Activist Who Opposed Indian Sports Nicknames Dies At 75

And who was it that treated your ancestors so badly? Are "your people" still immersed in poverty because of those who treated them so poorly? Did "your people" suffer a continued genocide that nearly wiped them out?

Is it fair to expect an ethnic group with traditionally close family ties to assume your stance, "They're all dead and have no effect on my life?"

Yes. They need to get over it.

Why do you expect American Indians to put up with your racism?

You're assuming it's racism. Others (American Indians included) disagree.
 
...snip...
And for those of you who didn't get my previous point:




Would anyone here who claimed I was overreacting support (or find humorous) a German team sporting this term?

Given the meaning of the word, I would think that it is an inappropriate name for a sports team.
 
Who are, of course, named for their all black uniform.

Or are they?

I have to say, I hate the idea of nicknames, whether they're offensive or not. I used to be able to watch a rugby match and know perfectly well that it was Swansea vs. Llanelli, or whoever. Now if I see anything it's always something like the Scarlets vs. the Dolphins and I have absolutely no idea who's actually playing, or if I should be supporting any of them. Just name the team after where they play and have done with it. Calling them silly names isn't going to make them play any better.

Who here believes that I don't have a valid complaint?

Me.

Now, who among you would defend a German sports team named the Kickass Kikes?

Oh come on. I'm hardly going to support the Germans.

Get the message now?

Nope.
 
It's impossible to make a man who refuses to walk a mile in another man's shoes see the other man's viewpoint!

This WHOLE affair is about race, so it's not race-baiting to ask of those who disagree with me:

A. Can you understand WHY an American sports team named the "Nashville N*gg*ers or the Savannah Slaves would anger African-Americans?

B. Can you understand why Jews the world over would protest a German sports team called "The Kikes?"

C. Do you actually believe that it would require personally interviewing all African-Americans or all people of Jewish descent for a consensus before admitting that either group was justified in their belief that the team names were racist?
 
It's impossible to make a man who refuses to walk a mile in another man's shoes see the other man's viewpoint!

This WHOLE affair is about race, so it's not race-baiting to ask of those who disagree with me:

A. Can you understand WHY an American sports team named the "Nashville N*gg*ers or the Savannah Slaves would anger African-Americans?
Yeap.

B. Can you understand why Jews the world over would protest a German sports team called "The Kikes?"
Yeap.

C. Do you actually believe that it would require personally interviewing all African-Americans or all people of Jewish descent for a consensus before admitting that either group was justified in their belief that the team names were racist?
Nope.

I will agree that the word "Redskins" has racist origins, and is considered derogatory. However, "Indians" and the like isn't. Though that doesn't necessarily mean I support a name change, nor even that I think it was the intention of the creators of said group. For all I know, the people that started the Redskins were very open-minded and non-racist individuals. However, that doesn't necessarily change the meaning of the word "redskins".

I don't see any real problem with comparing "redskins" to "*******" or "kikes" (speaking of which, why is the former censored but the latter not...? :)), because they all have the same kinds of origins; they were derogatory terms directed at certain individuals thanks to genetics or the color of their skin.
 
It's impossible to make a man who refuses to walk a mile in another man's shoes see the other man's viewpoint!

Yes, it is.

I've never looked at black comedians making fun of white stereotypes as racisim and you have never tried just getting over it and getting on with your life.


This WHOLE affair is about race, so it's not race-baiting to ask of those who disagree with me:

A. Can you understand WHY an American sports team named the "Nashville N*gg*ers or the Savannah Slaves would anger African-Americans?

Yes, but that is not what we are talking about here. Noone but you has been doing it. I think that someone should be able to name teams those words if they so choose.

The free market system will take care of it. I for one would not support sports franchises so named.


B. Can you understand why Jews the world over would protest a German sports team called "The Kikes?"

Again, as usual your arguement goes to the extreme. which is sad and leaves you sounding desperate. When on other topics you seem rational, composed and cogent.


C. Do you actually believe that it would require personally interviewing all African-Americans or all people of Jewish descent for a consensus before admitting that either group was justified in their belief that the team names were racist?

I believe in the free market system taking care of things like this, not the government or the courts (especially the courts).

Why do you respond so to issues that surround race in such an irrational manner?

I usually enjoy your posts on other topics.

Secondly, can you please tell me why you call me a racist?
 
Last edited:
I will agree that the word "Redskins" has racist origins, and is considered derogatory. However, "Indians" and the like isn't. Though that doesn't necessarily mean I support a name change, nor even that I think it was the intention of the creators of said group. For all I know, the people that started the Redskins were very open-minded and non-racist individuals. However, that doesn't necessarily change the meaning of the word "redskins".

I don't see any real problem with comparing "redskins" to "*******" or "kikes" (speaking of which, why is the former censored but the latter not...? :)), because they all have the same kinds of origins; they were derogatory terms directed at certain individuals thanks to genetics or the color of their skin.



You're right that the word Indians isn't necessarily racist, but isn't it still insensitive to continue using the name of an ethnic group when many people of that group feel offended? I'm old enough to remember when "Negro" was the accepted term for African-Americans (which gave rise to the more derogatory "N" word), would it be considered racist to name a sports team "The Negros" in spite of the objections of that ethnic group? How could anyone even consider naming a team the more politically correct "African-Americans without protests from the Black population of the U.S?

Even if the intention wasn't racist at the start (how many African-Americans [or Blacks] would be offended at being called Negro today?) isn't there a slight possibility that times have changed enough that an ethnic group doesn't want it's outdated names and stereotypes associated with a multi-million dollar sports franchise?

Why is it okay to use "Indians" (or even Native Americans) for a team name when there are no other teams similarly named? Why is it preposterous to suggest a team named the Asians or the Samoans without first considering the impact on those two groups? Why are stereotypical caricatures of a culture used as mascots when members of that culture object to them?

It's either insensitivity or outright disdain.
 
You're right that the word Indians isn't necessarily racist, but isn't it still insensitive to continue using the name of an ethnic group when many people of that group feel offended?
It may be. I dunno, call me heartless, but I don't see how "Indians" is all that bad. And I honestly don't think that a majority of Native Americans are up in arms about it. Even if they were, I'd think that they're being rather silly. Aren't there more important issues than the name of baseball team names? There's employment issues amongst Native American groups, drug issues, etc. that a lot of Native American groups have to deal with.

Quite frankly, I think that if they really are worried about their image, they should work on getting their "better" image out into the world. Heck, I've got songs downloaded onto my computer from Native Americans that use modern instruments and their old musical traditions; they made a few bucks out of it, and I get to listen to nifty music.

I'm old enough to remember when "Negro" was the accepted term for African-Americans (which gave rise to the more derogatory "N" word), would it be considered racist to name a sports team "The Negros" in spite of the objections of that ethnic group? How could anyone even consider naming a team the more politically correct "African-Americans without protests from the Black population of the U.S?
If you ask me, "African American" really isn't that PC, but that's my personal opinion... regardless, I think that this is honestly getting emotional over nothing.

Even if the intention wasn't racist at the start (how many African-Americans [or Blacks] would be offended at being called Negro today?) isn't there a slight possibility that times have changed enough that an ethnic group doesn't want it's outdated names and stereotypes associated with a multi-million dollar sports franchise?
Yes, there is the possibility.

Why is it okay to use "Indians" (or even Native Americans) for a team name when there are no other teams similarly named? Why is it preposterous to suggest a team named the Asians or the Samoans without first considering the impact on those two groups?
If you called a group the Vikings, Samoans, Norsemen, Orientals, or whatever else, I wouldn't be up in arms about it personally. I'd find people that work night and day trying to overturn it in desperate need of something better to do. :D

Why are stereotypical caricatures of a culture used as mascots when members of that culture object to them?
I dunno. I guess some people find it cute, or don't really connect "Native American" with "That funny little mascot".

It's either insensitivity or outright disdain.
I guess. There is such thing as being overly sensitive, though.

By the way... this is kinda amusing, because I've heard from friend's personal experiences with certain Native American groups that they're even more racist than any insensitive sports team you will ever run into. "Kike", "******", "Chink", "gook" and calling whites "Trash" are common talk amongst these groups. Of course, I'm not intending to generalize here, I'm just talking about some of his particular encounters... it's anecdotal and second hand at best.

Regardless, does anyone remember when people were up in arms over a sports team using a little "devil" mascot? Certain Christian groups considered it promoting atheism, and worked hard to get rid of the mascot. Most of us on the JREF would laugh at those people, I believe. To me, being up in arms over a little stereotyped "indian" figure is just a little less silly than being up in arms over a little devil figure, but not by much.
 
The thing that boggles my mind about this whole issue is how long it's been going on. Seriously, the protest have been going on for over 30 years. Imagine if, at the first stirrings of resentment, the teams and universities had gone to Native American groups--tribes, if they used specific tribal names--and said something like...

We would like to continue using Indian names and symbols in our marketing, but recognise that the way they are currently employed causes some offense. We invite you to work with us to develop a way to use these symbols that is truly respectful and honorable.

In all likelihood, the response to such a request would have been positive. "Redskins" would probably have had to go, along with caricatures, but compromises could have been reached on less flagrantly offensive items. The Indians themselves could use partnerships with the teams to more widely promote knowledge of their culture and history.

This is essentially the path FSU took with the Florida Seminole tribe. (It should be noted, however, that the Oklahoma Seminoles take a dimmer view of the situation.) The university leadership has worked closely with tribal leadership in all the ways Indian names and symbols are used. They have started Native American Studies programs, and even gone so far as to erect a statue of a mounted Indian with the inscription "Unconquered" in front of the football stadium, a reference to the fact that the Seminoles are the only tribe never to have signed a treaty with the US. Everyone talks about respect and honor, but FSU are the only ones who seem to do anything about it.

Why didn't everyone else?

ETA: The statue
 
Last edited:
Yes, it is.

I've never looked at black comedians making fun of white stereotypes as racisim and you have never tried just getting over it and getting on with your life.


It's humor when everyone laughs, it's racism when only one side thinks it's funny. I've tried to get over it and get on with my life, but there is always someone there to remind me that racism ISN'T a thing of the past!



I think that someone should be able to name teams those words if they so choose.


Then you ARE supporting racism. Perhaps I'm mistaken, but I believe that thinking men of conscience would object to ANY attempts to belittle another man or his culture and heritage. It shouldn't be so much out of honor or a sense of righteousness that we speak out against such slights, but empathy - it takes so little to understand how another man feels and to sympathize with him.



The free market system will take care of it. I for one would not support sports franchises so named.


What if the slighted cultural group has no pull in "the free market, is it okay to continue the racism? Even if every single American Indian in this country boycotted baseball games it wouldn't hurt the industry one iota! If money talks then the average Indian has a very small voice indeed!


Again, as usual your arguement goes to the extreme. which is sad and leaves you sounding desperate. When on other topics you seem rational, composed and cogent.


My argument only sounds extreme because you are on the opposite side of it. Certainly you can appreciate why people of Jewish descent the world over would object to German sports teams using ANYTHING from their culture, why is it so difficult to see why Native Americans object?



I believe in the free market system taking care of things like this, not the government or the courts (especially the courts).


The "free market" takes care of only the rich. Making more money doesn't make it right!


Why do you respond so to issues that surround race in such an irrational manner?


Because racism is such an irrational issue! Throughout the centuries there have been faulty justifications for why one race or culture is inferior to another, the tendency to belittle those races is a by-product of a more troubling insecurity which often justifies violence.


Secondly, can you please tell me why you call me a racist?


Because you don't stop to think of how Indian children must feel growing up in poverty amidst idiotic mascots like Chief Wahoo, because you defend the notion that if one Indian isn't repulsed by the stereotypes then no Indians deserve to feel slighted, but mostly because you try to belittle my viewpoint and suggest that I'm getting worked up over nothing!

Read this book and you'll know why well-meaning liberals are often more racist than the KKK or most Skinheads:

http://www.amazon.com/Never-Say-******-Again-Antiracism/dp/155523626X
 
You're right that the word Indians isn't necessarily racist, but isn't it still insensitive to continue using the name of an ethnic group when many people of that group feel offended?

So I'll ask again - are you offended by the State of Illinois? How about Seneca County in New York?
 
It's humor when everyone laughs, it's racism when only one side thinks it's funny. I've tried to get over it and get on with my life, but there is always someone there to remind me that racism ISN'T a thing of the past!

By that standard nothing would be humor and everything would be racism. If we all can learn to laugh at ourselves then we wont take everything so seriously and be able to discern what real issues to focus on.

All of this whining over minor issues is much like the boy who cried wolf. Not everything that offends you is racist.


Then you ARE supporting racism. Perhaps I'm mistaken, but I believe that thinking men of conscience would object to ANY attempts to belittle another man or his culture and heritage. It shouldn't be so much out of honor or a sense of righteousness that we speak out against such slights, but empathy - it takes so little to understand how another man feels and to sympathize with him.

No I am not supporting racism. I am supporting the free market system.

But I do agree that thinking thinking men of conscience should object to such things. I hardly think that Indians, Redskins or Seminoles were attempts to belittle the native american culture.

Now your Nashville team would be a different story. I support his right to create a team with that name, but I would not financially support it nor would anyone I know and feel that
someone who created such a team would be in my estimation a giant racist DICKWAD.


What if the slighted cultural group has no pull in "the free market, is it okay to continue the racism? Even if every single American Indian in this country boycotted baseball games it wouldn't hurt the industry one iota! If money talks then the average Indian has a very small voice indeed!

If the issue is a real issue then Americans are good to come to the aid of smaller groups. If is construed as whining then maybe not.

I think that the difference between our thoughts on this is that I think that "People are mostly good" and you feel that "People are mostly bad".



My argument only sounds extreme because you are on the opposite side of it. Certainly you can appreciate why people of Jewish descent the world over would object to German sports teams using ANYTHING from their culture, why is it so difficult to see why Native Americans object?

Because no one has named a team the "Dirty-Alcohol-swillin-head-scalpin Indians" (I have no idea what the n-word equivalent for a native american is, I asked my wife and she said something odd which if I print will cause her to most likely be called a racist.)



The "free market" takes care of only the rich. Making more money doesn't make it right!

False. See several radio "shock-jocks" for example.


Because racism is such an irrational issue! Throughout the centuries there have been faulty justifications for why one race or culture is inferior to another, the tendency to belittle those races is a by-product of a more troubling insecurity which often justifies violence.

I disagree with your finding that it is from some inferiority-complex that racism was born.

Sometimes scum is just scum.



Because you don't stop to think of how Indian children must feel growing up in poverty amidst idiotic mascots like Chief Wahoo, because you defend the notion that if one Indian isn't repulsed by the stereotypes then no Indians deserve to feel slighted, but mostly because you try to belittle my viewpoint and suggest that I'm getting worked up over nothing!

So you are calling me a racist because I upset you? Thank you for your honesty. I thought you saw a valid reason to do so.

And as far as native american children go, remember my wife is of Cherokee descent (not the 1/8th stuff her father was full-blooded) we have three kids. I'll admit that they do not live in poverty, but they tend to think people who put forth stereotypes of any nature are either comical or dickwads(depending on the case).
But they know that it is the other persons issue as they are well adjusted.


Read this book and you'll know why well-meaning liberals are often more racist than the KKK or most Skinheads:

Thank you for the link, I will get the book and read it. However I already know that liberals are more racist and have done more keep down minorities than any other group.

Also, thank you for the tone of the post.
 
Last edited:
Serious question, Mephisto: What should we do about this? What is your proposal?
 
I'm Native American, and the term redskin kinda bothers me, I won't lie. But at the end of the day, baseball is retarded (as are most of it's fans - honestly, it's the most boring way to spend your time imaginable. Try watching grass grow for a couple hours, then watch a game of baseball - you tell me what comes out on top) so who really gives a ****** Just a matter of time before people stop watching it (we can hope).

Now, once someone comes up with 'Future Baseball 2929', I expect to see some more creative names, or at least a nod to the League of Five Nations.

L5N represent!!!
 
Serious question, Mephisto: What should we do about this? What is your proposal?


Imagine if, at the first stirrings of resentment, the teams and universities had gone to Native American groups--tribes, if they used specific tribal names--and said something like...

We would like to continue using Indian names and symbols in our marketing, but recognise that the way they are currently employed causes some offense. We invite you to work with us to develop a way to use these symbols that is truly respectful and honorable.



This sounds like a perfectly reasonable suggestion. Someone mentioned that Mel Gibson's name couldn't be used without his permission, why shouldn't Indian nations benefit from the RESPECTFUL use of their names or symbols? If the "free market" actually gauges what can or cannot be used in good conscience wouldn't it be interesting to see which sports teams would pay for their use and which teams would simply change their name and mascots?
 
I'm Native American, and the term redskin kinda bothers me, I won't lie. But at the end of the day, baseball is retarded (as are most of it's fans - honestly, it's the most boring way to spend your time imaginable. Try watching grass grow for a couple hours, then watch a game of baseball - you tell me what comes out on top) so who really gives a ****** Just a matter of time before people stop watching it (we can hope).

Now, once someone comes up with 'Future Baseball 2929', I expect to see some more creative names, or at least a nod to the League of Five Nations.

L5N represent!!!


Amen to that brother! Isn't it odd that Cleveland has a chance at the World Series (isn't it funny how every year an American team wins? ;)) in the same season that Vernon Bellecourt dies?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom