large differences in small numbers/small differences in large numbers-- Mathematical errors. It is Finite Element Modeling (or Analysis), not continuous system analysis
The reason for that is exactly as you stated: the Brittle behavior of materials due to sudden loading can be considerably different from ductile behavior. You need to examine the worst case possible, without the deflection that the math inherently calculates for. Even Non-Linear FEM cannot overcome the limitations of the math.

This is why even relatively light taps with a hammer will break stuff that you could pull on all day and just bend it.


ETA: Just to clarify a bit: Modeling relies essentially on a single formula, Hooke's Law. F=KX. In the dynamics portion, for transient events, it adds Newton in to the equation, as well as some damping so that
Statics is F=KX
Dynamics is F=[M[{X''}+{X'}+[K]{X}

All of the effort in a FEM-FEA package goes into forming [K] and [M], along with [T] such that {X}=[T]{Xi}.
The rest is just matrix Algebra
 
Last edited:
I think maybe we need a new metric, ala FMEA, where in this case we multiply how the ludicrous the idea is by how much popularity it has attained.

Sure. I suggest that the first term, ludicrousness, be in stages rather than assigning a specific value to each.
Pure fantasy - 5 (includes such off the wall ideas and predictions as Kyloon)
Heavy fantasy - 4 (such as David Icke's reptilian overlords, and vicsims)
Science Fantasy - 3 ( for instance electric universe)
Political fantasy - 2 (NWO, Illuminatii)
Societal fantasy - 1 (Sharia Law is about to be implemented. + They are coming for your guns)

Popularity could be determined by tabulating the traffic on general conspiracy websites such as DIF, and ATS, and appearance in MSM.
 
I didn’t quite understand what you meant by “Graduate telecoms and radio”. You must be a video game geek, as they tend to try to be as abbreviated as possible and are often less explicit than necessary to get the point across.

You certainly aren't humble, which is quite surprising as this issue is completely outside of your field.

I hope you don't mind but I need to put you on ignore, so I won't be answering you.

Your nasty disposition and attempts to make problems out of nothing is not something I feel a need to tolerate.

Didn't take long for you to resort to insult, did it?

Oh well. No discussion to be had, clearly.
 
Seeing as skyeagle409 provided clear and dramatic photo and video evidence to support that claim, yes.

You missed the part where he also provided evidence that Ae911Truth was trying to pass these types of cuts off as "thermite."

Does anyone here believe that thermite was used to cut columns during execution of an unspecified "controlled demolition" for which no evidence exists?


My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Had anyone thought of checking for it, it would have taken expert inspections to distinguish between beams cut via thermite cutters and lances. Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.

No truck driver transporting the beams or any inspector at the storage areas had any reason to raise a red flag due to angle cut beams with melted metal sputter since the clean up crews left these sorts of marks on the beams. Beams cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to collapse could have been hidden in plain sight, right out in the open.

The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

BWT. Richard Gage does mention this famous angle cut beam photo in his lectures but he also talks about its controversy.
 
Nice change of subject. Somebody shoes you a picture of that which you deny exists, and you use it to go to the aftermath.
Answer the *********** question: Was there massive damage to that wall or not?

What wall? What are you ranting about this time?:eye-poppi
 
My point is that you all accept that without precise gov documentation with timestamped listing of cut beams, and further that you assume that ALL the cut beams found must have been cut during the clean up and that no beam could have been cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to building collapse.

Had anyone thought of checking for it, it would have taken expert inspections to distinguish between beams cut via thermite cutters and lances. Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.

No truck driver transporting the beams or any inspector at the storage areas had any reason to raise a red flag due to angle cut beams with melted metal sputter since the clean up crews left these sorts of marks on the beams. Beams cut via thermitic cutter charges prior to collapse could have been hidden in plain sight, right out in the open.

The direct evidence for thermite cut beams is there, but since the gov investigations did not go into forensic studies, this evidence is inconclusive on its own. There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials leave behind once ignited, the red-gray chips, the reports of melted steel etc. There is OTOH absolutely no evidence of any kind behind the official fire based explanations.

BWT. Richard Gage does mention this famous angle cut beam photo in his lectures but he also talks about its controversy.
There is no controversy. There is a patently obvious mechanism by which the towers collapsed, very large, very fast aircraft with large loads of fuel hit them causing immediate impact damage and igniting large area fires simultaneously on several vertically adjacent floors. These aircraft were caused to do this by a readily identifiable group with a well known history of wishing to attack American targets.

Thermite takes time, quite a bit of time relatively speaking, to cut through large columns. A large amount of thermite would be required to do this as well. There is no indicaton of thermite being used in the manner in which the towers collapsed, nor is there an identifiable group that would want to do this, nor is there an identified and plausible reason to do it. There is a non-peer reviewed, paper that concludes a certain amount of thermite like substance exists in the post collapse dust. It is disputed by another study.
Then there is the issue of, if the Harrit et al paper is correct then how much thermite does it imply was in each tower? The paper would imply a certain amount of unreacted thermite. If the thermite loaded into the buildings was such that a large percentage was left unburned then an enormous amount must have been loaded in order to allow the cutting to take place. If the thermite was efficient in burning but is found in concentration high enough to be easily found in a few small random dust samples then again an enormous amount must have been loaded.
This then begs the question, from those claiming thermite use in bringing the towers down, of HOW. Where is the scenario describing such a thing that conforms to the supposed evidence and sufficiently overturns the null hypothesis?
 
Last edited:
Ziggi:
You seem to accept a CD explanation without a concise report from anyone.

Don't you have unanswered questions regarding a CD of the buildings? If not, where can one find the one concise CD report that contains supporting links to documention?
 
Just FYI--I've corresponded with Dr. Beyler and he is considering making public the fire report he prepared in connection with WAI's analyses. He hasn't made it public yet because he is working on a journal article version of it, but he is now considering allowing me to post the original report on metabunk or a similar platform.
 
Just FYI--I've corresponded with Dr. Beyler and he is considering making public the fire report he prepared in connection with WAI's analyses. He hasn't made it public yet because he is working on a journal article version of it, but he is now considering allowing me to post the original report on metabunk or a similar platform.

Gee, you mean ask nicely works!!!!???? You mean to tell us that it isn't a deep dark Illuminatii-ish secret.

I can hardly wait for Scott Grainger and Edward Munyak to write a critque of it.

After all I would assume that fire protection engineers in AE911T would be the persons tasked with this.
 
Last edited:
Had FEMA and NIST followed the NFPA921, the first responder testimonies of melted metal and explosions would have automatically set in motion a forensic investigation which would have looked for forensic evidence for explosives and "exotic accelerants" including thermitic materials.
And had they followed NFPA914, they would have implemented features that are necessary to protect historic structures from fire, while safeguarding the elements, spaces, and features that make these sites historically or architecturally significant.

Both are equally inapplicable to the WTC case.

The WTC reports by FEMA and NIST were not "fire and explosion investigation". They were building performance investigations. The causes for the initiation and spread of the fire were crystal clear to anyone on Earth.


There is however plenty of other supporting evidence for thermitic materials thermal lances, including forensic evidence via WTC dust full of the signature iron spheres that these materials lances leave behind once ignited,
FTFY.
 
A different analogy for what Tony is trying to do is to (correctly) state that a map isn't the same as the real terrain, just as a model isn't necessarily reality. Where he goes wrong is insisting that any detail in the map that doesn't correlate with the actual terrain is reason to completely discard the map and substitute one's own reality. ...

An analogy in a different area of private study that currently fascinates me no end (and is the main reason I am often online at very sinful hours of the night):
I have inherited from my father a big box with copies and notes from genealogical documents for our family that a cousin of his had assembled in the 1980s. Her results go back to the 1500s, but unfortunately my father didn't copy or cite any sources for that oldest family history. That was a time before inheritable family names were in use in our neck of the world. That came sometime during the 1600s.

A couple of months ago, I googled my family name + "family tree", and found a very massive family tree, very nicely done by a guy married to woman with whom, it turned out, I share grand-grand-grand-grand-grand-parents :D

Both researchers traced my family name back to the given (Christian) name of a widow in the early 1600s.
However!!! Between that widow and our common ancestor, they have a different lineage! Whily "my" family tree has a "Joseph" as grand6-father, "hers" has a "Leonard" - grand6-mothers have same last name, but different first names, too. grand7-parents are different, but eventually, they both branch back to said widow.

And anyway, the other researcher's data records - at least half of them are "wrong" - or at least differ from mine: Different spellings, birth places, death years, numbers of children, etc.
And even original documents are sometimed wrong! My great-grandmother's official church obituary (that's a little printed card handed out to those who attend the funeral service) has her birth year wrong by three years, and the birth day by one day; onle the month is correct.

Now we are three researchers - the guy with the massive online tree, my father's cousin, and I. The former two have used previous work by at least three further researchers.

Now I can guarantee you: All six of us produce incorrect family trees!

Does this mean we are not relatives? Does this mean our family name is not derived from a widow's first name in the early 1600s? Is it more likely that we don't actually have any ancestors on planet earth before the year 1750?

Of course not.

All it means is that data before ca. 1800 is scarce, often ambiguous, and it is therefore nigh impossible to be certain of the genealogy.
None of this is reason to consider special creation or immigration from another galaxy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom