does anyone here want to support the NIST reports in a one-on-one debate with me

I'm getting there thanks, yes.

"Evidence discovered after June 15, 2009 revealed that, contrary to the information I had reviewed prior to that date, some shear studs were ultimately installed on each floor on the girder running between columns 79 and 44"

Did Bailey's expert report, as originally submitted in evidence state that there were shear studs on that girder? NO

Did his amended evidence change the report? YES (slightly)

Did NIST include studs on the girder in their analysis? NO

Did NIST address this shortcoming in their analysis? NO

Did NIST therefore accurately model the girder? NO

This demonstrates a lack of attention to detail on NIST's part, and does not instil confidence in their ability to accurately model the structure, which is borne out by the discovery of the further omissions and glaring errors that they made in modelling this, the area of the building that they put under most scrutiny. They are demonstrably incompetent.
Where do you get this BS from?

How will this help the fantasy of CD? What difference does this make? Why repeat BS from 9/11 truth failed attempts to back in CD?

Where is your study on WTC 7? All real world studies concluded fire caused the collapse. What is your fantasy version, and who are the bad guys?


Evidence discovered after June 15, 2009 revealed that, contrary to the information I had
reviewed prior to that date, some shear studs were ultimately installed on each floor on the girder
running between columns 79 and 44. This was done to increase the ability of this part of the
structure to support an additional 10 psf load above the original design load. As a result, only 30
shear studs were installed, which, in my opinion, was not sufficient to transfer thermal thrusts.
For a fully composite girder a total of 96 shear studs would be required, which would have
transferred the thermal thrusts.
OH? what does it mean, oops, fire did it... lol, this is standard copy and paste from other failed 9/11 truth CD guys, like gerrycan, and other, as if you cut and paste your BS... and make up opinions based on false information, bias, lies and nonsese.

12. The structural fire protection was specified by the 7WTC architect based on a restrained system. However, the main girder from Column 79 to 44 was not designed and constructed as restrained. The girder did not have a sufficient number of shear studs2 and the corrections were not constructed to allow the adequate transfer of thermal thrusts to the supports as specified in the UL Fire Resistance Directory for 1983 and 1985. Specifying a level of fire protection based on restrained systems to a constructed unrestrained system resulted in a reduction of fire resistance for 7WTC.

You are supporting fire did it... you are debunking yourself, and you don't know it.

https://www.metabunk.org/attachments/aegis-bailey-expert-report-pdf.16781/

Nest time don't cut and paste from failed 9/11 truth nuts, read and comprehend the source before posting junk from 9/11 truth.


So... based on engineering principles, does leaving out shear studs make it easier for fire to cause the failure, or less likely? Guess what? Why do you source studies which say fire did it, and try to make a weak attack on NIST?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Again all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...

and your pathetic response shows how far above your head this stuff is..


- U did not understand that Korol use of the double fuel load (40kg) is away to emulate higher temps from pre-heating IN ADDITION TO the 30 min!



- I quoted Korol who cites NIST: 20kg/meter2 is industry std office fire load according to NIST. Korol and Cardington list temps given the std 20kg an also the double 40kg. Korol also uses NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline.

- U cite F47 which cuts out at 170 min...10 min short of 3 hours



- F47 caption for graph says Test 4...Table 2 p17 says fuel load for that is 40kg...which is double the 20kg/meter2 industry std office fire load.

.........................

Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.

Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg/m3 (and NIST never claims this was some sort of high-end, worst case scenario load, by the way). It only says so right there on page 60 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9. Thanks for debunking Korol's attempted substitution of a "double fuel load" for a heating timeline that actually makes sense and pre-heating that actually makes sense. There was no basis for doing so, no evidence that it makes any sense to do so, and clear evidence it is inconsistent with both the actual timeline of the fires and with possible fire loading. It fails on every level.

Again..all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook.

U are not citing or addressing anything I said, this goes way over your head
Korol also uses NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline.

I already told you NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline...add 50% to 20 and u get 30...That NIST chose to assume 32kg or extra 12kg over the std 20kg does not change that 20 is std and 40 is double that


Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.
 
...

Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.
How is that fake news web site you post at doing? debunking the debunkers website of woo... http://911debunkers.blogspot.com/ the anti-intellectual celebration of woo on 9/11.

Projection... Got some evidence for CD? No
 
Last edited:
Again..all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook.

U are not citing or addressing anything I said, this goes way over your head


I already told you NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline...add 50% to 20 and u get 30...That NIST chose to assume 32kg or extra 12kg over the std 20kg does not change that 20 is std and 40 is double that


Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.

Add 50% to 20 and you get 32? Is that how math works?

Again, you have completely failed to establish any mathematical or theoretical connection between fire loads, pre-heating, and heating duration such that it makes sense to, on one hand, add 8 kg/m3 to NIST's model fire load and, on the other hand, remove all pre-heating from NIST's model and reduce NIST's direct heating time from over 50 minutes to between 25-30 min. There is simply no relationship between those actions that you have established that justifies undertaking them together as if they will just magically all balance out from an analytical standpoint and I am 100% confident you cannot find an actual published paper by an actual fire scientist who employs such a ridiculous, haphazard methodology. No matter which way you cut it, there is no basis for Korol's methodology.

And, by the way, even if you believed there were a basis for Korol's methodology of omitting all pre-heating in exchange for increasing the fire load to 40kg/m3, the fact that the '93 Cardington studies showed a protected beam subject to the actual true duration of direct heating experienced in a compartmental fire with a 40kg/m3 fire load (which was about 90 minutes) reached 750 C, shows that Korol is still mistaken in arbitrarily cutting the heating time by 66%.
 
Last edited:
To "rig" the building with explosives would require night access for a team for say 6 hours or so per night over the period of a week, depending on the size of the team.
To prevent detection or disturbance, the alarm system would need to also be rigged so that any systematic hot work or dust or any other potential sensor triggering events would not show up on the alarm printouts. I would propose in that circumstance that the alarm be set to test for this period in order that any trigger event would show as a single zone wherever it occurred in the building.
Putting such a system as existed in WTC7 on "test" would achieve this, thus allowing access with no systematic paper trail being left to be found.

Never mind the paper trail. What about the need to remove drywall over large areas in order to access the structural members of the building? What about the need to redecorate the replaced drywall and clean up every sign of work having been done overnight? What about the requirements for pre-weakening of the structure, which is always done for controlled demolitions? What about the many miles of wiring necessary to set off the charges, again as is always required for controlled demolitions? Have you ever seen the state of a building that's been prepared for demolition?

And to forestall the usual answer, which boils down to "They used some secret military demolition equipment that's never been seen elsewhere," this answer is equivalent to abandoning your claim that the building was destroyed by a well-known technique; you're having to specify, in order to support this hypothesis, that this well-known technique was not in fact followed; you have to refute your argument to support it.

This is indeed the case for WTC7 in the days leading up to the collapse of the building, which is suspicious to say the least. I understand that this would require the security at the building to either be absent, changed or complicit with such actions also, for which I have no explanation.

I do presume however that you are aware of the alarm being set to "test" for these periods leading up to the day of the collapse of the building.

Please supply plausible evidence for this (a) being true and (b) not being common procedure. Not that this evidence would be enough even to establish the possibility of a controlled demolition, but you should meet the burden of proof on every assertion you make.

Dave
 
Originally Posted by Ziggi View Post
Again..all u have is a lot of pompous ranting that avoids actually addressing anything I said, by either ignoring it or circumventing it..you have nothing to say to even try to refute what I said...U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook.
U are not citing or addressing anything I said, this goes way over your head


I already told you NISTs 50% extra fuel baseline...add 50% to 20 and u get 30...That NIST chose to assume 32kg or extra 12kg over the std 20kg does not change that 20 is std and 40 is double that


Again it is quite evident that you dont know what you are talking about, and if u have any of that intellectual honesty u keep ranting about you will stop this non-sense now and disappear.


Add 50% to 20 and you get 32? Is that how math works?
Again, you have completely failed to establish any mathematical or theoretical connection between fire loads, pre-heating, and heating duration such that it makes sense to, on one hand, add 8 kg/m3 to NIST's model fire load and, on the other hand, remove all pre-heating from NIST's model and reduce NIST's direct heating time from over 50 minutes to between 25-30 min. There is simply no relationship between those actions that you have established that justifies them from an analytical standpoint and I am 100% confident you cannot find an actual published paper by an actual fire scientist who employs such a ridiculous, haphazard methodology. No matter which way you cut it, there is no basis for Korol's methodology.

And, by the way, even if you believed there were a basis for Korol's methodology of omitting all pre-heating in exchange for increasing the fire load to 40kg/m3, the fact that the '93 Cardington studies showed a protected beam subject to the actual true duration of direct heating experienced in a compartmental fire with a 40kg/m3 fire load (which was about 90 minutes) reached 750 C, shows that Korol is still mistaken in arbitrarily cutting the heating time by 66%.

Everytime u post something I catch u lying and evading, and your response every time is changing the subject again and lying more...and now it is time to stop allowing u changing the subject again...and backtrack instead, starting from newest to oldest until I got a straight answer to everything u have avoided so far...and since u think repeating your claims about Tony endlessly is so cool I might do the same if u dont deliver.

Now, your latest post is full of gibberish to divert attention from your claim in the post before that:
Originally Posted by benthamitemetric View Post
Dude, I think you need to seriously check your sources. What was the fire load NIST used to estimate the fires on the floors it believed to be collapse initiating? It was 32kg/m3 (and NIST never claims this was some sort of high-end, worst case scenario load, by the way). It only says so right there on page 60 of NIST NCSTAR 1-9.

I told u that U are reduced to babbling gobbledygook...can u refute that? What did u think u were refuting? I told u nist went 50% over 20 to 30, about mid point between the 20 and 40. OK it 32 not 30 but that detail does not really change anything or refute anything i said ..so if not gibberish, why did u repeat info about nist choice of mid level fuel load and try to create some sort of controversy?
 
Wouldn't it make more sense to consider each potential reason for the building's collapse to see which can be rejected immediately and which deserve further consideration?

e.g.
Godzilla attack: Did Godzilla attack the building? No. So that falls at the first hurdle.
Then fire: Was the building on fire? Yes. Okay, that's still in contention.
Explosives: Were there explosions? No. Okay, so that's out of the running.

Anyone want to add to the list?
 
Wouldn't it make more sense to consider each potential reason for the building's collapse to see which can be rejected immediately and which deserve further consideration?

e.g.
Godzilla attack: Did Godzilla attack the building? No. So that falls at the first hurdle.
Then fire: Was the building on fire? Yes. Okay, that's still in contention.
Explosives: Were there explosions? No. Okay, so that's out of the running.

Anyone want to add to the list?

The Big Bad Wolf? Not witnessed at the site, and nobody reported excessive amounts of huffing or puffing. So that's out of the running, though no less likely than explosives.

Dave
 
Wouldn't it make more sense to consider each potential reason for the building's collapse to see which can be rejected immediately and which deserve further consideration?

e.g.
Godzilla attack: Did Godzilla attack the building? No. So that falls at the first hurdle.
Then fire: Was the building on fire? Yes. Okay, that's still in contention.
Explosives: Were there explosions? No. Okay, so that's out of the running.

Anyone want to add to the list?

The Klingons were not involved.

There was a photo long ago with Darth Vader, slicing though the column with a light saber.
 
The last few pages here highlight the reality that there are no legitimate engineering analyses that can show WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The three reports we have that make that claim require impossible situations and actually refute one another.

The ARUP analysis shows the NIST alleged walk-off of girder A2001 to the west was impossible, the Weidlinger report shows both NIST's and ARUP's alleged floor cascades were impossible and I had independently verified this before even seeing the Weidlinger report. Finally, the Weidlinger report needs to claim extreme steel temperatures not contained in either of the two earlier reports and which are not substantiated publicly.

It is clear from the last several pages here that those who still insist on believing that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire cannot provide a plausible hypothesis for their claim and are reduced to babbling things like "there were fires in the building and we know it distorts steel". It is also clear why none of these individuals will debate the issue in a one-on-one situation. They simply can't and know they will suffer the same ignominious fate as tfk.
 
Last edited:
The last few pages here highlight the reality that there are no legitimate engineering analyses that can show WTC 7 collapsed due to fire. The three reports we have that make that claim require impossible situations and actually refute one another.

The ARUP analysis shows the NIST alleged walk-off of girder A2001 to the west was impossible, the Weidlinger report shows both NIST's and ARUP's alleged floor cascades were impossible and I had independently verified this before even seeing the Weidlinger report. Finally, the Weidlinger report needs to claim extreme steel temperatures not contained in either of the two earlier reports and which are not substantiated publicly.

It is clear from the last several pages here that those who insist on still believing that WTC 7 collapsed due to fire cannot provide a plausible hypothesis for their claim and are reduced to babbling things like "there were fires in the building and we know it distorts steel". This kind of unsubstantiated claim belies the intent of those making it and shows they must have an agenda and why they tend to post using anonymous pseudonyms. It is also clear why none of these individuals who still insist that the building came down due to fire will debate the issue in a one-on-one situation.

Experimental proof of claim please, you say it is impossible up to you to prove it!

A calculator with fudged numbers is not proof.

Fly ash Microspheres, and red paint chips are no proof of crime Tony a new investigation will only prove you are lying, and have been lying for a very long time.
 
As opposed to the one that showed it did not collapse due to explosives, which you like to conveniently forget.

Dave

Your claim that there are no real world examples of something done covertly to a large building over time is refuted by the secret repair of the Citicorp building in 1978. The repair was done at night over a three month period without public knowledge and would never have even been publicly known without those who managed it choosing to make it known in the late 1990's.

Additionally, planting charges on core columns, via the elevator shafts, which allow access to them, is not observable.
 
Last edited:
Your claim that there are no real world examples of something done covertly to a large building over time is refuted by the secret repair of the Citicorp building in 1978. The repair was done at night over a three month period without public knowledge and would never have even been publicly known without those who managed it choosing to make it known in the late 1990's.

Planting charges on core columns, via the elevator shafts, which allow access to them, is not observable.
Would that be the "secret repair" where video of the welding was taken? :)
 
Would that be the "secret repair" where video of the welding was taken? :)

The public was not aware of the repair. You can't deny that.

Additionally, planting charges on core columns as would need to be done in WTC 7, via the elevator shafts, which allow access to them, is not even observable.

It is abundantly clear that you cannot present a plausible hypothesis for fire causing the collapse of WTC 7.
 
Last edited:
Additionally, planting charges on core columns as would need to be done in WTC 7, via the elevator shafts, which allow access to them, is not even observable.

We know that the initial failure in WTC7 was in columns 77-79, from the observation that the mechanical penthouse above them fell into the building; at the very least any hypothetical charges must have been placed on these columns. Would you like to show us a floor plan of WTC7 which shows how one would access columns 77-79 from the elevator shafts?

Dave
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom