Richard Gage just keeps getting dumber

Terral

You don't appear to understand the nature of debate.

YOU have proposed that "many" construction professionals support your argument. It is incumbent upon you to support that assertion when challenged. If you can't substantiate it - and I know you can't, because it's simply untrue that any notable proportion of said community has voiced concerns - then it's bollocks.

Put up, or shut up.
 
Terral, do you not understand the inherent contradiction of claiming that huge explosions blew out all the windows for a 400 foot radius, and then claiming that nobody heard this because they used thermite, which does not explode? Not to mention the fact that there is no evidence of all these windows being blown out, despite the hundreds of pictures and videos of the events.

Not to mention all the people who would have had their eardrums blown out by such an event.
 
Just an aside, Terral, do YOU accept that normal office fires can cause failure of structural steelwork?
 
The Architect Is Still Talking, Because He Has No "Building Fire Did It" Case

Hi Architect:

Architect >> You don't appear to understand the nature of debate.


Debate is about the presentation of opposing views.

Architect >> YOU have proposed that "many" construction professionals support your argument. It is incumbent upon you to support that assertion when challenged. If you can't substantiate it - and I know you can't, because it's simply untrue that any notable proportion of said community has voiced concerns - then it's bollocks. Put up, or shut up.


Since I am a registered member of AE911Truth.org, then perhaps I am in a better position to represent the views of those 266 architects and engineers than you. I suppose you think this group of professionals is petitioning Congress for a new 9/11 investigation, because they agree with the Bush Administration “Building Fires Did It” Fantasy; but this guy is not buying any of that for one second. Are we to assume by your insinuations that no “WTC-7 Collapsed From Building Fires” Thesis paper is coming from your “professional perspective?” My “WTC-7 Was Taken Down Using Controlled Demolition” Thread is posted, just in case you want to put up or shut up. Feel free to enter any of your Arups and Edinburgh University drivel if any of that appears to support your fantasy. Where is your precedent for building fires causing the demolition-style collapse of any modern day skyscraper before or since 9/11? Oh. That’s right. You do not have one. :0)

Again, this side of these debates knows darn good and well you have NO CASE, but talk yourself silly if that makes Architect happy . . .

GL,

Terral
 
The latest story on SLC has an amazing quote made by Richard Gage during a radio show with Steven Jones.



Yup, there was no pile driver. Whatsoever.

He doesn't seem to be all that far from Judy Wood's neck of the woods at this point.

And remember....Gage told me on CFRB radio that the noise of the bombs from this "extremely explosive event" was not captured on videos and microphones...because of thermite.



The building is creating this incredible mushroom cloud

Mushroom cloud? I didn't see a mushroom cloud.
 
Since I am a registered member of AE911Truth.org, then perhaps I am in a better position to represent the views of those 266 architects and engineers than you.


Are you implying that Architect was attempting to represent the views of AE911Truth? You do realize there are far, far more than 267 architects and engineers in the world, don't you? (That is, of course, ignoring the fact that many of the members of AE911Truth aren't even architects or engineers.)
 
Last edited:
No Sir. 1000 Degree Fires Simply Do NOT Melt 2800 Degree Structural Steel

Hi Architect:

Architect >> Just an aside, Terral, do YOU accept that normal office fires can cause failure of structural steelwork?


No sir. Building fires burn at around 800 to 1000 degrees and failure requires 2795 degrees to melt structural red-iron steel. This video does a wonderful job of showing these readers the difference. Dr. Steven Jones also does a good job here. The energy from any building fire is carried away from the fuel source to the cooler areas of the steel-frame network more quickly than the fire can cause proximal supports to reach failing temperatures. No sir. Open air fires have never caused the catastrophic failure of any steel-framed skyscraper and never will, because that is very much impossible.

GL,

Terral
 
Hi CHF:




Please forgive, but apparently you guys understand very little of what Richard is ineptly attempting to convey. First of all, the many explosions ‘are’ captured on video footage here and many other places, because ‘many’ different kinds of demolition charges were used in the WTC Controlled Demolition Jobs. However, the noise of ‘many bombs’ was eliminated from the WTC equation, BECAUSE the inside-job bad guys used Thermate ‘cutter charges’ to ‘sever’ MANY steel connections ‘rather than’ using TNT. This means MANY (most) of the WTC columns and beams were ‘chemically’ cut using Thermate Charges, which greatly reduced the “boom, boom, boom” from TNT charges that were removed from the equation.

You guys laugh at the conclusions of MANY professional architects and engineers drawing the same exact conclusions as Richard Gage, when the scientific data says his claims are 100 percent correct. How do you get 1500-degree “Molten Metal” pools under all three WTC skyscrapers “six weeks later” from building fires? :0) If you guys had one lick of real Architectural or Engineering sense, then you would not be actively participating in this Richard-bashing stupidity showing ‘you’ to be the real idiots without a “Building Fires Did It” thesis paper anywhere on this Board. None of you can prove building fires took down the WTC skyscrapers, because they do not burn nearly hot enough to melt or even soften red-iron structural steel.

If you really think Building Fires took down WTC-7 (like Bush = idiot), after being hit by no Jetliner or anything similar, then by all means start that thread and begin hauling out your evidence. Then the rest of us who know better can start laughing out loud at each of you. :0)

GL,

Terral

Strawman argument, shaped charges do not produce Fe3O4 cutting torch slag like on the beam cut at an angle.

The sound the firefighter hears could be a car tire popping for all we know.

Jones device is a thermal degrading oxygen cutter, however the beams in question testify to the fact that it was not used.

They show no marks of attachment and indicate intelligence behind the cut pattern, show me an intelligent device that could have made them you can do that can you not?
 
Terral, you should be aware that I am a chartered architect specialising in the design of tall structures. I have completed a number of major projects for a leading UK practice, including Manchester's tallest building, and now run my own firm. I sit on the national council and the professional practice committee of our professional institute. I am therefore in a position to comment both of the technical issues involved and, unlike you, on the wider professional views on the subject.

If you doubt any of this, as some previous posters have done, then feel free to PM Chillzero, the Mod, as she had sight of the necessary evidence of same.

Now, back on topic:

1. What evidence do you have that a substantive proportion of trained professionals have concerns about the NIST findings?

2. DO you, or do you not, believe that normal office fires can and do cause failure of structural steelwork?
 
Are you implying that Architect was attempting to represent the views of AE911Truth? You do realize there are far, far more than 267 architects and engineers in the world, don't you? (That is, of course, ignoring the fact that many of the members of AE911Truth aren't even architects or engineers.)

In fact, Terry, can you tell us just how many registered architects there are in the UK and the US respectively?
 
I suppose you think this group of professionals is petitioning Congress for a new 9/11 investigation...

But you said in a previous post that Congress already knows that 9/11 was "an inside job", so why petition them for a new investigation?
 
The Architect Can Either Make His "WTC-7 Collapsed From Building Fires" Case OR Not

Hi Cl1mh with Architect mentioned:

Cl1mh >> Are you implying that Architect was attempting to represent the views of AE911Truth? You do realize there are far, far more than 267 architects and engineers in the world, don't you? (That is, of course, ignoring the fact that many of the members of AE911Truth aren't even architects or engineers.)


Holy Cows! Am I now talking to Dumb or Dumber? :0) Let’s go back to my original statements in Post #15 of this thread:

I wrote:

Terral Original >> You guys laugh at the conclusions of MANY professional architects and engineers drawing the same exact conclusions as Richard Gage, when the scientific data says his claims are 100 percent correct.


Did I say anything about all the cotton picking architects and engineers in the world? No. My reference is to the architects and engineers over at 911Truth.org to where I provided the link in THAT SAME POST. What kind of person thinks there are only 200 building professionals on earth? Currently there are 266 architects and engineers with 914 supporters petitioning our do-nothing Congress for a new investigation shown here for those not paying attention. Now, what I want from Architect here or you or anyone is a link to 266 architects and engineers pushing the Bush Administration “Building Fires Did It” Explanation, so Mr. Architect’s statements here have some resemblance of merit:

Architect wrote:

Architect >> The architectural and engineering communities are almost completely behind the "official" study. The only debate, based upon papers by Arups and Edinburgh University, is whether a severe fire would have caused global failure even in the absence of the aircraft impact damage.


Since the “architectural and engineering communities are almost completely behind the "official" study,” then my 266 professionals must be in the minority; which means you owe me ‘more’ than just 266 of ‘your’ building professionals willing to put their reputations on the line in support of the Official “Building Fires Did It” Story. Right? You guys are out of your cotton picking tree . . . :0)

Since Architect has so much credible evidence (NOT) that the ‘official’ Bush Administration WTC-7 Cover Story is true, then he will have little trouble presenting his “WTC-7 Collapsed From Building Fires” paper in this Conspiracies Forum. Right? You guys have me laughing out loud already . . .

GL,

Terral
 
Gage Said:




I love it when alleged "scientists" talk about Disappearing Mass.

Its not wheres waldo, its "wheres the mass". I guess it must have been evaporated and then blew away.

TAM:)
Apparently the "inside-jobbers" used an yet unheard of (and fictional) anti-matter bomb that dispersed anti-matter throughout the WTC and caused the real matter to annhiliate. Hey, do you guys think I can replace Judy woowoo Wood?

BTW, anybody asks me how the anti-matter was obtained OR contained and my answer is...it's not my job to bother with such banal trivialities :D
 
Did I say anything about all the cotton picking architects and engineers in the world? No. My reference is to the architects and engineers over at 911Truth.org to where I provided the link in THAT SAME POST. What kind of person thinks there are only 200 building professionals on earth? Currently there are 266 architects and engineers with 914 supporters petitioning our do-nothing Congress for a new investigation shown here for those not paying attention. Now, what I want from Architect here or you or anyone is a link to 266 architects and engineers pushing the Bush Administration “Building Fires Did It” Explanation, so Mr. Architect’s statements here have some resemblance of merit:


Terry

You seem to be struggling with the point put to you here.

You have sought to rely on the statement that many architects and engineers support you, however the only substantiation which you have produced of same is the 266 members of AE911Truth.

"Many" is a subjective term but has been deployed by you in a manner that suggests substantive support. However 266 is not a lot at all, is? Tell me, Terry, how many chartered architects in the UK and the US? Likewise structural and fire engineers.

Now, if you only have...say...0.0001% on "your" side then it doesn't really support your case. There might be more with extreme political or racist views, but that wouldn't make them right.....would it?

So come on, what evidence do you have for substantive or substantial (whichever you prefer) support for the AE911Truth position within the wider professional communities and, if you cannot produce same, then why not?
 
This side of that debate is not holding his breath . . .
Debate?! When did you ever debate anything? Your an intellectual coward who can only "post" snake oil bs. If you are so "honest", why don't you put your money up and buy some cable access time and present your fantasy on TV? You woo are a bunch of impotent frauds.
 
BTW, anybody asks me how the anti-matter was obtained OR contained and my answer is...it's not my job to bother with such banal trivialities :D

The anti-matter store? Or perhaps ebay?
 
Open air fires have never caused the catastrophic failure of any steel-framed skyscraper and never will, because that is very much impossible.
Really?!


Either you are a filthy liar or you have the worst short term memory possible that is compatible with human (questionable) life.
 
The 911Movement Is a DoD/CIA/FBI CounterIntelligence Disinformation Front . . .

Hi Alt:

Alt >> But you said in a previous post that Congress already knows that 9/11 was "an inside job", so why petition them for a new investigation?


Richard Gage and company have yet to figure out that Congress knows more about 9/11 than anyone here. He is a very nice man with seemingly every good intention, but the inside-job bad guys have either hired a good ‘front man’ to run in place actually doing nothing, OR a guy deluded into thinking AE911Truth.org can make one lick of difference. Do you see the AE911Truth getting us anywhere near putting the real inside-job bad guys into the gas chamber? No? Neither do I . . .

From the best I can tell, the entire 911Movement is hired by the FBI/DoD/CIA Counterintelligence Disinformation Network commissioned to sell videos, CD’s and buttons, so no real 911Movement ever really gets started. That is the reason nothing is being done about the 9/11 Inside-Job and likely never will . . .

The people running these 911Movement Boards are not interested in telling 'the' 911Truth at all. They want to sell you videos on the twenty-five theories with the sequel coming out soon . . .

GL,

Terral
 
Terry

You seem to be struggling with the point put to you here.

You have sought to rely on the statement that many architects and engineers support you, however the only substantiation which you have produced of same is the 266 members of AE911Truth.

"Many" is a subjective term but has been deployed by you in a manner that suggests substantive support. However 266 is not a lot at all, is? Tell me, Terry, how many chartered architects in the UK and the US? Likewise structural and fire engineers.

Now, if you only have...say...0.0001% on "your" side then it doesn't really support your case. There might be more with extreme political or racist views, but that wouldn't make them right.....would it?

So come on, what evidence do you have for substantive or substantial (whichever you prefer) support for the AE911Truth position within the wider professional communities and, if you cannot produce same, then why not?

(cough)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom