You're right that the word Indians isn't necessarily racist, but isn't it still insensitive to continue using the name of an ethnic group when many people of that group feel offended?
It may be. I dunno, call me heartless, but I don't see how "Indians" is all that bad. And I honestly don't think that a majority of Native Americans are up in arms about it. Even if they were, I'd think that they're being rather silly. Aren't there more important issues than the name of baseball team names? There's employment issues amongst Native American groups, drug issues, etc. that a lot of Native American groups have to deal with.
Quite frankly, I think that if they really are worried about their image, they should work on getting their "better" image out into the world. Heck, I've got songs downloaded onto my computer from Native Americans that use modern instruments and their old musical traditions; they made a few bucks out of it, and I get to listen to nifty music.
I'm old enough to remember when "Negro" was the accepted term for African-Americans (which gave rise to the more derogatory "N" word), would it be considered racist to name a sports team "The Negros" in spite of the objections of that ethnic group? How could anyone even consider naming a team the more politically correct "African-Americans without protests from the Black population of the U.S?
If you ask me, "African American" really isn't that PC, but that's my personal opinion... regardless, I think that this is honestly getting emotional over nothing.
Even if the intention wasn't racist at the start (how many African-Americans [or Blacks] would be offended at being called Negro today?) isn't there a slight possibility that times have changed enough that an ethnic group doesn't want it's outdated names and stereotypes associated with a multi-million dollar sports franchise?
Yes, there is the possibility.
Why is it okay to use "Indians" (or even Native Americans) for a team name when there are no other teams similarly named? Why is it preposterous to suggest a team named the Asians or the Samoans without first considering the impact on those two groups?
If you called a group the Vikings, Samoans, Norsemen, Orientals, or whatever else, I wouldn't be up in arms about it personally. I'd find people that work night and day trying to overturn it in desperate need of something better to do.
Why are stereotypical caricatures of a culture used as mascots when members of that culture object to them?
I dunno. I guess some people find it cute, or don't really connect "Native American" with "That funny little mascot".
It's either insensitivity or outright disdain.
I guess. There is such thing as being overly sensitive, though.
By the way... this is kinda amusing, because I've heard from friend's personal experiences with certain Native American groups that they're even more racist than any insensitive sports team you will ever run into. "Kike", "******", "Chink", "gook" and calling whites "Trash" are common talk amongst these groups. Of course, I'm not intending to generalize here, I'm just talking about some of his particular encounters... it's anecdotal and second hand at best.
Regardless, does anyone remember when people were up in arms over a sports team using a little "devil" mascot? Certain Christian groups considered it promoting atheism, and worked hard to get rid of the mascot. Most of us on the JREF would laugh at those people, I believe. To me, being up in arms over a little stereotyped "indian" figure is just a little less silly than being up in arms over a little devil figure, but not by much.