Teenager Uses Father's Gun To Kill Entire Family

Well, that is what happened in Australia.

Do you have some kind of disability that prevents you from comprehending the studies and statistics posted here (some by you), or are you just trying to be as insulting as possible?

(For those of you playing along and who have some modicum of intellectual honesty: No, that's not what happened in Australia.)

If you're intent on ignoring the evidence presented to you, I guess there's not much more to do here.

Now if you'll excuse me, I've got to go stab someone. Apparently it's the done thing down under. :rolleyes:
 
If you watched the film "Bowling for Columbine", you should have noticed that it only spends a small amount of time on the events at the high school.

Do you believe that Michael Moore lied when he pointed out that Canadians often leave their doors unlocked?

I didn't say every word of it was a lie.

However, when a film maker, for example, stages a scene in which guns are handed out at a bank -- when, actually, customers are given a certificate to redeem at a gun store -- then faces the camera and asks, incredulously, if we think it's a good idea to hand out guns at a bank... it's an indication that you're going to need some salt with your popcorn.

MM is a chronic distorter of the truth.
 
If you watched the film "Bowling for Columbine", you should have noticed that it only spends a small amount of time on the events at the high school.

Do you believe that Michael Moore lied when he pointed out that Canadians often leave their doors unlocked?


I've seen it. It wasn't really about the Columbine shootings, it was about the philosophy which sees this sort of thing happening depressingly frequently in the USA.

Sure Michael Moore has an agenda, but he's entertaining, and since I'm not massively opposed to his agenda much of the time, I generally enjoy his work. (I do however take note that when he's dealing with things I know a lot about he is frequently inaccurate, so I factor that into the equation.)

The film was genuinely thoughtprovoking, and the point about Canada particularly so. I've found this (and other) threads to be useful in taking the argument forward from there. There is some truth in the observation that it doesn't seem just to be the guns, because other countries seem to be able to avoid these incidents (or at least the frequency) while still having guns around. It made me realise that in fact there are more guns even here than I'd really thought about, but because the legislation keeps them out of private households, they don't worry me.

It's not entirely that the Merikans are a bunch of gun nuts found nowhere else, either, because gun nuts also exist in Britain (I've met a couple), and presumably everywhere.

I think it's more that there are numerous unreconstructed gun nuts in the USA, and they feed into a vicious circle where they influence the gun legislation, and the lax gun legislation allows them to remain unreconstructed and teach their children to be the same way. This leads to the sort of arms race that sees citizens of a developed first world democracy which should be one of the safest places on the planet being so afraid of their neighbours that they feel impelled to walk around armed to the teeth.

I don't kow how you halt either the vicious circle or the arms race, but it's interesting to try to understand the situation a bit better.

Rolfe.
 
Do you believe that Michael Moore lied when he pointed out that Canadians often leave their doors unlocked?
Such a practice was the norm in the United States until a few decades ago, before the call for stricter gun control and well before laws like Brady.
 
Such a practice was the norm in the United States until a few decades ago, before the call for stricter gun control and well before laws like Brady.
I know plenty of people in the US who don't lock their doors, including my sister who lives in the western burbs.
 
Training exercises, accuracy at various target ranges (my tendency toward head shots puts me at a mild disadvantage), lack of skill at throwing knives (better at axes but really am against throwing except in true emergency).

How many beat me, how many I beat in variable situations, my speed compared to average, my current sight and running speed[re:knife/ax/ spear [yes, I use a special spear/cane/staff made by Randall - have 2 1/2 of them] (not high but sight fine IF glasses worn, good enough to point and fire at target with some accuracy without glasses. Aiming and hitting very good at 20-25 feet (note- that is hitting the aim point - hitting the target in a really annoying location (if it were a person) excellent
I assume you do not mean the actual mathmatics of it - that's too simple, just comparisons of my skill/physical/training level with the average of others
that I have the same data for. (I come out ahead for the most factors 7 out of 10 on gun use at at combat timing and accuracy). For knives, in combat sparring, I come out ahead in 4 of 10 (I'm more leery of blades than bullets - because most gunmen are lousy shots - my favorite story is of a shop keeper and a bad guy trading almost 20 shots with about 4 feet - and no bullets stopping things- between them. Storekeeper scored the only hit (s?) and bad guy ran). My martial arts (non-weapon) are fine and I have needed only the first (non-strike) part of them to avoid damage to two idiots and myself
but I am very unlikely to stop a guman unless he is idiot enough to have the gun in one hand and less than two feet from me. I would try at that range on knifeperson if concerned for continued existance but would more likely get cut (again, from practice sessions). Hope this helps.

Your calculations seem to only factor in your skill and marksmanship. What if your opponent doesn't challenge you to a duel, but instead whips out a weapon that you didn't even know that he had and immediately starts attacking? How is this factored into your odds?
 
I don't really know about guns, but how long does it take to get at one and get the safety off. Is it really likely that it would save a life in the unlikely event that you are in range of someone about to shoot. It just seems like such an unlikely scenario in the first place... and then to be carrying a loaded gun (with or without a safety) or having one near by at all times, just seems like an invitation for disaster. Maybe a taser... but a gun. Especially with teenage boys around (not know for great impulse control.).
 
I don't really know about guns, but how long does it take to get at one and get the safety off. Is it really likely that it would save a life in the unlikely event that you are in range of someone about to shoot. It just seems like such an unlikely scenario in the first place...
Not all that uncommon.
 

"Woman kills beer thief at convenience store

A woman working alone at an Old East Dallas convenience store in 2005 shot and killed a man who walked out without paying for two cases of beer.

As 32-year-old Joshua Coleman walked out the door, Basy Thach grabbed a pistol from beneath the counter and demanded that he stop. When he didn't, she shot him in the back.

Ms. Thach told police that because the man had tattoos, she felt threatened.

Police arrested her on suspicion of murder because Mr. Coleman was unarmed. A Dallas County grand jury declined to indict her."



:jaw-dropp

Seriously, thank freakin' Ed that I don't live in a country where it's OK to shoot shoplifters dead when they are walking away from you. What a disgraceful, barbaric act.
 
Last edited:
Yes... my feelings exactly. Doesn't she have feelings over the fact that she killed a guy because he stole beer? That's what I think is sick. I'd feel sick about myself if I did that. I'd feel sick that the gun was there and that I used it. That gun was bought for protection but destroyed at least one person's life. It didn't save anyone's life. And it illustrates how readily not completely sane people can access guns.

How many people are turning little fears, annoyances, or bad moods into ruined lives because of all these guns around for protection??

I just think it's crazy that people think this illustrates that guns protect people. If that's evidence of what guns are good for; I'll pass and hope my government comes to its senses.

I wonder if the woman was glad the gun was around or if she wishes it wasn't. A while back a Texan shot a repo man and he wasn't convicted, but he ended up killing himself because of the guilt.

No one thinks their gun will harm their life. But it seems far more likely that it will do so than save a life. Sooooo much more likely. I can't think of very many situations where having a loaded gun constantly near by would be a comfort to me.

I'm with my foreign friends on this issue. I see the gun nuts as "rednecky" as you do. They scare me even if they don't scare themselves. They remind me of the incompetents in my sig. I don't want a gun in my own hands... much less in theirs.
 
Last edited:
Seriously, thank freakin' Ed that I don't live in a country where it's OK to shoot shoplifters dead when they are walking away from you. What a disgraceful, barbaric act.
Do you live in a country where people live in fear of robbers and ask:
"There were four guys wearing balaclavas who went in and smashed the place up with hammers. You have to be worried and ask where was the security?"
Where, indeed, is the security once you outlaw the ability to protect private property?
 
Last edited:
If you watched the film "Bowling for Columbine", you should have noticed that it only spends a small amount of time on the events at the high school.

Do you believe that Michael Moore lied when he pointed out that Canadians often leave their doors unlocked?

Moore is hardly a grand arbiter of all truth. He's just as bad as Bill O'Riley, Ann Coulter and Sean Hannity, he's just on a different side of things.

Also, just FYI, I leave my doors unlocked and my keys in the ignition of my car. So do most people I know, in fact.
 
More news from the gun-free paradise of the UK:
With four youths already killed in the capital in 2008 and no sign of a halt to the slaughter by gun, knife, club or machete, highly-experienced cop Norman Brennan told The People: "I have the greatest concerns for law and order in Britain.​

...
Documentary makers quizzed 200 youths aged 11 to 18 on some of London and Glasgow's toughest estates.​

An amazing 84 of them admitted they were or had been caught up in gang life and committed serious violence against others.​


And 112 said they had been victims of serious attacks - 90 percent of which happened in the last 12 months. Teens told of being shot at, stabbed or threatened with knives and hit with blunt objects - but only 17 per cent dared tell the police.

But not to worry, the UK is gun-free! Can't imagine why they're ranked #3 in robbery victims! I guess outlawing self-defense has a price after all, oh well maybe you can overtake Italy and Poland before the decade is out!
​
 
Last edited:
I think I'll trust the bending of facts by Michael more than I will the selective attention of the "gun enthusiasts".
 
I think I'll trust the bending of facts by Michael more than I will the selective attention of the "gun enthusiasts".

Why, because Moore's conclusions agree with your own?

Must be a rather nice life, ignoring everything that runs contrary to your own narrow world views.

More news from the gun-free paradise of the UK:


But not to worry, the UK is gun-free! Can't imagine why they're ranked #3 in robbery victims! I guess outlawing self-defense has a price after all, oh well maybe you can overtake Italy and Poland before the decade is out!
​

Everyone knows crime is only wrong if you use a gun to do it, you crazy gun nutter!
 
Last edited:
No, because the one example you used is pretty terrible. I think most people would feel awful if their gun was used to kill someone because they were stealing beer. And there are so many more horrific possibilities as illustrated in this post and in the news every day.

Do you have a gun so you can kill beer stealers? Doesn't that make you the warped one? Why do you think you are more likely to have your gun used to stop a thief than all the other ways listed in this thread including the OP. Why are gun owners so slow in realizing that the guns they own are statistically more likely to destroy their lives than save them by several magnitudes.

I frankly feel a little nauseated by the story of someone shooting a beer thief in the back--especially since it's supposed to be a "reason" for keeping a loaded gun around. Gun nuts just sound like illogical scary people to me. It reminds me of religion... if prayers fail--it's cause you weren't praying hard enough-- solution: more prayer.

And I know I have neighbors that think just like some of the more redneckish guys on this thrad and own guns... with teenage boys and wives who work in stores and so forth. I think it's frightening. I think if you weren't such gun nuts you'd be sickened along with the rest of us reading it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom