Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

What alot of people dont realize is, that carbon dioxide levels do play a large role in climate change and that in the most literal sense, the photosythetic process that some carbon breathing plants and other organisms use is in the most literal sense, saving us from ourselves. The last time a global change in climate, be it cool or hot...effected the world naturally on a large scale, it took 60,000 years for the earth to regain its homeostasis. Nearly wiped out every living thing as well. Truthfully we are at the back end of a recent "global cooling" trend which was at its peak 10,000 years ago. But the levels of carbon (315 million molecules per square inch) are significantly up from the average of 250 million molecules. So its not un-reasonably hard to predict where it might be in a few thousand years. SO to all the climate skeptics, it is obvious that at the present, nobody in this generation or even the next will feel any effects of rising carbon levels aka global warming. But it is not wise to follow the path of the mediocrity of human assumption. Too many times has skeptisism been confused with ignorance in the science community, for gods sake the last remaining evidence of the "dodo" bird was thrown in a bon fire by a university dean of admissions?! We have caused roughly hundreds of species to become exticnt without even a second thought. We barley stopped using led in our gasoline in 1986! Its time for the self proclaimed skeptics to admit that they are ignorant of scientific vigorous research. You dont just proclaim yourself a skeptic, you become one by using research and logical methods to come to that conclusion. In other words, it is absurd to proclaim that anthropogenic global warming does not exist because "its not warm at all". It is absurd to believe that the intelliegence of humans can save us all from the universe when someday, all we will have left is the earths troposphere to seperate of from deadly cosmic rays and radiation.
 
Last edited:

Well, I dug and I dug until I got to your source. (Thanks for letting me do all the heavy lifting, BTW. Very bad form. :mad:) Anyway, that's an interesting graph. If carbon dioxide has reached an all time high, why are there four maxima in that graph? Some are even higher than 0 kyr BP (now).

I mean that is what the AGW is based on, right? That carbon dioxide is reaching unprecedented concentrations?
 
This reminds me so much of the creationist debate on carbon dating.

I went to http://www.warwickhughes.com/icecore/zjmar07.pdf and read the section entitled "The Truth About Ice Cores". On p. 4, there is a list of four assumptions concerning gases in ice that I find very difficult to agree with. Can you rebut them? (I tried cutting and pasting but the free version of Acrobat doesn't seem to want to let me.)

I haven't gone to a univeristy library to read the original publications but the assumptions I found in the above paper are untenable. Is there a different carbon dioxice reservoir avialable for cross-checking the ice core data? Stalagtites/stalagmites? Mineral formations? Any such thing?
 
I went to http://www.warwickhughes.com/icecore/zjmar07.pdf and read the section entitled "The Truth About Ice Cores". On p. 4, there is a list of four assumptions concerning gases in ice that I find very difficult to agree with. Can you rebut them? (I tried cutting and pasting but the free version of Acrobat doesn't seem to want to let me.)

I haven't gone to a univeristy library to read the original publications but the assumptions I found in the above paper are untenable. Is there a different carbon dioxice reservoir avialable for cross-checking the ice core data? Stalagtites/stalagmites? Mineral formations? Any such thing?

You're problem is that you are asking an amateur to contradict what a nutter is saying. The scientists who are taking the ice cores are just as competent as the ones doing carbon dating, IMHO. Warwick is a self proclaimed "free lance scientist", whatever that means.
 
Well, I dug and I dug until I got to your source. (Thanks for letting me do all the heavy lifting, BTW. Very bad form. :mad:) Anyway, that's an interesting graph. If carbon dioxide has reached an all time high, why are there four maxima in that graph? Some are even higher than 0 kyr BP (now).

I mean that is what the AGW is based on, right? That carbon dioxide is reaching unprecedented concentrations?

Not at all. It has been higher in the past, and it's been hotter in the past. The issue is not so much that climate is changing, (that's always going to happen), as it's changing now, and in geological terms, it's changing rapidly. That means for eco systems, there is not much chance to change and adapt to what will be a very different world. That means species extinction, and we are dependent to a large degree on the ecosystems. Apart from that, Polar Bears and other mega fauna are nice to have around.
 
You're problem is that you are asking an amateur to contradict what a nutter is saying. The scientists who are taking the ice cores are just as competent as the ones doing carbon dating, IMHO. Warwick is a self proclaimed "free lance scientist", whatever that means.

So, he pulled these assumptions out of thin air? (no pun intended) He has citations so I'll have to go to the U library to check them out. I'll let you know what I find.

Thanks for the reply. :)
 
Not at all. It has been higher in the past, and it's been hotter in the past. The issue is not so much that climate is changing, (that's always going to happen), as it's changing now, and in geological terms, it's changing rapidly. That means for eco systems, there is not much chance to change and adapt to what will be a very different world. That means species extinction, and we are dependent to a large degree on the ecosystems. Apart from that, Polar Bears and other mega fauna are nice to have around.

But there are upslopes at 120, 220 and 320 kyr BP that are as sharp as the one leading up to 0 kyr BP. What mechanisms were around back then that aren't around now (other than forests :D)? That's the troubling part for me, in the last 120,000 years, we apes have done a number on the forests.

I'm not much of a believer that mankind can despoil the planet before the planet can despoil man. I'm kinda caught between two major beliefs of mine. One is the scientific rigor that tells me to be vary wary of new hypotheses. The second is my resolute belief that humans just don't have the kind of self-denial and discipline needed to overcome AGW (if it is indeed true) in time enough to save themselves.
 
But there are upslopes at 120, 220 and 320 kyr BP that are as sharp as the one leading up to 0 kyr BP. What mechanisms were around back then that aren't around now (other than forests :D)? That's the troubling part for me, in the last 120,000 years, we apes have done a number on the forests.

I'm not much of a believer that mankind can despoil the planet before the planet can despoil man. I'm kinda caught between two major beliefs of mine. One is the scientific rigor that tells me to be vary wary of new hypotheses. The second is my resolute belief that humans just don't have the kind of self-denial and discipline needed to overcome AGW (if it is indeed true) in time enough to save themselves.

We got Y2K sorted out, didn't we?

Think of the time scales. 100 years compared to 100,000 years.
 
Think of the time scales. 100 years compared to 100,000 years.

You're saying that the abscissa on that graph is logarithmic? It could be but the graph posted by oponol isn't detailed enough to say one way or the other. I did find the data posted at the source. I'll feed it into Excel and play around with it a little.

Thanks.
 
You're saying that the abscissa on that graph is logarithmic? It could be but the graph posted by oponol isn't detailed enough to say one way or the other. I did find the data posted at the source. I'll feed it into Excel and play around with it a little.

Thanks.

No, I'm talking about the rate of change. You are looking at changes taking place on a much longer time scale than we are talking about taking place now.
 
I went to http://www.warwickhughes.com/icecore/zjmar07.pdf and read the section entitled "The Truth About Ice Cores". On p. 4, there is a list of four assumptions concerning gases in ice that I find very difficult to agree with. Can you rebut them? (I tried cutting and pasting but the free version of Acrobat doesn't seem to want to let me.)

I haven't gone to a univeristy library to read the original publications but the assumptions I found in the above paper are untenable. Is there a different carbon dioxice reservoir avialable for cross-checking the ice core data? Stalagtites/stalagmites? Mineral formations? Any such thing?

This is just one of a number of "divergence problems". Historical proxy data from tree rings for example do not line up with 20th century temperature series. More data splicing is required or the series are truncated....

Here is the list for four assumptions that you referenced in Z. Jawowowrski's 2007 paper.



Double click to enlarge.

Analysis of ice cores has came a long way. I believe When Gore's movie was made ice core data analyzed at 1000 year intervals, seemed to indicate that today we have "unprecedented warming". Later, the techniques improved and the ice cores showed the various historical warm periods such as the Medievel Warming Period. Gore's "documentary" was not updated and corrected for this or any other more recent findings.

The analysis of CO2 in the shallow ice cores was very early work.

Slimething asks an interesting question -

Is there a different carbon dioxice reservoir avialable for cross-checking the ice core data? Stalagtites/stalagmites? Mineral formations? Any such thing?

And that leads us back to Beck's review article, 180 Years of Gas CO2 Analysis by Chemical Means.
 
Beck makes a lot of 3% accuracy of chemical methods, but that's a red herring.

...Beck is claiming chemical measuring methods accurate to 3%, but leaves out what they were measuring. co2 variates a lot at the surface, the surface is afterall the point where hundreds of billions of tons of co2 are being emitted and absorbed each year. Measurements taken in and around cities are subject to large variations in surface co2 that can be carried by the wind. co2 concentration can differ by location by as much as 100ppm. The measurements from decades ago which were performed in such locations cannot be claimed to be as accurate as if they were taken in lab conditions for this reason.

Beck's paper is all about the history of co2 measurements so it's odd that he misses out key developments in that history and doesn't mention about this long running difficulty in obtaining atmospheric co2 concentration.

He doesn't answer the obvious question: Why would Keeling expend so much effort to set up the first long term co2 monitoring station in remote Hawaii if he could have just monitored it accurately from somewhere more local? Keeling sought such a remote location precisely to avoid the contamination issues that plagued co2 measurements elsewhere.

Your comments show you have not read the paper and have no knowledge of it's content or purpose. Look at the below illustration from the paper. Do you still want to assert as you did in your prior post? If so, on what basis?




Here are more excerpts from the paper to show that either you have not read the paper or comprehended it, or the Gristmill or Realclimate "talking points" page from which you have gotten your comments, is pure propaganda.
"intent of these authors was to identify CO2 determinations that were made using pure unpolluted air..."
"sampling was sporatic over a four year period at a site poorly chosen to study CO2"

"nearly all of the air sample measurements were originally obtained from rural areas or the peripher of towns under comparable conditions....distant from potential industrial or military contamination"

"volumetric apparatus used before Haldane (70) .... were open systems which lacked efficient control of reach temperature....their data were less reliable."
​
Beck comments in summary, "Discounting such unsatisfactory data, in every decade since 1857 we can still identify several measurement series that contain hundreds of precise, continuous data".

A lot of technical talk but that's the point - to confuse.

Beck's paper was published in "Energy and Environment". Remember the name of that journal, it comes up a lot. Whenever you hear of an AGW skeptic paper you can put money on it being published, or soon to be published in Energy and Environment. You will win the bet more often than not.
Whether your confusion is intentional or not, you may want to become acquainted with the actual facts and the actual content of Beck's paper.

I am certain that after doing so, if you still wish to produce a pro AGW argument somehow based on the 180 peer reviewed articles that Beck has reviewed, the compilation of data and resources on his website, that the argument so produced will be much superior to the ones above refuted.
 
But there are upslopes at 120, 220 and 320 kyr BP that are as sharp as the one leading up to 0 kyr BP. What mechanisms were around back then that aren't around now (other than forests :D)? That's the troubling part for me, in the last 120,000 years, we apes have done a number on the forests.

I'm not much of a believer that mankind can despoil the planet before the planet can despoil man. I'm kinda caught between two major beliefs of mine. One is the scientific rigor that tells me to be vary wary of new hypotheses. The second is my resolute belief that humans just don't have the kind of self-denial and discipline needed to overcome AGW (if it is indeed true) in time enough to save themselves.

This article looks interesting (bold is mine), although I do not have more than the abstract. It seems to show pretty rapid natural CO2 variations and notes in pass the "smoothing" of ice core CO2 data. Perhaps Pirirr or someone with more access to technical publications can pull it.

Last interglacial atmospheric CO2 changes from stomatal index data and their relation to climate variations by Mats Rundgren, Svante Björck and Dan Hammarlund 2005
A 300-year period of rapid CO2 oscillations immediately before the establishment of stable conditions is synchronous with a dry and cool event previously inferred from proxy data from the same sediment sequence, suggesting that this was a climatic event of regional or global significance.

The presented CO2 reconstruction is in general agreement with previous ice core and stomatal-based CO2 data, although a larger variability compared with Vostok ice core data is evident. This may be explained partly by the different resolution of the two records and the inherent smoothing of ice core gas records.
​
 
This article looks interesting (bold is mine), although I do not have more than the abstract. It seems to show pretty rapid natural CO2 variations and notes in pass the "smoothing" of ice core CO2 data. Perhaps Pirirr or someone with more access to technical publications can pull it.


Sure, here it is, if anyone wants a look.
 
Originally Posted by a_unique_person
:wink8:

He's just had to admit, NASA and the GISS got it right, not that anyone would notice, due to the fact that having got the source code and the classifications, the result of their calculations was just a verification of what was already known. Having fallen flat on his face there, he's off on a cherry picking tour ......
Rubbish. Your source gleefully pounced on John V's calculations that implied this posted at climateaudit.org.

John is now learning how to fix his errors from the master, Steve McIntyre. Not ever eating crow, just getting it right.
 
You know, SomeGuy never got back to this. I can't blame hir, it seems pretty clueless to me to maintain that a gas that does something in the laboratory does something different in the atmosphere, but I guess, as was stated on page 1 of this thread, it's difficult to find a GW denier who has a sound basis in science. Since SomeGuy abandoned this, I'll take it up.

The general physical basis you describe is sound. But the question is about showing an actual relationship, in the real world, where there are other factors at play in a dynamic and somewhat chaotic atmosphere.
What "other effects" will change how CO2 interacts with photons?

Not only that, but you've shifted the goalposts. You asked,
3. Can a AGW believer show correlation or causation, or any relationship, between global temperature and global atmospheric CO2 levels?
The relationship between heat absorbed from sunlight being re-radiated by the Earth, and the physics of how CO2 molecules absorb heat, and the global temperature, has been known for over a hundred and seventy years, and was first quantitatively investigated over a hundred and ten years ago. There's correlation, causation, and a relationship. Unless, of course, you propose woo physics.

That is, can you pick a range of years, and for that range of years, show that temperature tracks with CO2?
How close a tracking are you looking for? Obviously, in the "dynamic and somewhat chaotic atmosphere" (your characterization, immediately above), the tracking will not be perfect. Other factors than CO2 might intrude. But if you want a clear instance of correlation and causation, try 1870-2007. The causes of places where it did not track are all well documented. Note that you shifted the goalposts and I still have an answer.
 
What "other effects" will change how CO2 interacts with photons?

Obviously, in the "dynamic and somewhat chaotic atmosphere" (your characterization, immediately above), the tracking will not be perfect. Other factors than CO2 might intrude. But if you want a clear instance of correlation and causation, try 1870-2007. The causes of places where it did not track are all well documented.

Why did you ask a question that you answered yourself later? Since you know the answers already, why don't you elaborate on what factors moderate the thermal characteristics of carbon dioxide? Go ahead, we're all waiting intently for you to explain that nature is not a test tube or a Petri dish.

Note that you shifted the goalposts and I still have an answer.

Asking a subset question is not "shifting the goalpost". As usual, your answers are self-contradictory and less than honest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom