Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

The physics behind CO2 and the greenhouse effect is really extremely simple.

Like all gasses CO2 is transparent to most wavelengths and 'opaque' to only a small range of wavelengths.

When it's not transparent to a wavelength of light it absorps a photon which excites one of the atoms in the molecule, later this atom will collapse back into a lower shell and the molecule will reemit a photon but in a random direction.

The reason that CO2 is a greenhouse gas is that the wavelengths to which it is not transparent are in the infrared and infrared is more common in the light being radiated back into space than it is in light being radiated towards the earth.

Now let's do a simplified calculation about what this means:

We have an amount of CO2 in the air that absorps and reflects 5% of the light of the appropiate wavelengths (of this light, which is reemitted in a random direction 50% is send out into space and 50% to earth.)
Light in: Contains 5% of relevant wavelengths for absorption.
Light out: Contains 10% of relevant wavelengths for absorption

Light in: 50% of 5% of 5% is reflected back into space (0.125%): 99.875% goes to earth.
Light out: 50% of 5% of 10% is reflected back to earth: 0.250%, so the total of heat recevied is 100.125% of the actual sunlight.

Now we raise the amount of CO2 so 10% is absorped rather than 5%.
Light in: 50% of 10% of 5% is reflected back into space (0.25%): 99.75% to earth
Light out: 50% of 10% of 10% is reflected back to earth: 0.5%, so the total of heat received goes up to 100.25%

There's your causation.

The general physical basis you describe is sound. But the question is about showing an actual relationship, in the real world, where there are other factors at play in a dynamic and somewhat chaotic atmosphere.

That is, can you pick a range of years, and for that range of years, show that temperature tracks with CO2? That would be a correlation. A causative relationship would seem to be implied if there was a lag between the initial CO2 rise and the temperature rise. Or visa versa, if temperature rises caused CO2 increases.
 
Yes but...

How accurately is the current temp figured? With all of those zillions of thermometers allover the world, About a two degree range.

How accurate are the 'proxies'? At best about a two degree range.

How much overlap is there in those two ranges? A lot- enough to where I don't believe we can even state unequivocally that we are even hotter today than before.

To sum up the AGW'ers, our average temp used to be between 68 and 70. It is now between 68 and 70. MAN IS DESTROYING THE WORLD!
 
To sum up the AGW'ers, our average temp used to be between 68 and 70. It is now between 68 and 70. MAN IS DESTROYING THE WORLD!

So, I assume that three decades of evidence of warming, including the shifts of habitats northwards, southwards and upwards, just went over your head?

You are actually contending that the world didn't warm up?

Because, if it's a silly thing to try to argue that the warming is not anthropogenic, to try to argue that there is no warming is... well, curious...
 
I would have thought that if you are going to say that they haven't presented you with evidence, that would look at the evidence first. And I am talking here about a report on the accumulated knowledge of many scientists and reseach papers. That's what scepticism is about, the evidence. If you aren't going to read it, then you can't really criticise it.

To be fair, the debate isn't about the evidence anymore. The disagreement has shifted to the interpretation of the evidence. The fact is that the modeling used to predict the future effects of warming (anthropogenic or not) is not very robust at the moment and no models have been validated.

This situation is the cause for many of us to wonder whether or not it would be a mistake to act on GW, let alone AGW. As long as the problem cannot be assessed with a fair level of certainty, GW can only be seen as an unmanageable problem. That said, I'm all in favor of steps to avoid all types of pollution but I think any steps to restrict commerce in any way based on the predictions of unvalidated models is too extreme and premature at this time.
 
So, I assume that three decades of evidence of warming, including the shifts of habitats northwards, southwards and upwards, just went over your head?

You are actually contending that the world didn't warm up?

Because, if it's a silly thing to try to argue that the warming is not anthropogenic, to try to argue that there is no warming is... well, curious...

This thread is particularly about the science behind the global warming theory.

I would like 3 specific facts please.

1) What is the current average global temperature? To what accuracy?

2) What was the average global temperature of a particular year ? (pick one, say 902 AD) To what accuracy?

3) How much has it changed?

No need to be pedantic about average vs mean, accuracy vs precision, 'P' factors... Just use simple language, consistently.

I suspect the answers will be something like:

1) "we have a 90% chance that todays temp is 68-70".

2) "We have a 90% chance that the ancient temp was between 60-72"

3) Therefor, MAN IS DESTROYING THE EARTH.

But please, somebody find me the basic data.
 
We don't need a third thread on global warming, so I won't partake in this one, except to say that I'm dead tired of strawmen from both sides. I'm tired of having to put people on my ignore list because they can't help spewing immaturity at an all too regular basis. These people could have perfectly good things to add, and I don't get to hear it because I'm tired of their juvenile ways.

You should know who you are. Please grow up.
 
This thread is particularly about the science behind the global warming theory.

I would like 3 specific facts please.

1) What is the current average global temperature? To what accuracy?

2) What was the average global temperature of a particular year ? (pick one, say 902 AD) To what accuracy?

3) How much has it changed?

But please, somebody find me the basic data.

Sheesssh. I should know that and don't. That is, I should know the alleged values, and the alleged precisions.

But all we really know is the temperature of a group of points one or two meters above the ground level, and the temperatures of a group of sea buoys and numbers from ship engine rooms, lighthouses, along with inferences from satellite data.

There is a pretty strong argument that the number you seek cannot be known, because it cannot be defined. However if it was defined arbitrarily, then it could be known. The linked article below goes into a somewhat philosophical approach to this problem and has merit, however the rebuttal to that is simply an arbitrary definition.

REF: "Does a Global Temperature Exist?" Essex, Andresen and McKitrick, 2006.

[FONT=times new roman,times]Says Andresen, [/FONT]
[FONT=times new roman,times]"It is impossible to talk about a single temperature for something as complicated as the climate of Earth. A temperature can be defined only for a homogeneous system. Furthermore, the climate is not governed by a single temperature. Rather, differences of temperatures drive the processes and create the storms, sea currents, thunder, etc. which make up the climate."[/FONT]

​
If we just defined the World Temperature as the reading of one sensor outside the UN Building, then we'd have it cinched...:)
 
To be fair, the debate isn't about the evidence anymore. The disagreement has shifted to the interpretation of the evidence. The fact is that the modeling used to predict the future effects of warming (anthropogenic or not) is not very robust at the moment and no models have been validated.

This situation is the cause for many of us to wonder whether or not it would be a mistake to act on GW, let alone AGW. As long as the problem cannot be assessed with a fair level of certainty, GW can only be seen as an unmanageable problem. That said, I'm all in favor of steps to avoid all types of pollution but I think any steps to restrict commerce in any way based on the predictions of unvalidated models is too extreme and premature at this time.

I think that if you are going to deny the validity of evidence, then you would have to know what the evidence is first.

The models are validated, against existing records.
 
The general physical basis you describe is sound. But the question is about showing an actual relationship, in the real world, where there are other factors at play in a dynamic and somewhat chaotic atmosphere.

:confused: I thought that is exactly what you were asking for? Now it appears you are asking for something else.

If I have a chaotic system in a box, and I raise it's temperature, then it's still going to be a chaotic system, but at a higher temperature.
 
I think that if you are going to deny the validity of evidence, then you would have to know what the evidence is first.

I'm not denying any evidence. I'm less than confident on the interpretation. There's quite a difference.

The models are validated, against existing records.

When you write existing records, you mean past measurements? If so, that's not how models are validated. To formulate a model, the data are accrued and math is used to compose a system that is inherently consistent with that data. However, once that is done, a predictive model must do just that: predict. If a model fails to predict a given parameter with any accuracy then it is obvious that a component did not exist in the original data and the model must be corrected to agree with observation. That can be done simply (application of a correction factor) or, in most cases, a new compartment must be installed that reflects the known physics of the system.

A model that agrees only with the existing data cannot be used to predict future events until it is so validated. Perhaps the current models are good enough to predict with an accuracy of say, +/- 50% but, given what's at stake, I can't see responsible governments paying attention to that level of accuracy.
 
If I have a chaotic system in a box, and I raise it's temperature, then it's still going to be a chaotic system, but at a higher temperature.

The question being posed is: how do you measure the temperature of that chaotic system. If you have a planet in a box, it's easy. If it's in space, not so much. There are ways but they're fairly modern and then the question would be how to dovetail the new data to the old.
 
The question being posed is: how do you measure the temperature of that chaotic system. If you have a planet in a box, it's easy. If it's in space, not so much. There are ways but they're fairly modern and then the question would be how to dovetail the new data to the old.

They have, from what I can tell, taken a systematic average of readings from around the planet. If that systematic system stays constant, then a temperature rise from a good enough sample will give an indication of the planet as a whole. As time has gone by, technologies have improved for taking those readings. The BOM in Australia has it's own 'average' temperature for Australia that concurs with the NASA records.
 
They have, from what I can tell, taken a systematic average of readings from around the planet. If that systematic system stays constant, then a temperature rise from a good enough sample will give an indication of the planet as a whole. As time has gone by, technologies have improved for taking those readings. The BOM in Australia has it's own 'average' temperature for Australia that concurs with the NASA records.

OK. If that's what will be done consistently from now on, the models will have to predict those datapoints accurately enough to give decisoinmakers confidence in their veracity. Now, we just have to wait for validation. Depending on the fluctuations of the chaotic system, that may take a very long time.
 
I'm not denying any evidence. I'm less than confident on the interpretation. There's quite a difference.



When you write existing records, you mean past measurements? If so, that's not how models are validated. To formulate a model, the data are accrued and math is used to compose a system that is inherently consistent with that data. However, once that is done, a predictive model must do just that: predict. If a model fails to predict a given parameter with any accuracy then it is obvious that a component did not exist in the original data and the model must be corrected to agree with observation. That can be done simply (application of a correction factor) or, in most cases, a new compartment must be installed that reflects the known physics of the system.

A model that agrees only with the existing data cannot be used to predict future events until it is so validated. Perhaps the current models are good enough to predict with an accuracy of say, +/- 50% but, given what's at stake, I can't see responsible governments paying attention to that level of accuracy.

The models have been validated against predictions, as well.

http://www.columbia.edu/~jeh1/hansen_re-crichton.pdf for example. A very public prediction based on models, and substantially correct.
 
The models have been validated against predictions, as well.

http://www.columbia.edu/~jeh1/hansen_re-crichton.pdf for example. A very public prediction based on models, and substantially correct.

That publication is not research-grade. It seems to be part of a squabble. Didn't read it but noted that two of the scenarios deviated signficantly from observations while one seemed to track pretty well.


Nice publication. As you can see in the Executive Summary, long-term forecasting is still a work in progress. Didn't look at much else as this is a long, long chapter in the IPCC report.
 
That publication is not research-grade. It seems to be part of a squabble. Didn't read it but noted that two of the scenarios deviated signficantly from observations while one seemed to track pretty well.

The three scenarios were worst case, most likely and best case. The most likely case, which is what happened, was pretty accurate, as you noted.

Nice publication. As you can see in the Executive Summary, long-term forecasting is still a work in progress. Didn't look at much else as this is a long, long chapter in the IPCC report.

It's a work in progress, but the progress has been quite impressive, given the task they are undertaking. Given the gravity of what they are saying, I would hope that more people would take the time to read it if they have any doubts about the validty of their claims, since this document is based on the scientific research of many scientists.
 
It's a work in progress, but the progress has been quite impressive, given the task they are undertaking.

No question. This is an impressive achievement. Most models are way simpler than these and that's why these are so hard to tame.

Given the gravity of what they are saying, I would hope that more people would take the time to read it if they have any doubts about the validty of their claims, since this document is based on the scientific research of many scientists.

I agree but the problem still comes down to how precise the prognoses are. That can be solved with a little further work. The politicization of the issue has not helped the credibility of these reports, though. While most of the scientists are saying one thing ("probably x with a confidency of y"), the special interest folks are saying "definitely x + 3y, so send me money".

The problem today is the lack of more persuasive tools, having a clearer picture of problems and options, and the ability to weigh one choice against the other. Or, we could all panic but that's only fun for half an hour. :D
 
No question. This is an impressive achievement. Most models are way simpler than these and that's why these are so hard to tame.



I agree but the problem still comes down to how precise the prognoses are. That can be solved with a little further work. The politicization of the issue has not helped the credibility of these reports, though. While most of the scientists are saying one thing ("probably x with a confidency of y"), the special interest folks are saying "definitely x + 3y, so send me money".

The problem today is the lack of more persuasive tools, having a clearer picture of problems and options, and the ability to weigh one choice against the other. Or, we could all panic but that's only fun for half an hour. :D

They have already achieved a lot already, and explain in as much detail as you want what they have done, and why they think it is valid. You could try reading it. As a matter of risk management, it's better than a 50/50 bet, which, considering the gravity of the consequences, would make me think it warrants some attention.
 
They have already achieved a lot already, and explain in as much detail as you want what they have done, and why they think it is valid. You could try reading it. As a matter of risk management, it's better than a 50/50 bet, which, considering the gravity of the consequences, would make me think it warrants some attention.

No, it does not merit attention. As illustrated in post #19 above, both new scientific findings, and findings that were ignored in the production of that tome, invalidate conclusions reached that were specious even when they were asserted.

No reason to bother "reading the IPCC report". And suggesting that one do so (without any specific chapter or page citation) appears to be your most convenient answer to any logical, technical or factual issue encountered.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom