does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

It is not so much laughable, as pathetic that you clearly ignore the fact that you yourself quoted elsewhere, the "Supplemental and Amended Second Declaration of Colin G. Bailey"
Then denied any knowledge of same.

Do you not know what the word AMENDED means?

More evidence you got no evidence for CD, or the BS opinions on NIST.
 
It is not so much laughable, as pathetic that you clearly ignore the fact that you yourself quoted elsewhere, the "Supplemental and Amended Second Declaration of Colin G. Bailey"
Then denied any knowledge of same.

Do you not know what the word AMENDED means?

I get it--you think the affidavit itself is "original evidence"--a term of no particular legal import that you just conjured up and to which you have assigned your own special significance. Great. I didn't interpret your special made-up term of no particular legal import the same way you did in your head. To me, the expert report is the original evidence (and that makes perfect sense given that it is the factual basis for the declaration, and not the other way around), and it has not been amended according to the court record.

Who cares? Is this going to lead to you providing me with evidence that ARUP tested NIST's heating model? I doubt it.
 
I get it--you think the affidavit itself is "original evidence"--a term of no particular legal import that you just conjured up and to which you have assigned your own special significance. Great. I didn't interpret your special made-up term of no particular legal import the same way you did in your head. To me, the expert report is the original evidence (and that makes perfect sense given that it is the factual basis for the declaration, and not the other way around), and it has not been amended according to the court record.

Who cares? Is this going to lead to you providing me with evidence that ARUP tested NIST's heating model? I doubt it.

You clearly have no interest in having an HONEST discussion. It is abundantly clear to anyone who is following this thread EXACTLY what you just tried to do. You tried to keep the fact that Bailey AMENDED his evidence quiet, and even your wording is very telling. It appears you have been well and truly BUSTED.
You are dismissed as either entirely incompetent or completely dishonest. What would you plead?
 
You clearly have no interest in having an HONEST discussion. It is abundantly clear to anyone who is following this thread EXACTLY what you just tried to do. You tried to keep the fact that Bailey AMENDED his evidence quiet, and even your wording is very telling. It appears you have been well and truly BUSTED.
You are dismissed as either entirely incompetent or completely dishonest. What would you plead?

Bailey amended his declaration because the original declaration was submitted before he completed his expert report. I've read all of this stuff and I actually know civil procedure. Again, who cares? I certainly don't care to give weight to how he speculated the building could have most likely collapsed prior to completing his study when I have an actual copy of his final study.

I think you are having a little indigestion or something now that you realize you've been conceptualizing the relationship between the various collapse initiation models in a fundamentally flawed way. You are trying to make some big point in attacking me because I interpreted your made-up term of "original evidence" in the way that makes the most sense, and that's your prerogative. Whatever gets you another post deeper without addressing the fact that you do not have any evidence that ARUP tested NIST's heating scenario must be soothing to your cognitive dissonance.
 
Bailey amended his declaration because the original declaration was submitted before he completed his expert report. I've read all of this stuff and I actually know civil procedure. Again, who cares? I certainly don't care to give weight to how he speculated the building could have most likely collapsed prior to completing his study when I have an actual copy of his final study.

I think you are having a little indigestion or something now that you realize you've been conceptualizing the relationship between the various collapse initiation models in a fundamentally flawed way. You are trying to make some big point in attacking me because I interpreted your made-up term of "original evidence" in the way that makes the most sense, and that's your prerogative. Whatever gets you another post deeper without addressing the fact that you do not have any evidence that ARUP tested NIST's heating scenario must be soothing to your cognitive dissonance.

I will help you out here. The word you were looking for was "guilty".
As I said, you are easily dismissed and have been, accordingly.
 
I will help you out here. The word you were looking for was "guilty".
As I said, you are easily dismissed and have been, accordingly.

LOL--yes, because I interpret your made-up term of no particular legal significance in a completely logical way, everything else I've said can certainly be dismissed. You can't make this chutzpah up. Good lord. Yawn
 
I will help you out here. The word you were looking for was "guilty".
As I said, you are easily dismissed and have been, accordingly.

More evidence of no evidence for the claims and BS you made. Present evidence, stop the weak attack. Got a study which shows fire did not do it?

Got a Pulitzer for the CD claims?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Ziggi
Dave does appear to dismiss such things as minor details, but the president is supposedly representing an organization that opposes "groups who misuse and misrepresent science...to suit their own ends."

http://www.nmsr.org/about.htm
We are skeptical, however, of those groups who misuse and misrepresent science. We oppose the use of fabrication, flawed logic, distortion of facts, and pseudoscientific propaganda by any and all groups who twist science to suit their own ends

Perhaps they just forgot to add the the # by the "any and all groups" that leads to a disclaimer in a footnote saying #"except for identities set out to prove the official 9/11 narrative."

Are the so-called debunkers here perhaps trying to come up with excuses to avoid a debate were they would be set to defend the nist reports because they want to avoid the prospect of having to acknowledge and then condemn the omissions and distortions in those reports
Lets see if president Dave lives up to his spiel.

Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Dave Thomas! Mr. president! It does not give a flattering impression of u, to claim that truthers fear your analytical powers in a debate and then disappear when challenged. Are u not up to defending the NIST reports? Are u afraid of exposing them as woo-woo? Do u not live up to your spiel?

The NIST reports are not my area of expertise. I think it's quite obvious, however, that truthers are stuck on the "Black and White Logical Fallacy" (a.k.a. False Dilemma). Because the NIST reports might have a "t" uncrossed or an "i" undotted does not help in any way to prove that 9/11 was a "Controlled Demolition."

You guys are just gonna have to find someone else to play the role of Satan in your cheesy Passion Play. Good luck with that! :rolleyes:

Oh so Dave Thomas is now not knowledgeable enough about the official reports to debate truthers about them - the same guy that boasted only days ago about his essay on the matter, and the alleged fear the frontman debunker of NIST has for your debating skills:

For starters, there's my 10-year anniversary review in the Skeptical Inquirer, Vol. 35.4, July-August 2011. (Nice PDF version here.) You can whine that this is "refuted sleight-of-hand" all you want...

.... Gage was eager to debate me until the S/I piece came out. Since then he hasn't asked me for further debate, realizing that any possible benefit of appearing onstage with a real physicist was offset by the risk of having his followers read my non-nonsense, fact-based rebuttal of so-called "9/11 Truth"

You also continue to handwave NISTs omissions and distortions as just some minor details, but as I noted you are afraid of a situation were u would be forced to dig a bit deeper and confront "fabrication, flawed logic, distortion of facts"..as misconduct and possible fraud, and therefore the prospect of having to agree with truthers that those reports are woo-woo. And woo-woo reports about this huge tragedy would be a huge scandal that would lead to many hard questions, one of them being why fudge the investigation? You do not live up to your NMSR spiel, Mr. president.

This is not about black or white. In any case where someone wants a new investigation using public funds, the first step is to show that the original was insufficient, and that has been proven. You have created a strawman claim saying that truthers believe that NIST proven false makes our case for cd correct. We do not say that. We say that a new impartial investigation would conclude cd.

Do you want to debate me on the 911freeforum about thermite?
 
LOL--yes, because I interpret your made-up term of no particular legal significance in a completely logical way, everything else I've said can certainly be dismissed. You can't make this chutzpah up. Good lord. Yawn

No, Because you have exposed yourself as intellectually dishonest. Perhaps a course in ethics at a good law school would be a good way forward for you, if you cannot bring yourself to AMEND that flaw by yourself.
 
No, Because you have exposed yourself as intellectually dishonest. Perhaps a course in ethics at a good law school would be a good way forward for you, if you cannot bring yourself to AMEND that flaw by yourself.

Yes, by interpreting "original evidence" to be the expert report, which was the factual basis for the declaration, and not the declaration itself (which is merely based off of the evidence provided in the expert report), I have somehow been "dishonest", all while linking you directly to the amended declaration you think I'm trying to hide. I love how this line of thinking is flawed in a way that is completely consistent with the line of thinking that leads you you folks to conclude CD destroyed the WTC buildings. It could be an SAT analogy. Great stuff, man.
 
Yes, by interpreting "original evidence" to be the expert report, which was the factual basis for the declaration, and not the declaration itself (which is merely based off of the evidence provided in the expert report), I have somehow been "dishonest", all while linking you directly to the amended declaration you think I'm trying to hide. I love how this line of thinking is flawed in a way that is completely consistent with the line of thinking that leads you you folks to conclude CD destroyed the WTC buildings. It could be an SAT analogy. Great stuff, man.

Okay then. We will sort this out thus. I will ask you once again, in light of our exchange since...
"Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?"
 
Okay then. We will sort this out thus. I will ask you once again, in light of our exchange since...
"Did Bailey make any amendments to his original evidence to the court that you are aware of?"

Bailey amended his declaration to the court (which you believe to be his "original evidence") but not his expert report (which is his actual evidence).

Happy?
 
Bailey amended his declaration to the court (which you believe to be his "original evidence") but not his expert report (which is his actual evidence).

Happy?

I'm getting there thanks, yes.

"Evidence discovered after June 15, 2009 revealed that, contrary to the information I had reviewed prior to that date, some shear studs were ultimately installed on each floor on the girder running between columns 79 and 44"

Did Bailey's expert report, as originally submitted in evidence state that there were shear studs on that girder? NO

Did his amended evidence change the report? YES (slightly)

Did NIST include studs on the girder in their analysis? NO

Did NIST address this shortcoming in their analysis? NO

Did NIST therefore accurately model the girder? NO

This demonstrates a lack of attention to detail on NIST's part, and does not instil confidence in their ability to accurately model the structure, which is borne out by the discovery of the further omissions and glaring errors that they made in modelling this, the area of the building that they put under most scrutiny. They are demonstrably incompetent.
 
I'm getting there thanks, yes.

"Evidence discovered after June 15, 2009 revealed that, contrary to the information I had reviewed prior to that date, some shear studs were ultimately installed on each floor on the girder running between columns 79 and 44"

Did Bailey's expert report, as originally submitted in evidence state that there were shear studs on that girder? NO

Did his amended evidence change the report? YES (slightly)

Did NIST include studs on the girder in their analysis? NO

Did NIST address this shortcoming in their analysis? NO

Did NIST therefore accurately model the girder? NO

This demonstrates a lack of attention to detail on NIST's part, and does not instil confidence in their ability to accurately model the structure, which is borne out by the discovery of the further omissions and glaring errors that they made in modelling this, the area of the building that they put under most scrutiny. They are demonstrably incompetent.

You are conflating the expert report and the declaration again. He submitted his original declaration before he completed his expert report. Look at the date of the expert report (which is not amended)--February 15, 2010. It's right there on the front of the report.

And so what if NIST and Bailey disagreed on the inclusion of shear studs? Do you have any analysis that the inclusion of them materially changed Bailey's conclusion (which we've already established does not in any way invalidate NIST's, in any case)? How about evidence that if they were included in NIST's model that they would have materially changed NIST's conclusion?
 
Okay then.


If you plant explosives in a steel-framed building without the required structural pre-weakening before the placement of CD explosives, this is what you will get.


Building Photos

http://www.jadaliyya.com/content_images/3/Aftermathpic1.jpg

https://www.indybay.org/uploads/2004/03/04/bombedbuilding.jpg


The building in the following photo-absorbed multiple bomb strikes yet the building failed to collapse.

http://www.paulmidler.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a.jpg


Now, you know why structural pre-weakening is required prior to the placement of CD explosives on steel columns.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..

There is no support in your post or anywhere else for using a 20-30 min heating timeframe as the basis for estimating the maximum temperature reached in WTC7. Notice that? And you are just pulling numbers out of thin air re how much different fire loads would have incluenced the heating of beams. Why should I care about your made up numbers? Tony cited the Cardington Studies because they are the gold standard for experimental heating observations. They just happen to also prove him and you wrong. And you are comically misreading the '93 Cardington Study compartmental fire if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours (or were a "double fuel fire"). Check your eyes and reading comprehension if you want to have an adult conversation or just go back to scamming people.

Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...

and your pathetic response shows how far above your head this stuff is..

no support in your post or anywhere else for using a 20-30 min heating timeframe

- U did not understand that Korol use of the double fuel load (40kg) is away to emulate higher temps from pre-heating IN ADDITION TO the 30 min!

just pulling numbers out of thin air re how much different fire loads would have incluenced the heating of beams.

- I quoted Korol who cites NIST: 20kg/meter2 is industry std office fire load according to NIST. Korol and Cardington list temps given the std 20kg an also the double 40kg. Korol also uses NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline.

comically misreading the '93 Cardington Study compartmental fire if you think that those fires burned for anywhere near 3 hours

- U cite F47 which cuts out at 170 min...10 min short of 3 hours

"double fuel fire")

- F47 caption for graph says Test 4...Table 2 p17 says fuel load for that is 40kg...which is double the 20kg/meter2 industry std office fire load.

.........................

Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.
 
Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...

First of all, let's do a review here.

Buckling Steel

According to Shyam-Sunder, the concave bowing of the steel was seen on the sides of the towers opposite where the planes hit them. At 10:06 a.m. that morning, an officer in a police helicopter reported that ``it's not going to take long before the north tower comes down.'' This was 20 minutes before it collapsed. In another radio transmission at 10:21 a.m., the officer said he saw buckling in the north tower's southern face, Shyam-Sunder said. The report includes photographs taken from police helicopters showing the bending columns.
Police had already ordered a complete evacuation of the north tower at the time those transmissions were made, said Police Department Inspector Michael Coan. Both transmissions came after the south tower was already down, he said.


Remember, WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 incurred major impact damage and redistributed structural loads among structural members that were directly exposed to uncontrolled fires. Now, let's take a look here.

Temperature and Strength of Metals

Influence of temperature on the strength of metals

Some common types of steel lose 10% of their strength at 450 C (840 F), and 40% at 550 C (1022 F). At temperatures above 800 C ( 1475 F), it has lost 90% of its strength. Other types of steel are made to stand higher temperatures before losing 10% of their strength, but they are much more expensive (and are weaker at room temperature).

And there are types which actually get stronger, up to 450 F (but then get a lot weaker at higher temperatures

http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/metal-temperature-strength-d_1353.html


Why the World Trade Center Buildings Collapsed: A Fire Chief ’s Assessment

The steel truss floor supports probably started to fail quickly from the flames and the center steel supporting columns severed by plane parts heated by the flames began to buckle, sag, warp and fail.

http://vincentdunn.com/wtc.html


Remember, in the moments before the WTC buildings collapsed, observers saw the buildings buckle. That is undeniable proof that fire, not explosives, was responsible for the collapse of those buildings.
 
Last edited:
Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...

and your pathetic response shows how far above your head this stuff is..



- U did not understand that Korol use of the double fuel load (40kg) is away to emulate higher temps from pre-heating IN ADDITION TO the 30 min!



- I quoted Korol who cites NIST: 20kg/meter2 is industry std office fire load according to NIST. Korol and Cardington list temps given the std 20kg an also the double 40kg. Korol also uses NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline.



- U cite F47 which cuts out at 170 min...10 min short of 3 hours



- F47 caption for graph says Test 4...Table 2 p17 says fuel load for that is 40kg...which is double the 20kg/meter2 industry std office fire load.

.........................

Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.

Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg/m3 (and NIST never claims this was the worst case scenario load, by the way). It only says so right there on page 60 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9. Thanks for debunking Korol's attempted substitution of a "double fuel load" for a heating timeline that actually makes sense and pre-heating that actually makes sense. There was no basis for doing so, no evidence that it makes any sense to do so, and clear evidence it is inconsistent with both the actual timeline of the fires and with possible fire loading. It fails on every level.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom