Iranian President Denies Existence Of Homosexuality In Iran

Why didn't Mahmoud realise this will create life-long rumours of him attempting to keep himself in the closet by incredible methods?

'Burn the gays.... with anything menthol!'
 
I still think he looks like he has a touch of Down Syndrome. I think it's something around his eyes.

You can't have a touch of Down Syndrome: you've got it or you don't. But you can have a touch of fetal alcohol syndrome, which can produce similar facial distortions.
 
I don't think that much considering the tenacity with which he repeated it. He said: "In Iran we don't have homosexuals like in your country" and "In Iran we do not have this phenomenon, I don't know who has told you that we have it."

If he would have left it at "We don't have homosexuals" I could have understood the translation argument. But to repeat it the way he did leaves little room for translation error.

I was thinking about this statement. Maybe he was thinking about the way that gays are allowed to act in the US.
For instance: we don't have homosexuals like in your country. They are different. They don't have pride parades or demonstrate for rights. They keep there sexuality to themselves.
Is there any possibility that's what he meant?
 
I was thinking about this statement. Maybe he was thinking about the way that gays are allowed to act in the US.
For instance: we don't have homosexuals like in your country. They are different. They don't have pride parades or demonstrate for rights. They keep there sexuality to themselves.
Is there any possibility that's what he meant?

No.
 
To be fair, in the US you do not get hanged for being gay..
To be fair there are many places where one can live, largely, quite peaceably and openly as a homosexual.

I should note that not being gay I'm simply not qualified to speak to the level of bigotry gays might have to endure in any community.
 
I was thinking about this statement. Maybe he was thinking about the way that gays are allowed to act in the US.
That is one way to take his remarks.
For instance: we don't have homosexuals like in your country. They are different. They don't have pride parades or demonstrate for rights. They keep there sexuality to themselves. Is there any possibility that's what he meant?
I also suspect that the new hit by the band The Butthole Surfers, soon to be released in iTunes, entitled Pining for Pure Persian Pole, will not be played on Radio Teheran any time soon.

I am not sure his "keep them in the closet or shoot them" can be considered other than a false dichotomy in New York, and indeed, most places.

UW: I almost had a 'coffee out the nose" moment. Menthol. *Snort.* :D

DR

(This was an attempt at humor, and The Butthole Surfers were/are a real band. Said song may or may not have been written, or recorded, by said band, but it seems to fit their style. )
 
Last edited:
Actually, Oliver kind of raised an interesting point by saying he doesn't want to judge Iran because it is another country with different sets of rules (unfortunately he seems to forget that motto whenever it comes to the US, but that's another story). I've been thinking, should we judge Iranian law according to our own culture?

Ahmadinejad doesn't seem to be even aware of the incredibly stupid statement he made about homosexuals not existing in his country. So should we make him accountable for his own ignorance, or is it his culture that hasn't progressed enough to accept homosexuality, and women's right and abolish the death penalty (all of which could also be considered about other countries, inculding the US, but in a much lesser degree)?

Where does cultural differences end, and where does international consensus begin?

I'm inclined to think he should be accountable for his own ignorance in this case, since he took alot of time and energy in the beginning of his speech to praise the importance of science and academia. In this case, he has no excuse to deny the reality of homosexuality as a natural phenomenon, and he should know that to say that Iran is "immune" to it is utterly absurd.
 
Last edited:
I'm wondering how much of that is a translation error.

I would say it is more of an idiom than a translation error. I used to work with a fellow who was from Iran. He had escaped in 1979 and hadn't been back since. One day, I was talking to him about my electric guitars and he said, "In Iran, there aren't any electric guitars." But then he stopped himself and said, "Well, there are, but people keep them hidden." He went on to explain how they were a sign of Western culture, therefore, they were banned in Iran. People still had them but they had to be careful.

When I heard about the speech where gays were said not to exist, I remembered this and thought it was a figure of speech. Ahmadinejad might as well have said, "We don't electric guitars in Iran", or alcohol, or Beatles CD's, etc. The way I understand it Iran has everything we do, they just keep it hidden, and in their culture, things that are hidden 'do not exist'.
 
Ahmadinejad doesn't seem to be even aware of the incredibly stupid statement he made about homosexuals not existing in his country. So should we make him accountable for his own ignorance, or is it his culture that hasn't progressed enough to accept homosexuality, and women's right and abolish the death penalty (all of which could also be considered about other countries, inculding the US, but in a much lesser degree)?

Where does cultural differences end, and where does international consensus begin?
I draw the line when it comes to what I think are universal standards of human rights, and one of those is that you shouldn't be executed because you were born the way you were.

Don't expect Ahmadinejad to look beyond what the mullahs have decided is "science". And that would be like an American asking Kent Hovind the science of evolution.
 
I've been thinking, should we judge Iranian law according to our own culture?
Well, first, Ahmadinejad claimed to be an academic and a scientist when discussing nuclear science and his examination of the Holocaust. So I do think that even by his own standards, he can be roundly criticized for claiming that homosexuals do not exist in Iran.

Second, I absolutely despise cultural relativism. What is "our own culture"? If every culture must be judged under its own terms, what can we criticize? Can Europeans criticize Israelis? Can we judge Rwandan genocide? On what basis can Germans criticize Americans? On what basis can New Yorkers judge Pennsylvanians? Can Staten Islanders judge Manhattanites? Can folks on the Upper West Side of Manhattan judge behavior in the East Village?

Sure, this is a CF Larsen worthy line-drawing fallacy, but the problem is that cultural relativity assumes that cultures are distinct entities with isolated and cohesive standards. I say, that's rubbish. As humans we an obligation to judge. To judge one another, to judge ourselves. The answer is we must try to do so fairly and honestly and with an open mind. The fact that we so often fail is an impetus to judge better not to give up and refuse to judge at all.

So should we make him accountable for his own ignorance, or is it his culture that hasn't progressed enough to accept homosexuality, and women's right and abolish the death penalty (all of which could also be considered about other countries, inculding the US, but in a much lesser degree)?
His culture is a product of the choice of the individuals in that culture. So it's essentially a circular argument. The President of Iran has the information available to correct his ignorance. Ignorance is no defence to homophobia.
 
I would say it is more of an idiom than a translation error.... People still had them but they had to be careful.
So Ahmadinejad was really saying "Any homosexuals are kept in the closet lest they be killed under bulldozers"? (Which is what they do to homosexuals in Iran.) I'm not sure how this contextualization improves Ahmadinejad's response.
 
I for one am completely impressed and utterly convinced by Oliver's post. It's BIG and RED! :rolleyes:

Actually, Oliver kind of raised an interesting point by saying he doesn't want to judge Iran because it is another country with different sets of rules (unfortunately he seems to forget that motto whenever it comes to the US, but that's another story). I've been thinking, should we judge Iranian law according to our own culture?

When it involves human rights that should be universal, yes.

Ahmadinejad doesn't seem to be even aware of the incredibly stupid statement he made about homosexuals not existing in his country. So should we make him accountable for his own ignorance, or is it his culture that hasn't progressed enough to accept homosexuality, and women's right and abolish the death penalty (all of which could also be considered about other countries, inculding the US, but in a much lesser degree)?

Oh, I'm sure in many ways his bizarre views are a product of his culture. But more people believing something doesn't make it right. I don't care if even 100% of the people in a nation think it's okay to execute someone for being gay. I'm still going to say it's morally wrong.
 
I for one am completely impressed and utterly convinced by Oliver's post. It's BIG and RED! :rolleyes:

When it involves human rights that should be universal, yes.

Oh, I'm sure in many ways his bizarre views are a product of his culture. But more people believing something doesn't make it right. I don't care if even 100% of the people in a nation think it's okay to execute someone for being gay. I'm still going to say it's morally wrong.
:)

Said it better than I could have.
 
So Ahmadinejad was really saying "Any homosexuals are kept in the closet lest they be killed under bulldozers"? (Which is what they do to homosexuals in Iran.) I'm not sure how this contextualization improves Ahmadinejad's response.
It seems to me that if they remain in a closet, the bulldozer has a relatively easy job of dozing the entire house, and thus being assured of killing whoever is in the house, of which the closet is a subset.

The law seems to be a self licking ice cream cone, if your take on it is accurate, and all homosexuals in Iran must stay in the closet AND will be bulldozed. :cool:

DR
 
It seems to me that if they remain in a closet, the bulldozer has a relatively easy job of dozing the entire house, and thus being assured of killing whoever is in the house, of which the closet is a subset.

The law seems to be a self licking ice cream cone, if your take on it is accurate, and all homosexuals in Iran must stay in the closet AND will be bulldozed. :cool:

DR


Looking into it, does anyone have a reference for the bulldozers in Iran? I have only heard of hanging of homosexuals there and this

Reason Magazine said:
There's since been a return to the seventh century, when sodomites were executed by having a wall pushed over on them. The Taliban reinstituted that practice, using bulldozers to push over the walls
It does not seem to be referenceing Iran but Afganistan.

Link
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom