Bush Peace Plan - Let the thieves win

I object to the (only) calling the Arab neighbors of Israel "warlike". Yes, they are at war (formally) with Israel for 60 years now - Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Saudi Arabia and maybe others - but if we look at the episodes of armed conflict, they were as often started by Israel as by its neighbors. 1956 was an unprovoked attack by Israel on Egypt; 1967 started by Israel (called a "preemptive strike"); the 1982 invasion of Lebanon was also started by Israel. As to obliterate cities: have you forgotten how Israel wreaked havoc on Lebanon and Beirut in particular in 1982 and again in 2006?

Really, 1956 was unprovoked? Arab states, and Egypt in particular, created and supported the Fedayeen who conducted cross-border raids against Israelis. The Fedayeen were trained and equipped by Egyptian Intelligence; infiltrating Israel to commit acts of sabotage and murder. Add that to Nasser's soviet arms deal (announced as "Egypt has decided to dispatch her heroes, the disciples of pharaoh and the sons of Islam and they will cleanse the Land of Israel. ... There will be no peace on Israel's border because we demand vengeance, and vengeance is Israel's death.")

And if you think 1967 wasn't justified then I guess you have a problem with the whole concept of self defence...

etc etc


I wouldn't ascribe a particular "warlike" nature to the Arabs; it is not ingrained for centuries in their culture like it was with both the Germans (at least the Prussians) and the Japanese. The Arabs' abominable war track record does not speak for that either.

.

Just because you like something doesn't make you good at it.
 
I object to the (only) calling the Arab neighbors of Israel "warlike". Yes, they are at war (formally) with Israel for 60 years now - Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Saudi Arabia and maybe others - but if we look at the episodes of armed conflict, they were as often started by Israel as by its neighbors. 1956 was an unprovoked attack by Israel on Egypt; 1967 started by Israel (called a "preemptive strike"); the 1982 invasion of Lebanon was also started by Israel. As to obliterate cities: have you forgotten how Israel wreaked havoc on Lebanon and Beirut in particular in 1982 and again in 2006?
Revisionist history for $500 Alex!

Israel is a very small country if you haven't noticed, and they are well within their rights to strike first when their neighbors who have vowed to destroy them start massing troops on the border. And did you miss the part where Lebanon had become a haven for the PLO in 1982, or that Hezbollah (part of the Lebanese government in case you don't know) entered Israel proper and kidnapped (and most likely killed) Israeli soldiers in 2006? No nation except Israel, apparently, is supposed to tolerate such things.

I wouldn't ascribe a particular "warlike" nature to the Arabs; it is not ingrained for centuries in their culture like it was with both the Germans (at least the Prussians) and the Japanese. The Arabs' abominable war track record does not speak for that either.
Surely, this is a joke? Read up on Khalid bin Walid and Saladin and rectify that with your hilarious premise that Arabs are somehow the only people on earth who don't have a history of warfare. Success or lack thereof is hardly relevant.

Further, I'd like to stress the fact that the Arab Leag
ue has put out a peace proposal and thus far, Israel hasn't really said, we'll talk. There have been several other Arab initiatives to come to peace, which were never reciprocated by Israel.
Oh please, lets hear the details! Does it include the "right of return"? Maybe that will be a clue why Israel has been cool to it. While you're at it, can you tell me which Palestinian leader or faction has said they would ever recognize Israel's right to exist? What about that inconvenient language in the Palestinian Charter? You know, the stuff they said they'd change in 1996 but never got around to actually changing?

I won't go into the question about "nations" or "people" in 1948, but what happened the last twenty years makes clear that the Palestinians consider themselves a nation, distinct from the Jordanians. Therefore, they should also have their own state.
The only thing the Palestinians have made clear in the last 20 years is that they have no intention of ever living in peace with Israel.
 
Last edited:
So, do you think Israel should return the West Bank to Jordan?

Israel should return West Bank to Jordan.
I really should take up fishing as a hobby, because there's something very satisfying and appealing about carefully baiting a hook, casting it onto the waters, and watching as an unsuspecting fish you weren't even trying to catch chomps down on it.

The West Bank was controlled by Iraqi and Jordanian forces at the end of the 1948 War and the area was annexed by Jordan in 1950 but this annexation was recognized only by the United Kingdom
 
  1. . . . unless you believe the US Intelligence Community is idiot ridden, which I don't.

  2. Actually, the US and MANY other countries have taken and kept land long after the Middle Ages were over.
If I were a woman, I'd ask if I could bear your children.

As it is, my plumbing does not permit such an offer.

DR
 
Why?

E.J. and most of the world want Israel to return to the boundaries that Israel had from 1949 until 1967.
In that case, the French need to give Alsace and Lorraine back to Germany, since future events do not redraw the boundaries established in the Franco-Prussian War. :rolleyes:

You can't have it both ways, fool.

DR
 
Last edited:
So:
Germany gains territory, in 1871... then starts a war in 1914.
Germany loses territory in 1945... no more wars.

Perhaps the key to not starting more wars is when the population realizes what irresponsible aggression can cost them. Germans learnt that by 1945, and history/holocaust etc education has kept it fresh.
The problem with this comparison is that it does not scale. WW1 and WW2 were of such a devastating scale that this did make a lasting impression on all sides. France basically already had no morale in WW2 due to the sufferings on WW1. Plus to that the (German) guilt about the Holocaust, and you're set indeed that it won't happen again. But we wouldn't want to repeat that, would we?

In comparison, the death toll of the whole ME conflict, from 1947 to now, on all sides added, is less than that in anyone European country involved in WW2 individually, with the exception of Denmark and Luxembourg.

Perhaps if Palestinians realized that they would be held accountable for their actions by the international community (i.e. no halt in terror attacks - no movement along the roadmap) (vote in Hamas - no aid) then perhaps they would mend their ways...
What strikes me at such things is that always the Palestinians are painted as terrorists and the Israelis as lily-white. The numbers are clear though: for every Israeli victim of the conflict, 4 to 5 Palestinians are killed. You can see that in this press release of B'Tselem, an Israeli human rights organization. Isn't this Israeli violence as objectionable? Or even more, as Israel has the most modern and precise arms one can get today? Instead, Israel chooses to, e.g., put a missile in a whole apartment building to eliminate one top-shot Hamas man, killing a dozen innocent people in the process. And we all remember the footage of the first Intifada, where Israeli soldiers shot with live rounds at kids throwing stones.

And Israeli violence goes further than the killings say. Regularly closing off Gaza, not even letting food in, is part and parcel. Flying low with jets over Gaza, breaking the sound barrier is also part of the terror. The IDF regularly raids civilians' houses. Bullying at checkpoints. Over 800 Palestinians are in what's called "administrative detention": no indictment, no trial, no habeas corpus. In the rest of the world, that's called putting people in a concentration camp. Then there's the Apartheid Wall, which separates many farmers from their land, and lies on occupied territory. And the ever-growing settlements, which are built on land of which 30% is confiscated from Palestinian landowners.

I don't censure the Palestinians for fighting for their freedom in their own country. I don't censure them for voting Hamas - though I do despise every form of religious fundamentalism, Hamas's included. I don't think Hamas won on that account, but on account of its grassroots work and on account of Fatah's corruption. But we should respect the outcome of a democratic election, even if it doesn't suit us. Must I remind that we (Bush) insisted that Hamas could participate in the election? It does not become us to then say that they voted "wrong".

I don't censure Hamas either for resisting Israel, and don't call them terrorists for it - we don't call George Washington a terrorist either, do we? I do censure all parties for acts that disregard (civilian) human life.

Finally, as to the roadmap you mention: the current roadmap is a joke. It was set up by Sharon, and Bush willingly obliged (and in his footsteps, the EU). But if we look at the first attempt, from Oslo to Taba, then we can see that there was a clear timetable for Israeli retreat from the West Bank, and Netanyahu derailed that timetable. We've even seen the Israeli tanks besiege Arafat's residency, and we've seen the Israelis shelling the cities that were built up with our tax euros.
 
The problem with this comparison is that it does not scale. WW1 and WW2 were of such a devastating scale that this did make a lasting impression on all sides. France basically already had no morale in WW2 due to the sufferings on WW1. Plus to that the (German) guilt about the Holocaust, and you're set indeed that it won't happen again. But we wouldn't want to repeat that, would we?

In comparison, the death toll of the whole ME conflict, from 1947 to now, on all sides added, is less than that in anyone European country involved in WW2 individually, with the exception of Denmark and Luxembourg.

(...snip...)

We've even seen the Israeli tanks besiege Arafat's residency, and we've seen the Israelis shelling the cities that were built up with our tax euros.
So you're saying the Israelis would have to step up their bombings of Gaza and the West Bank to WW II proportions before the Palestinians get a clue? :confused:
 
I don't censure the Palestinians for fighting for their freedom in their own country.

Except it isn't freedom that the terrorists are fighting for. Read Hamas's charter sometime. You will search in vain for any mention of freedom. In fact, the only appearance of "free" is when they mention Freemasons in a rambling bit of conspiracy paranoia.

I don't censure them for voting Hamas - though I do despise every form of religious fundamentalism, Hamas's included.

In other words, you excuse them from doing what you consider to be wrong. Why would you do that?

But we should respect the outcome of a democratic election, even if it doesn't suit us.

What do you mean by "respect" the outcome? Do you mean accept that that's what happened? We did. Do you mean not change our policy towards them because of it? Why shouldn't we? One of the singular advantages of promoting democracy elsewhere is that it allows consequences to be attached to the decisions of the entire population, and hence promotes rational decision making. But if you try to insulate people from any consequences for their decisions, you're not actually helping.

I don't censure Hamas either for resisting Israel,

What, exactly, do you mean by "resisting" Israel? Honestly, how is this anything other than a euphemism for terrorist attacks? Because that's the only significant "resistance" they have on offer.

and don't call them terrorists for it

God forbid we should call a spade a spade.

- we don't call George Washington a terrorist either, do we?

No we don't, and for damn good reason. George Washington never attacked England. He never targeted civilians. He didn't glory in the slaughter of innocents. He was a rebel and an outlaw, but if you can't figure out the difference between George Washington and Sheik Yassin, you're a clueless moron. No, you're worse than that: you are one who refuses to recognize evil.
 
Last edited:
Revisionist history for $500 Alex!
Take a look in the mirror, WildCat.

Israel is a very small country if you haven't noticed, and they are well within their rights to strike first when their neighbors who have vowed to destroy them start massing troops on the border.
Referring to 1967? You may have missed that Nasser's best troops were still in Yemen.

And did you miss the part where Lebanon had become a haven for the PLO in 1982, or that Hezbollah (part of the Lebanese government in case you don't know) entered Israel proper and kidnapped (and most likely killed) Israeli soldiers in 2006? No nation except Israel, apparently, is supposed to tolerate such things.
No nation except Israel gets away with bombing a whole country into shambles for the abduction of two soldiers. And gets rewarded by the US with even bigger military aid.

ddt said:
I wouldn't ascribe a particular "warlike" nature to the Arabs; it is not ingrained for centuries in their culture like it was with both the Germans (at least the Prussians) and the Japanese. The Arabs' abominable war track record does not speak for that either.
Surely, this is a joke? Read up on Khalid bin Walid and Saladin and rectify that with your hilarious premise that Arabs are somehow the only people on earth who don't have a history of warfare. Success or lack thereof is hardly relevant.
Reading is an art too, that you apparently lack. Khalid bin Walid was in the 7th C., Saladin in the 12th C., and Saladin wasn't even an Arab. You clearly have to grasp at straws to call the current Arabs warlike. For the rest of the audience: I was, of course, referring to the fact that the German and Japanese societies were militaristic in all their fibres, that people were raised with it.

Oh please, lets hear the details! Does it include the "right of return"? Maybe that will be a clue why Israel has been cool to it.
I outlined the Saudi proposal already above.

While you're at it, can you tell me which Palestinian leader or faction has said they would ever recognize Israel's right to exist?
Arafat, as chairman of the PLO, has recognized Israel and its right to exist in 1988.

What about that inconvenient language in the Palestinian Charter? You know, the stuff they said they'd change in 1996 but never got around to actually changing?
Arafat renounced those, backed by the PLO congress, see his letter to Clinton. Clinton, Blair and Netanyahu were satisfied with that.

ddt said:
I won't go into the question about "nations" or "people" in 1948, but what happened the last twenty years makes clear that the Palestinians consider themselves a nation, distinct from the Jordanians. Therefore, they should also have their own state.
The only thing the Palestinians have made clear in the last 20 years is that they have no intention of ever living in peace with Israel.
If you look at it very selectively, as you obviously do; disregarding all crimes I listed that Israel perpetrates, and disregarding that Israel retaliates every hostile act from a Palestinian out of proportion. Violence begets violence! The big majority of the Palestinians just want to go to work, raise a family, and live in peace with their neighbors, be they Palestinians or Israelis.
 
Referring to 1967? You may have missed that Nasser's best troops were still in Yemen.
So what?

No nation except Israel gets away with bombing a whole country into shambles for the abduction of two soldiers. And gets rewarded by the US with even bigger military aid.
The whole country was bombed to shambles? I must have missed that in the news! Unless you're referring to the photoshopped pics that Hezbollah's media arm was putting out.

Reading is an art too, that you apparently lack. Khalid bin Walid was in the 7th C., Saladin in the 12th C., and Saladin wasn't even an Arab.
You're the one who denied there was a history of warfare among Arabs, I only went back that far to prove you wrong. Now you're claiming I went back too far? Bizarre. And those armies Saladin was leading were definitely Arab. How about you pick your mythical time where there was no Arab warfare so we can stop playiong wack-a-mole?

You clearly have to grasp at straws to call the current Arabs warlike.
So Saddam didn't actually invade Kuwait and attack Iran? Syria isn't meddling miltarily in Lebanon? Jihadists from all over arabia didn't flock to Afghanistan in the 1980's?

Are you serious?

Arafat, as chairman of the PLO, has recognized Israel and its right to exist in 1988.
Arafat lied, Palestine has never accepted Israel's right to exist and never changed their charter to reflect that.

Arafat renounced those, backed by the PLO congress, see his letter to Clinton. Clinton, Blair and Netanyahu were satisfied with that.
So it will be no problem for you to link to the updated Charter showing these revisions, yes? In particular, Article 33 makes clear that the only way to amend the Charter is by "a majority of two-thirds of the total membership of the National Congress of the Palestine Liberation Organization [taken] at a special session convened for that purpose". So when was this special session? :rolleyes:


If you look at it very selectively, as you obviously do; disregarding all crimes I listed that Israel perpetrates, and disregarding that Israel retaliates every hostile act from a Palestinian out of proportion.
Self-defense is not a crime and never has been. And Israel is under no mandate to tie one hand behind its back in order to respond proportionally. War doesn't work that way. If the Palestinians want peace all they have to do is to stop fighting, period. But the fact of the matter is it is a sick, twisted death culture that loves war more than they love their own children.
 
Last edited:
I really should take up fishing as a hobby, because there's something very satisfying and appealing about carefully baiting a hook, casting it onto the waters, and watching as an unsuspecting fish you weren't even trying to catch chomps down on it.
wiki said:
The West Bank was controlled by Iraqi and Jordanian forces at the end of the 1948 War and the area was annexed by Jordan in 1950 but this annexation was recognized only by the United Kingdom

Great :D. Thanks for the info. I suspected there was one or two states recognizing the attempted annexation.

I didn't suspect you deliberately planting this bait.
 
EJ Armstrong's peace plan: Let's give everyone their land back. OK, but to be fair, we should include everyone in the world who ever had stolen, right? Or just the Israelis, but everyone else gets to keep their stolen land?

Every tribe, every city, every nation that ever conquered another people and took their land should give it back, right? California should go back to Mexico, and all descendents of Europeans and Africans should return to their respective continents and let the various Native American tribes have their land back. Every diaspora should return whence they came.

Let's bring in archeologists and historians and figure out exactly who originally owned what, who conquered who, etc. and give it all back.

You're making me go back to Ireland! No fair! (Go Celtic!)
 
In your mind only.

West Bank was under Iraq and Jordan in 1948, Israel's boundaries were drawn in 1949 so it should return like I said.

That it was under Jordan in 1950, and recognized as such only by U.K., that's an anecdote that doesn't have importance to what I said.
 
Last edited:
In that case, the French need to give Alsace and Lorraine back to Germany, since future events do not redraw the boundaries established in the Franco-Prussian War. :rolleyes:

You can't have it both ways, fool.

DR
I don't care that much about Alsace and Lorraine, France should give them back to Germany if what you say it's true but they were France's before the Franco-Prussian war.
 
In your mind only.

West Bank was under Iraq and Jordan in 1948, Israel's boundaries were drawn in 1949 so it should return like I said.

That it was under Jordan in 1950, and recognized as such only by U.K., that's an anecdote that doesn't have importance to what I said.
Ion, you got pwned. Just be a big boy and admit it.
 
Ion, you got pwned. Just be a big boy and admit it.
What an idiot.

No wonder the U.S. standards are low, with idiots like this.

Like:

"-What time it is?"

"-Around 2:30."

"-Gotcha! It's 2:34!"

It doesn't bother you imbecile, that Israel breaches U.N. Resolutions 242, 338 and the Oslo Agreement it signed, but it 'bothers' you and you 'trick' -or rather you think with low standards that you trick- into saying to whom exactly Israel should return the territories it occupies.

I haven't studied the whole history there.

Well, 242, 338 and Oslo take care of saying to whom exactly Israel should return the territories it occupies.

So there is no need for tricks regarding to whom Israel should return the occupied territories to, because 242, 338 and Oslo spell exacly that.

That's why U.N. was invented for dispensing international law and Israel signed the Oslo Agreement, so that I don't spend time on this.

Israel should obey 242, 338 and Oslo.
 
Last edited:
So you're saying the Israelis would have to step up their bombings of Gaza and the West Bank to WW II proportions before the Palestinians get a clue? :confused:
That's a bit thin considering the breadth of my post, and it doesn't quite follow from the points I brought up. It raises suspicion that this is another bait, after the "West Bank to Jordan".

But I'll play along. What happens when Israel bombs Gaza in WW2 proportions? Let's see. That means 75% of the buildings bombed into ruins and 1% civilian death toll - 15,000 people - within three weeks.

In Londen, 1 million people go to the streets to protest this. Paris, Rome and other European cities follow. In Germany, the president of the Jewish council tries to downplay the events on national TV. Next day, the NPD organizes a demonstration with anti-semitic slogans. The police, expecting as usual an anti-demonstration, show up in great numbers, but no-one shows up for an anti-demonstration. That night, the first synagogue burns. In Holland, Leon de Winter also trivializes the Israeli actions on TV. The security agencies had advised him to leave the country - e.g., to visit his friend Ayaan in New York - but on his way out of the studio, he is attacked by a young muslim and stabbed to death. Similar events in other European countries. The police guard all synagogues against attacks, but cannot prevent material damage. The Foreign Ministries call on their nationals to leave Middle-Eastern countries. The EU envoy, Tony Blair, goes to church and lights a candle for world peace. He also tries to phone his former poodle-master, but he can't get hold of him. Various European countries condemn the Israeli actions.

In Palestine, the PA government dissolves itself, saying they won't continue with the charade of trying to cooperate with Israel while Israel displays unbridled aggression. Abbas, as chairman of the PLO, flies to New York and addresses the Security Council. Syria, backed by France, Russia and China, proposes a resolution under Chapter VI, explicitly urging the use of force against Israel. John Bolton vetoes the resolution without consulting his boss - afraid that the motorcade incident had been a "road to Damascus" for him.

In the US, Bush holds a press conference, saying he deplores Israels actions and urges them to stop. When asked about the veto, he tells the parable of the little goat. Abe Foxman also holds a press conference. He praises Israels decisive crackdown on the terrorists. CNN airs footage of Foxman's press conference split-screen with footage of the carnage in Gaza. That Saturday, 2 million people protest in front of 1600 Penn. Ave. Bush goes on vacation to his ranch. The State Department also issues warnings for US citizens in the ME.

In the Arab world, there are also massive demonstrations. 5 million people in Cairo and 1 million in Amman urge Mubarak and Abdullah to declare their peace treaties with Israel null and void. The Arab League convenes in an emergency session. Saudi King Abdullah proposes to withdraw his peace initiative, which is agreed unanimously. Instead, the League state the "four nos of Dubai". All of Israel's neighbors mobilize. The OPEC also convenes, and establishes an oil boycott against Israel and the US. Everyone agrees, even Iraq. In Iraq, meanwhile, the violence against US soldiers skyrockets.

Further east, Ahmadinejad condemns the Israeli actions, adding that this is the final proof the Holocaust did not happen, and announces to increase his arms deliveries to Hezbollah and Hamas. Russia closes billion arms deals with Egypt, Jordan and Syria.

In Pakistan, still unruly, Jihadists take power. Pakistani nuclear hero Khan travels the ME capitals to sell his nuclear technology but he is not very successful: they are not very interested in being still 15 years away from actually having a bomb.

A week after the OPEC embargo, the US govt issues a prohibition on driving SUV's. Another week later, only hybrid cars may drive. Al Gore says on Saturday Night Live that the Israeli aggression is actually part of the effort against global warming. His son demonstrates meanwhile that a Prius can even do 120 mph.

In Israel, there are hefty debates in the Knesset. The Arab parties heavily criticize the government. Likud, of course, praises the government and urges to step up the bombing until the last cockroach is dead. Labor resigns from the government, and Olmert hails Likud into government. Lieberman proposes to relocate Arab Israelis from the Galilee to Gaza, because now there is room for them.

At first, there is a gung-ho atmosphere in Israel, in which everyone gloats about the successes. All newspapers, including Haaretz, sing praise of the IAF. As the news of foreign reactions comes, and the effects of the oil embargo are felt, people become worried. Long lines assemble before the embassies in Tel Aviv and Jerusalem, with people who try to obtain a foreign passport. People actually emigrate. The press try to get numbers on that, but the Israeli Bureau of Statistics does not keep account of emigration numbers.

When the Russian arms deliveries come in, the Arab countries attack. Their leaders actually don't want war, but the streets are still unruly, and all leaders fear for their position. A US envoy had employed a month long shuttle diplomacy between the various countries, but as he can't satisfactorily explain the US veto he gets nowhere.

At first the IDF and the IAF are successful at repelling the attacks, but after 20 sorties the kerosene has run out. Due to shortage of diesel, the Israeli tanks get stuck halfway in the Sinai. Israel goes nuclear and sends missiles to Cairo and Damascus, doing immense damage.

The US calls for a Security Council meeting three days later. Meanwhile, Pakistan joins the war and sends its missiles to Tel Aviv, obliterating it. Israeli military planning and coordination breaks down. Millions of people flee the country.

Abbas returns to Jerusalem and proclaims the state of Palestine. Some of the Arab leaders contemplate carving a piece out of the country for themselves, but they are scared away from that by the great powers. Fatah and Hamas militants scour the country and round up the remaining Jews. Yad Vashem, built on the site of a former Palestinian village, is turned into a memorial for the Naqba.

Now what was the question again?
 
Last edited:
Now what was the question again?
I was going to nominate that for TLA until I saw you used the word "administrate."

John Derbyshire, that consummate pessimist, is somehow even more optimistic than you in predicting this:

Something inconceivably horrible will happen in the Middle East. Probably the following: The Arabs will commit some huge, gross atrocity against Israel. Surviving Israelis will respond by massacring the Palestinian Arabs, and perhaps erasing a couple of Arab capitals. 100 years of peace in the Middle East will follow.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom