Cosmic Yak
Philosopher
I might find the results of it vile sometimes. Fixating on the thing itself seems like puritanism to me.
Please be specific. What vile results have you seen, and what good effects have you seen?
I think one of the problems people here are finding with your position is your continued refusal to say why you think racism is in any way, wholly or partly, a good thing, or at least a neutral thing.
Depends what the results of it were. The thing itself doesn't bother me one way or the other.
You are contradicting yourself here. You said earlier that you didn't believe in imposing a universal morality on everyone. Having the state dictate who can marry whom, based solely on racial grounds, is imposing universal morality- or, to be more precise, universal immorality.
No. I absolutely don't. I had rather thought that was the majority view of the forum. People keep banging on about "democracy" and the "popular vote".
Yes, you absolutely do. You have stated several times that the majority of the public are opposed to immigration. That was not a statement about this forum, but about the whole of the UK.
I'm not value free, but the world is a fallen place and man is a fallen animal.
More vague waffling. What exactly do you mean by this?
Do your values make the world better in a way that doesn't circularly refer back to your values?
Yes. Inclusivity and diversity encourage creativity and a wider range of inputs in businesses, so our values have direct economic benefits.
Ending racial pogroms stops killing, another benefit I would have thought was immediately obvious.
Being on the receiving end of racial prejudice has direct effects on mental health: curbing that would lead to better mental health.
So, reducing violence, improving mental health and making us richer are just some of the benefits of combatting racism.
Now, how about you list the opposite: what specific benefits can you give for racism?
People complain about Christian morality being forced on people. You want to force your morality on people. I don't see much difference. It's just two different groups of people who are certain they know the right way to live. Again, ultimately I doubt your ability to persuade everybody to follow your morality.... so what then?
Not true. What people here are saying is that it is wrong to impose race-based morality on people. People should have the right to marry whom they choose, regardless of the colour of their skins. The stance of the majority on this forum is the opposite of what you claim. You are the one advocating- by silence and obfuscation, as much as anything else- the imposition of morality on a populace.
Like I say. Mixed race marriage doesn't bother me. If in the distant future we get to the point where it becomes an issue, I'll probably have more of an opinion. I'm sure there are plenty of things religious people think are very important theoretical issues, but because your world view is different you wouldn't feel strongly about them.
And yet you are still unwilling or unable to say what those negative results could be.
One big difference i suspect is between us is that I see a lot more problems as coming from the implementation of liberal goods. I see a much more mixed and equivocal story. That just makes me more sceptical about jumping in with both feet without looking first.
No, you are attempting to conceal your bigotry beneath a veil of circumspection and pragmatism. Your lack of concrete examples of the kind of negative effects possible from mixed-race marriages is evidence of this. You're basically just going 'Euw! Icky!' and dressing it up as a rational and informed choice. Word to the wise: you aren't fooling anybody with this.
Why would one defend it on scientific grounds? What has that got to do with it? I'm curious.
I think this was a reference to pseudo-scientific theories of racial superiority, such as those employed by the Nazis.
I'd like to add that you refuse to condemn racism on ideological grounds, or on grounds of morality, or from a human rights point of view, or any historical, economic or cultural grounds. You have ruled all these out. Now you're saying there's no scientific rebuttal to racism either. I can't help but conclude that you find nothing objectionable about racism, for any reason. And you know what that makes you.