does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I think that's pretty rich coming from a guy (Tony) who can't even put his loads and boundary conditions on a simple beam free body diagram, don't you?
It could be that he doesn't know what a free body diagram is. What he posted wasn't it.
It could be that you haven't asked for it often enough. When a new page turns, all the previous pages are amnesiaed, and the same zombie sham can stagger on.
And on.
 
I think that's pretty rich coming from a guy (Tony) who can't even put his loads and boundary conditions on a simple beam free body diagram, don't you?

What universe are you in? In reality, you put up a cut and pasted free body diagram from a book and I had to correct you on it, as it had a concentrated load and the girder in question in WTC 7 would have had a uniformly distributed load.

I think your free body diagram ploy has been worn out.
 
Last edited:
For starters, there's my 10-year anniversary review in the Skeptical Inquirer, Vol. 35.4, July-August 2011. (Nice PDF version here.) You can whine that this is "refuted sleight-of-hand" all you want, but I contend this is much more solid science than, say, your so-called "Missing Jolt" paper, or your pathetic attempts to imply that because NIST might have gotten a small detail wrong, then something "nefarious" happened on 9/11, or your continued refusal to provide even a bare outline of what you think really went down on 9/11.

As for Ziggi, he's trying desperately to dodge the fact that his baloney on the angle-cut steel beams was definitively shot down. As for Ziggi's so-called "science," how's that Basile study coming along? :rolleyes:

Fact is, Gage was eager to debate me until the S/I piece came out. Since then he hasn't asked me for further debate, realizing that any possible benefit of appearing onstage with a real physicist was offset by the risk of having his followers read my non-nonsense, fact-based rebuttal of so-called "9/11 Truth".

Dave, it is hard to understand how you can continue to crow about your Skeptical Inquirer magazine piece when it is not indicative of what could have happened.

You have the upper section of the North Tower in free fall between floor impacts from the beginning. That most certainly couldn't have happened in the first story as columns had to buckle there and they can't do that over one or two stories as there is still a significant resistance.

You have the velocity at the end of the first story of fall at 8.5 m/s, which is only possible with free fall acceleration. The measurements show it was about 6.1 m/s and there is no averaging through the first story, as there were no impacts to average in yet.

I am surprised you aren't embarrassed by this, but maybe you just didn't realize it or didn't know any better. I did try to explain it to you by e-mail a few years ago.

NIST got a lot more than a small detail wrong. They ignored girder trapping behind column 79's side plate. They omitted stiffeners that would not have allowed the flange to bend up and fail. They said the girder seat was only 11 inches wide when they thought the beams could only expand 5.5 inches. They made a false claim about the girder breaking through the next floor down and causing a floor cascade. In reality, they cannot show that column 79 could ever lose lateral support and buckle due to the above. Their entire WTC 7 report depends on that.

I have often said that based on the observations, you know like all four corners of the roof descending simultaneously in free fall in WTC 7, and no jolt in the North Tower, that I believe the buildings were intentionally demolished.

I am glad you brought up debates, as that is what this thread is about. Do you want to debate me on the 911 free forum? Let's see if what you have to say is really non-nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Tony--how long are you going to continue to dodge on addressing the fundamental error you and Korol made re the WTC7 heating model? Do you think if you keep hiding from it long enough people will forget that you were willing to blatantly make things up in support of a clearly erroneous methodology? If you had an ounce of intellectual honesty, you could just acknowledge you and Korol were wrong and move past it.
 
Last edited:
#

... got a lot more than a small detail wrong. They ignored girder trapping behind column 79's side plate. They omitted stiffeners that would not have allowed the flange to bend up and fail. They said the girder seat was only 11 inches wide when they thought the beams could only expand 5.5 inches. They made a false claim about the girder breaking through the next floor down and causing a floor cascade....

I am glad you brought up debates, as that is what this thread is about. Do you want to debate me on the 911 free forum? Let's see if what you have to say is really non-nonsense.

Tony, it would be really interesting to see you and Dave Thomas the president of NMSR go over the gross NIST omissions and distortions that it used to arrive at physically impossible conclusions that were needed to suit the official government approved conspiracy theory, including the impossible girder walk off and floor cascade stories. Do not forget the lack of evidence to prove that its progressive collapse could replicate the observed global collapse features, including free-fall, and of course the refusal to hand over its data for independent verification of its model results - the most basic scientific requirement.

Dave does appear to dismiss such things as minor details, but the president is supposedly representing an organization that opposes "groups who misuse and misrepresent science...to suit their own ends."

http://www.nmsr.org/about.htm

We are skeptical, however, of those groups who misuse and misrepresent science. We oppose the use of fabrication, flawed logic, distortion of facts, and pseudoscientific propaganda by any and all groups who twist science to suit their own ends

Perhaps they just forgot to add the the # by the "any and all groups" that leads to a disclaimer in a footnote saying #"except for identities set out to prove the official 9/11 narrative."

Are the so-called debunkers here perhaps trying to come up with excuses to avoid a debate were they would be set to defend the nist reports because they want to avoid the prospect of having to acknowledge and then condemn the omissions and distortions in those reports

Lets see if president Dave lives up to his spiel.
 
Last edited:
go over the gross NIST omissions and distortions .
Too bad you can't list one.

funny stuff, you and tony can't list one omission or distortion. you both are unable to grasp simple engineering concepts.

CD remains a fantasy for the anti-science fake movement of 9/11 truth.

How do you propose a debate when Tony's claims are lies? Ask an engineer at your school... get help from someone you trust outside the woo world of 9/11 truth.
 
Tony, it would be really interesting to see you and Dave Thomas the president of NMSR go over the gross NIST omissions and distortions that it used to arrive at physically impossible conclusions that were needed to suit the official government approved conspiracy theory, including the impossible girder walk off and floor cascade stories. Do not forget the lack of evidence to prove that its progressive collapse could replicate the observed global collapse features, including free-fall, and of course the refusal to hand over its data for independent verification of its model results - the most basic scientific requirement.

Dave does appear to dismiss such things as minor details, but the president is supposedly representing an organization that opposes "groups who misuse and misrepresent science...to suit their own ends."

http://www.nmsr.org/about.htm



Perhaps they just forgot to add the the # by the "any and all groups" that leads to a disclaimer in a footnote saying #"except for identities set out to prove the official 9/11 narrative."

Are the so-called debunkers here perhaps trying to come up with excuses to avoid a debate were they would be set to defend the nist reports because they want to avoid the prospect of having to acknowledge and then condemn the omissions and distortions in those reports

Lets see if president Dave lives up to his spiel.

Shall we debate, Goldie locks and the tree bears as well, as long as we are debating worthless fallacies?
 
Dave, it is hard to understand how you can continue to crow about your Skeptical Inquirer magazine piece when it is not indicative of what could have happened.

You have the upper section of the North Tower in free fall between floor impacts from the beginning. That most certainly couldn't have happened in the first story as columns had to buckle there and they can't do that over one or two stories as there is still a significant resistance.

You have the velocity at the end of the first story of fall at 8.5 m/s, which is only possible with free fall acceleration. The measurements show it was about 6.1 m/s and there is no averaging through the first story, as there were no impacts to average in yet.

I am surprised you aren't embarrassed by this, but maybe you just didn't realize it or didn't know any better. I did try to explain it to you by e-mail a few years ago.

NIST got a lot more than a small detail wrong. They ignored girder trapping behind column 79's side plate. They omitted stiffeners that would not have allowed the flange to bend up and fail. They said the girder seat was only 11 inches wide when they thought the beams could only expand 5.5 inches. They made a false claim about the girder breaking through the next floor down and causing a floor cascade. In reality, they cannot show that column 79 could ever lose lateral support and buckle due to the above. Their entire WTC 7 report depends on that.

I have often said that based on the observations, you know like all four corners of the roof descending simultaneously in free fall in WTC 7, and no jolt in the North Tower, that I believe the buildings were intentionally demolished.

I am glad you brought up debates, as that is what this thread is about. Do you want to debate me on the 911 free forum? Let's see if what you have to say is really non-nonsense.

Experimental evidence of claim please for bolt sheer without ductile damage to girder, set, and stiffeners, you do have the information do you not?
 
Do not forget the lack of evidence to prove that its progressive collapse could replicate the observed global collapse features, including free-fall, and of course the refusal to hand over its data for independent verification of its model results - the most basic scientific requirement.


The following photo proves beyond a shadow of a doubt the WTC Tower did not collapse at free-fall or even near-free-fall speed.


WTC Tower Collapse Photo

http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/Collapse.jpg


It is obvious that falling debris and dust plumes are outpacing the collapse of the WTC Tower, which simply means the building is not collapsing at free-fall speed.
 
You have the upper section of the North Tower in free fall between floor impacts from the beginning. That most certainly couldn't have happened in the first story as columns had to buckle there and they can't do that over one or two stories as there is still a significant resistance.

Does anyone think Tony's objective enough to notice that he's just debunked his Missing Jolt theory (yet again!)?

Dave
 
Tony Szamboti said:
You have the upper section of the North Tower in free fall between floor impacts from the beginning.
The collapse time for WTC 1 was over 22 seconds, which is not indicative of free-fall.

Tony isn't saying the towers collapsed at free fall, he is referring to my super-simplified one-dimensional model, as described here, here and here, which posits that the upper section fell through each empty floor at free-fall, and then was slowed down by impacting each floor, snapping the connections holding floor to walls, pushing the perimeter wall sections outward, and sliding down around the central core (a.k.a. "spires"). The model is based on sound conservation of energy and conservation of momentum principles. It predicts that the total collapse time was longer than a free-fall collapse, on the order of 11-13 seconds for the Twin Towers (for which free fall was 9 seconds). The collapse velocities predicted by the model compare very well to those measured by truther David Chandler.

Sarite?
 
..., that I believe the buildings were intentionally demolished.


That is false and for someone who is suppose to be knowledgeable about structures, you've failed that test because there were major indicators that pointed to fire and impact damage, not explosives, as responsible for the collapse of WTC 7 and any structural expert have understood the significance of what I posted.

You've failed to catch the hint when I posted references regarding structural load redistribution due to impact damage on the south wall and southwest corner of WTC 7 and fire-induced weakening of structural members within WTC 7. A structural expert should have understood where I was going, but you somehow had missed the boat, which to me personally, was an eye-opener. Do you know why WTC 7 tilted toward the south in the final seconds of its collapse?

You've failed to place importance on comments and reports issued by firefighters regarding major impact damage on the south wall of WTC 7 and sounds of structural weakening heard within WTC 7 by firefighters and structural buckling observed by witnesses. Firefighters understood the significance of their reports, which is why a collapse zone was created and the pull back of firefighters from within WTC 7. Prudent decisions based in visual observations and sounds of fire-induced structural weakening had saved lives.

You've also failed to catch the ball regarding structural buckling, which was a major sign that fire, not explosives, was slowing weakening structural members of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7, and that was another eye-opener because as a structural expert, you were supposed to catch the ball in that respect but you let the ball fly right on by as though you did not understand the importance of what that ball represented.

So what we have, are the following in reference to WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7:

* You've failed to understand the significance of structural buckling

* You've failed to place importance regarding structural load redistribution due to major impact damage in the presence of uncontrolled fires raging within WTC 7 for hours.

Explosives planted within WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 would have been detonated either by fire or impact damage, yet no secondary CD explosions were observed nor heard at any time.

The fact that WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 withstood major structural damage due to those impacts, should have been a clue to you that explosives alone would not have been effective against those buildings, which was evident back in 1993 when a vehicle bomb failed to drop WTC 1, whereas, structural members remained standing within that huge bomb crater.

If you were a true structural, demolition, or even an explosive expert, you would have understood why the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 had nothing to do with CD and why many structural experts, architects, firefighters, and demolition experts do not agree with CD claims in regard to the collapse of those buildings.

WTC 5 had suffered an internal collapse, so where's the CD evidence for its internal collapse?
 
Last edited:
... that I believe the buildings were intentionally demolished.


In that case, I would like for you to provide a few details such as:


1. What type of explosives were used?

2. How was structural pre-weakening conducted within the crowded steel-framed buildings in secret?

3. How do you rig a crowded steel-framed building with CD explosives and thousands of feet of detonation wire in secret?

4. How was access gained to structural members of those buildings in secret, and how long would it have taken to properly prepare WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 for demolition?

5. Explain the absence of demolition explosions as WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 collapsed?

6. Who ordered the demolition of the WTC buildings, and why?

7. Explain the absence of demolition hardware at ground zero?

8. Explain the absence of physical evidence on structural members that would have indicated the use of explosives.

9. Explain the lack of seismic evidence that would have indicated the use of explosives.

10. Explain how planted explosives withstood major impacts and uncontrolled fires for long periods of time without detonating

11. How many people were involved?

12. How many specialties were involved in preparing each of the WTC buildings for demolition?

13. What type of tools and equipment were used to prepare each of the WTC buildings for demolition?

14. How were hazardous environmental conditions and high noise levels addressed during structural pre-weakening operations?

15. How was hazardous waste disposed of during structural pre-weakening operations?

16. Why would the government use explosives to illegally demolish the WTC buildings knowing that the use of explosives would leave behind physical evidence?

17. Why would the government demolish the WTC buildings with explosives in order to go to war with Afghanistan when in fact, the Taliban had issued a warning to the United States that Osama bin Laden would launch a massive terrorist attack on America?


Taliban Warned US of Huge Attack


http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/2242594.stm


18. Why would the government demolish the WTC buildings with explosives in order to go to war with Iraq when it could have used Iraq's deliberate violations of UN resolutions and blatant disregard of human rights and other violations as an excuse to go to war with Iraq?


Long list of Saddam's violations

According to Britain, Saddam Hussein is ignoring 23 out of 27 obligations set out in nine separate resolutions.

If Washington and London decide to go it alone, they will probably argue that the authorisation for the 1991 Gulf War remains in force because Iraq has breached the ceasefire conditions set out by the UN.
"There was no truce, armistice or treaty to end the war," one senior Western diplomat said. "A ceasefire is a temporary thing."

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor.../1406490/Long-list-of-Saddams-violations.html


The US didn't go to war when terrorist bombed our embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, bombed Pan Am 103 out of the sky or after the bombing of the USS Cole, which brings up this question:

What was the purpose of a 9/11 attack (inside job) when the US did not go war despite previous terrorist attacks against the US and its citizens?

.
 
Last edited:
Tony isn't saying the towers collapsed at free fall, he is referring to my super-simplified one-dimensional model, as described here, here and here, which posits that the upper section fell through each empty floor at free-fall, and then was slowed down by impacting each floor, snapping the connections holding floor to walls, pushing the perimeter wall sections outward, and sliding down around the central core (a.k.a. "spires"). The model is based on sound conservation of energy and conservation of momentum principles. It predicts that the total collapse time was longer than a free-fall collapse, on the order of 11-13 seconds for the Twin Towers (for which free fall was 9 seconds). The collapse velocities predicted by the model compare very well to those measured by truther David Chandler.

Sarite?

Thank you for the clarification!
 
Does anyone think Tony's objective enough to notice that he's just debunked his Missing Jolt theory (yet again!)?

Dave

Tony, Ziggi, and Jones, were never anything but frauds, there is enough evidence now to prove that.

Ziggi, When will you be returning the $5000, or more in I'll gotten gains, from the non existent Mark Imbecile study?

PS. Someone please Quote this as Ziggi has me on ignore.
 
That is false and for someone who is suppose to be knowledgeable about structures, you've failed that test because there were major indicators that pointed to fire and impact damage, not explosives, as responsible for the collapse of WTC 7 and any structural expert have understood the significance of what I posted.

Yep, like the recorded videos of impact and fires.
:eek::jaw-dropp
 
In that case, I would like for you to provide a few details such as:
..............

19. Why demolish WTC 7? It contributed little to 'shock and awe' since no one died and it was a relatively unknown structure. Demolition most certainly would be an extremely inefficient form of document destruction(would have been better to just have all floors eventually burn out). Other (barely) surviving WTC structures had gov't and security offices including WTC 5 which did burn out.
 
If 7wtc was an inside job intended destruction....what would be the motive? This makes no sense at all.

One could see that staging the destruction of the iconic buildings like the twin towers, the pentagon, the capital, white house.... CIA and so forth can be understood at hitting symbolic targets as well as actually causing serious chaos to the US... But 7wtc? Absolutely makes no sense at all.

And it looks like collateral damage from the strike to the twin towers was what led to its collapse.
 
If 7wtc was an inside job intended destruction....what would be the motive? This makes no sense at all.

One could see that staging the destruction of the iconic buildings like the twin towers, the pentagon, the capital, white house.... CIA and so forth can be understood at hitting symbolic targets as well as actually causing serious chaos to the US... But 7wtc? Absolutely makes no sense at all.

And it looks like collateral damage from the strike to the twin towers was what led to its collapse.

The only motive I can see is to make Tony, and Ziggi appear to be insane fanatics.
That and save peoples lives by preventing Tony from actually doing any real engineering.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom