federal reserve conspiracy!!!

Belz, I'm having a hard time believing that you are as stupid as you act.

I'm much, much smarter than you think I act.

If a counterfeiter devalues his own currency, but creates enough of it to more than make up the difference, then he has benefited on net. This is obvious.

Yeah, sure. But once he spends that money, every penny he's got is worth less. How is that a net gain ?

Belz, a rise in the standard of living does not cause inflation.

REALLY ? What causes the higher standard of living ? Higher wages ? What's the consequence of higher wages for everyone, Ace ?

On the free market, the natural tendency is for prices to fall

Really ? Why ? When's the last time you asked for a lower salary ?
 
I'm much, much smarter than you think I act.


Yeah, sure. But once he spends that money, every penny he's got is worth less. How is that a net gain ?



REALLY ? What causes the higher standard of living ? Higher wages ? What's the consequence of higher wages for everyone, Ace ?



Really ? Why ? When's the last time you asked for a lower salary ?

Maybe you are as stupid as you act.

1. If a counterfeiter prints $1,000,000 of new money in a $1 trillion dollar economy, he has devalued each dollar by about 1 billionth of a dollar. Let's round that way, way up and say each dollar is now worth $.99. Assuming he had $100,000 to begin with, he now has $1,100,000 dollars which are worth $1,089,000. This is net gain of $989,000 in real terms.

2. Higher standards of living are defined as being able to consume more goods for a given amount of work. This is caused by increases in productivity, usually by technological advancement. Farm machinery allowed the productivity of farming to radically increase. More food was produced by less people, freeing up other people to do other work, which increased the total amount of goods produced. Thus people could consume more in total.

3. You must distinguish between increasing prices/salaries in money terms, vs. real terms. As explained, money is relative. $1,000,000 per year salary is poverty if bread costs $10,000/loaf.

4. Inflating the money supply cannot possibly cause an increase in the standard of living. If it could, all any nation would have to do is print money and become prosperous. It doesn't work that way. The key to prosperity to is to produce more goods and services.

5. Higher wages in real terms (not money terms) increase the standard of living. What determines real wages on the market is the marginal productivity of labor. Any worker who costs more in wages than he produces in profits will cause losses to the firm. This situation cannot persist. Any worker who costs less in wages than he produces in profit will be offered higher wages by a competitor, so this situation cannot persist either.
 
If they just started arbitrarily creating money, inflation would shoot up and hurt the economy including these supposed people doing it. So it wouldn't help anyone. The whole point is to keep the economy stable.

And because it is directed by so many people from different areas, there isn't enough power in any ones hands to abuse the system. This is why it's not just private or government.

With the Gold standard you can't have that stability and your unemployment is going to shoot up. The many problems Gold brings are not worth the benefit of preventing inflation from going up to high, which can be controlled much better with flat currency.

And how many countries are on the Gold standard? Since this is always presented as a conspiracy of the US government.
 
Maybe you are as stupid as you act.

That, however, is entirely possible.

1. If a counterfeiter prints $1,000,000 of new money in a $1 trillion dollar economy, he has devalued each dollar by about 1 billionth of a dollar. Let's round that way, way up and say each dollar is now worth $.99. Assuming he had $100,000 to begin with, he now has $1,100,000 dollars which are worth $1,089,000. This is net gain of $989,000 in real terms.

Well, perhaps you're right. Assuming that the devaluing is linear, which I wouldn't know.

Of course all this "net gain" is offset by the huge fine he's going to have to pay.

2. Higher standards of living are defined as being able to consume more goods for a given amount of work. This is caused by increases in productivity, usually by technological advancement.

And HIGHER WAGES.

4. Inflating the money supply cannot possibly cause an increase in the standard of living.

That's why I never said it.

The key to prosperity to is to produce more goods and services.

Not individually. The key to MY prosperity is more cash.
 
@Truthseeker1234

1. If a counterfeiter prints $1,000,000 of new money in a $1 trillion dollar economy, he has devalued each dollar by about 1 billionth of a dollar. Let's round that way, way up and say each dollar is now worth $.99. Assuming he had $100,000 to begin with, he now has $1,100,000 dollars which are worth $1,089,000. This is net gain of $989,000 in real terms.

Can you tell me the economic reasoning behind this assertion? And is this devaluation taking place relative to what, good and services or another currency?

And even if the counterfeiter had a "gain" from this operation, he still was affected by inflation in the same way as any other economic agent in that economy. So what's exactly your point?

2. Higher standards of living are defined as being able to consume more goods for a given amount of work. This is caused by increases in productivity, usually by technological advancement.

An increase in the productivity of labor leads to an increase in wages. Didn't you say you were "very knowledgeable in undergrad econ"? It sure doesn't seem so.

What determines real wages on the market is the marginal productivity of labor.

And that's one of the things that makes your particular price theory to be nothing else than a huge absurdity. I've already told you a few times but you keep pretending you did not read it so you can keep repeating the same absurdities over and over and over. Hmmm seems like that's an habit among "truth" people.

Tell me TS1234, what exactly are you arguing now? All your points "supporting" your assertion about using fiat money being the same as theft turned out to be incorrect, which is not a surprise since you are just clueless when it comes to economics ... so what exactly is your point now?
 
Last edited:
Can you tell me the economic reasoning behind this assertion [that money creation devalues money]? And is this devaluation taking place relative to what, good and services or another currency?

Both. There are more dollars chasing the same amount of goods and services, therefore each dollar is worth less, relative to the goods and services. This particular point is not controversial, and is accepted by economists of all stripes.

And even if the counterfeiter had a "gain" from this operation, he still was affected by inflation in the same way as any other economic agent in that economy. So what's exactly your point?

My point is the point of the entire thread. That money creation redistributes wealth, away from the late-receivers, and into the hands of the money creators. How many times do I have to say it?

Nobody has refuted the point.

 
If they just started arbitrarily creating money, inflation would shoot up and hurt the economy including these supposed people doing it. So it wouldn't help anyone. The whole point is to keep the economy stable.

You are clueless, Jonny! What do you mean, if they started creating money? They do! Money creation does not hurt everyone, it hurts most people, but greatly benefits those who create it, and also those who are close to them.

I have explained this repeatedly.
 
TS, I am more interested in the mathematical approach rather than in the theoretical concept you used to assume that relation. Did you arbitrarily chose the numbers? Or did you use an already established model (no matter how simple) ?

This particular point is not controversial, and is accepted by economists of all stripes.

Sure, and that would be the only thing you’ve got right so far. But as I already told you, that’s not what I asked you. Don’t you think that when you have to get to the point of editing something you are supposedly quoting, it is a strong sign that you are not right.

That money creation redistributes wealth, away from the late-receivers, and into the hands of the money creators.

Oh that, I’ve already shown an example that does away with your argument. If income is rising and people demand more credit (or more money so you can understand it), the Central Bank can expand the money supply by lowering the amount of legal reserves.

Nobody is stealing from anybody. But if you think about it, not even in the absurd examples you provided there is no theft taking place. All we saw was a rise in the price level when the “early receivers” spent the “newly created” money and prices went up, eroding everyone’s current purchasing power in the same proportion.

If you tried not make such an over-reaching statement you might have a valid point. Something like: “An unneeded expansion of the money supply will erode people’s purchasing power”. But that would be too boring right? And you would have to actually prove using the publicly available data that The Fed is, in fact, “printing money out of thin air” and “giving” it to the government … but wait, you already claimed this and ignored all requests for you to be responsible and backup what you say.

Nobody has refuted the point.

Yes, you keep pretending that you have not read the posts where your point has been refuted over, and over again. Just like you will do with this post I am writing now, in a few pages, and some more absurdities on your behalf, you’ll go again “nobody has refuted my point”.
 
Both. There are more dollars chasing the same amount of goods and services

Actually, more goods and services, according to you.

My point is the point of the entire thread. That money creation redistributes wealth

And yet people have more purchasing power now than they had 50 years ago.

Nobody has refuted the point.

Nobody has agreed with you, you mean.

You are clueless, Jonny! What do you mean, if they started creating money? They do!

I do believe he said arbitrarily.
 
WildCat: TS1234 is just clueless. What he actually meant is that if the marginal cost of a factor is less than the marginal revenue then a competitor can offer a higher salary that is still below marginal revenue and steal away that resource. This is in a purely theoretical setup: perfect competition. And yes, in this setup profit maximizing agents are producing where economic profits (sometimes economic profits differ from what an accountant would call profits) equal zero. Again, this is a purely theoretical setup.

Truthseeker1234: grab a book some day, it won't hurt you.
 
I just want to mention this little bit when it comes to the printing of money:

Printing of new bills goes on all the time since old bills are being withdrawn from circulation.

Back in 1987, the Canadian government stopped printing $1 bills and replaced them with a coin (informally called the "loonie" due to the engraved image of a loon on one of its sides). The reason for this change was to save money. The $1 bills were in wide circulation and used often in transactions and as a result their lifespan was quite short. Once a bill was sufficiently torn, faded, or what have you, it had to be withdrawn from circulation and a new bill printed to take its place. The lifespan of a $1 bill was only a couple of years; a coin on the other hand had a lifespan easily reaching twenty years. This change meant lower government operational costs in terms of printing the money needed for circulation.

Several years afterwards, the $2 bill was similarly replaced with a coin (informally called the "toonie").

I would expect the U.S. faces similar issues in regards to withdrawing old, worn out bills from circulation and replacing them with newly printed bills.
 
I just want to mention this little bit when it comes to the printing of money:

Printing of new bills goes on all the time since old bills are being withdrawn from circulation.

Back in 1987, the Canadian government stopped printing $1 bills and replaced them with a coin (informally called the "loonie" due to the engraved image of a loon on one of its sides). The reason for this change was to save money. The $1 bills were in wide circulation and used often in transactions and as a result their lifespan was quite short. Once a bill was sufficiently torn, faded, or what have you, it had to be withdrawn from circulation and a new bill printed to take its place. The lifespan of a $1 bill was only a couple of years; a coin on the other hand had a lifespan easily reaching twenty years. This change meant lower government operational costs in terms of printing the money needed for circulation.

Several years afterwards, the $2 bill was similarly replaced with a coin (informally called the "toonie").

I would expect the U.S. faces similar issues in regards to withdrawing old, worn out bills from circulation and replacing them with newly printed bills.

No, No. In this discussion, references to the "printing" of money refer to the expansion of the money supply by any means, least of which is the literal printing of new bills to replace worn out ones. That is an interesting topic perhaps, but not the subject of the thread.
 
Truthseeker1234 so you are actually going to ignore all posts refuting your assertions so you can come back and repeat them later? Is this some sort of thing you have learn and apply in order to be a "truther"? I ask you because I've seen many "truthers" doing the exact same thing.
 
Alan, nobody has refuted the assertion that money creation redistributes wealth. I have given the concise explanation for why this is so.

Why don't you have a go at a concise explanation for why it is not so. Take one paragraph. Go ahead.
 
Last edited:
Yes Truthseeker1234, i already refuted your assertion over and over again. The last time was in this post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2798371&postcount=348

A post which you ignored and then went back to repeating the same absurdity pretending that you didn't read it. Just like i predicted you would.

Wow. You nailed that one.

Yes, you keep pretending that you have not read the posts where your point has been refuted over, and over again. Just like you will do with this post I am writing now, in a few pages, and some more absurdities on your behalf, you’ll go again “nobody has refuted my point”.

Randi better watch that million dollar challenge...
 
Yes Truthseeker1234, i already refuted your assertion over and over again. The last time was in this post: http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=2798371&postcount=348

A post which you ignored and then went back to repeating the same absurdity pretending that you didn't read it. Just like i predicted you would.

What you said was this, genius:

If income is rising and people demand more credit (or more money so you can understand it), the Central Bank can expand the money supply by lowering the amount of legal reserves.

Nobody is stealing from anybody.

You have not presented any sort of argument at all. You are simply saying, "Oh no it isn't".

I, on the other hand, have presented a concise theoretical explanation of why money creation must redistribute real wealth.


In support of my position, I have presented Murray Rothbard's treatise on money, which stands uncontested.
 
What i said was this:

Oh that, I’ve already shown an example that does away with your argument. If income is rising and people demand more credit (or more money so you can understand it), the Central Bank can expand the money supply by lowering the amount of legal reserves.

Nobody is stealing from anybody. But if you think about it, not even in the absurd examples you provided there is no theft taking place. All we saw was a rise in the price level when the “early receivers” spent the “newly created” money and prices went up, eroding everyone’s current purchasing power in the same proportion.

If you tried not make such an over-reaching statement you might have a valid point. Something like: “An unneeded expansion of the money supply will erode people’s purchasing power”. But that would be too boring right? And you would have to actually prove using the publicly available data that The Fed is, in fact, “printing money out of thin air” and “giving” it to the government … but wait, you already claimed this and ignored all requests for you to be responsible and backup what you say.


I wonder why did you leave the bold part out of your quote? Lack of honesty is the first thing that comes to my mind. And by the way, in the first paragraph that you quoted ... did you understand what you read? Because you claim i only said "no it doesn't" which means you don't understand what an increase in the demand for credit is. But wait you already established you didn't know how the fractional reserve system works when you stated that banks can loan six times the amount they have in reserves, which means you probably won't know what contracting the amount of legal reserves means.

Just because you don't understand the arguments refuting the absurdities you say it does not mean you are correct. As i said before, grab a book someday ... it won't hurt you.

I, on the other hand, have presented a concise theoretical explanation of why money creation must redistribute real wealth.

A theoretical explanation completely unrelated to the concept of central banking and the Federal Reserve in particular and on top ends up with an increase in prices affecting everyone in the same proportion, which contradicts your point about redistribution of wealth.

In support of my position, I have presented Murray Rothbard's treatise on money, which stands uncontested.

Murray's paper makes a wonderful job telling us why the government should not increase its revenues by expanding the money supply. How does it apply to your current argument about The Fed? Have you demonstrated yet that the U.S. government is financing a significant part of its expenditures in this manner? No you haven't, but that hasn't stop you from repeating shamelessly the same unsubstantiated claim.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom