Science of Global Warming And Possible Man Made Causation

Yes but warming or cooling this instant is meaningless without comparing to ancient ranges. One thing is constant in climate, that is variability. Yes, Capeldoger, I know you think that is taking refuse in the past. But without past records to compare to, we just don't know whether this warm period is abnormal or not.

But, like the above discussion of inherent averaging within ice cores, we have a problem with tree rings. They just don't have the acuity to tell us if 1-2 degrees per century is a normal historical range. In a system that varies by 80 degrees some days, some places.

That's right, species come and go with amazing regularity.

Hang on, we're a species, aren't we?
 
As it happens, there is, we are living in it. Ecosystems are so finely balanced in terms of temperature in Kelvin, that even a 1% change in their climate can cause huge changes, destabilising and then destroying them. In their bid to optimise the advantages they can gain, they become highly specialised and susceptible to what are, relatively speaking, the slightest changes. The bacteria will be fine, so will the rocks.

Already the slightest change is causing an acceleration in the melting of glaciers, and changes in albedo.

My comments were specifically toward the provability of AGW. I agree with you totally in your worry about the environment, to a point. I've gone on record with my belief that humans will not destroy then environment. I believe that the environment will destroy humans long before we get anywhere near.

Additionally, as I stated earlier, I don't believe that global warming can be proven because we just don't have the necessary data. That does not mean it's not happening. However, if it is happening and if the consequences will be as dire as predicted by some, it's all the more reason to do the job right. Wouldn't you agree?
 
My comments were specifically toward the provability of AGW. I agree with you totally in your worry about the environment, to a point. I've gone on record with my belief that humans will not destroy then environment. I believe that the environment will destroy humans long before we get anywhere near.

Additionally, as I stated earlier, I don't believe that global warming can be proven because we just don't have the necessary data. That does not mean it's not happening. However, if it is happening and if the consequences will be as dire as predicted by some, it's all the more reason to do the job right. Wouldn't you agree?

If you want definitive proof, 100%, that won't arrive for another 50 years or so. Even then, there will be people who deny it.
 
Yes but warming or cooling this instant is meaningless without comparing to ancient ranges. One thing is constant in climate, that is variability. Yes, Capeldoger, I know you think that is taking refuse in the past. But without past records to compare to, we just don't know whether this warm period is abnormal or not.
Let's put it this way: Ice that hasn't melted since the end of the last glaciation is melting now. A LOT of it. Most of the ice in the Arctic melted this summer and fall, which hasn't happened in at least a hundred and ten thousand years. Is that abnormal enough for you?

But, like the above discussion of inherent averaging within ice cores, we have a problem with tree rings. They just don't have the acuity to tell us if 1-2 degrees per century is a normal historical range. In a system that varies by 80 degrees some days, some places.
We're not talking about tree rings any more. Read any newspapers lately?
 
If you want definitive proof, 100%, that won't arrive for another 50 years or so. Even then, there will be people who deny it.

No need for definitive proof, AUP, just some authoritative proof would do. And, science isn't a popularity contest. We need a metric to assess our progress in dealing with any problem, if for nothing else.

There will always be people who deny established fact. That's what JREF is all about. You can't blame people for doubting something as fact when you have nothing but secondary evidence, though.
 
No need for definitive proof, AUP, just some authoritative proof would do. And, science isn't a popularity contest. We need a metric to assess our progress in dealing with any problem, if for nothing else.

There will always be people who deny established fact. That's what JREF is all about. You can't blame people for doubting something as fact when you have nothing but secondary evidence, though.

There is authoritative proof.

The IPCC report goes into great detail about the scientific studies that have been done.

As Schneibster says, the melting of ice and permafrost that hasn't melted for 100,000 year is pretty good too.
 
There is authoritative proof.

The IPCC report goes into great detail about the scientific studies that have been done.

There is no authoritative proof. There is authoritative evidence...on both sides of the issue. When the secondary data are ambiguous, we have to seek a more direct measure. Either that, or independent confirmatory data. (That's why I asked if there was a separate carbon dioxide reservoir that confirmed ice core measurments.)

As Schneibster says, the melting of ice and permafrost that hasn't melted for 100,000 year is pretty good too.

Schenibster has posted a lot of things and they are all speculation. (You didn't notice his hasty retreat from his original claim that carbon dioxide must radiate heat once excited?) Melting of ice indicates, in the strictest sense, a localized warming. There is no real reason to take it beyond that. If you want to globalize the observation, you need a global metric. Even if the statement applied everywhere, it would not be proof that warming was anthropogenic.
 
Schenibster has posted a lot of things and they are all speculation. (You didn't notice his hasty retreat from his original claim that carbon dioxide must radiate heat once excited?)
This is ridiculous. If the heat isn't radiated, it heats up the atmosphere- what, do you think it just GOES AWAY? The First Law of Thermodynamics is conservation of energy.

Either way, whether it heats the ground, or heats the air, it's greenhouse warming. That's because it didn't escape to space. And if half the re-radiated heat goes back to the ground, and not all of the heat is re-radiated, then MORE THAN HALF of the heat stays to create greenhouse warming.

And you claim to know thermodynamics? You don't know
Edited by tim: 
Rule 10 - please don't try and get around it by using asterisks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
At room temperature? You're kidding, right? At STP, no more than one in a thousand vibrationally excited CO2 molecules is going to get quenched before it re-radiates. But here's the real kicker: quenching excites the quenching molecule. In other words, either the heat gets re-radiated, back toward Earth's surface in half the cases, or the heat stays in the atmosphere, right there where the quenching interaction occurred.

Conservation of energy, remember?
Just in case there was any question.
 
There is no authoritative proof. There is authoritative evidence...on both sides of the issue. When the secondary data are ambiguous, we have to seek a more direct measure. Either that, or independent confirmatory data. (That's why I asked if there was a separate carbon dioxide reservoir that confirmed ice core measurments.)



Schenibster has posted a lot of things and they are all speculation. (You didn't notice his hasty retreat from his original claim that carbon dioxide must radiate heat once excited?) Melting of ice indicates, in the strictest sense, a localized warming. There is no real reason to take it beyond that. If you want to globalize the observation, you need a global metric. Even if the statement applied everywhere, it would not be proof that warming was anthropogenic.

S is right. The heat will be radiated as quanta, at random intervals, IIRC. It won't sit there forever.

Having a tantrum and demanding a global metric won't get you anwhere. We play the hand we are dealt with, and the science, to me, appears as sound as you are going to get. That there is evidence of change in numerous indicators, from flowering times, bird migration, ice retreat, ocean warming, measured temperatures, permafrost melting, the Arctic. Sooner or later you have to say, OK, that's close enough.
 
No need for definitive proof, AUP, just some authoritative proof would do. And, science isn't a popularity contest. We need a metric to assess our progress in dealing with any problem, if for nothing else.

There will always be people who deny established fact. That's what JREF is all about. You can't blame people for doubting something as fact when you have nothing but secondary evidence, though.

Authoritative and definitive proof abounds.

Jones et al 1990 is a hallmark study of global temperatures and the Urban Heat Island effect. It was relied on by the IPCC for the basis of their global temperature and radiative forcing calculations.

Jones et al 1990 is incorporated in most climate models.

Jones has been formally accused of scientific fraud. This was discussed on JREF here. The usual suspects lined up to defend Jones - Schneib, CapelDodger, AUP. Unfortunately in this case, they backed a lame horse.

Authoritative proof seems to point in the direction of disproving the AGW hypothesis.

For more authoritataive proof, let's take a brief look at tree ring data from Osborn and Briffa, also prominent in the IPCC report (although in compiling the Briffa data, the IPCC truncated the years past 1960). Osborn and Briffa looked at tree ring data and "found global warming".
In 2006, an article appeared in Science magazine reconstructing the temperature of the Northern Hemisphere back to 800 AD based on 14 smoothed and normalized temperature proxies (e.g., tree ring records). Osborn and Briffa proclaimed at the time that “the 20th century is the most anomalous interval in the entire analysis period, with highly significant occurrences of positive anomalies and positive extremes in the proxy records.”
​
Burger looks at their work and corrected statistical errors that slipped through peer review.
Gerd Bürger of Berlin’s Institut für Meteorologie decided to revisit the work of Osborn and Briffa, and his results raise serious questions about the claim that the 20th century has been unusually warm. Bürger argues that Osborn and Briffa did not apply the appropriate statistical tests that link the proxy records to observational data, and as such, Osborn and Briffa did not properly quantify the statistical uncertainties in their analyses.

Bürger repeated all analyses with the appropriate adjustments and concluded “As a result, the ‘highly significant’ occurrences of positive anomalies during the 20th century disappear.” Further, he reports that “The 95th percentile is exceeded mostly in the early 20th century, but also about the year 1000.”

​
How much authoritative proof exactly is required? In these short paragraphs I have pointed out -The overwhelming preponderance of evidence that Warmers must deny in order to keep their believe set unchallenged is a matter of fact, not assertion or opinion.

Bürger, G., 2007. Comment on “The Spatial Extent of 20th-Century Warmth in the Context of the Past 1200 Years”. Science, 316, 1844a.

Osborn, T.J., and Briffa, K.R., 2006. The spatial extent of 20th-century warmth in the context of the past 1200 years. Science, 311, 841-844.
 
Let's put it this way: Ice that hasn't melted since the end of the last glaciation is melting now. A LOT of it. Most of the ice in the Arctic melted this summer and fall, which hasn't happened in at least a hundred and ten thousand years. Is that abnormal enough for you?

We're not talking about tree rings any more. Read any newspapers lately?
Of course you're not talking about tree rings because the hockey stick is a fraud.

110,000 years? Is that right? Of course you have references to back that up, correct?

I don't read newspapers to get scientific data, but since you don't wish to read what I say, you'll never be able to respond to the following:

http://www.geo.umass.edu/climate/papers/brineretal2006.pdf
Reconstructions of past environmental changes are critical for understanding the natural variability of Earth’s climate system and for providing a context for present and future global change. Radiocarbon-dated lake sediments from Lake CF3, northeastern Baffin Island,
Arctic Canada, are used to reconstruct past environmental conditions over the last 11,200 years. Numerous proxies, including chironomidinferred July air temperatures, diatom-inferred lakewater pH, and sediment organic matter, reveal a pronounced Holocene thermal maximum as much as 5-C warmer than historic summer temperatures from ¨10,000 to 8500 cal yr B.P. Following rapid cooling ¨8500 cal yr B.P., Lake CF3 proxies indicate cooling through the late Holocene. At many sites in northeastern Canada, the Holocene thermal maximum occurred later than at Lake CF3; this late onset of Holocene warmth is generally attributed to the impacts of the decaying Laurentide Ice
Sheet on early Holocene temperatures in northeastern Canada. However, the lacustrine proxies in Lake CF3 apparently responded to insolation-driven warmth, despite the proximity of Lake CF3 to the Laurentide Ice Sheet and its meltwater. The magnitude and timing of the Holocene thermal maximum at Lake CF3 indicate that temperatures and environmental conditions at this site are highly sensitive to changes in radiative forcing.


http://esp.cr.usgs.gov/research/alaska/PDF/KaufmanAger2004QSR.pdf
At the 16 terrestrial sites where quantitative
estimates have been obtained, local HTM temperatures (primarily summer estimates) were on average 1.67 +/-0.8C higher than
present (approximate average of the 20th century),


http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/geog/downloads/634/269.pdf
During the period of maximum forest extension, the mean July temperatures along the northern coastline of Russia may have been 2.5° to
7.0°C warmer than modern.


http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/lookingatearth/quikscat-20071001.html
http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/2007/2007GL031138.shtml
I have the full article. Not one reference is made to "global warming", "anthropogenic" or anything else relating to AGW, CO2 levels etc. Keep circling the wagons Schneibster.
Nghiem said the rapid decline in winter perennial ice the past two years was caused by unusual winds. "Unusual atmospheric conditions set up wind patterns that compressed the sea ice, loaded it into the Transpolar Drift Stream and then sped its flow out of the Arctic," he said. When that sea ice reached lower latitudes, it rapidly melted in the warmer waters.

"The winds causing this trend in ice reduction were set up by an unusual pattern of atmospheric pressure that began at the beginning of this century," Nghiem said.

The new study differs significantly from other recent studies that only looked at the Arctic's total sea ice extent.
 
Last edited:
S is right. The heat will be radiated as quanta, at random intervals, IIRC. It won't sit there forever.

When he first entered this discussion, schriebest ridiculed me for not agreeing with him that a molecule of carbon dioxide, having absorbed a photon in the infrared, would necessarily relax by radiating a photon in the infrared. That is provably wrong and he knows it. I hope you do too. That's why he wouldn't commit himself to repeating that idiocy when I asked him to directly. I lost my cool but that happens when I deal with things of that ilk.

I you believe that excited CO2 must radiate heat to reach a stable ground state, you know nothing of chemistry, or even physics. The electrons in carbon dioxide have an infinite number of permissible energy states to occupy once excited. They can hop back down in one or many steps. It is not my fault that molecules are so complex. I only know that they are. If you want to believe someone who pulls quantum mechanics out of thin air anytime they can't deal with reality, that's on you not me.

Having a tantrum and demanding a global metric won't get you anwhere.

Who's having a tantrum? What I am saying is that, absent a verifiable basis, I don't believe we as a society should act rashly on a hypothesis which is currently unmamagable. Whether or not it even has a basis in fact is also open to question but that has nothing to do with the fact that we don't have the tools to manage the problem right now even if it were true. Let me put it this way, AUP, if you had to start a program to ameliorate global warming today, say by reducing carbon dioxide, how would you quantify your progress?

We play the hand we are dealt with, and the science, to me, appears as sound as you are going to get. That there is evidence of change in numerous indicators, from flowering times, bird migration, ice retreat, ocean warming, measured temperatures, permafrost melting, the Arctic. Sooner or later you have to say, OK, that's close enough.

Well, no. That's not why I became a scientist. We could have much better science than what is being presented right now. Your stance befuddles me. Why are you demanding action instead of better science?
 
Originally Posted by Schneibster
Let's put it this way: Ice that hasn't melted since the end of the last glaciation is melting now. A LOT of it. Most of the ice in the Arctic melted this summer and fall, which hasn't happened in at least a hundred and ten thousand years. Is that abnormal enough for you?

We're not talking about tree rings any more. Read any newspapers lately?

Of course you're not talking about tree rings because the hockey stick is a fraud.

110,000 years? Is that right? Of course you have references to back that up, correct?

I don't read newspapers to get scientific data, but since you don't wish to read what I say, you'll never be able to respond to the following:

http://www.geo.umass.edu/climate/pap...eretal2006.pdf
Quote:
Reconstructions of past environmental changes are critical for understanding the natural variability of Earth’s climate system and for providing a context for present and future global change. Radiocarbon-dated lake sediments from Lake CF3, northeastern Baffin Island,
Arctic Canada, are used to reconstruct past environmental conditions over the last 11,200 years. Numerous proxies, including chironomidinferred July air temperatures, diatom-inferred lakewater pH, and sediment organic matter, reveal a pronounced Holocene thermal maximum as much as 5-C warmer than historic summer temperatures from ¨10,000 to 8500 cal yr B.P. Following rapid cooling ¨8500 cal yr B.P., Lake CF3 proxies indicate cooling through the late Holocene. At many sites in northeastern Canada, the Holocene thermal maximum occurred later than at Lake CF3; this late onset of Holocene warmth is generally attributed to the impacts of the decaying Laurentide Ice
Sheet on early Holocene temperatures in northeastern Canada. However, the lacustrine proxies in Lake CF3 apparently responded to insolation-driven warmth, despite the proximity of Lake CF3 to the Laurentide Ice Sheet and its meltwater. The magnitude and timing of the Holocene thermal maximum at Lake CF3 indicate that temperatures and environmental conditions at this site are highly sensitive to changes in radiative forcing.


http://esp.cr.usgs.gov/research/alas...ger2004QSR.pdf
Quote:
At the 16 terrestrial sites where quantitative
estimates have been obtained, local HTM temperatures (primarily summer estimates) were on average 1.67 +/-0.8C higher than
present (approximate average of the 20th century),


http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/geog/downloads/634/269.pdf
Quote:
During the period of maximum forest extension, the mean July temperatures along the northern coastline of Russia may have been 2.5° to
7.0°C warmer than modern.


http://www.nasa.gov/vision/earth/loo...-20071001.html
http://www.agu.org/pubs/crossref/200...GL031138.shtml
I have the full article. Not one reference is made to "global warming", "anthropogenic" or anything else relating to AGW, CO2 levels etc. Keep circling the wagons Schneibster.
Quote:
Nghiem said the rapid decline in winter perennial ice the past two years was caused by unusual winds. "Unusual atmospheric conditions set up wind patterns that compressed the sea ice, loaded it into the Transpolar Drift Stream and then sped its flow out of the Arctic," he said. When that sea ice reached lower latitudes, it rapidly melted in the warmer waters.

"The winds causing this trend in ice reduction were set up by an unusual pattern of atmospheric pressure that began at the beginning of this century," Nghiem said.

The new study differs significantly from other recent studies that only looked at the Arctic's total sea ice extent.

And there is a truly eerie silence from the Warmer community on the subject of "Asian brown clouds". Any scientific findings which may dent their cherished CO2 hypothesis, must be disregarded.
 
When he first entered this discussion, schriebest ridiculed me for not agreeing with him that a molecule of carbon dioxide, having absorbed a photon in the infrared, would necessarily relax by radiating a photon in the infrared.
All you have is to lie about what was said; and that's all you've ever done. Proof quoted above.
 
And there is a truly eerie silence from the Warmer community on the subject of "Asian brown clouds". Any scientific findings which may dent their cherished CO2 hypothesis, must be disregarded.
First of all, it's the Asian Brown Cloud, not "brown clouds." Second, you might want to take a look at this article. Of particular note:
NASA said:
This new study looks at ozone as a greenhouse gas, one that can warm the planet. "The ozone pollution we studied also adds to heating effects, which take place throughout the lower atmosphere," Chatfield stated.
NASA said:
The scientists' analysis concurs with previous researchers' judgments – both smoggy ozone and smoggy brown aerosol allow for quick and relatively low-cost fixes compared to carbon dioxide.
Looks like the Asian Brown Cloud is just another red herring by you.
 
Originally Posted by mhaze
And there is a truly eerie silence from the Warmer community on the subject of "Asian brown clouds". Any scientific findings which may dent their cherished CO2 hypothesis, must be disregarded.

First of all, it's the Asian Brown Cloud, not "brown clouds." Second, you might want to take a look at this article. Of particular note:
Originally Posted by NASA
This new study looks at ozone as a greenhouse gas, one that can warm the planet. "The ozone pollution we studied also adds to heating effects, which take place throughout the lower atmosphere," Chatfield stated.

Originally Posted by NASA
The scientists' analysis concurs with previous researchers' judgments – both smoggy ozone and smoggy brown aerosol allow for quick and relatively low-cost fixes compared to carbon dioxide.

Looks like the Asian Brown Cloud is just another red herring by you.

Then again, maybe there have been no red herrings by me, and perhaps you picked the wrong article to cite. In fact, perhaps your cite is helpful to my position.

Let's examine that -

"smoggy ozone and smoggy brown aerosol allow for quick and relatively low-cost fixes compared to carbon dioxide".

A. Quick and relatively low-cost fixes.
Just get everyone in southeast Asia to change their lifestyle.
​
B. Compared to carbon dioxide.
Fix a problem that can't be proven to be a problem?
​
Indeed. Thank you for your prompt reply.
 
Before jumping on that horse to go ride, might ought ta check if it's dead.

One more thing....

"Validated?"
By the way, I think it is reasonable to postpone any discussion about tree rings for a few weeks since there is actual new data in the process of being evaluated by McIntyre's group on this subject.

Essentially, let's not waste our time on speculation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom