Tips on finding & submitting cases
As I mentioned above, every time I whip out my Google-fu I can find more cases for the site. Many are years old, but often were never written about in the skepti-sphere. I find them buried in the oddest places, too. I found a woman who treated her cancer with homeopathy (with predictable outcome) in a
theater review in the New York Times for petes sake!
I get the feeling that there are hundreds of these cases out there, just waiting to be found. You folks can help me with this!
Tip 1: Simply combining the name of some form of woo with the word "died" or "injured", often gets amazing results. For example, "
naturopath died". It is worth nothing that Google will return variant forms of the word without you doing anything special, so for instance a search for "homeopath" will return an article with only "homeopathic" in it if the other search terms match. (It didn't used to work this way, I'm not sure when Google added that).
Tip 2: Use the archive search on Google News. Current news stories often get alot of attention here in the forums. That makes older stories much more useful. You can search older news at Google here:
http://news.google.com/archivesearch
There are tools there to limit the year as well, another good way to avoid cases I already have.
One amusing thing about this: the New York Times has over 100 years of archives online now, so if you search on "quack" or "homeopath", you can find stories from 1895 that seem not too different from the modern ones.
Remember, however, I'm deliberately confining What's The Harm to the last 50 years (with a few exceptions for notable stories). This is because I think the idea that people believed crazy stuff in 1780 is just not that surprising to anyone. For other guidelines on what I'm looking for in cases, see
http://whatstheharm.net/contact.html.
Tip 3: Please check the site to see if I already have the case! No sense wasting your time on something I already have. However, if you find a link that is better than the link I'm using on a given story, feel free to send that in.
Tip 4: Pick a category I don't have many cases in. If you don't have a favorite form of woo that you would rather concentrate on, browse the
whatstheharm.net topics list and pick a topic I have under 20 cases in. (There are a bunch). This makes it easier to avoid having to scroll through stories I already have while searching.
Tip 5: If you have non-web resources available, use them. Anybody have access to Lexis/Nexis or other non-public databases? Many news web sites cycle their stories very quickly. I've had some of my links go stale just in the four months I've been doing this. But those pay databases keep everything. I'm thinking the same search techniques that I mention above might work well there. If you can limit to older stories only, so much the better.
Finally, please start sending all CASE STORIES to this address:
SUBMIT (at)
WHATSTHEHARM (dot)
NET
I can manage the workload better using the email as a queue. One case per email with the victim's name in the subject line makes that even easier, but I'll take anything you send me!
Thanks again for all the help.