Kid re-wires clock, gets suspended from school for "bomb hoax"

And they pretend to be lawyer or knows about law ? Libel and first amendment have nothing to do with each other. It may or may not be SLAPP (frankly after seeing what **** thrown on the family, from terrorist to diva, I tend to disagree) , but this is NOT an issue about government impacting those who spoke, it is about a private entity suing another for libel, and as such so far as I can see first amendment does not apply. First amendment does not protect you against libel in the least.

That's just wrong. The First Amendment provides substantial (though not absolute) protection against suits for libelous or defaming speech. The private party is asking the government to impose a penalty for acts of speech or functioning as the press.

New York Times v. Sullivan is probably the landmark case in this regard.
 
Last edited:
" it was patently opinion based on reported facts about an issue of public interest, and therefore protected by the First Amendment."

And they pretend to be lawyer or knows about law ? Libel and first amendment have nothing to do with each other. It may or may not be SLAPP (frankly after seeing what **** thrown on the family, from terrorist to diva, I tend to disagree) , but this is NOT an issue about government impacting those who spoke, it is about a private entity suing another for libel, and as such so far as I can see first amendment does not apply. First amendment does not protect you against libel in the least.

Well, I am certainly no lawyer, but Ken White, who writes the Popehat blog is in fact a practicing lawyer, not "pretending to be a lawyer". (Actually it is group blog, he's not the only blogger there.) And the law around free speech issues seems to be his main area of interest so maybe he is a bit of an expert in this area.

Anyway, I think what you are doing here might be called "splitting hairs". Maybe I phrased what I said in a sloppy way, because as I already admitted, I am not a lawyer. I'll try to rephrase it:

Or looked at another way, to protect the the right of people to freely express themselves without being dragged into court and sued by somebody who didn't like what they said.

This is an issue that affects skeptics too, by the way. Skeptics have been sued for defamation or libel for calling things that they think are fraud, fraud.

Some examples:
Junk Scientist Greets Skepticism With Legal Threats, Sues Blogger For Criticizing Him And His Work
I got sued for $3 Million by a religious cult
Simon Singh wins libel court battle

What anti-SLAPP laws do is allow the defendants in these cases to recover legal costs. Because if you state an opinion that is legally protected speech, you shouldn't have to worry that you might be sued and have to face ruinous legal costs in defending yourself, even if you prevail.

https://www.popehat.com/about/

What is Popehat about? It's about whatever its authors want. Often its authors want to talk about free speech, liberty, criminal justice, the legal system and its foibles, and related issues.
 
" it was patently opinion based on reported facts about an issue of public interest, and therefore protected by the First Amendment."

And they pretend to be lawyer or knows about law ? Libel and first amendment have nothing to do with each other. It may or may not be SLAPP (frankly after seeing what **** thrown on the family, from terrorist to diva, I tend to disagree) , but this is NOT an issue about government impacting those who spoke, it is about a private entity suing another for libel, and as such so far as I can see first amendment does not apply. First amendment does not protect you against libel in the least.

Hmm, who's opinion should I value the most, a named lawyer on a blog writing within his area of expertise plus a Judge who made the ruling or an anonymous internet poster, such a tough decision :rolleyes:.

They plaintiff is probably free to appeal the decision but they will have to take into account that if they loose the amount owed to the defendants will increase, possibly more than double, appeals are expensive.
 
B-b-but he's a kid and a Muslim, and he's brown. That a lone entitles him to a massive payout for having to grow up in our islamophobic white-male dominated cis-patriarchy. You islamophobes disgust me.
 
Ha! Great news.

and the lil inventor and his mercenary family thought they were going to make bank.
 
In young master Mohamed's honor, I shall take the back cover off of my old NOAA weather radio, dump the contents out into a shoe box, and name the result The Official Ahmed Memorial NOAA Weather Radio That I Invented Myself. And when a local television station interviews me I will hold up an old broken motherboard and say "I like to invent things like this", explaining that I was inspired by Ahmed.
 
Last edited:
So nice to the more right-leaning members of the forum chiming in. Unfortunately it's with their usual avalanche of fact-free and racist slurs that I've come to expect from them.

Yes, Mohamed said he "invented" a clock, when all he did was a case mod. Chalk that up to a teenager who may not have an adult's sophisticated command of English.

Also, he didn't file the lawsuit (being a minor, I don't think he can.) It was filed on his behalf, and I've never heard from the boy himself if he approved of the action or not. Even if he did, who's to say he did it to get a financial windfall as opposed to, maybe, get some redress from a school district that assumed he had a bomb when he didn't (maybe because he was brown and a Muslim?), arrested and held in custody over a simple frigging case mod!

Wolrab, Tony, The Big Dog, and Checkmite: what have you got against someone seeking redress for an incredible over-reaction to a simple electronic device?
 
Last edited:
In young master Mohamed's honor, I shall take the back cover off of my old NOAA weather radio, dump the contents out into a shoe box, and name the result The Official Ahmed Memorial NOAA Weather Radio That I Invented Myself. And when a local television station interviews me I will hold up an old broken motherboard and say "I like to invent things like this", explaining that I was inspired by Ahmed.

make sure you fail to drill a hole in the box for the existing power cord that you invented so you can invent the idea of not being able to close the box
 
So nice to the more right-leaning members of the forum chiming in. Unfortunately it's with their usual avalanche of fact-free and racist slurs that I've come to expect from them.

Yes, Mohamed said he "invented" a clock, when all he did was a case mod. Chalk that up to a teenager who may not have an adult's sophisticated command of English.

Also, he didn't file the lawsuit (being a minor, I don't think he can.) It was filed on his behalf, and I've never heard from the boy himself if he approved of the action or not. Even if he did, who's to say he did it to get a financial windfall as opposed to, maybe, get some redress from a school district that assumed he had a bomb when he didn't (maybe because he was brown and a Muslim?), arrested and held in custody over a simple frigging case mod!

Wolrab, Tony, The Big Dog, and Checkmite: what have you got against someone seeking redress for an incredible over-reaction to a simple electronic device?

My super favorite part? When you said that our posts are "fact free" and then manage to utterly fail to understand the actual linked article which concerned the Lil Inventor family's SLAPP suit against a reporter and others for daring to question his (and his Father's) claims despite knowing that the Lil Inventor and his family and were "brown and Muslim."

What have you got against skepticism?
 
Yes, Mohamed said he "invented" a clock, when all he did was a case mod. Chalk that up to a teenager who may not have an adult's sophisticated command of English.

No...I've seen the interviews, the kid had a perfectly fluent high-school-age-appropriate command of English. He said he "invented" the clock because he intended people to believe he literally took disparate wires and components that had once not been a clock and connected them together in order to create a clock. When he held up a circuit board from some kind of AV component on television and explained "I like to make stuff...like this", he intended to communicate that he literally put that thing together.
 
Last edited:
No...I've seen the interviews, the kid had a perfectly fluent high-school-age-appropriate command of English. He said he "invented" the clock because he intended people to believe he literally took disparate wires and components that had once not been a clock and connected them together in order to create a clock. When he held up a circuit board from some kind of AV component on television and explained "I like to make stuff...like this", he intended to communicate that he literally put that thing together.


I see that your psychic powers are still strong. You can read his mind.

(Perfectly fluent? Are you certain about that?)

Have you ever shopped for a clock? Any kind of clock?

Have you noticed that are several (Hundreds of? Thousands of?) different shapes and styles of every kind to choose from?

I expect that most of them have some sort of design patent (Also known as 'invented'.) on their particular model, even when the innards are off-the-shelf and patented by someone else.

Why is it any different for this kid? He took some clock circuitry and arranged it into a presentation of his own design. This sort of initiative, small as it may be, is to be prized, not ridiculed. And certainly not punished with public shaming and police harassment.
 
Wolrab, Tony, The Big Dog, and Checkmite: what have you got against someone seeking redress for an incredible over-reaction to a simple electronic device?

I'm not a right leaning member so I don't know this was addressed to me.
 
No payday for the super smart inventor? I so sorry from the heart of my bottom.

Ha! Great news.

and the lil inventor and his mercenary family thought they were going to make bank.

Both these quotes imply the KID filed the lawsuit to make HIM rich, although The Big Dog's version of it also implies he filed the suit to enrich his whole family. Both are wrong. The boy's father filed the suit, possibly for financial gain, or possibly because he believed he had a legitimate grievance against Shapiro. Given the father's reputation as an activist, he probably wasn't in it for the money.

I also find the belittling insults against Ahmed disgusting. Did he say he invented a clock, or just "invented" the case mod?. He couldn't use the term "invented" if he had followed instructions on a YouTube video or DIY magazine of some description, but if he came up with the case mod idea on his own without assistance from others then, yes, he did invent it in the sense he did something that was novel (for him.)

If he did it at 25 and tried to patent his "invention," it would probably be rejected based on prior art.

ETA: Just because his father might be a jerk doesn't mean the son is.
 
Last edited:
I see that your psychic powers are still strong. You can read his mind.

That is the*amazing thing that*human language allows us to do, yes.

(Perfectly fluent? Are you certain about that?)

Reasonably confident. He speaks like a very typical American-raised kid (which he is), without an accent or any speech impediments or verbal tics that would indicate he has a less than age-appropriate command of English.

Have you ever shopped for a clock? Any kind of clock?

Have you noticed that are several (Hundreds of? Thousands of?) different shapes and styles of every kind to choose from?

I expect that most of them have some sort of design patent (Also known as 'invented'.) on their particular model, even when the innards are off-the-shelf and patented by someone else.

No; you are*inaccurately juxtaposing the concept of a "design patent"*- which applies to a thing's ornamental configuration - with a strict "patent", which applies to*the invention of a functional item or process. But*even if you weren't, you're still wrong - a company which fabricates its own plastic shell for a clock*can*be given a design patent for the specific*original shell they've designed; they cannot take an already-designed item, like a pencil case,*lay an already-designed electronic clock inside it, and claim that*the pencil-case (originally designed by someone else) and this particular electronic clock (originally designed by someone else) together now comprise a wholly new item*"originally designed by*me".

Why is it any different for this kid? He took some clock circuitry and arranged it into a presentation of his own design. This sort of initiative, small as it may be, is to be prized, not ridiculed. And certainly not punished with public shaming and police harassment.

Except that he did not present it as someone else's item that he has "uniquely arranged", he presented it as*an*example of something he*put together out of bits and pieces. He stated in multiple interviews that the clock was assembled from "scrap around the house".* The narrative built by his many media interviews*makes it very clear the public is intended to believe he*builds original contraptions out of wires and components scavenged from other devices using a working knowledge of electronics, which is a lie. It is no more true than opening and pouring the contents of a microwavable-container of canned pasta into your own bowl before sticking it into the microwave, rather than heating it using the container it came in, means you have created your own unique variety of canned pasta. And no, this sort of "initiative" is not to be prized, it is*not to be rewarded. It is to be called out plainly for what it is without a moment's hesitation, lest the*boy become encouraged to tell bigger and more frequent lies by the realization that lying is an effective and effortless path to recognition and reward (unfortunately, it's possible that ship may have already sailed in this case).

As for the police - I*have no intention of arguing about that situation. In point of fact I thought it was ridiculous; I don't buy for a moment that anyone actually believed the*thing "could be a bomb", or*thought that some other person could reasonably suspect it was a bomb. And neither, if you are interested, to I believe that he created the thing intending to cause a law-enforcement incident. I don't know if the case against the actual school/police department has been disposed yet or how; but if it is still on going, I certainly hope he wins. The boy is an utter fraud, and his family are knowing enablers of his fraud, but it wasn't fraud of a criminal degree, just one worthy of notice and ridicule.
 
This kid didn't "Re-Wire" a clock: he just took the plastic shell off of it and called it his own "piece of resistance" (as they'd say in France). What this kid did was 2 grade levels below High School and a testament to the kid's sub-normal intelligence. The whole deal is really pathetic.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom