Project for the New American Century

Stop trying to pick apart my every word, and just - LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE PLEASE.
The never-ending cycle of CT-deception!

Your whole "argument" is based on one sentence you totally take out of context. And when this argument is repeatedly trashed, you retreat to the "BIG PICTURE".

However, you fail to realize that your "BIG PICTURE" is nothing more than the aggregation of many small falsehoods.
Sadly for you, most people here do realize this. That's why you getting nowhere so far. And lying won't help, quite the contrary.
 
Well... you really don't need to say in your plan... word for word. "Oh God, I WANT to hit the lottery, so I don't have to do all this other 3445." It just goes without saying.

The problem with this is, you're equating saying "I hope I win the lottery" with "I'm going to go out and rig the lottery so I will win". Hoping for an event, and actually working to create that event are not the same thing.

And that doesn't even address the idea that they "wanted" or "hoped for" such an event. They merely recognized that such an event could have an effect. Again, not the same thing at all.

In their eyes and in their own words...they clearly stated a belief (pre 9/11) that gives them a motive to perpetrate 9/11... and that is the point.


So if you ever win the lottery, you'll be okay with all of us accusing you of rigging the lottery? After all, by your logic, "wanting" to win clearly gives you a motive for "making it happen" by rigging the lotery.
 
You people are your own worse enemy... why don't you stop being so fastidious about the words I'm using... and see the undeniable point I have made over the course of 10+ posts.

Stop trying to pick apart my every word, and just - LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE PLEASE.

Maybe, I shouldn't have said, "PNAC SAID A NEW PEARL HARBOR WOULD BENEFIT THEM," to you left-b's, because I guess that confuses you. Even though... the PNAC did SAY without all the words... that a New Pearl Harbor would benefit them. Unless... you don't think expediting someone's goals from years/decades to a day is beneficial.

Saying something would benefit you is different from saying that you "wish" it would happen, or "let's make it happen".

Saying "winning the lottery would be beneficiall to me" is not quite the same thing as saying "I wish I would win the lottery". It's just stating a supposed outcome.
Saying that the former implies the latter is just an interpretation of the writer's intention by the reader.

It is also very different from saying "I am going to win the lottery by doing X,Y,Z to make it happen"

Drat! Horatius beat me to it!
 
Last edited:
9/11 was a catastrophe. 9/11 was a catalyzing event. Obviously. But if your MOTIVE was to catalyze Americans towards a goal of high-tech military buildup against a high-tech threat, then you have NO MOTIVE for creating a false flag op designed to look like a low-tech threat that your high-tech goals would be useless against.

This is the type of warped logic I have been dealing with since I joined JREF. Reading and trying to analyze stuff like this... makes it feel like my brain is eating itself.

DUDE... do you really think Americans... are sitting around, thinking... hmmm 3,000 people just died... we are told that more attacks may come... we are in fear for our safety and lives... but HEY WAIT A MINUTE! These attacks fall under the category of low-tech threats... but, the USG is trying to increase spending for high-tech weaponry. Whoa buster... you ain't gonna pull this one by us... we're all gonna take off work and go protest on capitol hill to stop this insanity.

I mean... what is wrong with you people... at times, you seem like intelligent good-minded folks... but sometimes, it feels like you are going out of your way to defend this tyrannical regime.
 
Sometimes your complete lack of comprehension is quite astounding.
 
I mean... what is wrong with you people... at times, you seem like intelligent good-minded folks... but sometimes, it feels like you are going out of your way to defend this tyrannical regime.

____________________________________________

It´s pretty simple for me: I look for truth - or in other
words: I accept if the government was innocent in a
wrong accusation against them. Concerning PNAC you
seem to ride a dead horse and therefore i guess you
never would admit that the PNAC smoking gun is so
weak that it finally isn´t any smoking gun at all.

____________________________________________
 
DUDE... do you really think Americans... are sitting around, thinking... hmmm 3,000 people just died... we are told that more attacks may come... we are in fear for our safety and lives... but HEY WAIT A MINUTE! These attacks fall under the category of low-tech threats... but, the USG is trying to increase spending for high-tech weaponry. Whoa buster... you ain't gonna pull this one by us... we're all gonna take off work and go protest on capitol hill to stop this insanity.
DUDE... do you really think Americans are so stupid that they'd support a star wars program to combat a "War on Terror"?!!?!!

What you wrote here is EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED, except for the "USG is trying to increase spending for high-tech weaponry" part. Granted, some people still tried to push it through, but the folks on capitol hill mostly turned their attention to combatting terrorism and were quick to judge support for new high-tech military spending as an unpopular and untenable position, preferring to support a defense budget that leaned heavily towards spending that could more easily be justified as necessary to defend the country against terrorism.
 
You people are your own worse enemy... why don't you stop being so fastidious about the words I'm using... and see the undeniable point I have made over the course of 10+ posts.

Stop trying to pick apart my every word, and just - LOOK AT THE BIG PICTURE PLEASE.

Maybe, I shouldn't have said, "PNAC SAID A NEW PEARL HARBOR WOULD BENEFIT THEM," to you left-b's, because I guess that confuses you. Even though... the PNAC did SAY without all the words... that a New Pearl Harbor would benefit them. Unless... you don't think expediting someone's goals from years/decades to a day is beneficial.

What you view as us being "fastidious" we view as the mortal flaw in your arguments and intellectual dishonesty. We can't "look at the big picture" and overlook a fatal flaw. That's now how rational minds work.

PNAC never said what you claim you they said. That's what you interpret. There are alternate interpretations. Your interpretation, in my opinion, is wrong. Therefore you peddling your (wrong) interpretation as fact strikes me as being highly intellectually dishonest.
 
Ahhhhh I see where the liar 28th Kingdom is coming from now.

It's ok to lie about a tyrannical regime or government, in just the same way that it was ok to lie about babies being thrown out of incubators by the iraqis in kuwait, because iraq had invaded and obviously were the bad guys so we can tell whatever lies we like about them.

In fact we will deliberately lie and accuse them of the most despicable crimes because...well, there's always someone out there willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, so lying about a regime is jusitified if it shows the fencesitters or the bleeding hearts the true light which we, as superior intellects have already found out, but that they, the great unwashed, are willing to ignore.

So, let's all LIE LIE LIE until everyone believes the same as we do.

We don't like Bush, so a few lies about 9/11 wont hurt to get people onside so that they can dislike him too.

The world according to 28th Kingdom, renowned liar.
 
You need more than motive to prove beyond reasonable doubt that someone was responsible for an event.

Of course... and I agree with that. When did I say, I only need a motive? A motive is just the first step.... if I couldn't provide a reasonable motive for elements within the USG to perpetrate 9/11, than there would be nothing to build the case upon.

Look... on the surface... it kind of goes against common logic, to think that a country can actually benefit from being attacked... but, the PNAC shows us how this can happen... so that's why it's so important and pertinent to proving the case for 9/11 being an inside job. False flags... and their desired effect... also show us what would motivate a country to attack itself.

Maybe I need to take all of these grand schemes and ideas... and make them more comparable to something you might experience in your everyday lives...

Picture this... if you may... it's like dating a crazy women... who becomes so psychotic after you break up with her... that she gives herself bruises... and then goes to the police, and says you beat her up. It's the ole... DOMESTIC FALSE FIST, tactic.

...bad boys...bad boys... whatcha gonna do...
 
Last edited:
Ahhhhh I see where the liar 28th Kingdom is coming from now.

It's ok to lie about a tyrannical regime or government, in just the same way that it was ok to lie about babies being thrown out of incubators by the iraqis in kuwait, because iraq had invaded and obviously were the bad guys so we can tell whatever lies we like about them.

In fact we will deliberately lie and accuse them of the most despicable crimes because...well, there's always someone out there willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, so lying about a regime is jusitified if it shows the fencesitters or the bleeding hearts the true light which we, as superior intellects have already found out, but that they, the great unwashed, are willing to ignore.

So, let's all LIE LIE LIE until everyone believes the same as we do.

We don't like Bush, so a few lies about 9/11 wont hurt to get people onside so that they can dislike him too.

The world according to 28th Kingdom, renowned liar.
Edited by Darat: 
Content in breach of Membership Agreement removed
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Picture this... is you may... it's like dating a crazy women... who becomes so psychic after you break up with her... that she gives herself bruises... and then goes to the police, and says you beat her up. It's the ole... DOMESTIC FALSE FIST, tactic.

And that was another Officer Crabtree moment brought to you by 28IQ. 150 IQ my foot.
 
This is the type of warped logic I have been dealing with since I joined JREF. Reading and trying to analyze stuff like this... makes it feel like my brain is eating itself.

DUDE... do you really think Americans... are sitting around, thinking... hmmm 3,000 people just died... we are told that more attacks may come... we are in fear for our safety and lives... but HEY WAIT A MINUTE! These attacks fall under the category of low-tech threats... but, the USG is trying to increase spending for high-tech weaponry. Whoa buster... you ain't gonna pull this one by us... we're all gonna take off work and go protest on capitol hill to stop this insanity.

I mean... what is wrong with you people... at times, you seem like intelligent good-minded folks... but sometimes, it feels like you are going out of your way to defend this tyrannical regime.

Ahem!. canceled after 9/11
Cancellation of the RAH-66 Comanche
Cancellation of the XM2001 Crusader( thisone might have been before 9/11)
Cancellation of "Blackstar" a military space plane
Cancelation of the TOW-FF anti-tank missle
Cancellation of the Army's Tactical High Energy Laser Project
Cancellation of DARPA's lifelog project
Cancellation of the Army's WALRUS Hybrid Ultra-Large Aircraft project
Cancellation of several weapon aquisition systems software
Cutting the budget for the Joint Strike fighter
Plans for constructing new military bases have been shelved.
Plans for more military base closures

Yep, 9/11 sure catelyzed the development of those projects
 
The never-ending cycle of CT-deception!

Your whole "argument" is based on one sentence you totally take out of context. And when this argument is repeatedly trashed, you retreat to the "BIG PICTURE".

However, you fail to realize that your "BIG PICTURE" is nothing more than the aggregation of many small falsehoods.
Sadly for you, most people here do realize this. That's why you getting nowhere so far. And lying won't help, quite the contrary.

I agree having just read the entire document. This single sentence is taken totally out of context.

Interestingly I notice that the cters also fail to mention the Pearl Harbor is actually mentioned twice in this document.

Once on page 51 in the sentence 28th is desperately trying to twist out of context.

The second time Pearl Harbor is mention on page 67, where it is explained quite clearly why it is referenced. Here is the sentence from page 67.

Absent a rigours program of experimentation to investigate the nature in military affairs as it applies to war at sea, the Navy might face a future Pearl harbor-as unprepared for war in the post carrier era as it was unprepared for war at the dawn of the carrier age.

28th in case you missed it, the reference to Pearl harbour is to a surprise attack, being unprepared for such an attack and paying the price for such unready ness. Strange you failed to mention the second mentioning of Pearl Harbor since you have read the entire document and fully understand it.

Try reading 28th.

http://www.newamericancentury.org/RebuildingAmericasDefenses.pdf
 
Last edited:
Of course... and I agree with that. When did I say, I only need a motive?

You haven't provided evidence that the guys from PNAC are behind 9/11 other than the motive.

A motive is just the first step.... if I couldn't provide a reasonable motive for elements within the USG to perpetrate 9/11, than there would be nothing to build the case upon.

I suggest you read that over and over until it sinks in.

Look... on the surface... it kind of goes against common logic, to think that a country can actually benefit from being attacked... but, the PNAC shows us how this can happen... so that's why it's so important and pertinent to proving the case for 9/11 being an inside job. False flags... and their desired effect... also show us what would motivate a country to attack itself.

Again. Only Motive. No evidence.

Picture this... if you may... it's like dating a crazy women... who becomes so psychotic after you break up with her... that she gives herself bruises... and then goes to the police, and says you beat her up. It's the ole... DOMESTIC FALSE FIST, tactic.

...bad boys...bad boys... whatcha gonna do...

28th every single analogy you post here is absolutely ridiculous. In this case the woman would then have to prove that you beat her up. She won't get anywhere without proof.

Just like you. YOU HAVE NO PROOF.
 
if I couldn't provide a reasonable motive for elements within the USG to perpetrate 9/11, than there would be nothing to build the case upon.
Then you might as well stop now.


it kind of goes against common logic
Is this common logic anything like the common sense you also spectacularly failed to comprehend?


Maybe I need to take all of these grand schemes and ideas... and make them more comparable to something you might experience in your everyday lives...
OK then...


Picture this... is you may... it's like dating a crazy women
so far so not everyday...


who becomes so psychic after you break up with her
ooh, I have the power to make people psychic, cool...


that she gives herself bruises... and then goes to the police, and says you beat her up. It's the ole... DOMESTIC FALSE FIST, tactic.
ah, the old filing a false police report/writing a neo-conservative defence strategy report analogy, I'm glad you clarified that for us.
 
Then you might as well stop now.


Is this common logic anything like the common sense you also spectacularly failed to comprehend?


OK then...


so far so not everyday...


ooh, I have the power to make people psychic, cool...


ah, the old filing a false police report/writing a neo-conservative defence strategy report analogy, I'm glad you clarified that for us.

It took you at least 18 minutes to write this? Your quotes of mine contain typos that I corrected at least 18 minutes before you posted this... Compare the last time I edited the post you quoted, against the time you submitted your reply. I'd say, it probably took you 25+ minutes to whip up that in depth reply. Hahahahaha - Gotcha!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom