(Merged Thread) Facts and fictions in acupuncture

What makes you accept Mayer as an authority? Why not examine the evidence for yourself?

The abstract is here, for those who noticed that Yrreg didn't provide a link, but you need to pay to access the full text.

Yrreg, do you have the full text? Do you think it is possible to get any more than the most superficial and facile impression of the credibility of this work without reading the full text? Come back when you have read the full text and are prepared to defend it against critical discussion.

Rolfe.
 
More than one white crow

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
To the people in the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research, if they possess reading comprehension, the answer is Yes.

http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publications/reports/acupuncture.pdf

Acupuncture: Evidence from Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses​
Patricia Leggett Tait, Laurie Brooks,
Christa Harstall

March 2002
HTA 27: Series A Health Technology Assessment

Alberta Heritage Foundation
for Medical Research

Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research
Health Technology Assessment

------------------------
SUMMARY
(Selected items, please read complete report, in http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publications/reports/acupuncture.pdf)

 Acupuncture, in the strictest sense refers to “insertion of dry needles, at specially chosen sites, for the treatment or prevention of symptoms and conditions.” It is a
elatively safe procedure, but it can lead to both minor (fainting, exacerbation of symptoms) and serious (hepatitis, traumatic injury of body tissue) adverse events.

 Twenty-three reviews were included: two on dental and temperomandibular dysfunction (TMD) pain; one on headaches; one on tinnitus; three on asthma; one on stroke rehabilitation; two on antiemesis; five on neck/back pain; two on chronic pain; one on fibromyalgia; one on induction of labour; one on addictions; two on smoking cessation; and one on weight reduction. Unanimously these reviews call for higher quality research with greater sample size.

 Acupuncture was found to be effective for the treatment of dental and TMD pain and antiemesis (nausea/vomiting) in comparison to other chosen interventions. The results for idiopathic headaches and fibromyalgia were reported as encouraging. The evidence was inclusive for the treatment of back pain, chronic pain, smoking cessation, and asthma. Effectiveness was not supported by the evidence for tinnitus,
stroke rehabilitation, neck pain, addictions, and weight reduction.

 Dental and TMD pain and antiemesis appear to be two areas in which acupuncture is reproducibly effective. For all other indications the methodology design and quality is either too weak to draw conclusions, the studies have not been done, or, in studies of better quality, acupuncture does not appear to be more effective than standard of care or control chosen.

What studies were included in this report?

(Selected items, please read complete report, in http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publications/reports/acupuncture.pdf)


Of the thirty-three studies selected, twenty-three systematic reviews met the inclusion criteria, including five Cochrane Reviews (see Appendix A). A table of data extraction and quality assessment of included systematic reviews can be found in Appendix B.

Though there is growing debate as to whether the Cochrane Reviews should continue to be a ‘gold standard’ for systematic review methodology, they currently have the most rigorous methodology, and therefore, a quality assessment of these reviews was not undertaken.

The other reviews were assessed using criteria based on those set out in Greenhalgh (see Appendix D). Though this quality assessment may not be as rigorous as initially intended by its authors, it has been consistent across the reviews.

Once agreed upon, criteria have been developed for the assessment of the methodological quality of primary studies in acupuncture, the same approach should be taken for the assessment of systematic reviews.

The methodology of a review was considered to be satisfactory if it contained a concise research question(s) and inclusion criteria, an adequate search strategy, and included a quality assessment evaluation 22-28. If a review also attempted to integrate and/or statistically analyze the data, it was considered to be of good quality. The rest of the reviews were considered to be of poor methodological quality.

To recapitulate:

(Selected items, please read complete report, in http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publications/reports/acupuncture.pdf)


Growing demands on the health care system for public funding of complementary health services, the changes in legislation regarding the regulation of health care professionals, in conjunction with demand from the community for funding coverage for acupuncture treatment underline the importance and timeliness of this review.

A large body of primary research exists in acupuncture, covering virtually every symptom. Due to the breadth of this topic and the challenge of reviewing the extensive body of research on acupuncture, the approach of systematically assessing the available reviews was chosen to evaluate the current evidence for the efficacy of acupuncture. In choosing this approach, it is acknowledged that there are limitations.

Twenty-three systematic reviews on conditions such as dental pain/TMD, headaches, tinnitus, asthma, stroke, nausea/vomiting, neck/back pain, chronic pain, fibromyalgia, labour, addictions, and obesity, were included in this appraisal of systematic reviews.

This systematic review confirms the findings from other reviews which indicate consistent support for the effectiveness of acupuncture in the treatment of postoperative nausea/vomiting, and dental pain. For other indicators the robustness of the effect of acupuncture is debatable and its clinical value questionable for conditions such as idiopathic headaches, chronic pain, smoking and fibromyalgia, however some reviews indicated promising results.

The results from these reviews, the majority of which had a good quality rating, found acupuncture to be as effective as the alternative interventions or no treatment in the short term.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Another white crow

To the question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

German researchers in a surgical clinic in Jena obviously answer Yes.

[Please read the complete article in]​

http://www.icmart.org/icmart00/abstract/abst9.html


Postoperative pain management with acupuncture

GRUBE Th., KORNBERG A,
UHLEMANN Ch, MEISSNER W, SCHEELE J
(GERMANY) Surgical Clinic Jena
e-mail: [email protected]​


Background: Acupuncture has become very popular in several fields of pain management, especially in treatment of chronic pain. The purpose of this study is the assessment of acupuncture in the treatment of postoperative pain.

Material and methods: After defined operations (vaginal and laparoscopic hysterectomy, laparoscopic appendectomy), all patients received patient controlled analgesia (PCA) with piritramid and we randomized in three groups:

----------------

Results: The use of acupuncture (group 1) lead to a reduction of piritramid application of more than 50 percent compared to group 3. In group 2, the consumption of piritramid was less than in group 3, but still higher than in group 1. We also noticed a good impact of acupuncture concerning nausea and vomiting.

Conclusion: Using scientific and reproducible parameters, acupuncture proved to be sufficient in the management of postoperative pain, nausea and vomiting. Especially multimorbid patients with risk of operation related or pharmacological side effects benefit from acupuncture. There was no effect of acupuncture regarding blood pressure and heart rate.

Abstracts of ICMART 2000 International Medical Acupuncture Congress​


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
To the question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

German researchers in a surgical clinic in Jena obviously answer Yes.
Unfortunately, that study doesn't seem to have been blinded, with no placebo for the acupuncture being used, so the placebo effect hasn't been eliminated (especially since the study was looking at conditions such as pain and nausea, which have some subjective component and which the patients were asked to assess).

But at least you're now looking at clinical trials rather than single anecdotes.
 
Last edited:
Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
To the people in the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research, if they possess reading comprehension, the answer is Yes.
In the two circumstances in which it appeared to them to be reproducibly effective (dental and TMD pain and nausea and vomiting) it is relieving symptoms rather than curing a complaint (as, indeed, is the case for the German study you quoted in the next post).

You also missed out a paragraph at the end of the first quotation:
Clearly, more research of higher methodological quality is called for. Issues of blinding, the use of a credible control, varying diagnosis amonsgst differing philosophical approaches, and the diversity of treatment points chosen and techniques used challenge this particular area of complementary medicine.
This is precisely the sort of thing that people have been telling you in this thread: the evidence so far published is generally not good enough to draw a definate conclusion one way or another.
 
Start of Acupuncture 'Fever' in US

The Facts in the Start of Acupuncture 'Fever' in the US:

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2006-03/07/content_4269160.htm

www.chinaview.cn 2006-03-07 12:39:51

NEW YORK, March 6 (Xinhuanet) -- How did acupuncture come to the United States around the 1970's? That is the question that has intrigued Li Yongming, a Chinese-American physician in New Jersey, for years.

There have been different answers to the question, some are facts mixed with hearsay, others are pure fabrication. But all of them give credit to a New York Times story, supposedly written by a reporter on President Richard Nixon' s epoch-making China visit.

Receiving his undergraduate education in traditional Chinese medicine in China and trained to practice western medicine after he came to the United States, Li sees himself as the right choice to fill the historical gap and facilitate the future cultural exchange between the two nations.

He seized all opportunities to do research on historic files, and interview people relevant to the event. His efforts finally paid off.

snip snip snip

On the basis of his research and investigation in both countries , Li came to the conclusion that James Reston, high-calibre journalist of the New York Times, served as a catalyst in the spread of acupuncture fever in the United States. But the time was 1971, several months before Nixon's China visit.

Li said that at the time Reston visited China and tried to get interviews with top Chinese leaders.

"The first stab of pain went through my groin," Reston later wrote in a story titled "Now Let Me Tell You the Story of My [appendectomy] Operation in Beijing" printed on the New York Times on July 26, 1971 with a front page lead.

snip snip snip

The operation was a success, but Reston complained "considerable discomfort if not pain" the night after the operation. With his approval, acupuncturist Li Chang Yuan inserted three long thin needles into the outer part of his right elbow and below his knees while holding two pieces of what "looked like the burning stumps of a broken cheap cigar" close to his abdomen.

The whole treatment took about 20 minutes, sending ripples of pain racing through the patient's limbs and having the effect of diverting his attention from the distress of his stomach. It turned out to be "noticeable relaxation of the pressure and distention within an hour and no recurrence of the problem thereafter," Reston said in the article.

According to Li Yongming, his research has found that this is the first ever mentioning of the modern acupuncture practiced in China's mainland in the U.S. mainstream media. Reston's China tour may not [be] as fruitful as he expected from a journalistic viewpoint, but his story has unwittingly sparked off a widespread "acupuncture fever" across the United States in the coming years, Li said.

snip snip snip


Li Yongming said he was overjoyed he is finally able to make a clear account of how acupuncture came to the United States. He noted that today acupuncture has grown into a profession with an annual output value of 1.65 billion dollars. Across the country there are more than 50 acupuncture schools, some 20,000 licensed acupuncturists and another 5,000 physicians with acupuncture license.

Citing the Chinese saying, "All who drink from the well should remember the well diggers," he said acupuncturists in America are grateful to Reston and his medical team for what they did to help spread this ancient Chinese therapy.

snip snip snip


Comment from Pes Oir Amsus:

To resist provisional assent in the face of overwhelming facts, and instead of investigating new directions of evidence instead of insisting on present directions of evidence, that is the most unscientific of attitude.​


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Comment from Pes Oir Amsus:

To resist provisional assent in the face of overwhelming facts, and instead of investigating new directions of evidence instead of insisting on present directions of evidence, that is the most unscientific of attitude.​

For once I agree with 'Pes Oir Amsus'.

Now, where is the evidence?
 
Note that Reston did not have his appendix out under acupuncture anaesthesia, as is often claimed. He suffered some postoperative pain, which is not unusual, usually due to ileus (stasis of the gut). This normally resolves spontaneously, a day or two after the operation.

There is no evidence at all that the magical rite described with the needles and the cheap cigar had any influence on this outcome whatsoever.

Rolfe.
 
More white crows from the folks at Cochrane

From The Cochrane Library, Issue 2, 2005. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. All rights reserved.

http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htm

Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)
Furlan AD, van Tulder MW, Cherkin DC, Tsukayama H, Lao L, Koes BW, Berman BM

snip snip snip

Main results: Thirty-five RCTs were included; 20 were published in English, seven in Japanese, five in Chinese and one each in Norwegian, Polish and German. There were only three trials of acupuncture for acute low-back pain. They did not justify firm conclusions, because of small sample sizes and low methodological quality of the studies. For chronic low-back pain there is evidence of pain relief and functional improvement for acupuncture, compared to no treatment or sham therapy. These effects were only observed immediately after the end of the sessions and at short-term follow-up. There is evidence that acupuncture, added to other conventional therapies, relieves pain and improves function better than the conventional therapies alone. However, effects are only small. Dry-needling appears to be a useful adjunct to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. No clear recommendations could be made about the most effective acupuncture technique.

Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain. For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than other conventional and "alternative" treatments. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodological quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area.

snip snip snip

In a test on reading comprehension, students are asked to answer the following question with Yes or No:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

What do readers of this thread think should their answer be?


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
In a test on reading comprehension, students are asked to answer the following question with Yes or No:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

From your source, as quoted:

Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.

So I guess, if we were cornered and forced to choose an alternative, that would be no. But, until evidence to support either yes or no is in, it's a maybe.
 
Test of reading comprehension

Originally Posted by yrreg :
In a test on reading comprehension, students are asked to answer the following question with Yes or No:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

-------------------

From your source, as quoted:

Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.​

So I guess, if we were cornered and forced to choose an alternative, that would be no. But, until evidence to support either yes or no is in, it's a maybe.

Imagine that you are looking for a white crow among the crows in a field, so you have to look very carefully, for it is very difficult to spot a white crow in the midst of black crows which are the rule.

Suppose you read the Cochrane excerpts again, and remember that you are allowed to answer only Yes or No, what do you think is or should be your answer in order to pass the reading comprehension test in this question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

-----------------

I have the impression here that there are people -- it could be all in my mind of course -- who insist that acupuncture has not effected even just one cure to any one medical complaint.

So, I wish to attain a consensus from people here that acupuncture actually has effected at least one cure to a medical complaint.

To the people in the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research, if they possess reading comprehension, the answer is Yes.

http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publi...cupuncture.pdf

See my post #142 http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1491533&postcount=142, above.

----------------------

Do you think honestly that I will not succeed in arriving at a consensus from people here on the fact of at least one cure effected from acupuncture to one medical complaint? Perhaps a more fruitful inquiry in this connection might be the psychology of why and how people have vaccinated themselves into immunity to see at least one cure from acupuncture to a medical complaint, whereas they can be presumed to know that there is a world greater than the one they are accustomed to from their knowledge of science today.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
Suppose you read the Cochrane excerpts again, and remember that you are allowed to answer only Yes or No, what do you think is or should be your answer in order to pass the reading comprehension test in this question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
It appears that you are the person who is having trouble with reading comprehension, if you are expecting people to answer yes or no to your question on the basis of a review that found the evidence inconclusive, and said that "there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area."

I have the impression here that there are people -- it could be all in my mind of course -- who insist that acupuncture has not effected even just one cure to any one medical complaint.
And, once again, you have cited a review that is focusing on the use of acupuncture to alleviate symptoms (i.e. back pain, in this case) rather than actually curing a complaint.

So, I wish to attain a consensus from people here that acupuncture actually has effected at least one cure to a medical complaint.
I suggest that you go and get some good evidence for this, then.

To the people in the Alberta Heritage Foundation for Medical Research, if they possess reading comprehension, the answer is Yes.

http://www.ahfmr.ab.ca/hta/hta-publi...cupuncture.pdf

See my post #142 http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1491533&postcount=142, above.
let's see what they actually said: "Clearly, more research of higher methodological quality is called for. Issues of blinding, the use of a credible control, varying diagnosis amonsgst differing philosophical approaches, and the diversity of treatment points chosen and techniques used challenge this particular area of complementary medicine." That looks more like a "maybe", even for the alleviation of symptoms they were looking at.

Amazing, isn't it, that while "alternative" medicine claims to be "holistic" and to treat the underlying condition, so much of what it actually appears to do focuses solely on subjective symptoms.


Do you think honestly that I will not succeed in arriving at a consensus from people here on the fact of at least one cure effected from acupuncture to one medical complaint?
You will only achieve this if you can provide evidence that acupuncture can in fact do this. So far all the evidence you have cited appears to be in the form of rather inconclusive studies of the ability of acupuncture to alleviate symptoms, rather than to cure a condition..
 
Does this person actually exist, or is it just something yrreg has made up to try to give his opinions an air of authority?

I suspect the latter, but have no hard and conclusive evidence.
 
The board belongs to something called The Immortality Institute, by the way:
Section 1 -- Name
The name of this nonprofit organization shall be “The Immortality Institute” or “Immortality Institute,” abbreviated to “ImmInst” and heretofore referred to as such by this constituting instrument.

Section 2 -- Duration
The duration of ImmInst shall be perpetual.
I guess it would have to be! :D
 
Yrreg is a Phillipino, and there's an expletive expression used in the Phillipines of "Susmariosep!", which is a contraction of "Jesus, Maria, Joseph!" Write that backwards and you get "Pes Oir Amsus".

Google for susmariosep, and you'll find several forum postings whose style look pretty similar to Yrreg's postings here. The same ignorance, condescention, veiled insults and copious straw.

But as I said, there's no hard evidence, and I'm not claiming Yrreg is Pes Oir Amsus. I only suspect that he is.
 
Last edited:
Yes, acupuncture has effected a cure to a medical complaint.

I am referring to this abstract from Cochrane:

http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htmFrom

The Cochrane Library, Issue 2, 2005.
Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. All rights reserved.​
Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)
Furlan AD, van Tulder MW, Cherkin DC, Tsukayama H, Lao L, Koes BW, Berman BM
​

ABSTRACT

snip snip snip

Main results: Thirty-five RCTs were included; 20 were published in English, seven in Japanese, five in Chinese and one each in Norwegian, Polish and German. There were only three trials of acupuncture for acute low-back pain. They did not justify firm conclusions, because of small sample sizes and low methodological quality of the studies. For chronic low-back pain there is evidence of pain relief and functional improvement for acupuncture, compared to no treatment or sham therapy. These effects were only observed immediately after the end of the sessions and at short-term follow-up. There is evidence that acupuncture, added to other conventional therapies, relieves pain and improves function better than the conventional therapies alone. However, effects are only small. Dry-needling appears to be a useful adjunct to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. No clear recommendations could be made about the most effective acupuncture technique.

Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain. For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only. Acupuncture is not more effective than other conventional and "alternative" treatments. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. Because most of the studies were of lower methodological quality, there certainly is a further need for higher quality trials in this area.

snip snip snip

The medical complaint dealed with in the report is low-back pain.

A test of reading comprehension reveals that there are mentioned what we might consider kinds of pain being treated by acupuncture.

What does the report say about the evidence of acupuncture effecting relief from low-back pain?

See next post for a list of mentions of low-back pain and acupuncture in the whole report of Cochrane in http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane/revabstr/AB001351.htmFrom


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 
List of mentions of pain and acupuncture in Cochrane's report

In a reading comprehension test for promotion to the chief-editor's post in a newspaper, among other screening measures subjects are given the text of the report from Cochrane:

Acupuncture and dry-needling for low back pain (Cochrane Review)​

And they are required to answer the following question with an Yes or No reply, or abstain from answering the question.

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​

One enterprising subject made a list of the mentions of pain and acupuncture, by encircling with his pen all mentions of pain and acupuncture in the given text.

1. Acupuncture and dry-needling for low-back pain (Cochrane Review) Furlan AD, van Tulder MW, Cherkin DC, Tsukayama H, Lao L, Koes BW, Berman BM ABSTRACT...

2. Background: Although low-back pain is usually a self-limiting and benign disease that tends to improve spontaneously over time, a large variety of therapeutic interventions are available for its treatment.

3. Objectives: To assess the effects of acupuncture for the treatment of non-specific low-back pain and dry-needling for myofascial pain syndrome in the low-back region. Search strategy...

4. Selection criteria: Randomized trials of acupuncture (that involves needling) for adults with non-specific (sub)acute or chronic low-back pain, or dry-needling for myofascial pain syndrome in the low-back region.

5. There were only three trials of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.

6. For chronic low-back pain there is evidence of pain relief and functional improvement for acupuncture, compared to no treatment or sham therapy.

7. There is evidence that acupuncture, added to other conventional therapies, relieves pain and improves function better than the conventional therapies alone.

8. Dry-needling appears to be a useful adjunct to other therapies for chronic low-back pain. No clear recommendations could be made about the most effective acupuncture technique.

9. Authors' conclusions: The data do not allow firm conclusions about the effectiveness of acupuncture for acute low-back pain.

10. For chronic low-back pain, acupuncture is more effective for pain relief and functional improvement than no treatment or sham treatment immediately after treatment and in the short-term only.

11. The data suggest that acupuncture and dry-needling may be useful adjuncts to other therapies for chronic low-back pain.

12. AD, van Tulder MW, Cherkin DC, Tsukayama H, Lao L, Koes BW, Berman BM. Acupuncture and dry-needling for low-back pain. The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2005, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD001351.pub2.

And that enterprising subject chose the answer Yes, to the question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
The rest answered No or chose to abstain from answering.

If the people here in this thread should do as the enterprising subject did, what is your answer or reaction to the question:

Has acupuncture effected a cure to a medical complaint? Yes or No.​
Hint: Avoid reading and attending only to what concords with your made-up mind, pay attention to lines #6 and #10 where you have categorical affirmative statements.


Yrreg, aspiring Fat Laughing Buddha

---------------

From Nirvana with love, Bude.
3buddhas5oh.gif
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom