Questions outside of Gravy's threads

Dragon

Graduate Poster
Joined
Mar 20, 2002
Messages
1,639
I'll answer any questions outside of Gravy's threads.
OK Killtown, I'll bite - here are some questions for you -

1) You claim to be investigating the events of 9/11. You have a great deal of information on your websites, and claim to have over 200 "smoking guns" that show that the attacks were not carried out according to the official version. You claim that flights 93 and 77 did not crash where the OV says they did. Who, among the thousands of first responders and investigators at those scenes, have you spoken to, and what did they say?

2) You have repeatedly stated that the red bandanna found at the flight 93 scene could not have survived the crash. This post (on SLC) shows many other items that survived, and the Moussaoui trial exhibits show more. What is your reaction to this evidence, and will you change the way you present this claim?

3) Why do you think that a 757's tail section would remain intact after a nearly 600 mph head-on collision with the ground?

4) Likewise, why do you think the "nose cone" of the plane that hit the Pentagon remained intact and caused the exit hole damage in C ring?

Amended from the original with acknowledgement to the author.
 
Who, among the thousands of first responders and investigators at those scenes, have you spoken to, and what did they say?

This mirrors a question I have asked a different CT on another board. At least 45,000 employees of thw WTC and it's tenants thankfully got away alive from that dyas events.

Why haven't the CTs interviewed any of them? All we have heard is one pencil pusher (not the building manager or any of the maintenance crew) speak of a 36 hour partial powerdown of one tower with little to no corroboration.

Someone among 45,000 people would have noticed something. Why are they so afraid to... you know... investigate 9-11?
 
OK Killtown, I'll bite - here are some questions for you -

1) Who, among the thousands of first responders and investigators at those scenes, have you spoken to, and what did they say?

2) What is your reaction to this evidence, and will you change the way you present this claim?

3) Why do you think that a 757's tail section would remain intact after a nearly 600 mph head-on collision with the ground?

4) Likewise, why do you think the "nose cone" of the plane that hit the Pentagon remained intact and caused the exit hole damage in C ring?
1) Well for example, I emailed one of the photographers who took pics inside the Pentagon, and asked them questions and all I got back in reply was "who are you?," "Why are you asking?", "what org are you from?" and questions like that. I replied saying I'm just a curious ordinary citizens wanting of few questions cleared up and then they never responded back and they NEVER answered my questions. Suspicious, huh?

2) As Operation Northwoods mentions, planted!

3) Obviously someone doesn't read well. Go back and look at my blog about 77's missing tail section.

4) Hey, I'm just repeating what the officials first claimed. Did their story change again?
 
1) Well for example, I emailed one of the photographers who took pics inside the Pentagon, and asked them questions and all I got back in reply was "who are you?," "Why are you asking?", "what org are you from?" and questions like that. I replied saying I'm just a curious ordinary citizens wanting of few questions cleared up and then they never responded back and they NEVER answered my questions. Suspicious, huh?

So you asked one person and didn't get an answer, presumably because they couldn't see any reason to waste their time on non-work related things. One person out of how many thousands?

2) As Operation Northwoods mentions, planted!

Evidence?

3) Obviously someone doesn't read well. Go back and look at my blog about 77's missing tail section.

No. If you have an answer, say it.

4) Hey, I'm just repeating what the officials first claimed. Did their story change again?

Source?
 
Hello Killtown,

Welcome to the JREF forum. I have never conversed with you before on any forum and only heard your name in passing, so rest assured I have no personal vendetta. This does, however, make conversation difficult, since I do not fully understand what your position, credentials, or claims are. I invite you to clarify them.

I will ask this one question, however: On your site, you have a list of what you term "Smoking Guns:"
Killtown @ his site said:
WTC 7 becomes first steel high-rise building in history to collapse solely from an alleged fire. (Chicago Tribune, Stanford Report)
I invite you to consider this photograph by Steve Spak brought to my attention by poster Kent1 in this post. This photograph, as well as several others contained in the NIST WTC 7 collapse presentation, demonstrate clearly that WTC 7 sustained heavy structural damage, in addition to the fire, prior to collapse.

The question is this: In light of this evidence, do you stand by your claim that WTC 7 collapsed "solely" from an "alleged" fire? If so, why? If not, how will you modify this claim?
 
The question is this: In light of this evidence, do you stand by your claim that WTC 7 collapsed "solely" from an "alleged" fire? If so, why? If not, how will you modify this claim?
I see how my wording can seem misleading. I'll change it.
 
2) As Operation Northwoods mentions, planted!

4) Hey, I'm just repeating what the officials first claimed. Did their story change again?

I can speak to at least part of your answers, Killtown. As for #2, that certainly is a LOT of evidence they had to plant. 3 crash sites, all in broad daylight. Here are just two examples you're going to need to explain though

A) Engine Part in Manhattan:
Please view this photo: http://www.magnumphotos.com/c/htm/C...2V6DH6VKE5OJF&SID=JMGEJNTIS3JFS&Pic=380&o=UY5

Note that the engine part is covered in a fine layer of dust, indicating that it was in place "prior" to the collapses of the WTC. Are you claiming that someone planted this engine part on a busy NYC street prior to the attacks? It certainly wasn't dragged into place afterwards, as that would have seen the tracks in the dust on the sidewalk.

B) Pentagon Wreckage:
PLease watch the following video:
http://judicialwatch.org/flight77.shtml

It is the security camera shots that were recently released via a FOIA request from Judicial Watch. Note that both videos run for a considerable amount of time after the crash. Please show me the evidence planters in these videos.

Likewise here are shots within 15 minutes of the crash: http://digitaljournalist.org/issue0110/pentagon.htm

Please show me evidence planters in this video.

=======

4) Your "nose cone" comment. You say you are repeating what the "officials first claimed", but in actuality they claimed no such thing. And yes, unlike so-called 'truth seekers', real investigators DO change their stories when new evidence arrives. The press conference you are referring to was 4 days after the attack, during the cleanup process. They are watching a video of the damage and cleanup at the Pentagon. One of the questioners inquired as to the "nose cone", and the person replied that the punchout hole was the farthest the nose of the plane had gone into the building.

From here: http://www.defenselink.mil/transcripts/2001/t09152001_t915evey.html (note that the date of this is 11/15/2001 and that the guy they are answering questions is Lee Evey, the project manager for the Pentagon rennovation, and NOT an aviation accident investigator)

There are 10 radial corridors in the building that extend from A ring out through E ring, and this is the fourth of those radial corridors. So it impacted the building in an area that had been renovated, but its path was at a -- it appears to be at a diagonal, so that it entered in wedge one but passed through into areas of wedge two, an unrenovated portion of the building. And, of course, you all know it's got rings A through E, five stories tall, et cetera.

Q: That seems to indicate that it came to rest in ring C, the nose cone.

Evey: Let me talk to that, because you've asked a number of questions already about the extent of penetration, et cetera. This is an overhead of the building. The point of penetration was right here, and we blocked that out to show that's the area of collapse. The plane actually penetrated through the E ring, C ring -- excuse me -- E ring, D ring, C ring.

This area right here is what we call A-E Drive. And unlike other rings in the building, it's actually a driveway that circles the building inside, between the B and the C ring. The nose of the plane just barely broke through the inside of the C ring, so it was extending into A-E Drive a little bit. So that's the extent of penetration of the aircraft.

Bolding mine - note that the QUESTION asks about the nose cone, and responds with the extent of penetration of the nose of the aircraft.

As time passed, and actual accident investigators, and not the project manager in charge of the Pentagon retrofit, it was determined that the nose of the plane probably didn't make it that far. If you notice the NIST report refers to it as "fuselage debris". No where does it say nose or "nose cone".

So .. officials first called it the "nose" a few days after the event, and then on further examination months later called it "fuselage debris". By those standards, officials first claimed that 12 people survived the Sago Mine Disaster. Is that the story you're going with there too?

So .. the question remains, do you still claim that the nose cone of the aircraft remained intact when it hit the pentagon and caused the exit hole damage in Ring C?
 
So .. the question remains, do you still claim that the nose cone of the aircraft remained intact when it hit the pentagon and caused the exit hole damage in Ring C?

If he claims that he can be dismissed as a complete ignoramus.

A simple analysis of kinetic energy abosrbtion by the front of an airliner answers the question. I don't understand why Killtown doesn't use the manufacturing specs on a 757, and solve for forces at impact with standard steel girders aat 460 knots. 1/2 m*V^2, will the nose cone bend, crumple, break, or resist plastic deformation? Is he too lazy to prove his claim, I don't see why others should do his homework for him. He is making the claim that the nose cone withstood impact with 4 exterior walls after the initial impact at 460 knots. OK, I'd like to see him reduce the equations and get me to buy his line. Show your work, Killtown.

The main structural members of the airframe, the wing roots, and the landing gear are very robust and would have a much higher chance at retaining structural integrity as the aircraft penetrates the building's walls from E ring toward C Ring. Lesser members (wings, stringers, frames) would tend to crush, crumple, or worse, as the momentum shift at impact caused longitudinal failure in the long pieces of the airframe. (Sort of an Euler Column failure in compression)

DR
 
I've got a general question of the 9/11 CT Truth movement. I don't really know what you expouse, so I don't mean to suggest that you believe or support the points that I attribute to Truthers. And I apologize if this has already been discussed elsewhere.


A rather typical debunking of the Popular Mechanics article is that the writer, Ben Chertoff, is cousin's with Homeland Security Director Michael Chertoff. Despite the fact that both Ben and Michael deny that this is true, Truthers continue to past this information off as those it were legitimate.

Question #1, if they are not really related, why do Truthers not admit to this?

Question #2, if Truthers believe that they are related, why doesn't someone do the basic researcher to prove that they are? Genelogical research is not very difficult, especially for two people born so recently.
 
Hey KT, you remember back in the LC forums when I showed you that pic of WTC7 and you said it was probably doctored and I asked how many more you would like and you said something like more than 1. Well, I found another one.

http://www.debunking911.com/WTC72.htm


Of course, it's probably doctored too. I think it's funny you can say these pics are "doctored" even though in another thread you just admitted you're not an expert in the field.
 
Hey KT, you remember back in the LC forums when I showed you that pic of WTC7 and you said it was probably doctored and I asked how many more you would like and you said something like more than 1. Well, I found another one.

http://www.debunking911.com/WTC72.htm


Of course, it's probably doctored too. I think it's funny you can say these pics are "doctored" even though in another thread you just admitted you're not an expert in the field.

Doctored?:
http://www.magnumphotos.com/c/htm/C...2V6DH6VKE5OJF&SID=JMGEJNTIS3JFS&Pic=170&o=UY5

Photoshop?:
http://www.magnumphotos.com/c/htm/C...2V6DH6VKE5OJF&SID=JMGEJNTIS3JFS&Pic=338&o=UY5

MS Paint?:
http://www.magnumphotos.com/c/htm/C...7O3RTAP4C&DT=DOC&Pass=&Total=109&Pic=90&o=UY5

Just asking questions.

-Joytown
 
LOL, you must not know about "Truth" seekers. Anything that contradicts their theory is "doctored" or fake evidence or some other such thing. How else do you think they could convince themselves Loose Change is true?
 
I see how my wording can seem misleading. I'll change it.
Thank you. I see you have effected the change already.

Let me now consider your entire section on WTC 7. I believe there are many other cases of misleading phrases that you may wish to correct, if it is not your intent. The section from your "Smoking Guns" list is the following:

Killtown @ his site said:
71. 9/11 - 6:47am, WTC 7's fire alarm is placed on 8 hr 'test' mode which any alarms received are ignored. (NIST)

72. WTC landlord Larry Silverstein says he gets a call from a fire chief about the WTC 7 and he recommends to him to 'pull it' and after they 'decided to pull,' they all watched the 7 collapse. (PBS video)

73. Firefighter Scott Holowach says he and his crew were just 'hanging out' until tower WTC 7 came down and went right to work to put the 7's fires out. (NY Times)

74. Paramedic Steven Pilla says he and his crew didn't do any further because they were 'waiting' for WTC 7 to come down. (NY Times)

75. Firefighter Lt William Ryan says he and his crew were told WTC 7 was going to collapse 'around 3 pm' and 'fell back' until it came down. (NY Times)

76. Firefighter Frank Sweeney says he and his crew were sent back down near the WTC 7 and 'stood and waited' for it to come down. (NY Times)

77. WTC 7 becomes first steel high-rise building in history to collapse due to mostly fire. (Chicago Tribune, Stanford Report)

78. The collapse of the 47 story WTC 7 skyscraper hardly gets any media attention. (NY Times)

79. WTC 7 debris was removed without investigators having the chance to examine it at the scene to help determine the cause of failure. (History Channel)

80. FEMA report concludes specifics of WTC 7 fires and how they caused it to collapse remain unknown and call for further investigation and also says the building collapsed as a result of an 'implosion.' (FEMA)
Comments on each of these points:

71. The interim NIST report you cite indicates that fires were reported visually as they started, and that the standpipe system appears to have been destroyed, from interviews. This suggests that the alarm being in "test" mode did not contribute to WTC 7's collapse -- its notification would have been redundant. Setting the alarm to "test" is not an unusual occurrence and appears to have had no impact on the outcome. Do you disagree?

72. I find nothing sinister in this comment. How much time elapsed between Silverstein's "pull it" order and the collapse? Hours? Your phrasing suggests that the two events were almost simultaneous, though I understand this may not have been your intent.

73. Since the FDNY feared a building collapse and did not want to risk the lives of firefighters, this seems utterly logical. Do you disagree?

74. See 73. above. What do you suggest they should have done?

75. The phrasing is ambiguous. Were the firefighters told, at around 3 PM, that the building was going to collapse? Or were they told that the building "was going to collapse at around 3 PM?" (Moot point, collapse occured hours later than 3 PM.) Given the damage and volume of fire, WTC 7's collapse was indeed expected, as corroborated by interviews and your own selections. What about this claim is surprising?

76. See 73-75. Everybody expected WTC 7 to collapse, leaving a fire to put out. How is this a "smoking gun?"

77. You have changed this to "WTC 7 becomes first steel high-rise building in history to collapse due to mostly fire." (emphasis added) "Mostly fire" is too vague to be objective: the Madrid Windsor Building, if treated as a steel high-rise structure built atop a concrete structure, is one that did collapse due to nothing but fire -- does that fit into "mostly?"

It would be far more correct to say "WTC 7 becomes the first steel high-rise building in history to collapse due to fire after being hit and sustaining significant structural damage by falling debris from a nearby high-rise collapse." However, while true, I doubt many would conclude it never happening before makes it impossible or even suspicious. How is this a "smoking gun?"

78. WTC 7's collapse was overshadowed by much larger, deadlier, more expensive collapses. Are you surprised that WTC 1 and 2 got more media coverage? How is this a "smoking gun?"

79. This phrasing is misleading. You are correct that "debris was removed without investigators having the chance to examine it at the scene" (emphasis added), but investigators were allowed to examine debris after rescue operations were concluded. Again, how is this a "smoking gun?" Are you proposing that rescue operations were unusual?

80. This phrasing is misleading and slightly incorrect. The FEMA Report does not say WTC 7 "was caused by implosion." On pg. 31 it says "The collapse of WTC 7 had a small debris field as the facade was pulled downward, suggesting an internal failure and implosion." (emphasis added) The later NIST results corroborate this suggestion, but it is an "implosion" only in the sense that the building collapsed in on itself following the failure of a major load-bearing column on the lower floors, viz. implosion vs. pancake collapse, which is correct. There was never any insinuation of demolition technique. How is this a "smoking gun?" How is FEMA calling for more data and investigation a "smoking gun?"

To summarize my questions:

  • I don't understand how any of these ten "Smoking Guns" are the least bit suspicious. Could you please elaborate your position for me?
  • I find your phrasing on #72, 75, 77, 79, and 80 to be misleading. Do you understand my objections?

ETA: Clarified my complaint on #72.
 
Last edited:
BTW, if I'm reading him correctly, I think he claims that the "official version" claims this - which is an equal stretch.

-Joytown
Using an error in nomenclature as proof of an event is an odd approach to "Truth Seeking."

DR
 
1) ...Who, among the thousands of first responders and investigators at those scenes, have you spoken to, and what did they say?
1) Well for example, I emailed one of the photographers who took pics inside the Pentagon, and asked them questions and all I got back in reply was "who are you?," "Why are you asking?", "what org are you from?" and questions like that. I replied saying I'm just a curious ordinary citizens wanting of few questions cleared up and then they never responded back and they NEVER answered my questions. Suspicious, huh?
In other words your answer so far is "1". And they declined to respond to your questions. If you want to know if I think that is suspicious perhaps you could post the text of your email and, with appropriate permission, the reply you recieved. Otherwise, suspicious - no.
 
80. This phrasing is misleading and slightly incorrect. The FEMA Report does not say WTC 7 "was caused by implosion." On pg. 31 it says "The collapse of WTC 7 had a small debris field as the facade was pulled downward, suggesting an internal failure and implosion." (emphasis added) The later NIST results corroborate this suggestion, but it is an "implosion" only in the sense that the building collapsed in on itself following the failure of a major load-bearing column on the lower floors, viz. implosion vs. pancake collapse, which is correct. There was never any insinuation of demolition technique. How is this a "smoking gun?" How is FEMA calling for more data and investigation a "smoking gun?"

something else to note, "implosion" is probably the rarest (and most difficult) form of explosive demolition, it is only used when the building to be brought down is surrounded on all sides by existing structures that cant be damaged

even if WTC7 was brought down in a controlled demolition its very unlikely they would choose the most difficult form (especially when they could just crop it towards WTC1+2)

and damage to surrounding buildings indicates it wasnt a CD-style implosion anyway
 
something else to note, "implosion" is probably the rarest (and most difficult) form of explosive demolition, it is only used when the building to be brought down is surrounded on all sides by existing structures that cant be damaged

even if WTC7 was brought down in a controlled demolition its very unlikely they would choose the most difficult form (especially when they could just crop it towards WTC1+2)

and damage to surrounding buildings indicates it wasnt a CD-style implosion anyway
Not to be cavalier, but a conspirator who was blowing up the buildings would hardly care if adjacent building were damaged. The conspirator would not hold himself to the high standards of the professional CD artist, but would only have to ensure that the buildings went down . . . unless he had an interest in adjacent buildings not being harmed. (Aha, look for conspirator in all adjacent buildings, and their ownership, and the onwership of all compaines with offices in those buildings!!!!)

Given the bloodthirsty character of these conspirators, I find the 'care enough to bring it down like a CD guy' not fitting of the psychological profile. ;)

DR
 
Not to be cavalier, but a conspirator who was blowing up the buildings would hardly care if adjacent building were damaged. The conspirator would not hold himself to the high standards of the professional CD artist, but would only have to ensure that the buildings went down . . . unless he had an interest in adjacent buildings not being harmed. (Aha, look for conspirator in all adjacent buildings, and their ownership, and the onwership of all compaines with offices in those buildings!!!!)

Given the bloodthirsty character of these conspirators, I find the 'care enough to bring it down like a CD guy' not fitting of the psychological profile. ;)

DR

well obviously, my argument is more of an "in for a penny in for a pound" thing

if they want to claim the building was "imploded" CD style, it helps to know what CD experts mean by implode

same applies to "pull" (which is a mechanical demolition, not explosive)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom