Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

Also, strategically, when one looks at the bigger picture, those of us in the Western world simply must grasp that we're in the jihadists' gunsights as well.

Some photos of a recent demonstration (England) in support of the jihadists:
Pic1

and

Pic2

and

Pic3

It's right there in the open -- nothing is being hidden.
 
Last edited:
You are seriously argueing that because they are not killing everybody, they can't be intending to kill some of the civilians they are blowing up on roads as they flee the areas they are told to flee?

Fleeing civilian vehicles hit by Israeli missiles

The Allies bombed French infrastructure heavily pre D-Day, resulting in the deaths of thousands of French civilians.

That wasn't the point the point of the exercise though.
 
Some photos of a recent demonstration (England) in support of the jihadists:
Pic1

and

Pic2

and

Pic3

It's right there in the open -- nothing is being hidden.

If I remember correctly, these pictures were taken when Muslims protested against the Danish cartoons. I don't know what you meant by "recent".
 
You have to judge people's actions in the context of the times they were done in....


Is there any level of lebanese deaths you would condemn? If so....what level would that be?....no answer?
I can try an answer.

Whatever level is required for them to decide to stop making war.

You, and many others, seem to conveniently ignore the fact that Israel has no desire to occupy and annex Lebanon (or Gaza, or most of the West Bank).

The Lebanese pretend to be a nation and the rest of the world pretends that they are. All they have to do is stop attacking a neighboring country and this can end in one day.

Sometimes peoples ARE actually responsible for the consequences of their actions.
 
If I remember correctly, these pictures were taken when Muslims protested against the Danish cartoons. I don't know what you meant by "recent".

2006.

Are there more recent examples of islamofascists showing their true faces in the context of the IDF "Milhemet Tamuz" battles currently raging against the bloodthirsty jihadists in Gaza and Lebanon?

Let's take a look, and see:

http://www.lebanese4ever.com/albums...non/Other Occasions/lebanon_revolution_83.jpg
and
http://ikhnaton2.manalaa.net/files/ikhnaton2/images/6_0.JPG
and
http://ikhnaton2.manalaa.net/files/ikhnaton2/images/1_0.JPG


Ooops, wrong groups of demonstrators --- let me try again ---
http://www.foxnews.com/photo_essay/photoessay_326_images/030805_beirut_protest7.jpg


Anyway, you get the point...
 
In south Lebanon, the reporters seem to be in areas controlled by Hisbollah or Hamas, which means what they say and do may be interfered with by patrols on the ground, but such patrols are unlikely to have a centralised policy and may have nobody fluent in English, or any of the other languages broadcasters may be using.
Actually Hezbollah has a very effective and centralized policy. I started a thread about it but here's the gist:
NIC ROBERTSON, CNN CORRESPONDENT: Well, Howard, there's no doubt about it: Hezbollah has a very, very sophisticated and slick media operations. In fact, beyond that, it has very, very good control over its areas in the south of Beirut. They deny journalists access into those areas. They can turn on and off access to hospitals in those areas. They have a lot of power and influence. You don't get in there without their permission.

And when I went we were given about 10 or 15 minutes, quite literally running through a number of neighborhoods that they directed and they took us to.

...But there's no doubt about it. They had control of the situation. They designated the places that we went to, and we certainly didn't have time to go into the houses or lift up the rubble to see what was underneath.
Source.
 
I can try an answer.

Whatever level is required for them to decide to stop making war.

You, and many others, seem to conveniently ignore the fact that Israel has no desire to occupy and annex Lebanon (or Gaza, or most of the West Bank).

The Lebanese pretend to be a nation and the rest of the world pretends that they are. All they have to do is stop attacking a neighboring country and this can end in one day.

Sometimes peoples ARE actually responsible for the consequences of their actions.

The Lebanese are not Hizbollah.

http://www.theage.com.au/articles/2006/07/27/1153816320611.html

"Even before we know who will win this campaign, we can state with certainty that Israel has suffered a terrible propaganda defeat in Lebanon and the Arab world," wrote Maariv columnist Jacky Hugi. "From being our silent allies, the Lebanese have become the victims of our blind pounding."
 
Let's try to remember to be skeptical of those "civilian deaths" numbers. They are give to us by the Hezbolla/Lebanese. There have been almost no BDA from the IDF, for security purposes. How many of those bombed cars had AK-47's in them? How many of the bomb craters in villages have rocket launchers in the bottom? How many Hizbollah "civilians" bodies were found at the UN out post? (11, form one Izzy site) How many "civilians" were killed at the big site in South Beruit, vs the secondary explosions from the munitions stored under the building?

Exactly. Do you bomb the car, then inspect it to see if there is an AK-47 in there? If you bombed several cars in the US, you would have a good chance of finding guns in one.
 
AUP:
"The Lebanese are not Hizbollah."

You think that matters to the usual suspects? (Rhetorical question of course).


According to Ynetnews, "Israel's most comprehensive, authoritative daily source for 24/7 breaking news", the Israelis have killed at least 421, of which a mere 27 were Hizbollah, while Hizboallah have killed only 41 of which 24 were Israeli soldiers.
(http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3281352,00.html)

Oy gevalt!
Self-hating Jews have infiltrated the Israeli media. How gosh-darned existential can a threat get?

Anyway, as for the pretty poor first post in this thread, are people really suggesting that simply because Israel isn't definitely trying to kill AS MANY CIVILIANS AS IT CAN, it isn't trying at all?
Why would they want to kill millions of Lebanese, and get their US funding cut as US public opinion falls away?
Using collective punishment was a favourite tactic of the nazis, and I think collective punishment can be definitely identified with the targeted civilians in Lebanon . Or are some people going to impress us all with brain bending mental gymnastics and deny that too?
 
Time for a little lesson from history...I posted this before I`m sure, but it`s time to post it again in the light of this thread.

Here is part of an interview with General Gur of the IDF, hero of Entebbe, and of Israel in 1978:

Q-Is it true [during the March 1978 Israeli invasion of Lebanon] that you bombarded agglomerations [of people] without distinction.

A-I am not one of those people who have a selective memory. Do you think that I pretend not to know what we have done all these years? What did we do the entire length of the Suez Canal? A million and a half refugees! Really: where do you live? …we bombarded Ismailia, Suez, Port Said, and Port Faud. A million and a half refugees…Since when has the population of South Lebanon become so sacred? They knew perfectly well what the terrorists were doing. After the massacre at Avivim, I had four villages in South Lebanon bombed without authorization.

Q-Without making distinctions between civilians and noncivilians?

A-What distinction? What had the inhabitants of Irbid [a large town in northern Jordan, principally Palestinian in population] done to deserve bombing by us?

Q-But military communiqués always spoke of returning fire and counterstrikes against terrorist objectives.

A-Please be serious. Did you not know that the entire valley of the Jordan had been emptied of its inhabitants as the result of the war of attrition?

Q-Then you claim that the population ought to be punished?

A-Of course, and I have never had any doubt about that. When I authorised Yanouch [diminutive name for the commander of the northern front, responsible for the Lebanese operation] to use aviation, artillery and tanks [in the invasion] I knew exactly what I was doing. It has now been thirty years, from the time of our Independence War, until now, that we have been fighting the civilian [Arab] population which inhabited the villages and towns, and everytime that we do it, the same question gets asked: should we or should we not strike at civilians?[Al-Hamishmar, May 10, 1978]


I have copied this interview from “The Question of Palestine” by Edward Said (published in 1979) General Gur is at least honest and provides a straightforward account and context for understanding the Israeli way of war which does not seem to have changed very much.
 
I have copied this interview from “The Question of Palestine” by Edward Said (published in 1979) General Gur is at least honest and provides a straightforward account and context for understanding the Israeli way of war which does not seem to have changed very much.
Where is the part where Gur claims Israel dropped brochures to warn Lebanese civilians of an impending attack?

Surely that was also a standard Israeli way of war in '78?
 
2006.

Are there more recent examples of islamofascists showing their true faces in the context of the IDF "Milhemet Tamuz" battles currently raging against the bloodthirsty jihadists in Gaza and Lebanon?

Let's take a look, and see:

http://www.lebanese4ever.com/albums...non/Other Occasions/lebanon_revolution_83.jpg
and
http://ikhnaton2.manalaa.net/files/ikhnaton2/images/6_0.JPG
and
http://ikhnaton2.manalaa.net/files/ikhnaton2/images/1_0.JPG


Ooops, wrong groups of demonstrators --- let me try again ---
http://www.foxnews.com/photo_essay/photoessay_326_images/030805_beirut_protest7.jpg


Anyway, you get the point...

If your point was to say Lebanese women are gorgeous, I totally agree. :D

Seriously, I don't really see why you post these pics of manifestations, I personally never take them seriously. I think it's a way people have to express themselves, sort of a way to unleash some frustrations. So of course they're going to have hateful slogans, it's expected.

Respectfully.
 
Last edited:
Give me a break with this wisdom. Hizaballah are Lebanese. Do you identify yourself as a member of one of your political parties, or are you an Australian?

I agree with AUP, the entire Lebanese people are not responsible for the actions of this group of extremists.

I take my own people as an example: Quebecers were not responsible for the actions of the terrorist group FLQ, back in 1970, but yet the Canadian government sent in the armed forces in the streets of Montréal and arrested hundreds of people for no reason.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/October_crisis

But I do agree that the Lebanese government is responsible for letting Hizbollah get away with murder, yet alone become a 'legitimate' political entity. There should have been long ago better efforts to curb them. What is happening right now was IMO inevitable because of that, even though I tend to believe Israel's response was way too extreme. But as I said, it was bound to happen...
 
It's pardalis BTW. ;)

ETA: was this poll done scientifically, and during the bombings? If so, how on earth did they accomplish it?
 
"Where is the part where Gur claims Israel dropped brochures to warn Lebanese civilians of an impending attack?
Surely that was also a standard Israeli way of war in '78?"

Well, seems like you are making the claim that they did this, so you supply the evidence.
 
Webbie:
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/743948.html
A poll (in Lebanon) on Thursday confirmed ... Some 96 percent of Shiites expressed support for the abduction of the Israeli soldiers, as did 73 percent of Sunnis...

Come on Webbie...(why do I always think I`m talking to Spiderman when we cross swords? lol...hope all is well with you)...I notice in an earlier post you credit me with having a little understanding with what`s going on in the region....I credit you with the same....I think you are scoring a cheap point here.
To put it bluntly, why the hell do you think that poll confirms what it does...if infact it does...I`m going to bed here so haven`t had time to really look at it.
 
According to Ynetnews, "Israel's most comprehensive, authoritative daily source for 24/7 breaking news", the Israelis have killed at least 421, of which a mere 27 were Hizbollah, while Hizboallah have killed only 41 of which 24 were Israeli soldiers.
(http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3281352,00.html)
27, you believe that? I have some magic beans I'd like to sell you sucker, I mean sir... :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom