The following has been posted already. My apologies to people keeping up in the thread. It is a long, well worth reading discussion of events that preceded the COVID pandemic.
MIT Tech Review: PANDEMIC TECHNOLOGY PROJECT
Inside the risky bat-virus engineering that links America to Wuhan - China emulated US techniques to construct novel coronaviruses in unsafe conditions
In 2013, the American virologist Ralph Baric approached Zhengli Shi at a meeting. Baric was a top expert in coronaviruses, with hundreds of papers to his credit, and Shi, along with her team at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, had been discovering them by the fistful in bat caves. In one sample of bat guano, Shi had detected the genome of a new virus, called SHC014, that was one of the two closest relatives to the original SARS virus, but her team had not been able to culture it in the lab.
Baric had developed a way around that problem—a technique for “reverse genetics” in coronaviruses. Not only did it allow him to bring an actual virus to life from its genetic code, but he could mix and match parts of multiple viruses.
So unless people think this MIT author is a CT believer, ...
Oh dear, am I data dumping again.

It's so hard not to. I and others have done so many literature reviews for this thread.
Sigh, all that work and here we are again having to repeat what is already in the thread to newcomers to the conversation who so triumphantly believe they know it all.
If you study a hundred different bat viruses, your luck may run out.
-Ralph Baric, University of North Carolina
There was a mutually beneficial trade between Baric and Shi.
Baric asked Shi if he could have the genetic data for SHC014. “She was gracious enough to send us those sequences almost immediately,” he says. His team introduced the virus modified with that code into mice and into a petri dish of human airway cells. Sure enough, the chimera exhibited “robust replication” in the human cells—evidence that nature was full of coronaviruses ready to leap directly to people.
Shi et al assisted nature in producing recombinant versions of SARSr CoVs. That's how one does GoF research in the lab.
Angrysoba posted rebuttals to these research papers. I don't recall what the objections were. Some were reasonable (that have been countered), some not so much like dismissing everything out of hand that Quay, Chan and a few others had to say. I'll let AS remind us.
Baric was extremely careful, the WIV, not so much:
The NIH decided the risk was worth it. In a potentially fateful decision, it funded work similar to Baric’s at the Wuhan Institute of Virology, which soon used its own reverse-genetics technology to make numerous coronavirus chimeras.
Unnoticed by most, however, was a key difference that significantly shifted the risk calculation. The Chinese work was carried out at biosafety level 2 (BSL-2), a much lower tier than Baric’s BSL-3+.
Shi worked at BSL2, not even BSL3 let alone BSL4, which BTW was also plagued by a shortage of expertise and other problems described in a US diplomatic cable. And coronaviruses were recovered from sewage runoff from the WIV. Again links are posted up thread and I'm not going to hunt them down. Anyone who wants to, feel free.
Moving on:
What caused the covid-19 pandemic remains uncertain, and Shi says her lab never encountered the SARS-CoV-2 virus before the Wuhan outbreak. But now that US officials have said the possibility of a lab accident needs to be investigated, the spotlight has fallen on American funding of the Wuhan lab’s less safe research. Today a chorus of scientists, including Baric, are coming forward to say this was a misstep. Even if there is no link to covid-19, allowing work on potentially dangerous bat viruses at BSL-2 is “an actual scandal,” says Michael Lin, a bioengineer at Stanford University.
Then we get to Rand Paul and his fixation on Fauci who also lied (or in his mind used a pedantic argument) when he claimed the US did not fund any GoF research at the WIV. That's another waste of time sidetrack that only serves to discredit actual supportable facts. The NIH did admit they funded GoF research at the WIV (documented up thread).
Who cares? I don't, not at this point. There is plenty of blame to go around.
One thing that does matter: you cannot do GoF research without live cultures.
They [Baric and Shi] did share resources—for example, Baric sent the transgenic mice with human lung receptors to Wuhan. But after their initial collaboration, the two centers were more like competitors. They were in a race to identify dangerous coronaviruses, assess the potential threat, and develop countermeasures like vaccines. ...
By taking thousands of samples from guano, fecal swabs, and bat tissue, and searching those samples for genetic sequences similar to SARS, Shi’s team began to discover many closely related viruses. In a cave in Yunnan Province in 2011 or 2012, they discovered the two closest, which they named WIV1 and SHC014.
Shi managed to culture WIV1 in her lab from a fecal sample and show that it could directly infect human cells, proving that SARS-like viruses ready to leap straight from bats to humans already lurked in the natural world. This showed, Daszak and Shi argued, that bat coronaviruses were a “substantial global threat.” Scientists, they said, needed to find them, and study them, before they found us.
If there had been a trail of a bat spillover into humans in Wuhan one might argue it was a natural spillover, not a lab leak. Bats were not a popular item for sale in Wuhan wet markets. And now we have the spillover proponents in a tizzy because raccoon dogs were around when COVID-19 was. No bats though.
We are back to a coincidence that is about as likely as a meteorite hitting my house. First one needs human adapted or a virus very closely related to SARS CoV2 to be circulating in bats in Yunnan.
That has not been found. Then a raccoon dog needs to get infected with that virus. That could happen in the wild or it could happen in an animal farm that raccoon dogs and bats are in contact with each other.
Said related virus has yet to be found circulating in raccoon dogs anywhere.
Now you have to multiply the probability one or more of those raccoon dogs made it to the Wuhan wet market without a single person in contact with the animals—trappers, farmers, transporters—getting infected until an exposure at the wet market.
And that virus has to die out in the raccoon dogs and/or in the bats because again, there were no COVID infections until Wuhan. And that was searched for in a number of different ways (again, sources posted up thread).
Multiply that probability by the odds the person infected in the wet market was a super spreader. Or maybe the first person infected spread the virus more silently in Wuhan until it made its way back to the wet market super spreader. ??? But then how does this explain the dog DNA/virus RNA recovery in one stall at the market?
This chain of events has plot holes, lots of them. And Worobey ignored them.
Daszak was excited about GoF research with coronaviruses. He was sure it would lead to a universal vaccine before a deadly virus spread.
Baric’s system provided a way to rapidly test their spikes by engineering them into similar viruses. When the chimera he made using SHC014 proved able to infect human cells in a dish, Daszak told the press that these revelations should “move this virus from a candidate emerging pathogen to a clear and present danger.”
And why not? That could mean millions more in grants that the EchoHealth Alliance controlled. And he'd be a hero.
To others, it was the perfect example of the unnecessary dangers of gain-of-function science. “The only impact of this work is the creation, in a lab, of a new, non-natural risk,” the Rutgers microbiologist Richard Ebright, a longtime critic of such research, told Nature. ...
In 2014, the NIH awarded a five-year, $3.75 million grant to EcoHealth Alliance to study the risk that more bat-borne coronaviruses would emerge in China, using the same kind of techniques Baric had pioneered. Some of that work was to be subcontracted to the Wuhan Institute of Virology.
The evidence is in their published papers before Dec 2019. They can't take those back or hide them from the internet.
Two years later, Daszak and Shi published a paper reporting how the Chinese lab had engineered different versions of WIV1 and tested their infectiousness in human cells. The paper announced that the WIV had developed its own reverse-genetics system, following the Americans’ lead. It also included a troubling detail: the work, which was funded in part by the NIH grant, had been done in a BSL-2 lab. That meant the same viruses that Daszak was holding up as a clear and present danger to the world were being studied under conditions that, according to Richard Ebright, matched “the biosafety level of a US dentist’s office.”
These were clearly viable PPPs, not some segments whose genomes were analyzed.
There's a further discussion in the paper that is well worth reading.