A Dragon in my Garage - Questions

"In the absence of scientific evidence that there is __________ don't believe in _________"?

Not believing in something is a different opinion to believing its opposite.

EG: I'm going to toss a coin. I don't believe it will land heads up. Does that mean I believe it will land tails up?

No.
I have no belief either way.


And Sagan's advice makes sense. Because the list of things without evidence can get very long.
 
Last edited:
Not believing in something is a different opinion to believing its opposite.

EG: I'm going to toss a coin. I don't believe it will land heads up. Does that mean I believe it will land tails up?

No.
I have no belief either way.


And Sagan's advice makes sense. Because the list of things without evidence can get very long.

I've been re-reading that story and there is one thing Carl Sagan never pointed out. Why should I care whether there was an invisible dragon? I can think of many reasons why I would care and if I did care I wouldn't stop looking for him even if science couldn't prove he was or wasn't there. I'd try to find other ways to find out.
 
But caring about a god means that you have to assume that whatever ways you are learning what it is he does and wants is as subject to fault and delusion and confirmation bias as every other god belief past and present. There is no reason to imagine the knowledge you have or the god that you believe in to be more real or more worth exploring than Zeus or Allah or Xenu. You are imagining someone who wants you to believe in them and get to know them--but they've left no clear rubric and tons of people are sure they know the truth and none of them believe the same thing. The majority of god believers past and present must be wrong by virtue of the fact that the beliefs are in conflict and no believer has access to any more measurable evidence than any other believer and all believers are human-- who are very prone to these kinds of beliefs when indoctrinated young.

So you can never ever know if the god you believe in is more true or real or right than any other god and you still will be going to hell according to most religions because they all seem to be certain different things are required for heaven and different things land a person in hell. And if you believe in such things, then you have to either assume you have somehow gotten "the truth" knowing that most of humanity has been deceived... or you have to wonder if you may be screwing up your eternity for a wrong belief.

I think non-belief makes the most sense. I don't understand the confidence people get in their myths. If your god was as much of a myth as gods you find mythological and/or if there were no gods and you were fooling yourself, would you want to know?

I think your answer is no. And that just isn't very skeptical. You believe in your god and you don't want to know that you might be wrong. That is the opposite of skepticism and science.

Why should you care about a god that you've invented in your head and not other gods or other powers or demons? I think you care because you are afraid you'll be punished by this invisible guy for doubting and you'll feel embarrassed that you fooled yourself into accepting common mental illusions as special messages for the magical creator of all giving special messages to you via signs and telepathic good feelings.

You wanted to see a shoot star and you saw one? Perhaps you saw one subconsciously out of the corner of your eye and hoped to see another one. And there happened to be a meteor shower that night... or the invisible guy in the sky could have altered physics for one of billions 0f humans in a speck of a planet to push photons in such a way as to give you a special sign.

And learn why we perceive flowers as beautiful and why they evolved with the colors and designs they have... it's not magic or god.... and flowers aren't "beautiful" to anyone outside of the earthly critters who evolved to prefer the site of some things and not so much others.
 
Last edited:
So you can never ever know if the god you believe in is more true or real or right than any other god and you still will be going to hell according to most religions because they all seem to be certain different things are required for heaven and different things land a person in hell.

I'm not sure what heaven or hell have anything to do with just trying to find if he exists and going from there. But yes, those would also be things one would have to consider once they come to that point.

I think non-belief makes the most sense. I don't understand the confidence people get in their myths. If your god was as much of a myth as gods you find mythological ... would you want to know?
Absolutely.

and/or if there were no gods and you were fooling yourself, would you want to know?

I think it wouldn't be me fooling myself unless I was following a religion I created.


You believe in your god and you don't want to know that you might be wrong.
If you can prove to me there is no God that would be helpful. That's what these posts are meant for - to see why people don't believe. But so far they don't show me anything that make me think I'm wrong that there is a God or even that there might be a God. I definitely don't know how I could say that I know there is no god.

Why should you care about a god that you've invented in your head and not other gods or other powers or demons?
I only care about the god not a god or any other god. I don't really care about following any sub-god if there is such a thing.

I think you care because you are afraid you'll be punished by this invisible guy for doubting and you'll feel embarrassed that you fooled yourself into accepting common mental illusions as special messages for the magical creator of all giving special messages to you via signs and telepathic good feelings.

Well - the God I follow doesn't punish people for doubting.

You wanted to see a shoot star and you saw one? Perhaps you saw one subconsciously out of the corner of your eye and hoped to see another one. And there happened to be a meteor shower that night... or the invisible guy in the sky could have altered physics for one of billions 0f humans in a speck of a planet to push photons in such a way as to give you a special sign.

Possibly either way. This happened after I was already a Christian, so I never saw it as more than anything but nice of him to do if he did it. Never proof for anything. I would hope no one else would consider that proof of anything. But it's what happened so I add that to my life's experience and compare it to everything else I know and experience and measure it's importance and adjust my beliefs accordingly if need be. Go by your own life's experience - not mine.
 
Last edited:
No... I go by common life experiences. If you visited a tribal community at the same time as a natural disaster they might think you brought the disaster. If they killed you and never had the disaster again they might think of that as confirmation that they were right. If they had the disaster again, they would look for the next person that needed killing. I think humans look for "signs" to confirm the beliefs they've come to. I don't want to be making up signs. I've been there and done that... but it still didn't make it any more likely to be true. The feelings that felt truest and best to me were more Eastern-- reincarnation... god never made sense... but even though those beliefs felt good and I found signs affirming that belief to me... I was also aware that other people were equally sure and seeing signs for stuff I knew they had to be fooling themselves on. I decided that I was more interested in whether I was fooling myself than whether I could feel the truth. And I came to the conclusion, that I was--and all theists are. They cannot know what they claim to know... they can only "feel" like they know something... and then confirm that something via confirmation bias like "shooting stars" as signs. It's exactly what mentalists are doing... it's so easy to see once you've thought your way out of it...

I do go by my own experiences. But I am trying to understand how people of assorted beliefs who come here so certain of some proposition are able to see other woo as "woo" but not subject their own "woo" beliefs to the same scrutiny. Why do you imagine other people believe such different things. They can't all be right, right? It just sounds weirdly arrogant to me the way everyone is sure that they've achieved some "subjective truth"-- but reality isn't subjective and god isn't supposed to be. Nobody thinks of their god as imaginary. So I just think that people that believe in gods are the same as people who believe in rain dances or psychics or demons or all the other things people believe in that have never been demonstrated to exist. It's a fake answer. A non-answer. You believe because you "feel" there must be a god because someone indoctrinated you with that belief and told you it was bad not to believe... so you've spent a lifetime spinning that truth in your head.

I think your belief started much the same way Bart Ehrman's did-- he became very religious as a teen because someone told him he had a jesus sized hole in his heart...

Michael Shermer was once an evangelical Christian too. I just hear their words echoed in yours. They are not believers any more. The reasons they use to explain why they believed before sound like yours... it just sounds so normal and human and faulty in reason to me. And I feel like you would know this if someone believed a very different thing like reincarnation or something and gave you similar anecdotes as to why.
 
I think non-belief makes the most sense. I don't understand the confidence people get in their myths. If your god was as much of a myth as gods you find mythological and/or if there were no gods and you were fooling yourself, would you want to know?

I think your answer is no. And that just isn't very skeptical. You believe in your god and you don't want to know that you might be wrong. That is the opposite of skepticism and science.

You still leave out the evidence. Do they claim evidence of their beliefs, or do they refer to their myths as myths that make sense to them?

People didn't just believe in Zeus for the sake of believing in a god. They believed because it also gave them an explanation of the world, and a sense of meaning.

Even today, when Zeus believers are somewhat hard to find, we can still derive meaning from myths. They can tell us a lot about ourselves.

When you ignore that aspect, you ignore a large part of our understanding of ourselves. So maybe it is not so strange that you have such a hard time understanding believers.

No... I go by common life experiences.
...
I do go by my own experiences.

That is precisely the same argument that people use to argue that Sylvia Browne has psychic powers.

"But my personal experience tells me so!"

Instead of your own "common life experiences", you should try evidence.
 
Instead of your own "common life experiences", you should try evidence.

Which is precisely what evidence is. Observations which are held in account of a belief.

Theists commence with a proposition - their version of a deity exists. Religion is a social paradigm which then extends around it, based on the shared faith that said deity exists.

Many theists (I might even be persuaded to think all) search for observations which compete with their reasoning that says their deity does not exist. For instance, Christians see it as a test of their faith to address the dissonance of their faith with observations that they can attest to their view of the truth.

We all have the capabilities to do this. While science itself is a method, we being people will often accept a view out of a social conditioning and accept evidence which accounts for it. Afterall, evidence in the empiricist sense is simply an observation which can be accounted for by a model we believe in.

Critical thinking is a tool which can be applied to evidence to gauge a level of confidence in whether our model is the only one which could account for that observation. Science is superior to theology in creating models of the universe because it allows us to assess observations much more efficiently than any other system.

A theist could quite honestly and truthfully say that their faith is enforced by evidence, such as a loved one recovering rapidly from an illness. Afterall, this is seriously evidence for a deity. It is also evidence for many other things...most of which are much, much more likely than supernatural intervention.

We must take care when defining evidence in such a way. Skeptics are quite quick to denounce others as not having come to a conclusion based on evidence, which is not exactly true. Often, people have arrived at a weak conclusion because they have poorly connected evidence with an unlikely cause.

Athon
 
I've been re-reading that story and there is one thing Carl Sagan never pointed out. Why should I care whether there was an invisible dragon? I can think of many reasons why I would care and if I did care I wouldn't stop looking for him even if science couldn't prove he was or wasn't there. I'd try to find other ways to find out.

So, how many other things would you expend resources to find?

I make a claim there are elves in my back yard. How long are you going to look for them until you find them?

I claim there's a dragon in my garage. How long are you going to look for him?

I claim there's an invisible god that tells me what to do.

I claim there's an invisible monster in my body.

I claim there are aliens visiting me nightly.








Are you going to follow up on every single claim I just made, and if not, then why not?


As for why should you care... I dunno. Why should I care that there is an invisible bearded man in the sky watching down on us? If you care, that's fine... but as long as the catholic church and neocons try to tell me what to do according to their religion... or as long as religious "values" keep getting in the way of good science... well... there ya go.

If religion had no power over me or mine at all, or the future of mankind, I'd be cool with it. So far, though, it's been a waste of resources and human life.
 
Last edited:
Which is precisely what evidence is. Observations which are held in account of a belief.

No, that's experience - not evidence. Evidence is a little more than merely believed observations.

If you experience a fairy does not mean you have evidence of a fairy. You have an observation, which is somewhat dubious, and is probably something else. But unless more observations are made, independently, or verifiable evidence like fairy bodies are found, there's not much more we can do about it. It's just an unverifiable anecdote.

Theists commence with a proposition - their version of a deity exists. Religion is a social paradigm which then extends around it, based on the shared faith that said deity exists.

It is important to note that they share it based on two kinds of observations: The personal observations ("Jesus came to me in a light, when I was in bed") and the shared observations (Multiple sightings of angels, or pareidolia like nuns-in-buns and jesus-in-a-cheese-sandwich).

The first kind is hard to do anything about, other than come up with natural explanations (dream, hallucination, etc). The second is far more interesting: Now we have something tangible to investigate - but we can still come up with natural explanations.

Many theists (I might even be persuaded to think all) search for observations which compete with their reasoning that says their deity does not exist. For instance, Christians see it as a test of their faith to address the dissonance of their faith with observations that they can attest to their view of the truth.

We all have the capabilities to do this. While science itself is a method, we being people will often accept a view out of a social conditioning and accept evidence which accounts for it. Afterall, evidence in the empiricist sense is simply an observation which can be accounted for by a model we believe in.

An observation that can be independently verified, yes. Otherwise, you end up as a new Blondlot.

Critical thinking is a tool which can be applied to evidence to gauge a level of confidence in whether our model is the only one which could account for that observation. Science is superior to theology in creating models of the universe because it allows us to assess observations much more efficiently than any other system.

Science is superior to theology in creating models of the universe that are better at explaining it. The models are far better supported.

A theist could quite honestly and truthfully say that their faith is enforced by evidence, such as a loved one recovering rapidly from an illness. Afterall, this is seriously evidence for a deity. It is also evidence for many other things...most of which are much, much more likely than supernatural intervention.

We must take care when defining evidence in such a way. Skeptics are quite quick to denounce others as not having come to a conclusion based on evidence, which is not exactly true. Often, people have arrived at a weak conclusion because they have poorly connected evidence with an unlikely cause.

That's where skepticism comes in, in the form of Occam's razor. Is it really evidence in favor of a god, when we have natural explanations?

If everything can be called evidence of anything, then "evidence" loses its meaning.

"Hvis alt er lige gyldigt, så er alt ligegyldigt"
(Danish pun: If everything is equally valid, then everything is indifferent)
 
I've been re-reading that story and there is one thing Carl Sagan never pointed out. Why should I care whether there was an invisible dragon? I can think of many reasons why I would care and if I did care I wouldn't stop looking for him even if science couldn't prove he was or wasn't there. I'd try to find other ways to find out.

I think Sagan has been clever in illustrating the chain of thoughts you'd have to go through. So it's invisible, "Does it leave footprints?" So it floats, "what about the draft from its wings beating?" It doesn't fly, it just floats. And so on.

All methods of finding evidence for the dragon are attempts to answer: "what's the difference between an invisible, incorporeal, floating dragon who spits heatless fire and no dragon at all?"

btw,
Do you think that forming a belief would help in the search for evidence?
 
So, how many other things would you expend resources to find?

I make a claim there are elves in my back yard. How long are you going to look for them until you find them?

I claim there's a dragon in my garage. How long are you going to look for him?

I claim there's an invisible god that tells me what to do.

I claim there's an invisible monster in my body.

I claim there are aliens visiting me nightly.

Are you going to follow up on every single claim I just made, and if not, then why not?

That's a great question, Lonewolf. I would have to honestly answer that if I felt any of those claims mattered to my life I would search for them. But me personally, I don't really care if any of those claims are true (except the god one). All I care about is whether there is an ultimate god out there - anything less for me isn't really worthy of my time. For other people, apparently it is. Now if any of those claims impact my life somehow then I would look into them. For example: If I felt the invisible dragon was a threat to me or people I care about I'd investigate until I felt he wasn't there or that he wasn't a threat. If I thought the invisible dragon was god, then I suppose I'd investigate that too. But if he's just an invisible dragon then if he's there then strange, might be interesting how he is invisible, but really - I don't care.

As for why should you care... I dunno. Why should I care that there is an invisible bearded man in the sky watching down on us? If you care, that's fine... but as long as the catholic church and neocons try to tell me what to do according to their religion... or as long as religious "values" keep getting in the way of good science... well... there ya go.
I totally agree. Don't believe in something simply because some "expert" tells you to.
 
I think forming beliefs ensures you'll see things as evidence and draw incorrect inferences, because science shows us people do exactly this.

I have Claus on ignore, but if his tangential question was towards me, I was merely answering Christian Skeptics claim that one most look for their own evidence. Subjective experiences and inferences are not useful evidence for understand the truth as one can readily see when looking at the evidence claimed for things one does not believe in... those who look at their horoscope or visit psychics. And the idea that one should believe or seek evidence if the proposition is important is similar to telling someone that buried treasure is buried in their back yard... it would be a pain to believe it if it wasn't so, and you could waste a lot of time and energy looking for it if you thought there was a good reason to believe it. The same goes for Atlantis.

My house has a floor safe in the floor of a closet which I didn't discover until years after I bought it. The house was an older house in foreclosure. I've tried various ways to open the safe or find the combination, but so far I've been unsuccessful. It would cost be a hundred dollars to have someone come out at do it for me. But so far, the chance for there to be something worthwhile in there feels less likely than any effort I want to spend.

With god, I figured there IS no way to know if there is a god or if you are accessing the right one and doing the right thing to please him if he is conscious or whatever. It seems like a cruel mind game... like telling people there is treasure buried in their back yard and they must keep searching, and it's their fault if they don't find it. I can't even imagine how consciousness can exist without a body--or sensory organs for input... how could a god want, think, remember, know-- without a brain... and why should I care if I won't have a brain after I die. You can't even make new memories without a brain organ called the hippocampus... and there is a genetic disorder that makes it impossible to feel pain... so how can we be anything without a brain? How could a god? How can anyone "know" anything about invisible undetectable entities or forces? And if they assume they do... how can they assume they are correct when others are clearly wrong with the same "types" of "sources" and "evidence".

I think it's all an appeal to ignorance--someone must be in charge... someone somewhere must understand... and egotism "I'm here for a special reason"-- "I'm chosen".

I just don't think faith and feelings and anecdotes and cryptic signs and coincidences are a very good foundation to build an objective view of the reality we all share. To me, all gods are invisible dragons... there is nothing to distinguish them from such--they all have assorted traits that are wholly invented in the mind of the assorted believers as far as I can tell... and they pretend they all believe in the same thing though the details are very different as are the wants and the rubric of these gods--what he does and why and when and who he gives "special signs" too.

How can any god envisioned by a human be any more truer than any other god envisioned by a human. How could anyone actually "know" there was a god and that their "evidence" meant what they've inferred it to mean?
 
Y'know, I may not agree with Christian Skeptic on the whole sky-daddy thing, but I like 'im so far.

Can we keep him? Plz?

I'd prefer a hundred Christian Skeptics to one Claus.
 
Last edited:
Y'know, I may not agree with Christian Skeptic on the whole sky-daddy thing, but I like 'im so far.

Can we keep him? Plz?

I'd prefer a hundred Christian Skeptics to one Claus.

I agree, I haven't agreed with almost a single thing he has said (about religion), I think, but he seems like a genuinly nice guy... ACS that is, not Claus :)
 
I've been re-reading that story and there is one thing Carl Sagan never pointed out. Why should I care whether there was an invisible dragon?
What if people tell you you can't be a good person because you don't believe there was an invisible dragon? What if people were making decisions on how the nation should be run because they believe there was an invisible dragon? etc.

I can think of many reasons why I would care and if I did care I wouldn't stop looking for him even if science couldn't prove he was or wasn't there. I'd try to find other ways to find out.
Like what?
 
What if people tell you you can't be a good person because you don't believe there was an invisible dragon?

You can be a good person without a dragon.

What if people were making decisions on how the nation should be run because they believe there was an invisible dragon? etc.

I would only care about the decisions being made. If they are good decisions I wouldn't care.
 
You can be a good person without a dragon.
But that may, or may not, be the way things are. There are people who state, and act upon, the opposite of what you stated. You recognize that one doesn't need the IPU (or dragon, etc) to be good; other people are not that way.

I would only care about the decisions being made. If they are good decisions I wouldn't care.
But what if they are not good decisions.


You asked why you should care if someone claims there is an invisible dragon. I have provided answers. That those answers are not applicable to you as an individual does not mean they are not valid answers.
 
That's a great question, Lonewolf. I would have to honestly answer that if I felt any of those claims mattered to my life I would search for them. But me personally, I don't really care if any of those claims are true (except the god one). All I care about is whether there is an ultimate god out there - anything less for me isn't really worthy of my time. For other people, apparently it is. Now if any of those claims impact my life somehow then I would look into them. For example: If I felt the invisible dragon was a threat to me or people I care about I'd investigate until I felt he wasn't there or that he wasn't a threat. If I thought the invisible dragon was god, then I suppose I'd investigate that too. But if he's just an invisible dragon then if he's there then strange, might be interesting how he is invisible, but really - I don't care.
When I was a kid, for a short period of time (a few weeks) I had the idea that I had been kidnapped by aliens. I remember thinking that my whole family were aliens, that I wasn't really on earth any more, I was just in a small "city" that included only the places I usually go, and that if, for instance, my family went on vacation to somewhere that was supposedly another city I'd be taken (while sleeping in the car) to some other manufactured city made to look like what I expected that place to be.
I was very frightened of this. I remember thinking that my brothers had some sinister ulterior motives when we were playing together. I didn't know why I had been kidnapped, but I was sure there was some evil reason. I even worried that i had been kidnapped at birth and my whole life had been lived with aliens.
I'm not sure if I came up with this scenario myself, or if my older brothers told it to me to scare me.

Anyway, it could have been true. It could still be true. Why shouldn't I worry about this as much as the existence of god?
There are things I could do to try to expose my position as someone kidnapped by aliens. I might try to stop them from doing whatever it is that they're doing. All of this (if true) should matter to me very much.

Why is the idea of god more important?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom