IAF Pin Point Bombing

Let's see, there's you, George Galloway, Robert Fiske (debatable), your sister

My sister is insane. She is also married to a faith healer 30 years older than her. By comparison, he is sane. I have no idea what she thinks about Israel, and don't care, since I only speak to her once a year. :)

Believe me, most of the people I know are anti-american and anti-israeli. Perhaps I just hang around with terrorists who read The Guardian.
 
Last edited:
Maybe if there is someone who knows more about military weaponry that knows of a weapon that does this kind of damage?

Some of the holes look like small arms fire. Notice the ones with good symmetry. The big hole in the middle is not from anything the IDF would be using unless the ordnance did not explode. The majority of damage seems secondary - e.g. debris shrapnel.
 
Some of the holes look like small arms fire. Notice the ones with good symmetry. The big hole in the middle is not from anything the IDF would be using unless the ordnance did not explode. The majority of damage seems secondary - e.g. debris shrapnel.


Exactly. I've seen plenty of pictures of vehicles struck by rocket fire. They don't look like that.
 
Some of the holes look like small arms fire. Notice the ones with good symmetry. The big hole in the middle is not from anything the IDF would be using unless the ordnance did not explode. The majority of damage seems secondary - e.g. debris shrapnel.

A car in Israel that was damaged by a Hizabollah rockect had the same damage. It's called shrapnel.
 
No one has claimed that there are no errors.

Imprecise? You bet.
Indiscriminate? Hell no.
Can you tell the difference? I'm not betting on it.
Four U.N. observers died Tuesday when an Israeli precision-guided bomb hit their post in southern Lebanon, said Lebanese security sources and a Western diplomat.
Israel has said the attack was an accident.
But U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan contended otherwise, and a U.N. officer said the Israeli military liaison was told 10 times in six hours that aerial attacks were getting close to the bunker manned by the U.N. Interim Force in Lebanon. (Full story)
U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations John Bolton said Israel was investigating the bombing.
"The government of Israel has definitively said that they were not deliberately targeting the UNIFIL outpost," he said. "We certainly take them at their word and note that there's no evidence to the contrary."


http://www.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/meast/07/26/mideast.main/index.html
 
Another account:

http://www.imra.org.il/story.php3?id=30314

Wednesday, July 26, 2006
Canadian killed from UN force complained his position shielding Hizbullah

Dr. Aaron Lerner Date: 26 July 2006

"...the tragic loss of a soldier yesterday who I happen to know and I think
probably is from my Regiment. We've received e-mails from him a few days ago
and he described the fact that he was taking within - in one case - three
meters of his position "for tactical necessity - not being targeted". Now
that's veiled speech in the military and what he was telling us was
Hizbullah fighters were all over his position and the IDF were (sic)
targeting them and that's a favorite trick by people who don't have
representation in the UN. They use the UN as shields knowing that they
can't be punished for it."

Retired Canadian Major General Lewis MacKenzie interviewed on CBC Toronto
radio 26 July 2006
For recording:
http://cbc.ca/metromorning/media/20060726LMCJUL26.ram

If this is true, I bet Hezbollah are loving all the useful idiots abounding on this issue.
 
In breakinmg news it is reported that 4 unarmed UN military observers have been killed by an Israeli bomb. Initial report with numbers of dead in http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1153291996858&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull

A pin point strike by the IAF on unarmed UN observers plus 14 other incidents? How can this be a mistake? And if isn't a mistake what is it?


Why it's payback for 6 years of broken promises to keep the peace by the UN:boggled:

The real question is under what fantasy were these people still there, dutifully counting one violation after another, six years (or is it 28?) later?
 
A car in Israel that was damaged by a Hizabollah rockect had the same damage. It's called shrapnel.

Actually it is not the same at all.

You, as usual have your funny glasses on. If Helzbollah wanted to destroy Israeli infrastructure, even with bad aim, they would pack as much explosives as they could into those rockets.

Instead what they do is take out a large proprtion of the explosive payload and substitute it with ball bearings, giving a much reduced bang, but much greater chance of hitting any bodies in the area. That is what is called deliberate indiscriminate attempts to create random civilian casualties. Sometimes referred to as terrorism, except by those who prefer to ignore the obvious when it doesn't suit their politics.
 
Why it's payback for 6 years of broken promises to keep the peace by the UN:boggled:

The real question is under what fantasy were these people still there, dutifully counting one violation after another, six years (or is it 28?) later?

The UN may have done something wrong, those killed were not a part of any of it. They were there just doing a job, harming no-one.

Anyway, the attack appears to have had the desired effect. Australia is pulling out it's troops from the area. Other countries due to follow, I guess.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200607/s1698472.htm

The Federal Government says a dozen Australian troops in southern Lebanon will be moved to Beirut to avoid bombing.
The 12 Australians were sent to Lebanon to assist with the evacuation of Australians in the country's south.
They have been deployed in a number of areas in the region.
Yesterday an Israeli air strike hit a UN post in the town of Khiam in southern Lebanon, killing four people.
 
Actually it is not the same at all.

You, as usual have your funny glasses on. If Helzbollah wanted to destroy Israeli infrastructure, even with bad aim, they would pack as much explosives as they could into those rockets.

Instead what they do is take out a large proprtion of the explosive payload and substitute it with ball bearings, giving a much reduced bang, but much greater chance of hitting any bodies in the area. That is what is called deliberate indiscriminate attempts to create random civilian casualties. Sometimes referred to as terrorism, except by those who prefer to ignore the obvious when it doesn't suit their politics.
And you know this, how?
 
Actually it is not the same at all.

You, as usual have your funny glasses on. If Helzbollah wanted to destroy Israeli infrastructure, even with bad aim, they would pack as much explosives as they could into those rockets.

Instead what they do is take out a large proprtion of the explosive payload and substitute it with ball bearings, giving a much reduced bang, but much greater chance of hitting any bodies in the area. That is what is called deliberate indiscriminate attempts to create random civilian casualties. Sometimes referred to as terrorism, except by those who prefer to ignore the obvious when it doesn't suit their politics.

bollocks..

Hezbollah would fire whatever they can get...some of which I have no doubt would contain ballbearings (a common anti personnel fill)...the thought that Hezbolla fighters are going to be stuffing about with rocket warheads to remove or alter part of the sealed filling is just hilarious.

This is rocketry dude....some silly twit hacking about with the wieght of the warhead like that and the cente of balance changes and the rocket stability goes bye bye and the thing goes unstable....likely to land closer to where it took off than anywhere else.

nice story though......
 
And you know this, how?

http://www.theage.com.au/news/world/australian-troops-ordered-out/2006/07/27/1153816286737.html

Twelve Australian defence personnel helping evacuate Australians in southern Lebanon are being withdrawn after Israel refused to guarantee the safety of UN peacekeepers.
Defence Minister Brendan Nelson said the decision was due to the dangers of the war between Israel and Hezbollah guerillas, which resulted in the death this week of four UN observers.
 

Can you tell the difference between "refuse to guarantee" and "deiberate attack"?

By the way, shows how much the UN force was worth. It was all well and good... until the fighting started, when they were evacuated.

What's the point of a UN force which is, essentially, simply another mass of civilians that needs to be protected and evcuated once fighting starts?
 
There still hasn't been any evidence presented that the UNIFIL site was bombed from the air.
 
a_unique_person said:
Anyway, the attack appears to have had the desired effect. Australia is pulling out it's troops from the area.

Can you tell the difference between "refuse to guarantee" and "deiberate attack"??

Actually a_u_p seems to be claiming to know why it was attacked as well.
 
If the reports I have read are correct, Hezbollah is using primarily BM-21 launchers. It is the 1963 upgrade to the WWII "Stalin's Organ" (named for it's resemblance to a pipe organ, not Stalin's wiener) launcher which fired the Katy (I love a fearsome weapon named after a woman). It is more of a saturation bomb type of weapon than a surgical strike kind of weapon.

Most of the available ammo for the BM-21 is already anti-personnel. More rare are anti-tank, incendiary and RF jamming payloads. No need to re-pack with ball bearings. This system uses a rifled tube, so an out-of-balance rocket could end up poking out of your arse if you tried to fire it. There is a dummy round that is made deliberately off balance to stress test the tube. It is fired into a dirt bank by remote control.

I would put this weapon in the category of guerrilla warfare more so than terrorism. Subtle difference, I guess. :confused:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom