[Split]Income Tax conspiracy - split from: ZEITGEIST, The Movie

Every post you do says the same thing "lies lies lies" "idiots idiots"

You never disprove anything.

You are from america right?

You are proud to live in the land of the free right?

You would pick up a gun and defend america when it is a total police state right?
America is not in a police state, I have a few guns. You are totally ignorant on 9/11, and income tax laws of the United States! You are getting sleepy, have a great night.

Your videos posted are total junk. You have lost this one, but then you are not knowledgeable enough to understand US laws, or the lies posted on the internet, which you are now supporting.

You say there is no law in the US for income tax; you are wrong.

Simple stuff, you are wrong about United States income tax laws. This is not news, some real dumb people in the United States believe what you say, they are wrong. I am so sad you are not able to understand I am calling the liars who made the movies idiots, but it is the people who believe the lies of the videos that are the real idiots! Sorry, the truth is too much for you. Please try harder to learn about the liars on the internet. Good luck, but you should listen to the poster from Norway, he was polite and correct. You have failed to study this subject; try again.
 
Last edited:
I hope you don't think you answered my question. I asked you what was illegal about the income tax? I did not ask for a documentary. Please answer this simple question.

Malmoesoldier, address this question.
 
You mean nothing i said is true? please say yes
Sorry, you'll have to play with someone else. Been there, done that, stopped doing speed and re-discovered the real world.

I'll just watch and enjoy. You sort of make me nostalgic for the good old days. :)
 
Last edited:
I am trying to figure out why a Swedish Citizen is getting so worked up about a tax that only effects US Citizens.
And Using as proof a documentary that has been proven to be pure nonsense. Nice going,guy.
 
Sorry, you'll have to play with someone else. Been there, done that, stopped doing speed and re-discovered the real world.

I'll just watch and enjoy. You sort of make me nostalgic for the good old days. :)
The funny thing is he told the truth once.
Originally Posted by Malmoesoldier
You mean nothing i said is true? please say yes
 
Lol

America is not in a police state, I have a few guns. You are totally ignorant on 9/11, and income tax laws of the United States! You are getting sleepy, have a great night.

Your videos posted are total junk. You have lost this one, but then you are not knowledgeable enough to understand US laws, or the lies posted on the internet, which you are now supporting.

You say there is no law in the US for income tax; you are wrong.

Simple stuff, you are wrong about United States income tax laws. Not new, some real dumb people in the United States believe what you say, they are wrong. I am so sad you are not able to understand I am calling the liars who made the movies idiots, but it is the people who believe the lies of the videos that are the real idiots! Sorry, the truth is too much for you. Please try harder to learn about the liars on the internet. Good luck, but you should listen to the poster from Norway, he was polite and correct. You have failed to study this subject; try again.

You have problems. are you 12 years old? all you can do is write "not true" "lies" "idiots". are you on prozac??.

Malmoesoldier, address this question.

Every tax law must clearly and plainly identify three things:

1) The subject of the tax;

2) The amount of the tax; and

3)The persons or entities liable for the tax.

The income tax law is the only instance where there is no clear liability provision applicable to those the IRS claims are liable for the tax. Although partners are called liable for taxes on partnerships, that “liability” is only in their “individual capacity”, and there is no provision making them liable in their “individual capacity.” The only clear liability provision is § 1461, which specifically assigns liability for the tax to those required to withhold taxes on Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Corporations! Are you required to withhold taxes on a nonresident alien? A foreign corporation?

While 26 U.S.C. § 3403, which is not part of the income tax law, does require employers to withhold income tax owed by their employees, there is no law that makes the employee liable for the tax in the first place.

Search the Internal Revenue Code for “liable”, then search for “must pay”, “obligated to pay”, then search for “responsible for payment” or any other configuration of words that would designate who is liable for the income tax. You will find plenty of liability provisions for other taxes, but not for the income tax.

There is no law.

Watch "america freedom to fascism" learn how people have won in court.

Read: http://www.amazon.com/coming-battle-complete-history-national/dp/0965636909
 
Last edited:
You have problems. are you 12 years old? all you can do is write "not true" "lies" "idiots". are you on prozac??.

Every tax law must clearly and plainly identify three things:

1) The subject of the tax;

2) The amount of the tax; and

3)The persons or entities liable for the tax.

The income tax law is the only instance where there is no clear liability provision applicable to those the IRS claims are liable for the tax. Although partners are called liable for taxes on partnerships, that “liability” is only in their “individual capacity”, and there is no provision making them liable in their “individual capacity.” The only clear liability provision is § 1461, which specifically assigns liability for the tax to those required to withhold taxes on Nonresident Aliens and Foreign Corporations!

While 26 U.S.C. § 3403, which is not part of the income tax law, does require employers to withhold income tax owed by their employees, there is no law that makes the employee liable for the tax in the first place.

Search the Internal Revenue Code for “liable”, then search for “must pay”, “obligated to pay”, then search for “responsible for payment” or any other configuration of words that would designate who is liable for the income tax. You will find plenty of liability provisions for other taxes, but not for the income tax.

There is no law.

Watch "america freedom to fascism" learn how people have won in court.

Read: http://www.amazon.com/coming-battle-complete-history-national/dp/0965636909
Your posting books which are lies. Sad, you post crap, and junk about the US income tax.

There is a cure for terminal stupidity; it is education! I suggest you get an education now. Your post is full of lies. There is a law and I will post the rebuttal web sites as soon as I can google some truth into your ignorant posts.

Coming soon to this location, some web sites that have rational thought! What a concept!
http://www.unclefed.com/Tax-News/1993/Nr93-114.html
If you do not understand; study harder!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_protester_statutory_arguments
OMG, wiki actually has some stuff right? Could be... who would know?
http://www.irs.gov/taxpros/article/0,,id=159853,00.html
Darn, the IRS gets their money. But they wait until it is a big pile! Like more than you can pay; then they take your horse and your gun! LOL, you are in Sweden telling me the income tax law is not!? Your posts are nuts.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode26/usc_sup_01_26.html
Darn, I hate it when you are wrong on the law; I thought you Swedes were smart.

now some independent debunking sites who warn you not too smart guys...
http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html
next
http://www.quatloos.com/
Good luck; you have lost your no US income tax law stuff; Better luck next scam!

http://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/index.php/Income_tax

It is called judgement; learn how to figure out who is telling lies; knowledge helps!
 
Last edited:
Where is the Law?

16th amendment
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

That seems pretty clear cut to me.
 
Every tax law must clearly and plainly identify three things:

1) The subject of the tax;

2) The amount of the tax; and

3)The persons or entities liable for the tax.

Seems to me you just made that up.

there is no law that makes the employee liable for the tax in the first place.
Yes there is. We've already shown it to you. It's the part that says there is a tax on the "taxable income" of "every individual". Employees are individuals and their wages are taxable income.

Search the Internal Revenue Code for “liable”, then search for “must pay”, “obligated to pay”, then search for “responsible for payment” or any other configuration of words that would designate who is liable for the income tax. You will find plenty of liability provisions for other taxes, but not for the income tax.
Try searching for "imposed a tax". Imposing a tax creates a liability.

There is no law.
PL 83-591. We've already been over this. Why do you keep repeating things that are in direct contradiction with the evidence?

Watch "america freedom to fascism" learn how people have won in court.
No one has ever won what you think they've won, in court. No court has ever said someone wasn't liable for their taxes based on your frivolous arguments.

The closest you can come is people who have been not-guilty of tax evasion but (and this is the important part) STILL HAD TO PAY THEIR TAXES.

Not guilty of tax evasion doesn't, hasn't, and won't -ever- mean not liable.
 
Last edited:
If anti-sophist actually showing him the law isn't good enough, perhaps the invaluable Tax Protestor FAQ can help malmoesoldier understand.

It seems that the status of the very law anti-sophist cited, now commonly known as the Internal Revenue Code, as a law has been adjudicated, as the FAQ makes clear with no fewer than six citations of court decisions.

If malmoesoldier insists on arguing about taxes which have no effect on him (assuming that he is in Sweden and not earning income in the USA), he really ought to peruse the FAQ. It addresses all of the popular tax protestor arguments, including everything in "Freedom to Fascism" and demonstrates, with citations of case law, how all of them without exception have been shredded, pulped and put in the cat litter box by the courts.

The only challenge these hoary old claims pose to the government now is that they cause judges to wear out thesauruses in search of a way to say "demented sheep-wit" without destroying their judicial dignity.

That doesn't stop the producers of paranoid conspiracy theory products or the promoters of tax-evasion schemes from endlessy recycling them. There's always a fresh crop of rubes who, as Honest John Barlow said, "won't know enough to do any smart checking".
 
Seems to me you just made that up.

Yes there is. We've already shown it to you. It's the part that says there is a tax on the "taxable income" of "every individual". Employees are individuals and their wages are taxable income.

Try searching for "imposed a tax". Imposing a tax creates a liability.

PL 83-591. We've already been over this. Why do you keep repeating things that are in direct contradiction with the evidence?

No one has ever won what you think they've won, in court. No court has ever said someone wasn't liable for their taxes based on your frivolous arguments.

The closest you can come is people who have been not-guilty of tax evasion but (and this is the important part) STILL HAD TO PAY THEIR TAXES.

Not guilty of tax evasion doesn't, hasn't, and won't -ever- mean not liable.

You are wrong i will show you some facts then i want you to read the memo i give you that proves that there is NO law.

"The issue is whether the income tax is a direct tax, which can be levied on virtually anything, or an indirect tax, which can only be laid on those activities listed in Flint. In 1861 the federal government imposed a tax on income derived from property. The tax was never challenged, but was referred to by Chief Justice

White in Brushaber as an excise tax. Brushaber, supra, p. 15. Prior to Brushaber, however, the nature of the income tax had come into question.
In Pollock v. Farmers' Loan and T. Co., 157 U.S. 429 (1895), the Supreme Court held that the Income Tax Act of 1894 imposing a tax on income from real estate and investments was a direct tax, and, therefore invalid for want of apportionment. The basis of the ruling was that the tax on the revenues from real estate was a burden on the ownership of the real estate, and, hence, a tax on the property itself. The decision that the tax was direct turned on the source of the income, rather than the income itself and was not in agreement with prior Supreme Court reasoning, such as in Hylton, supra. In response to the ruling the federal government sought an amendment to overrule the Pollock decision. Ultimately, in 1913, the Sixteenth Amendment to the Constitution was certified as adopted. It read:
"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration." Congress immediately passed the Income Tax of 1913, imposing a tax on net income, "from whatever source derived." The law was challenged in Brushaber v.

Union Pac. R.R. Co., 240 U.S. 1, 36 S.Ct. 236 (1916), requiring the Court to determine the impact of the Sixteenth Amendment on tax authority. Chief Justice White, who had dissented in Pollock, wrote for the Court, holding that the Sixteenth Amendment did not confer any additional authority to tax and that its sole purpose and effect was to preclude the consideration of the source of income in order to reclassify the tax as a direct tax, requiring apportionment.There has been some confusion regarding the actual import of the Brushaber ruling, one court actually holding that the effect of Brushaber was to uphold the constitutionality of the Sixteenth Amendment7(?), and another has held that Congress was given the power to tax incomes by the Sixteenth Amendment8. One court, incredibly, cited Brushaber as holding that the Sixteenth Amendment "provided the needed constitutional basis for the imposition of a direct non-apportioned income tax,"9 a proposition that the Supreme Court in Brushaber categorically rejected! The clear and unequivocal ruling of the Court in Brushaber is that the Sixteenth Amendment granted no new powers to Congress:

"It is clear on the face of this text that it does not purport to confer power to levy income taxes in a generic sense — an authority already possessed and never questioned — or to limit and distinguish between one kind of income taxes and another, but that the whole purpose of the Amendment was to relieve all income taxes when imposed from apportionment from a consideration of the source whence the income was derived." Brushaber, supra, at 17-8
(emphasis added)

nor did the Court recognize a third class of taxes, a direct tax not requiring apportionment:

"The various propositions are so intermingled as to cause it to be difficult to classify them. We are of opinion, however, that the confusion is not inherent, but rather arises from the conclusion that the Sixteenth Amendment provides for a hitherto unknown power of taxation, that is, a power to levy an income tax which although direct should not be subject to the regulation of apportionment applicable to all other direct taxes. And the far-reaching effect of this erroneous assumption will be made clear by generalizing the many contentions advanced in argument to support it, . . ." Brushaber, supra, at 10-11
(emphasis added)

The effect of the Sixteenth Amendment was not to permit a direct income tax, nor to grant Congress any additional power of taxation. If that conclusion can be in any doubt from the difficulties experienced by some in understanding the Brushaber opinion, the point is reiterated in Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103 (1916), the Supreme Court held:

". . . The provisions of the Sixteenth Amendment conferred no new power of taxation but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged and being placed in the category of direct taxation subject to apportionment by a consideration of the sources from which the income was derived, . . ."
Stanton, supra, at 112-3
(emphasis added)

and by the Supreme Court, again, in Peck & Co. v. Lowe, 247 U.S. 165 (1918), at p. 172-3:

"The Sixteenth Amendment, although referred to in argument, has no real bearing and may be put out of view. As pointed out in recent decisions, it does not extend the taxing power to new or excepted subjects, but merely removes all occasion, which otherwise might exist, for an apportionment among the States of taxes laid on income, whether it be derived from one source or another. Brushaber v. Union Pacific R.R. Co., 240 U.S. 1, 17-19; Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103, 112-113."
(emphasis added)

and by the Supreme Court, again, in Eisner v. Macomber, 252 U.S. 189 (1920), at p. 206:

As repeatedly held, this [the 16th Amendment] did not extend the taxing power to new subjects, but merely removed the necessity which otherwise might exist for an apportionment among the States of taxes laid on income. Brushaber v. Union Pacific R.R. Co., 240 U.S. 1, 17-19; Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co., 240 U.S. 103, 112 et seq.; Peck & Co. v. Lowe, 247 U.S. 165, 172-173.

(emphasis and [bracketed material] added)


The Supreme Court in Flora v. U.S., 362 US 145 (1959) stated: "Our system of taxation is based upon voluntary assessment and payment not upon distraint."

Justice J. Blackmun in the Supreme Court Case of Laing v. U.S. et al 423 US 161 (1975), states: "Our income tax system is primarily a self-reporting and self-assessment one. It is 'based upon voluntary assessment and payment, not upon distraint.'..."


Tommy Cryer won against IRS in court 2007. trial transcript, page 109 "not gulity" http://www.truthattack.org/Cryer_trial_Volume_IV.pdf

Please read this memo that proves that there is NO law. http://www.truthattack.org/cryer_MEMORANDUM.pdf

Please read Tommy cryers letter to the government that proves that there is NO law: http://www.truthattack.org/CryerReplytoGovtResponse.pdf

A federal jury unanimously found Tommy Cryer not guilty this week on two misdemeanor counts of failure to file.

And according to Cryer, the prosecution dismissed two felony charges of tax evasion prior to trial.

Attempts by The Times on Thursday to reach U.S. Attorney Donald Washington or Bill Flanagan, first assistant U.S. attorney, were not successful. Calls made to the two were not immediately returned.

"The court could not find a law that makes me liable or makes my revenues taxable," Cryer said. "The Supreme Court has ruled that the government cannot impose an income tax on anything but the profits and gains. When you work for someone you give your service and labor in exchange for money, so everything you make is not profit or gain. You put something into it."

http://www.shreveporttimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2007707130321
 
Last edited:
These are the first-hand accounts and articles that document the collusion of international banks to form the Federal Reserve and gain control of America.

Read about the manipulation of our money and its supply, the intentional creation of recessions, depressions and panics. The manipulation of the stock markets. The demonetization of silver. A breathtaking history told in the words of a contemporary witness to these events.

The Coming Battle documents from congressional records, newspaper reports and writings by the founding fathers and others a chronology of events long forgotten that shaped our fledgling nation from 1776 to 1899.

Now, read for the first time in almost a century, the book that documents how and why our elected representatives and the banking money power deliberatly created the national debt. The Coming Battle, first published in 1899, is the chronological history of the usurping of every American's sovereign rights by the unseen money powers and their agents.

READ how recessions, depressions, and panics are created at will and how the stock markets are manipulated for power and gain.

READ how the manufacturers, with the backing of the money power, import cheap foreign labor, resulting in countless labor riots.

READ how the money power took control of the influential colleges and universities in the United States.

READ how the money power created starvation and suffering in a nation of plenty and how small family farms are set up for foreclosures.

READ how silver was demonetized by the money power, resulting in a five -year depression, that devastated the people and the western regions of the United States.

READ about the Democratic platform of 1840.

READ how the banking money power fleeced the treasury of our gold and silver and replaced it with their worthless paper money.

READ how legislation was signed and passed into law pledging every American citizen as collateral for the repayment of all government debts in gold and silver.

READ about Napoleon The III, attempting to unite nations under a common currency.

READ about the corporate takeover of America.

Told in breathtaking detail with proof-positive evidence taken from Congressional records, newspaper reports, writings of the day, and statements by our founding fathers.

http://www.amazon.com/coming-battle-complete-history-national/dp/0965636909
 
You are wrong i will show you some facts then i want you to read the memo i give you that proves that there is NO law.

It's bizarre you can keep claiming there is no law when I keep telling you what it is. It's Public Law 83-591.

<snip offtopic spam>
While I appreciate your attempt to educate me by pasting someone elses thoughts and opinion, you haven't really accomplished anything.

First, and most important, you have changed the subject. You said there is no law. I told you there is. I told you it's citation. I told you when it was signed. I told you who signed it.

What did you do? You said I was wrong and changed the subject by pasting off-topic nonsense.

Please stop telling us the law doesn't exist when I'm showing it to you. It's Public Law 83-591.


As for the actual document, it's chock full of myths.

The income is a direct tax but does not require apportionment. See 16th amendment.

The 16th amendment conferred no new power of taxation because Congress already had the power. It is a commonly held and -mistaken- belief that the 16th amendment gave Congress the power to tax income. It didn't.

Your memo ignores the -fact- that Congress always had the power to tax income.



Tommy Cryer won against IRS in court 2007. trial transcript, page 9 "not gulity" http://www.truthattack.org/Cryer_trial_Volume_IV.pdf
Tom Cryer did _not_ win his case against the IRS. Tom Cryer won a CRIMINAL case against the US government by being found NOT GUILTY of tax evasion.

Repeat after me: HE WAS NOT CLEARED OF HIS TAX LIABILITY. HE JUST GETS TO PAY HIS BACK TAXES WITHOUT GOING TO JAIL.

Do you understand? Maybe I need to repeat it: HE WAS NOT CLEARED OF HIS TAX LIABILITY.

Please read this memo that proves that there is NO law. http://www.truthattack.org/cryer_MEMORANDUM.pdf
Nothing in that memo proves to me the dis-existance of something I've already demonstrated to exist. PL 83-591.

Please read Tommy cryers letter to the government that proves that there is NO law: http://www.truthattack.org/CryerReplytoGovtResponse.pdf
I have. Many times. Nothing about that document disproves the very OBVIOUS existence of PL 83-591. Stop denying reality. You are staring evidence in the face and just ignoring it. PL 83-591. Have I repeated it enough times, yet?

I really don't understand your tactic here. You make a claim. I give you a piece of evidence that -directly- contradicts it. You keep restating your disproven claim and citing material that doesn't even purport to say what you claim it says. You can't make PL 83-591 go away by wishing it away. It's here. It exists. Stop pretending it doesn't, please.
 
Last edited:
The Illuminati were an obscure German group that was dissolved in 1786. They were not Freemasons.

The earliest reference that I have seen to the Illuminati as part of the secret rulers of the World is from 1797 in a series of books by a French cleric named Barruel who posited that the Illuminati were the rulers of a secret society that incorporates the Order of Templars (officially disbanded in 1314); the Freemasons; Voltaire etc. He was apparently influenced by a Scottish mathematician called John Robinson who also blamed 'Reading Societies'.

Eventually Barruel would discover that the Illuminati were, in turn, controled by the Jews and that the Persian Mani (a 3rd century religious leader who founded Manicheeism) and The Old Man of the Mountain (the supreme ruler of the 12th century Muslim sect known as the Assasins). It is argued that this part of the conspiracy theory was created by the French political police as an attempt to influence Napolean against the Jews.

All this is taken from a history of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion called 'Warrant for Genocide' by Norman Cohn.

Anyone who takes talk of the Illuminati or the NWO seriously is simply falling for a 200 year old Conspiracy Theory that, even at the time, was obviously rubbish and has since led to the deaths of millions of Jews in pogroms from Russia to Germany. It also seems to be the basis of the Davinci Code.
 


Still wrong, do you ever actually examine what you post as evidence? As for the Cryer case, had you actually read about the case you might have noted that Cryer did not dispute the legality of income tax (apparently he saves that argument for nutty conventions). He argued that he did not think the weird little trust fund he set up to pay himself was taxable. The jury believed this defence, essentially a plea of stupidity. He must still pay the taxes and, as the parties noted afterwards, it's a one off defence. Like the Canadian case, he cannot use it again. As case precedent it's worthless in any argument against the legality of income tax.
 
It's bizarre you can keep claiming there is no law when I keep telling you what it is. It's Public Law 83-591.

While I appreciate your attempt to educate me by pasting someone elses thoughts and opinion, you haven't really accomplished anything.

First, and most important, you have changed the subject. You said there is no law. I told you there is. I told you it's citation. I told you when it was signed. I told you who signed it.

What did you do? You said I was wrong and changed the subject by pasting off-topic nonsense.

Please stop telling us the law doesn't exist when I'm showing it to you. It's Public Law 83-591.


As for the actual document, it's chock full of myths.

The income is a direct tax but does not require apportionment. See 16th amendment.

The 16th amendment conferred no new power of taxation because Congress already had the power. It is a commonly held and -mistaken- belief that the 16th amendment gave Congress the power to tax income. It didn't.

Your memo ignores the -fact- that Congress always had the power to tax income.



Tom Cryer did _not_ win his case against the IRS. Tom Cryer won a CRIMINAL case against the US government by being found NOT GUILTY of tax evasion.

Repeat after me: HE WAS NOT CLEARED OF HIS TAX LIABILITY. HE JUST GETS TO PAY HIS BACK TAXES WITHOUT GOING TO JAIL.

Do you understand? Maybe I need to repeat it: HE WAS NOT CLEARED OF HIS TAX LIABILITY.

Nothing in that memo proves to me the dis-existance of something I've already demonstrated to exist. PL 83-591.

I have. Many times. Nothing about that document disproves the very OBVIOUS existence of PL 83-591. Stop denying reality. You are staring evidence in the face and just ignoring it. PL 83-591. Have I repeated it enough times, yet?

I really don't understand your tactic here. You make a claim. I give you a piece of evidence that -directly- contradicts it. You keep restating your disproven claim and citing material that doesn't even purport to say what you claim it says. You can't make PL 83-591 go away by wishing it away. It's here. It exists. Stop pretending it doesn't, please.

Why do you choose to be a lier? why not be honest?. dont lie and say the document is full with myths, its not. the governemnt is full with criminals, do you get that?, are you on their side? are you a cop?.

PL 83-591 is not the law as the memo proves. the 16th amendment passed in 1913 does not give theme new powers to tax (they didnt have powers to tax before, as everybody know)

This is pathetic

why do you IGNORE the court cases that says the 16th amendment didnt give theme new powers to tax.

TOMMY CRYER BEAT THE IRS IN COURT HE DIDNT PAY HIS INCOME TAX HE WON IN COURT AND DIDNT HAFT TO PAY. how STUPID are you?? there is NO law and thats WHY he WON he didnt haft to pay.

go and work for the IRS
Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So when faced with evidence, you resort to belligerence. Interesting.

Why do you choose to be a lier? why not be honest?. dont lie and say the document is full with myths, its not. the governemnt is full with criminals, do you get that?, are you on their side? are you a cop?.

I don't really appreciate being called a liar by someone who has refused all the evidence given him and refused to check it for himself. You've provided absolutely no evidence, whatsoever, that anything I have said is a lie. All you've done is proclaim me to be a liar.

At the end of the day, your opinion of me is equally as worthless as my opinion of you. At the end of the day, what matters is the evidence we bring to the table. I've brought the evidence. PL 83-591.

PL 83-591 is not the law as the memo proves. the 16th amendment passed in 1913 does not give theme new powers to tax (they didnt have powers to tax before, as everybody know)
The boldfaced part is flat wrong. Not only is it flat wrong, but you disproved this myth yourself. Did _YOU_ read the memo _YOU_ posted? Let me copy the appropriate part for you.

". . . The provisions of the Sixteenth Amendment conferred no new power of taxation but simply prohibited the previous complete and plenary power of income taxation possessed by Congress from the beginning from being taken out of the category of indirect taxation to which it inherently belonged and being placed in the category of direct taxation subject to apportionment by a consideration of the sources from which the income was derived, . . ."
Stanton, supra, at 112-3
(emphasis added)
Please notice. YOU posted this. It says, _very_ clearly, that Congress already had the power to tax incomes.

why do you IGNORE the court cases that says the 16th amendment didnt give theme new powers to tax.
WHy do you IGNORE the _same_ court case that says that Congress already had the power to do so?

TOMMY CRYER BEAT THE IRS IN COURT HE DIDNT PAY HIS INCOME TAX HE WON IN COURT AND DIDNT HAFT TO PAY. how STUPID are you?? there is NO law and thats WHY he WON he didnt haft to pay.
Wrong. He didn't go to jail. He still had to pay. Nowhere in a "not-guilty" verdict for tax evasion does it mean he's cleared from his tax liability. Show me -any- proof, at all, that he was cleared of tax liability. You can't. Because it's not true.

The sad truth is that people found not guilty of tax evasion still have to pay their taxes.

Listen for yourself.
http://hearliberty.com/ameradio013104h2.mp3

Tax protester found not guilty of tax evasion... still had to pay all the taxes.

Edited by chillzero: 
Edited for civility
Wish I had gotten to see the original.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom