Being Reasoned Out Of Religion.

Well, at least that explains Squeegee's love of strawman!

I say that "as soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world." (This is an actual quotation, not the Squeegee kind!)

Squeegee then pretends that somebody, a nun (and later seminar-school students and whoever else read it) already found out what God is, except that they didn't, but this pretense is necessary for the apparent paradox he is going for: "Yet many of those scholars remain Christians." His paradox works only if they remain Christian in spite of the awareness that God doesn't actually exist. His anecdote never showed that, but he seems to think that if he repeats the claim often enough it will somehow come true.
 
There you go again with your tired old strawman.




As if what were some kind of virtue? Your straw man?

When all else fails just throw in a "straw man" accusation - always a vote winner.


Exactly! The battle has actually been won, at least to some extent. Not by atheists, however, but by social reforms, the work of the trade-union movement. And it could easily be lost again - not really because of Christians or Muslims, but because of conservative politics.

The battle has been won because of the collapse of the authority of the church, and that is because of the reduced support for the church by the people - a growing number of non believing people. Generally conservative politicians tend to be religious, most certainly so in Australia.


ETA:


When you say "we", I guess you're referring to yourself and all the Australian Christians, right?! Or would you rather cling to the delusion that "we" are a handful of atheists courageously taking on the Christian stormtroopers?!

Most Christians in Australia support marriage equality and want a free vote

Myself and all the Australian Christians??? We do seem to have a communication problem ...... perhaps I caught something from Squeegee.:D
 
When all else fails just throw in a "straw man" accusation - always a vote winner.


I've asked you to document them, and you didn't. You just keep repeating them - you even do so in other threads - in the apparent hope that somebody believes your lies. Also very Trump-like. So sad!

The battle has been won because of the collapse of the authority of the church, and that is because of the reduced support for the church by the people - a growing number of non believing people. Generally conservative politicians tend to be religious, most certainly so in Australia.


But your example was of opposition to gay marriage, and I documented that a majority of Christians, i.e. obviously not your "non believing people", are in favor of gay marriage.

Myself and all the Australian Christians??? We do seem to have a communication problem ...... perhaps I caught something from Squeegee.:D


Yes, it is very difficult to communicate with people who lie. In particular when they just continue to lie instead of documenting their claims (which, of course, they can't) when they are asked to do so: "There you go with that stuff about not caring about what theists think again."

And again: very Trump-like!
 
Well, at least that explains Squeegee's love of strawman!

I say that "as soon as you find out what God actually is, i.e. an idea created by people to fulfill a need to imagine that such a creature exists, you stop looking for god(s) in the real world." (This is an actual quotation, not the Squeegee kind!)

Squeegee then pretends that somebody, a nun (and later seminar-school students and whoever else read it) already found out what God is, except that they didn't, but this pretense is necessary for the apparent paradox he is going for: "Yet many of those scholars remain Christians." His paradox works only if they remain Christian in spite of the awareness that God doesn't actually exist. His anecdote never showed that, but he seems to think that if he repeats the claim often enough it will somehow come true.

Speaking of straw men. That's a shame, as I thought you were one of the few people in this subforum I could actually have an honest debate with. I won't make that mistake again.
 
Speaking of straw men. That's a shame, as I thought you were one of the few people in this subforum I could actually have an honest debate with. I won't make that mistake again.


You completely ignored my argument against your idea that noticing that an idea evolves is the same thing as recognizing that an actual object exists:

That the idea of disease evolves isn't very difficult to discover - the ancients had their ideas and today we think very differently - but discovering that the idea of disease evolves doesn't mean that medical doctors have now concluded that disease doesn't exist! On the contrary, they know not only that it is, but also what it is.
See?! Recognizing that an idea evolves is not the same thing as recognizing that the thing that the idea is about doesn't actually exist. You are the one who has been claiming the identity of the two very different things in order to insist on the tautology of your strawman.
 
My sentence above should have been:

You completely ignored my argument against your idea that noticing that an idea evolves is the same thing as recognizing that an actual object does not exist:
 
I've asked you to document them, and you didn't. You just keep repeating them - you even do so in other threads - in the apparent hope that somebody believes your lies. Also very Trump-like. So sad!




But your example was of opposition to gay marriage, and I documented that a majority of Christians, i.e. obviously not your "non believing people", are in favor of gay marriage.




Yes, it is very difficult to communicate with people who lie. In particular when they just continue to lie instead of documenting their claims (which, of course, they can't) when they are asked to do so: "There you go with that stuff about not caring about what theists think again."

And again: very Trump-like!


So now we resort to name calling, saying I tell lies and playing the Trump card once again, even though it is off suit.

The survey you quote claims that 54% of Christians (from a sample of 1000) where in favour of same sex marriage, whereas the postal survey showed nationally people were 61.6% in favour, indicating a much higher % of non religious voted yes.

We had the very vocal churches campaigning for a no vote also, the Catholic Church predominantly, although others as well. I got some crap in my letterbox from one.
 
So now we resort to name calling, saying I tell lies and playing the Trump card once again, even though it is off suit.

The survey you quote claims that 54% of Christians (from a sample of 1000) where in favour of same sex marriage, whereas the postal survey showed nationally people were 61.6% in favour, indicating a much higher % of non religious voted yes.

We had the very vocal churches campaigning for a no vote also, the Catholic Church predominantly, although others as well. I got some crap in my letterbox from one.
Still actually ;)
 
A lie doesn't get better because you repeat it! He could have documented his accusation (which I've asked him to do and which he'd be able to do if if weren't a strawman) but instead he's offended. Ynot might have helped him, but he'd rather keep up the pretense.
 
We are definitely going round in circles. You keep denying dictionary definitions of words while claiming that it's incorrect to use words to mean what they are defined as meaning. You also keep asserting that it's impossible for people to say that they are certain something is true unless it actually is objective fact - that it's impossible to believe something to be true unless it actually is objective fact. You also keep asserting that I think and have said things which I do and have not.

In other words, you keep ignoring or handwaving away all evidence that you are wrong in order to keep banging the same tin drum, simply repeating your straw men, ignorance, and downright bizarre anti-factualism. I'd like it if you'd stop doing this and would instead address what I've actually said, but it seems you will not.


I was reading something on the UK BBC news on Friday (nothing to do with this thread), and they were quoting something that was said a few years ago by some US politician. It was a reply to some assertion by someone, and he said “sir your are entitled to your own opinions, but not to your own facts” …

… I don't know who politician was and I am certainly not endorsing any of his politics or any other things he may or may not have done. But that answer sums up this situation entirely -

“You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own Facts” .
 
I was reading something on the UK BBC news on Friday (nothing to do with this thread), and they were quoting something that was said a few years ago by some US politician. It was a reply to some assertion by someone, and he said “sir your are entitled to your own opinions, but not to your own facts” …

… I don't know who politician was and I am certainly not endorsing any of his politics or any other things he may or may not have done. But that answer sums up this situation entirely -

“You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own Facts” .

Not all facts are objective, scientific facts established with evidence through science.
The fact that I use secular humanism as part of my morality/ethics is a fact, but it is a subjective fact. Or if you like in objective terms, all cases of morality/ethics are not Objective Facts, but subjective opinion, feeling, emotion and what not.
And now you are going to mention laws, but laws are not Objective Facts.
Indeed that you treat subjectivity as "subjectivity", is something you do subjectively.

https://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/whatisscience_12
Now that you subjectively ignore this, is evidence for subjectivity.
That you deny subjectivity, is subjective and is evidence for subjectivity.

Reality is not objective in practice and you can't do:
  • Morality/ethics
  • Aesthetics
  • Politics
  • The meaning of life
using science.

With regards
 
Not all facts are objective, scientific facts established with evidence through science.
The fact that I use secular humanism as part of my morality/ethics is a fact, but it is a subjective fact. Or if you like in objective terms, all cases of morality/ethics are not Objective Facts, but subjective opinion, feeling, emotion and what not.
And now you are going to mention laws, but laws are not Objective Facts.
Indeed that you treat subjectivity as "subjectivity", is something you do subjectively.

https://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/whatisscience_12
Now that you subjectively ignore this, is evidence for subjectivity.
That you deny subjectivity, is subjective and is evidence for subjectivity.

Reality is not objective in practice and you can't do:
  • Morality/ethics
  • Aesthetics
  • Politics
  • The meaning of life
using science.

With regards


Well first of all science does not claim to prove "facts".

And secondly we are talking specifically about the existence of God in cases where theists claim "God exists, it's a fact and I am certain of it" ... at best they can only really mean "I believe it's a fact" ...

... they can not make God pop into existence merely by saying "its' a fact and I am certain of it".
 
Well first of all science does not claim to prove "facts".

And secondly we are talking specifically about the existence of God in cases where theists claim "God exists, it's a fact and I am certain of it" ... at best they can only really mean "I believe it's a fact" ...

... they can not make God pop into existence merely by saying "its' a fact and I am certain of it".

Well, first I said nothing about proof.

Secondly, as for God, yes belief doesn't cut it as a fact. The same as whether you are a brain in a vat or not; belief doesn't cut it as a fact.
You believe in a world, which is as it appears to you in your mind. That makes you a believer, just not a religious one.
 
Well, first I said nothing about proof.


Look back at your own post, you talked about “scientific facts”. Here is what you actually said “scientific facts established with evidence through science.”.

What I said to you was, and is, “science does not claim to prove facts”.

A “fact” is something that can only be shown by a literal “proof”. If something is claimed to be a “fact” about the observable universe, in this case specifically the claim that “it is a fact that God exists”, then you must produce a literal proof for your claim of “fact” … science does not claim to do that … it does not claim to show any literal “proofs”, and that's why it does not claim "certainty of fact”.


Secondly, as for God, yes belief doesn't cut it as a fact. The same as whether you are a brain in a vat or not; belief doesn't cut it as a fact.


Indeed belief does not equate to “fact”. And when any theist says “I know God exists, it's a fact, I am certain of it”, that statement is completely worthless until they can produce an absolute proof showing God actually does exist. And the same would be true if any atheist is silly enough to say "I know God does not exist, it is a fact, and I am certain of it". That is a similarly erroneous statement for exactly the same reasons.


You believe in a world, which is as it appears to you in your mind. That makes you a believer, just not a religious one.


Firstly – do not to tell me or anyone else what I believe. I & others will decide what we believe for ourselves.

Secondly – indeed I believe all sorts of things are likely to be true, and that all sorts of other things are likely to be untrue. And as far as I know everyone else on the planet does exactly that too. And you will search in vain anywhere on the internet (or anywhere else) for me ever claiming anything other than “belief” about anything (I am not in the habit of claiming ever to know things as absolute facts or as literal certainty).

As I have actually said here many times - I do not believe a supernatural God (such as the Christian God) exists. I think that's entirely an untrue myth that arose in ancient times when people did not have the benefit of any modern scientific education about what the real evidence shows for ideas such as a world created by a biblical superhuman God.

It's entirely a matter of credible honest evidence. Not actually a matter of “fact” or “certainty”.

And by the way you are now slipping rapidly downhill towards yet another claim of solipsism asserting that none of the observed world is real. And that is just a total waste of everyones time, patience, and good faith.
 
Well first of all science does not claim to prove "facts".

I beg your pardon.

A “fact” is something that can only be shown by a literal “proof”. If something is claimed to be a “fact” about the observable universe(...), then you must produce a literal proof for your claim of “fact” … science does not claim to do that … it does not claim to show any literal “proofs”, and that's why it does not claim "certainty of fact”.

I beg your pardon!!
 
Last edited:
You completely ignored my argument against your idea that noticing that an idea evolves is the same thing as recognizing that an actual object exists:

I did quote that, but it was factored into my reply. Which you ignored with a wave of your hand in order to fashion a straw man. Which is a shame.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom