Looking for Truth in Credentials: The WTC "Experts"

The NIST report is pretty dry reading. I appreciate your leaving out the other 9,999 1/2 pages.

Hit me with it, better still hit Dr Steven Jones, they love dry material professors. Just the bit that deals with the collapse of each building. We're talking 10 seconds, 10 seconds and 6 seconds - it's a 10,000 page report on the collapse, surely there is a more thorough explanation, I don't want the preface or the summary - where's the actual explanation?

What I'm really interested in - you've got this falling mass of debris, much of it ejected laterally, therefore reducing the mass available to impact lower floors. Where are the figures on this - how much mass reduction did they estimate from the collapse photo's and the residual debris field - I heard it was something like 5 times the diameter of the base of the tower - I dunno, rule of thumb - reduced by 4 fifths - 20%? I'm guessing - where are the real figures?
 
Last edited:
RUH ROH!!

We have presented at 2 conferences for the 9/11 movement within the past month.

The 9/11 accountability conference in AZ last month and the Freedom and Justice conference in CA just this past weekend.

The attendees were a mixture of people of all ages, classes, etc.

The presenters were people like Dylan Avery, April Gallop, Dave VonKliest, Barbara Honegger, Russ Whitenberg, Steven Jones, Webster Tarpley and of course CIT.

Not a single presenter at either conference suggested that it's possible that a 757 hit the Pentagon.

Not a single attendee at either conference spoke out against this or approached me with such a sentiment.

The notion that the movement is split in this regard is a LIE that is perpetuated by a few loud mouths online.

People like Russell Pickering and Jim Hoffman are clearly leading a disinformation campaign to give the appearance of a split when the reality is that virtually everyone who questions 9/11 questions whether or not a plane hit the Pentagon.

The irony is that they present themselves as logical saviours of disinfo while they work night and day to preserve the official story in this regard.

Of course some people online have fallen for the 757 impact conspiracy theory and have abandoned the very questions that got us all started on the movement to begin with......

The anomalous physical evidence at the Pentagon.

Remember this?

The Pentagon Strike

Most of it is still completely relevant today and this particular animation is almost singlehandedly responsible for bringing 9/11 truth to a wide audience.

Obviously the theories have undergone revisions and some of the questions posed have been debunked.

The global hawk/A3 skywarrior junk has been proven incorrect and although plenty of people still embrace it; the missle theory is dead.

There most certainly was a low flying passenger jet in the area that day.

But the notion that a 757 hit the Pentagon is certainly more ludicrous than a missile and the notion that the movement is actually split on this is a clear farce.

Don't let the disinfobots sway you from the truth.

9/11 was a world wide psychological operation of epic proportions and to think that the perpetrators didn't have the means or balls to fake this part of the plan in their own backyard is disingenuous to say the least.

Sincerely,
Lyte Trip
CIT

Does anyone know this expert's credentials, he works for the dumb side? Like Star Wars but the other side is not dark, they are dumb. They have this big death star of truth, kind of a big beam weapon where darth Fetzer sits with the evail Judy Wood, das beam weapon woman. I know Fetzer looks like jabba the gut, but who would play darth?

LyteTrip, what is he? What makes him qualified to be so dumb? May be Scoooooooby knows?
 
Last edited:
I dunno, rule of thumb - reduced by 4 fifths - 20%? I'm guessing - where are the real figures?

I'm sorry, are you proposing that 80% of the mass of the WTC towers was "ejected laterally" during the collapse?

-Gumboot
 
It is claimed by theology professor Dr David Ray Griffin and physics professor Dr Steven Jones that the NIST report does not explain how the World Trade Center towers or WTC7 collapsed, and this is a tall one to deny, when it is common knowledge that the report into WTC7 does not exist and the ability to read is a common skill available to anyone.

But go for it anyway - where is the explanation doc?

Scooby, you are going to have a very hard time pulling that "WTC7 report does not exist" when it is released this Spring. Unlike Jones analysis, the NIST report has to be peer-reviewed and published. Extensive investigations have to be performed to determine why the towers collapsed. What is common knowledge is that the WTC7 NIST report is due out this year. Wake up.

The NIST report does explain why World Trade Centers 1 and 2 collapsed. We know that the buildings themselves failed due to the failure of the inwardly bowed perimeter columns. That is collapse initiation, according to an analysis conducted by 200 government and private scientists that has been extensively peer-reviewed.

So if we know why the building came down, why does it matter how the building came down? More government funding so we can simply be told what any sane person already knows? Do you want a floor-by-floor analysis of what happened in the 10 seconds that it took each tower to fall? What kind of analysis are you after Scooby?

Do you honestly think any "controlled demolition" plan would rely on the buildings first initiating collapsing due to the failure of inwardly bowed perimeter columns? Tell me Scooby - how does such a controlled demolition work? Man across the street waits until the building starts falling and starts setting of charges? What if the building doesn't fall Scooby? All those un-detonated charges covering the largest crime scene in modern history wouldn't go down too well would it?

I think it is time you got your head around the fact that the NIST report was an investigation to assist future construction methods and determine why the buildings collapsed. The NIST report was not created to debate lunatic conspiracy theorists. Get used to it.
 
... The only supposedly independent corroboration that the Bush scientists at NIST
The Bush scientists? Most of the staff at NIST were hired long before Bush Sr. or Bush Jr. were ever in office. This is the first outright lie in your article, and I expect you'll agree that this characterization of NIST scientists being somehow connected or ingratiated to the Bush administration is both false and libelous.
could produce for their appalling pack of lies
Unsupported assertion.
was from that old respected scientific institution, Popular Mechanics. This Hearst magazine is not, as most people know, a scientific publication in any way, shape or form. When they talk about Mechanics, they do not mean Quantum Mechanics or Statistical Mechanics, or even Classical Mechanics. Popular Mechanics (PM) is simply a gloss-covered advertisement for numerous consumer items ranging from ATVs to lawn mowers. You know – mechanics.
This is opinion, and obviously from someone who is not a regular reader of PM. Pretty pathetic.
This hasn’t prevented many who cling to the official story from using PM as their scientific champion.
Or, rather, a brief companion for the laity.
For example, in his poorly researched hit piece against “conspiracy theorists”, British essayist George Monbiot foists Popular Mechanics upon us, saying they “polled 300 experts” to support their findings.[16] But science is not about popularity, and PM’s “poll” of “structural engineering/building collapse experts” actually consisted of only about 33 people, some of them listed as photographers, media-relations staff and spokespersons. Of those that were engineering-related, most were in some way related to OKC, FEMA, NIST or DOD, and many were responsible for the Weidlinger report, the Pancake Theory, or the NIST report.[17] It turns out that, when it comes to scientific explanations for terrorist acts, it’s a small world after all.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v491/reprehensor/911/demo-matrix.jpg

http://www.911blogger.com/node/6765

The rest of this post is known as "Poisoning the Well" and without Arkan Wolfshade here to direct you to the proper resources, I would suggest wikipedia to allay your ignorance. Nothing that you've shown here proves any form of conflict of interest.
A Chemistry laboratory manager like myself can work without permits or licenses, but people can’t just go out and build a bridge or a tall building on their own.

Kevin Ryan's BS has gotten rather thick lately. Does he think that a chemistry lab is no less under the scrutiny of numerous regulatory agencies? Yes, he must apply for and pay to have hazardous wastes disposed of. Yes, he must apply for and submit to inspections for nuclear or radioactive materials. Those permits and licenses are no less important than any of the bridge building permits.

So on what scientific basis does this theory of a fire induced total collapse rest exactly? Is there anything published in academia that describes the mechanism by which it occurred, other than the work of the Scholars for 911 Truth and Justice?
Yes. MIT professors have published several articles, and the NCSTAR was the result of collaborations with dozens of Universities around the US. Leave us not forget, the NCSTAR was subjected to peer review, public review, the Washington Editorial Review Board, another public review and a final peer review before it was published in its final form.

It is claimed by theology professor Dr David Ray Griffin and physics professor Dr Steven Jones that the NIST report does not explain how the World Trade Center towers or WTC7 collapsed

You will now have the honor of being the 4th conspiracy fantasist to have repeated this particularly stupid argument. The entirety of the National Construction Safety Team Act is reprinted at the end of NCSTAR 1. Read it. Point out to me where Congress directs NIST to study the collapse of the WTC towers beyond the collapse initiation state. Point out to me where they direct NIST to model the collapse. Be the first truther to do that.
, and this is a tall one to deny, when it is common knowledge that the report into WTC7 does not exist and the ability to read is a common skill available to anyone.

Appendix L, but then again, your ignorance of the NCSTAR is so deep, it is no wonder why you didn't know this existed. The final report on the WTC 7 collapse is due this year. It does indeed exist, but not in a form that is available for public comment or viewing.

Hit me with it, better still hit Dr Steven Jones, they love dry material professors. Just the bit that deals with the collapse of each building. We're talking 10 seconds, 10 seconds and 6 seconds - it's a 10,000 page report on the collapse, surely there is a more thorough explanation, I don't want the preface or the summary - where's the actual explanation?

So, you want an answer, but you don't want to read it? The NCSTAR explains why the towers collapsed and how NIST arrived at this conclusion. Each test, each experiment, every equation, all of them are covered in the exhaustive detail that is the hallmark of good scientific research. I'm terribly sorry that real science doesn't fit into the truther definition of "research" which is YouTube and Google plus 25 minutes of copy and paste.
What I'm really interested in - you've got this falling mass of debris, much of it ejected laterally, therefore reducing the mass available to impact lower floors. Where are the figures on this - how much mass reduction did they estimate from the collapse photo's and the residual debris field - I heard it was something like 5 times the diameter of the base of the tower - I dunno, rule of thumb - reduced by 4 fifths - 20%? I'm guessing - where are the real figures?
Indeed, where are they? To me, it looks like you're making up numbers.
 
Let's try something else:

Scooby, so you are now building your argument from the (correct) fact that neither the NIST report nor any other official report has analyzed the collapse sequence in detail, right?

We might look into that in a moment, but first:

Can we take it then that you are satisfied with the account of the events that lead up to the collapse sequence. From the hijacking of the planes by Moslem terrorists and up to and including the moment where structural failure initiates collapse?

Hans
 
Hit me with it, better still hit Dr Steven Jones, they love dry material professors. Just the bit that deals with the collapse of each building. We're talking 10 seconds, 10 seconds and 6 seconds - it's a 10,000 page report on the collapse, surely there is a more thorough explanation, I don't want the preface or the summary - where's the actual explanation?

What I'm really interested in - you've got this falling mass of debris, much of it ejected laterally, therefore reducing the mass available to impact lower floors. Where are the figures on this - how much mass reduction did they estimate from the collapse photo's and the residual debris field - I heard it was something like 5 times the diameter of the base of the tower - I dunno, rule of thumb - reduced by 4 fifths - 20%? I'm guessing - where are the real figures?

Firstly, the towers did not collapse in ten seconds:
455alqg.jpg


10 seconds in, debris still 800ft+ away from the ground.

The explanation is simple physics. If we say the top section of WTC2 weighed 110,000 tons, with floor areas of 3716 sqm we can calculate that the failure floor in WTC2 was under a pressure of approx 30 tons/sqm, all taken by columns designed to support that load.

If that 110,000 ton mass drops 3.7m, upon striking the floor below it would exert 10.6 billion newtons of force, or 290 tons/sqm, taken largely by floorslabs which were not designed to take any appreciable vertical load.

The debris 'ejected laterally' was perimeter columns tipping over in large sections. The perimeter columns were not needed to pancake the structure, the 104 floorplates were able to do that, and none of those would have been ejected out of the footprint. Once the floors had been torn from their connections by the falling mass, columns were free of lateral support and thus able to tip over away from the footprint.
 
Hit me with it, better still hit Dr Steven Jones, they love dry material professors. Just the bit that deals with the collapse of each building. We're talking 10 seconds, 10 seconds and 6 seconds - it's a 10,000 page report on the collapse, surely there is a more thorough explanation, I don't want the preface or the summary - where's the actual explanation?

How about you actually READ THE REPORT in question? Even the shorter 250+ page version, for example.

Ignorance is NOT a strength, scooby.
 
No - so say sorry again.

You might want to post a disclaimer to your earlier post then. Because regardless of what you INTENDED to say, what your post actually states is that 4/5 (80%) of the mass of the towers was ejected laterally, thus reducing the mass of the material collapsing the building.

-Gumboot
 
Let's try something else:

Scooby, so you are now building your argument from the (correct) fact that neither the NIST report nor any other official report has analyzed the collapse sequence in detail, right?

We might look into that in a moment, but first:

Can we take it then that you are satisfied with the account of the events that lead up to the collapse sequence. From the hijacking of the planes by Moslem terrorists and up to and including the moment where structural failure initiates collapse?

Hans

I'm not building an argument.

How could I, when I'm asking people to think for themselves and make their own minds up?
 
Firstly, the towers did not collapse in ten seconds:
http://i16.tinypic.com/455alqg.jpg

10 seconds in, debris still 800ft+ away from the ground.

The explanation is simple physics. If we say the top section of WTC2 weighed 110,000 tons, with floor areas of 3716 sqm we can calculate that the failure floor in WTC2 was under a pressure of approx 30 tons/sqm, all taken by columns designed to support that load.

The 10 second fig is an approximation, I believe the exact figure is difficult to ascertain precisely, but is a matter of seconds, and well within the capability of a 10,000 page report to describe.

As for the rest of this explanation - is it from the NIST report?

30 tons per square metre - whats that about 38 PSI - something like the pressure in a bicycle tyre? Not much really is it? You don't even get to say 'undreds and undreds' - 38. Hmmm.

No - I'll wait for the official excuses thanks.
When the real figures are published - perhaps we can discuss them then.
 
I'm not building an argument.

How could I, when I'm asking people to think for themselves and make their own minds up?
But you've already made up your mind, thermite and explosives, without a shred of real evidence. You're a joke, a bad one at that.
 
But you've already made up your mind, thermite and explosives, without a shred of real evidence. You're a joke, a bad one at that.

But there is plenty of real evidence that I have used to base my conclusions on. That you have come to different conclusions - is fine by me. You have every right to your opinion. Just stay out of tall buildings.
 
The 10 second fig is an approximation, I believe the exact figure is difficult to ascertain precisely, but is a matter of seconds, and well within the capability of a 10,000 page report to describe.

As for the rest of this explanation - is it from the NIST report?

30 tons per square metre - whats that about 38 PSI - something like the pressure in a bicycle tyre? Not much really is it? You don't even get to say 'undreds and undreds' - 38. Hmmm.

No - I'll wait for the official excuses thanks.
When the real figures are published - perhaps we can discuss them then.
actually, it's 19.55 psi. or, 1.6 tons per square foot.
basically, its is 1 volkswagon parked on EVERY SQUARE FOOT of floor space.
Obviously, a V-dub cannot even be compacted to fit in a 1 square foot space, unless you make it really long (tall)

and an automobile tire runs about 35 psi.Ever seen one break a rim? I have. The guy I replace at the tire store my Jr. year of high school died when one blew...
Forcee=pressure x area. it adds up quickly. 14 psi will crush a steel can.
So your point is?
 
But you've already made up your mind, thermite and explosives, without a shred of real evidence. You're a joke, a bad one at that.

LOL - I clicked on your 'blog' - my interest lasted less than the collapse of WTC7 - I won't do it again. But I had one laugh, some skeptic you are ...

Politically Correct and Proud of It
March 10th, 2007


"Hello, my name is Dave, I'm politically correct and proud of it...."

So Mr Politically correct and proud of it, which side of the fence would you have been on when the flat earthers were persecuting people like Galileo? And you flounce round on here claiming to be a skeptic - while bragging about your blind obedience to convention on your blog. Hilarious.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom