General questions from a new member...

The first thing you could do is simply run your concerns by qualified people to determine if there was enough reason to continue.


Then, if they don't give you the answer you want, call them disinfo! It's so easy!
 
It's certainly valid to ask questions if you don't know or don't understand something. But when you're given a valid answer, one that's supported by the evidence, the laws of physics, and so on, you should accept it and move on. It's the Truthers' inability to do this that makes dealing with them so frustrating. You can debunk them a thousand times, and they'll pop up with the same nonsense again.

Oh, and check out McAdams's site if you have any JFK questions. That guy is the shizzle.

http://mcadams.posc.mu.edu/home.htm
 
I disagree.

If one truly believed these theories there are any number of people you can approach, especially at a University.

The first thing you could do is simply run your concerns by qualified people to determine if there was enough reason to continue. These people are in the business of educating and most will answer your questions if you are polite, brief and to the point.

When these theories first began to surface I was working for the University of Texas and I did just that. Every time I heard a new one I’d walk over to the Engineering School and ask a few questions.

Now considering that Engineering is their life they already had a keen interest in what happened and I can assure you that they already knew the details of the buildings design and exactly what forces they were subjected to, a far deeper knowledge and understanding than some kid on the internet.

Needless to say every flawed logic or understanding of structural engineering proposed by the conspiracy camp was explained to me in great detail.

Now consider this. Suppose I had approached them with something that was not nonsense, something that they had simply not considered or had been unaware of.

Do you think that someone with no training would be able to understand the implications of such an anomaly but not someone with a lifetime of experience in the field? I think not.

Do you think that every professional approached and confronted with evidence that their own government cold-bloodily murdered thousands of its own citizens would just clam up and refuse to act? Again I think not.

All one would need to do is enlist the aid of someone with the proper credentials that people would listen to which would be easy enough to do if one truly had evidence or even legitimate questions that needed resolving.

Another approach I have used is email. I have looked up the names and emailed Egyptologists, Video Experts, you name it, at one time or another and have been pleasantly surprised at how willing most are to answer questions if you are brief and polite.

If you truly seek the truth, don’t question Loose Change. Don’t question the JREF forums. Ask an expert.

For example, If you’ve heard that the fires during 911 were not hot enough to cause the building to collapse then write that as a question, go online, google ‘Structural Engineer’, get some names and email 10 of them with that question

You’ll be separating the wheat from the chaff in no time.


Good advice. Thanks. I think I will.

The only thing I am willing to ask about is WTC 7. It just doesn't seem logical to me that a fire brought it down the way it did.

Yea yea, I know you have Scientific proof and all but I am going off my own feelings.

I really wish some rich bastard would take an old building scheduled for demo and do some testing. I would like to see what happens when just the bottom supports are taken out and nothing else. If I see a similiar fall, that is probably the only thing that will convince me. And that is of course, assuming a fire can take out or (weaken) the supports like they did. But even if all the bottom supports were bombed or (cut) and I saw a similiar fall, I would believe the official story.
 
Yea yea, I know you have Scientific proof and all but I am going off my own feelings.

yeah well, unless those feelings are informed by some kind of technical expertise, I suggest you don't put too much faith in them. There are plenty of counter intuitive realities out there, where your common sense doesn't mean squat.

I really wish some rich bastard would take an old building scheduled for demo and do some testing. I would like to see what happens when just the bottom supports are taken out and nothing else. If I see a similiar fall, that is probably the only thing that will convince me. And that is of course, assuming a fire can take out or (weaken) the supports like they did. But even if all the bottom supports were bombed or (cut) and I saw a similiar fall, I would believe the official story.

Not necessary. The collapse of the wtc towers is not difficult to explain in general terms. But the building collapse is a chaotic event which requires huge amounts of data to provide a blow by blow narrative. Doing the same thing to another building is unlikely to produce any worthwhile additional information.

And anyway, with all due respect, no one bloody well cares whether you understand the collapse of the towers. If you're a structural engineer and you don't understand it then you should go back to university. If you're not a structural engineer and you don't understand it, find an engineer to explain it to you.
 
yeah well, unless those feelings are informed by some kind of technical expertise, I suggest you don't put too much faith in them. There are plenty of counter intuitive realities out there, where your common sense doesn't mean squat.



Not necessary. The collapse of the wtc towers is not difficult to explain in general terms. But the building collapse is a chaotic event which requires huge amounts of data to provide a blow by blow narrative. Doing the same thing to another building is unlikely to produce any worthwhile additional information.

And anyway, with all due respect, no one bloody well cares whether you understand the collapse of the towers. If you're a structural engineer and you don't understand it then you should go back to university. If you're not a structural engineer and you don't understand it, find an engineer to explain it to you.

Well, my common sense has served me well as a mechanical engineer so far. It never fails.

Your basically saying, if your an engineer and you think there is something wrong with the official story, go back to school because your stupid... according to other engineers.

Like I said, who determines what "expert" is wrong and right if they contradict eachother?
 
Im trying to put together a question but first I need to know the answer to this question...

Did any of the building fall at free fall speed?

If no, how far was the time off from being what would be called "free" fall speed?
 
ok, another question....

is this the best picture we have showing the damage to WTC 7?

wtc7.jpg


If not, can you help me find it?
 
There's one showing the south face with the gouge ....we need e^n, he has these things at his fingertips.

Maybe try Christopher7 never ending thread. Haven't read any of it for months but I'm sure the damage to wtc7 must be featured on there.....somewhere.
 
more....

Which one of these "tops" would fall at free fall speed?

ab.jpg


A?
B?
Both?
Or None?
 
ab.jpg


If this was a mock up model and it took 5 seconds for figure A to fall at free fall, is there any good way to determine how much slower figure B would fall if any?
 
Provide the names of the structural engineers within that ...... site..... who have experience of multi-storey steel structures.

Ok, I will try to get to that in a bit.

You are basically saying you discredit all 226 of these engineers?

I don't want to put words in your mouth but that is the impression I am getting.
 
I know, I said sorry. I should have kept that idea to myself. It just seems as though nobody here can say the government does no wrong and every event that occured that appears that way, people are telling me there is no way it could have happened.

There's a Politics forum here, and there are plenty of people there from a number of countries telling how their government is currently involved in sending their respective countries to hell in a handbasket.
 
Ok, I will try to get to that in a bit.

You are basically saying you discredit all 226 of these engineers?

I don't want to put words in your mouth but that is the impression I am getting.

Yes.

Hardly any of them are structural engineers and of those who are none seem to have the requisite experience in the type of construction they presume to speak with authority on.

Also, there is an alarming lack of technical papers from these 'experts' to back up their 'gut feelings'.

A&Etruth is a joke.

The way they are presented is also deceptive in that they seek to give the impression that they are an organisation representing architects and engineers involved in the structural design of buildings. This is far from the truth when you consider the number of engineers who have absolutely nothing to do with structural design, i.e mechanical and electrical engineers. Their PI insurance wouldn't cover them to provide a structural design of a building, so why should they be held up as experts in the field?
 
Last edited:
more....
Which one of these "tops" would fall at free fall speed?
http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z194/curtislee5/ab.jpg
A?
B?
Both?
Or None?


<sigh> there is plenty of evidence that the towers did not wholly fall at free-fall speed e.g.:-

Nist Faq said:
From video evidence, significant portions of the cores of both buildings (roughly 60 stories of WTC 1 and 40 stories of WTC 2) are known to have stood 15 to 25 seconds after collapse initiation before they, too, began to collapse. Neither the duration of the seismic records nor video evidence (due to obstruction of view caused by debris clouds) are reliable indicators of the total time it took for each building to collapse completely.
LINK

go back, look again.

BV
 
more....

Which one of these "tops" would fall at free fall speed?

[qimg]http://i191.photobucket.com/albums/z194/curtislee5/ab.jpg[/qimg]

A?
B?
Both?
Or None?

Hello Jref members!


Oh, also, I would like to note that most of my questions won't revolve around 9/11. At least not directly. Im kind of sick about most of the debates on that topic (ie: controlled dems and such). And honestly, I am starting to believe more of the official story. The aspects of 9/11 that bother me are geared towards the supposed "funders" and the mistakes made that day. Tie that in with some of our history as a nation, and it makes me wonder why 9/11 really happened.

Its hard to keep up the pretence for long isnt it?:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom