Why do we continue to hear about Israel targeting civilians?

I will agree Demon that Israel might be targeting some "civilians" in certain situations....such as when said "civilians" are driving amulances loaded with munitions...or possibly when "children" are firing AKs at Isreali troops...or when the "civilians" are directing fire onto Israeli positions.

The point of my pretty poor post was to point out the absurdity of the "Israel is committing genoicide & war crimes" voices we keep keep hearing so much of. The ultimate absurdity of course are those who keep equating Israel to the Nazis.....such as you seem to be doing.



I don't suppose you've got EVIDENCE children are firing AK47's at Israeli soldiers or that the ambulance targeted was loaded with munitions?
 
Juding by other conflicts throughout history, the usual reaction when someone shoots at your family and friends is to get angry at the people doing the shooting, rather than at whomever they are trying to kill.

I agree with you Leif, most people (ordinary innocent civilians who have nothing to do with the conflict), when faced with such grief and destruction inflicted on them, won't look at the whole political problem and go far back in time to find out who initiated the conflict to begin with. It's impossible to expect them to be be objective and to look at the "big picture". Their suffering is far more than what any human can bare, so of course they will accuse the people who attacked them. I can't blame them.

To say that they had time to leave is a wrong argument. That's just a poor excuse to dismiss responsability. As Lief said, it's not enough to give them warnings, you have to give them support and structure for evacuation.
 



I don't see how any of that is the evidence I asked for.


I didn't ask for Evidence children belonged to Hezbollah. Or evidence there were children suicide bombers in the middle east.


I asked clearly for evidence that Children were used as military fighters in THIS conflict.

And evidence the ambulance that Israel targeted was filled with Munitions.

Somehow ALL of the news organizations failed to mention it. But I guess you've got "inside information" eh?




Work on your reading comprehension.
 
Kids are part of the battles -- 15, 16 and 17 years olds are in action, both in gaza and lebanon.

Munitions are routinely transported in vans marked with red crosses. It's a standard operating procedure of the terrorists.

I suggest you read the reports more carefully. You seem to have missed these bits of information.
Sorry, I can't help you, Dustin.
Apparently you prefer to maintain your illusions of the jews killing whatever moves.
 
Kids are part of the battles -- 15, 16 and 17 years olds are in action, both in gaza and lebanon.


18 year olds fight in the UNITED STATES military. They would be "kids" too. Just as much as any 16 or 17 year old is.

When I say "kids" I mean 11 or 12 year olds. Not nearly fully grown teenagers(Which are used in nearly all modern milatries INCLUDING the israeli military).

Munitions are routinely transported in vans marked with red crosses. It's a standard operating procedure of the terrorists.

Again..You're evading. I asked for proof THAT red cross van had munitions in it. THAT is what was implied. If you can't prove that claim then stop wasting my time.

I suggest you read the reports more carefully. You seem to have missed these bits of information.
Sorry, I can't help you, Dustin.
Apparently you prefer to maintain your illusions of the jews killing whatever moves.


I've read the reports clearly and none of them support your claims.

From the reports i've read and the statements of the U.N. and numerous other neutral countries...It seems pretty clear Israel doesn't have a clue what they're doing.


The only one delusional here is you.


Now provide the proof I asked for or stop wasting my time.
 
When I say "kids" I mean 11 or 12 year olds.

OIC.

I've read the reports clearly and none of them support your claims.

http://www.jewishworldreview.com/michelle/malkin_ambulances_for_terrorists.php3
According to the Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center at the Center for Special Studies (CSS), senior UNRWA employee Nahed Rashid Ahmed Attalah confessed to using his official U.N. vehicle to bypass security and smuggle arms, explosives, and terrorists to and from terror attacks. Nidal 'Abd al-Fataah 'Abdallah Nizal, a Hamas activist in gaza, worked as an UNRWA ambulance driver and admitted he had used an emergency vehicle to transport munitions to terrorists. An intensive care ambulance carrying the acronym of the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) was used to deliver an explosive belt found underneath a stretcher on which a sick child was laying, in spring 2002. Rep. Eric Cantor, R-Va., chairman of the Congressional Task Force on Terrorism and Unconventional Warfare, recently documented how "buildings and warehouses under UNRWA supervision are allegedly being used as storage areas for Palestinian ammunition.
--- M. Malkin, June 2004



Yep, Dustin, you got me covered --- I'm the one who is delusional, not you.
Check.
 
OIC.



http://www.jewishworldreview.com/michelle/malkin_ambulances_for_terrorists.php3
According to the Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center at the Center for Special Studies (CSS), senior UNRWA employee Nahed Rashid Ahmed Attalah confessed to using his official U.N. vehicle to bypass security and smuggle arms, explosives, and terrorists to and from terror attacks. Nidal 'Abd al-Fataah 'Abdallah Nizal, a Hamas activist in gaza, worked as an UNRWA ambulance driver and admitted he had used an emergency vehicle to transport munitions to terrorists. An intensive care ambulance carrying the acronym of the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS) was used to deliver an explosive belt found underneath a stretcher on which a sick child was laying, in spring 2002. Rep. Eric Cantor, R-Va., chairman of the Congressional Task Force on Terrorism and Unconventional Warfare, recently documented how "buildings and warehouses under UNRWA supervision are allegedly being used as storage areas for Palestinian ammunition.
--- M. Malkin, June 2004



Yep, Dustin, you got me covered --- I'm the one who is delusional, not you.
Check.



Yes you're definitly delusional. Not to mention unable to read basic english.


I asked for proof children were used in THIS conflict. And proof that THE ambulance that was targeted in THIS conflict was carrying munitions.

So far you've done nothing but evade and not provide any proof.


So i'm still waiting for the proof I asked for.
 
Webfusion, I've asked this question on the "Why people hate Jews" thread, but since it is off topic, I'll ask it again here, because you haven't answered it.

Are three lives worth killing 500 ?
 
We want them back.
Period.

If we have to kill all 6000 hezbollah and kill all 3000 hamas, then so be it.
 
So webfusion:

-Why are the lives of these soldiers more important than the lives of the hundreds of innocent Lebanese caught in the crossfire?

-Do you honestly expect the Hizbollah to return the hostages?

-If they do return them (if they are still alive), would you agree that Israel should stop bombarding Lebanon?

-Whatever people say, whatever happens, is Israel always right?

-If you answered yes to the previous question, do you consider yourself a critical thinker?

thanks
 
webfusion,

That slide show of kids in the Middle East dressed as suicide bombers and brandishing AK-47s and M-16s and RPGs was one of the most disturbing things I've ever seen. I've seen pics before, but all of them put together in a 2 minutes slide show was scary.

AS
 
So webfusion:

-Why are the lives of these soldiers more important than the lives of the hundreds of innocent Lebanese caught in the crossfire?

-Do you honestly expect the Hizbollah to return the hostages?

-If they do return them (if they are still alive), would you agree that Israel should stop bombarding Lebanon?

-Whatever people say, whatever happens, is Israel always right?

-If you answered yes to the previous question, do you consider yourself a critical thinker?

thanks

Starting from last to first --

I am, for sure, a critical thinker.

Israel is sometimes wrong.
Criticism of Israel is sometimes valid.
Israelis are fallible no more or less so than others.

Once the hostages are returned (and they will be returned) the IDF will stand down.

Yes, the return of all three hostages is being considered, at various levels.
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/744049.html

There is not at the present time any coordination between Hamas and Hezbollah, but this could change as Syria (on Iranian orders) could influence both (Khaled Mashaal who initiated the June 25th operation at Sufa Crossing, is headquartered in Syria, and apparently now the Syrians are hosting Ali
Larijani
--- and both kidnappings were, IMO, directed from Tehran.

As to the first question ---
Wanton acts of war are not defined by how many people are killed by an enemy but rather by the seriousness of the enemy's intent and the nature of the enemy's act.
(see: Archduke Franz Ferdinand)

The IDF soldiers were kidnapped by HAMAS and HEZBOLLAH, two terror organizations that operate from within the civilian populations of Gaza and Lebanon, respectively.
The IDF is going after the command and control structures and crushing the abilities of HAMAS and HEZBOLLAH to continue functioning as they had been.
That is the aim of this two-front war, which was started by two attacks across Israel's 'borders' ----------- and no amount of collateral civilian deaths is relevent, so long as the war is being carried on and the HAMAS and HEZBOLLAH do not surrender, without conditions.

http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/744359.html

It is a lesson these enemies of Israel have yet to learn.
(see: 1956, 1967, 1973)
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom