The Guardian and Loose Change Again

One minor thing which the Trio et al. will seize upon: the flight instructor they interviewed is not the person who trained Hani, but the one who refused to let Hani rent a Cessna. Otherwise, it's spot on.
 
Dont get a lot by Monbiot in Aussie papers, but this is the first one I have agreed with. Good to see. But, according to CTs anything from mainstream press is written for sheeple and is thefore safely ignored.
 
Well worth a read.
A snippet :
"There is a virus sweeping the world. It infects opponents of the Bush government, sucks their brains out through their eyes and turns them into gibbering idiots"
 
It's a good article, but a lot of the comments after it are the usual insanity.

It's frustrating to see opponents of the Iraq war and Prez Bush jumping on the truth movement bandwagon. There are lots of ways to debate the war and the presidency, but accusing them of masterminding a conspiracy isn't it.

I know its a sweeping statement, but the left loses so much credibility. How many war protests are accompanied by 9/11 truth banners? Too many.
 
"After doing at least 2 weeks of solid research i came to the conclusion that NIST and The Commission report were just quite simply inaccurate, and there was plenty of valid material omitted."

At least TWO WEEKS of SOLID research!

That'd do it.
 
Nice article.

It's frustrating to see opponents of the Iraq war and Prez Bush jumping on the truth movement bandwagon. There are lots of ways to debate the war and the presidency, but accusing them of masterminding a conspiracy isn't it.

Yep. I find it pretty scary and depressing.
 
"After doing at least 2 weeks of solid research i came to the conclusion that NIST and The Commission report were just quite simply inaccurate, and there was plenty of valid material omitted."

At least TWO WEEKS of SOLID research!

That'd do it.


That kind of shoddy thinking has been one of the main arguments against CTists for me.

Never mind the fact that an expert (and I mean someone with the proper technical credentials) needs days, even weeks, to come to valid conclusions for something as minor as a house fire or a car accident, those clowns pretend they can determine the cause(s) of such an enormous event in a mere two weeks of reading reports that took specialists months, even years to compile ... :rolleyes:

I can easily imagine the howls should an insurance expert use the same standards in awarding them compensation after a house robbery or a car wreck ...
 
Dylan is not happy ...

Disclaimer:
Dear mods,
Since this is an open letter, I think that rule 4 doesn't apply.
If I'm wrong, please be lenient when punishing me. :eusa_angel:

Thanks

Yours truly

Firestone

--------------------------------------------------------
Dylan writes an open letter:

Dear Letters,

The fact that George Monbiot's article contains more ad-hominem attacks and circular logic than an actual debate on evidence shows how little Manbiot understands the core issues of the 9/11 Truth Movement. Had he taken the extra time to actually RESEARCH, he would inevitably have stumbled upon the research of Paul Thompson and Jim Hoffman, and actually come to some fair conclusions instead of basing it on our film, which we have openly stated does not even begin to cover the entire 9/11 movement.

Also, Manbiot might have stumbled upon some articles from his very employers that cast doubt upon the official story. Such as, oh, I dunno, this one?

The Pakistan connection
http://www.guardian.co.uk/comment/story/0,3604,1266317,00.html

But I digress. A couple laughable excerpts from Manbiot's article:

"The next evident flaw is that the plot they propose must have involved tens of thousands of people ... People appear on the Jerry Springer Show to admit to carnal relations with their tractors. "

That suggestion is ludicrous and is not based in any reality or fact. The Manhattan Project cost nearly $2 billion dollars and employed over 100,000 people, and a majority of the details surrounding it remain classified to this day. Comparing a national tragedy and colossal failure such as 9/11 to someone having sex with a tractor exposes George for the journalistic embarrassment he is.

"Hundreds of people saw a plane hit the Pentagon."

We've spoken to a number of those people, including Mike Walter. We never said a cruise missile did hit. We merely advanced it as a possible theory. Anything could have happened at the Pentagon, and the core issue remains that the government has controlled the information from start to finish, and has refused citizens' requests at almost every turn.

One of the people who saw the plane hit, Lt. Col. Karen Kwiatkowski, Ph.D, has this to say:
"... I saw nothing of significance at the point of impact - no airplane metal or cargo debris was blowing on the lawn in front of the damaged building as smoke billowed from within the Pentagon. ... all of us staring at the Pentagon that morning were indeed looking for such debris, but what we expected to see was not evident.

The same is true with regard to the kind of damage we expected. ... But I did not see this kind of damage. Rather, the facade had a rather small hole, no larger than 20 feet in diameter. Although this facade later collapsed, it remained standing for 30 or 40 minutes, with the roof line remaining relatively straight.

The scene, in short, was not what I would have expected from a strike by a large jetliner. It was, however, exactly what one would expect if a missile had struck the Pentagon.

... More information is certainly needed regarding the events of 9/11 and the events leading up to that terrible day."

"The failure of the twin towers has been exhaustively documented by the National Institute of Standards and Technology. Far from being impossible, the collapse turns out to have been inevitable."

That statement is false. The actual collapse mechanism for the entire building was never documented by NIST, and they have openly stated that it was not their job. We have footage of them on camera saying so. They cover the "collapse initiation" and state flatly that it leads to "global collapse." The fact that NIST wants us to believe that an entire 90-story structure could have come crashing down at any moment, and the fact that people such as George Manbiot parrot this nonsense, is absurd beyond belief.

"He also demonstrates how Building 7 collapsed."

Really? Perhaps he should pass this information onto NIST, who has yet to release their final report on WTC7.

FEMA themselves admitted in their 2002 status report, "The specifics of the fires in WTC 7 and how they caused the building to collapse remain unknown at this time. Although the total diesel fuel on the premises contained massive potential energy, the best hypothesis has only a low probability of occurrence. Further research, investigation, and analyses are needed to resolve this issue."

"The film's greatest flaw is this: the men who made it are still alive. If the US government is running an all-knowing, all-encompassing conspiracy, why did it not snuff them out long ago?"

Manbiot closes his article with the most ridiculous counter-argument I've ever encountered.

They're still alive, therefore, their movie is false. This premise was first advanced by Maddox, an online satirist who dresses like a pirate. What's even funnier is people like George actually find this as grounds to disbelieve EVERYTHING we could mention.

If the government rubbed us out tomorrow, don't you think red flags would start popping up all over the place?

I would like to think that if anything came out of our suspicious death, it would be an apology from individuals such as George Manbiot.

Try contacting us next time before you write an article about us. Ed Pilkington had the decency to travel to our house. You couldn't even put in a phone call.

-Dylan Avery

ETA: the letter is already gone :confused: :confused: :confused:
 
Last edited:
Disclaimer:
Dear mods,
Since this is an open letter, I think that rule 4 doesn't apply.
If I'm wrong, please be lenient when punishing me. :eusa_angel:

Thanks

Yours truly

Firestone

--------------------------------------------------------
Dylan writes an open letter:

That statement is false. The actual collapse mechanism for the entire building was never documented by NIST, and they have openly stated that it was not their job.

Is he on crack? Just because they didn't go into detail on say, how the collapse of the 23rd floor effected the 22nd floor, does not mean they did not explain the collapse mechanism of the building.
 
Sorry Dylan, you're an idiot. He is just mad that the article blatantly exposes him for the liar that he is. Great article.
 
from Dylan's open letter:
One of the people who saw the plane hit, Lt. Col. Karen Kwiatkowski, Ph.D, has this to say:
"... The scene, in short, was not what I would have expected from a strike by a large jetliner. It was, however, exactly what one would expect if a missile had struck the Pentagon...."
You said it, Dylan......
 
"After doing at least 2 weeks of solid research i came to the conclusion that NIST and The Commission report were just quite simply inaccurate, and there was plenty of valid material omitted."

At least TWO WEEKS of SOLID research!

That'd do it.

I bet this research was "google".
 
from Dylan's open letter:

One of the people who saw the plane hit, Lt. Col. Karen Kwiatkowski, Ph.D, has this to say:
"... The scene, in short, was not what I would have expected from a strike by a large jetliner. It was, however, exactly what one would expect if a missile had struck the Pentagon...."

You said it, Dylan......

you hit the nail there sophia.
this is one of the most inanely hilarious uses of testimony i have ever seen. he uses a witness who saw a plane to somehow indicate it might have been a missile. very funny. no wonder the moron took the letter down.

BV
 
The Manhattan Project cost nearly $2 billion dollars and employed over 100,000 people, and a majority of the details surrounding it remain classified to this day.

ive seen the Manhattan Project used a number of times by the CTers as a hedge against the whistle blower argument. the argument just doesn't hold water. that project was conducted against a background of national crisis and unity under martial law i think. any whistle-blowers would have been clapped in irons and charged with treason (perhaps rightly so)besides, (i believe) most of the people involved were virtually imprisoned in a remote facility with no access to the mass communication we have today, mobile phones, WWW etc. any country nowadays would find it much more difficult to keep such a project secret. ie Iran and N. Korea.
avery is clutching at straws.

BV
 
ive seen the Manhattan Project used a number of times by the CTers as a hedge against the whistle blower argument. the argument just doesn't hold water. that project was conducted against a background of national crisis and unity under martial law i think. any whistle-blowers would have been clapped in irons and charged with treason (perhaps rightly so)besides, (i believe) most of the people involved were virtually imprisoned in a remote facility with no access to the mass communication we have today, mobile phones, WWW etc. any country nowadays would find it much more difficult to keep such a project secret. ie Iran and N. Korea.
avery is clutching at straws.

BV

This is EXACTLY what I was about to post. Further more though, the Manhattan Project did not involve killing thousands of our own citizens. It was seen as a just cause. And as said before, times were very different back then. Mass Media was not yet available as it is today. Dylan is a VERY desperate man.
 
Oh and on top of that, we were in the middle of a damn war! Plus it was perfectly legal. I could keep going on and on about it but it is painstakingly obvious that a 9/11 conspiracy and the Manhattan Project are not in any way alike. Dylan is indulging himself in fantasy again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom