A unique proposal for The Randi

This I would love to see, but it will never happen. It would require no interpretation after the fact, no vague and irrelevant phrasing bent so as to reveal the hidden truths and no backtracking to avoid the harsh reality that he can't do what he claims.

... and it may be too boring for him.
 
In this case, the curious odds made the point, for me.


RW, can you please calculate the "curious odds" that you speak of?

The odds of something happening somewhere at some time are 1:1. You did not say that a Blue Angel jet would crash three weeks after your prediction. You said, basically, that there would be a continent-wide plague. Since you didn't predict the event, what exact odds are you talking about?
 
It's very simple, just make up a load of nonsensicle bollocks, and then weeks later when something happens relate it to the vague rubbish you came up with.

For example, I predict that in the next week a great entity will be toppled by forces unknown.

So next week when one of the following happens, I can claim to be psychic:

1) Someone famous dies in unusual circumstances
2) A building is bombed or collapses
3) A world leader steps down
4) I fall over my wife's shoes in the bedroom again

Whatever, I'll find something to relate it to. If I make five of these vague predicions then one is bound to be workable, and one out of five seems acceptable accuracy for most psychics.

What would be impressive is if the OP could do something "boring", like predict the roll of a die 6 times in a row, out of 6 tries.
 
RW, can you please calculate the "curious odds" that you speak of?

The odds of something happening somewhere at some time are 1:1. You did not say that a Blue Angel jet would crash three weeks after your prediction. You said, basically, that there would be a continent-wide plague. Since you didn't predict the event, what exact odds are you talking about?
Your interpretation of the warning is without foundation, because you haven't read what led up to it, or why I would say such a thing. Manifest destiny is the core theme, and to ignore this, is to miss the point.

It would really take awhile to lay out the entire case, so why not focus on the easier examples that I provided in [Post #5.] I have done some statistical work on these, but you sound anxious to provide us with your analysis of the odds, so please tell me what you think they are. Don't forget, the number 48 repeats for a good reason. ;)
 
RW, can you please calculate the "curious odds" that you speak of?

The odds of something happening somewhere at some time are 1:1. You did not say that a Blue Angel jet would crash three weeks after your prediction. You said, basically, that there would be a continent-wide plague. Since you didn't predict the event, what exact odds are you talking about?
Your interpretation of the warning is without foundation, because you haven't read what led up to it, or why I would say such a thing. Manifest destiny is the core theme, and to ignore this, is to miss the point.

It would really take awhile to lay out the entire case, so why not focus on the easier examples that I provided in [Post #5.] I have done some statistical work on these, but you sound anxious to provide us with your analysis of the odds, so please tell me what you think they are. Don't forget, the number 48 repeats for [good reason.] ;)

"If prophesying the weather doesn't interest you, then maybe football will."​
 
Last edited:
Mr. Witness, if you have a paranormal ability, then demonstrate it. That is all that is required. We neither want nor need all the philosophical/religious nonsense you seem particularly keen to share with us.

Just show us, simply, what you can do.

Thanks.

M.
 
As a trusts and estates lawyer, I frequently start out seminars by telling the people there, "I am not psychic but I can guarantee this: you are going to die." I get some pretty shocked looks to which I always reply, "You didn't know?"
:shocked:

While predicting dice rolls may be boring to you, RW, it would make a lot of people sit up and take notice. I doubt the resulting attention would be boring. Not only would you be able to make a change by donating such parts of the prize that you deem right to any worthy cause of your choice, you would also find yourself in possession of a rapt audience and a good platform from which to convey your message to masses of influential people.
Would not that end justify the rather trivial means?
I agree with your basic argument, but I don't see much difference in calling hurricanes and football games and dice, from a statistical standpoint. It should be the odds that matter, not the method for obtaining them.

What I can do, to establish a better and more observable track record is to begin copying my predictions on this forum in a specific thread. I don't make predictions to show off per se, but rather, when I feel when the time is right. For example, I could have chosen any number of the college bowl games to forecast, and there were [33,] but I picked only one, and it just happened to be the one that contained a [manifest destiny] theme, although I wasn't conscious aware of this at the time that I made the prediction. A ["sooner"] is ... a person who settles on government land before it is legally opened to settlers in order to gain the choice of location.

I guess what I'm saying is, I have to do what I'm led to do, and then you guys can calculate the odds.
I'll never be led to throw dice and guess the outcome.
 
Last edited:
I have done some statistical work on these, but you sound anxious to provide us with your analysis of the odds, so please tell me what you think they are.



I note that you refused to answer my question. I asked you what you thought the odds of the Blue Angels crash were. I've already told you what I thought the odds were: one to one.

If you have the ability to make predictions, fill out the application and do so.
 
:shocked:


I agree with your basic argument, but I don't see much difference in calling hurricanes and football games and dice, from a statistical standpoint. It should be the odds that matter, not the method for obtaining them.


Since you clearly can't see the big picture (if it is you're not just pretending), I'll draw it for you:

We have no evidence of your such claimed hurricane and ball games predictions. Just because you're saying it, it doesn't mean anything to us. I for example predicted the 9/11 attacks. See? No way to prove that just because I said so.

If you film yourself and make some good dice roll predictions and then post it here, all of us would have clear evidence of what you can do.

Two pages and still no evidence of anything, other than gibberish. I'll be reminding you as the numbers go up.
 
I agree with your basic argument, but I don't see much difference in calling hurricanes and football games and dice, from a statistical standpoint. It should be the odds that matter, not the method for obtaining them.

It is both. The odds are obviously important, but the method is just as important. The problem with some methods is that we can't actually get odds from them at all. For example, hurricanes. Predicting the weather is much better than it used to be, but it's still nowhere near accurate enough to put solid odds on a challenge. Football is easier, but it is still not possible to know the exact odds of a certain result, and so that is not really suitable either. Dice are great. We know exactly what the odds are of any throw.

In addition, there is the ease of testing. There are only a few hurricanes every year. Since you'll need to do whatever it is you do more than once, you're likely looking at at least a couple of years for a test to finish. Again, football is easier, but it's still not under your control and, like lottery predictions, will take weeks or months for a test. And again, dice are great. A test would take maybe an hour at most, and you can do it whenever and wherever you like, as many times as you like.

Assuming you can actually predict the future, what is so special about hurricanes and football games? The only difference between them and dice is that they are much more difficult to test. This is a common theme with people claiming powers, they often look for more complex tests because when they try the simlpe ones, they fail. The reason for this is simply that the simple tests are easy to run and so don't tend to fall foul of experimental error and bias as much. If you are being honest about wanting a test, can you come up with a good reason why dice are not acceptable, or are you just going the usual route of refusing to take a test that would actually be objective?
 
Assuming you can actually predict the future, what is so special about hurricanes and football games? The only difference between them and dice is that they are much more difficult to test. This is a common theme with people claiming powers, they often look for more complex tests because when they try the simlpe ones, they fail. The reason for this is simply that the simple tests are easy to run and so don't tend to fall foul of experimental error and bias as much. If you are being honest about wanting a test, can you come up with a good reason why dice are not acceptable, or are you just going the usual route of refusing to take a test that would actually be objective?
Agreed. Claiming that dice rolls are too boring, when it would in fact be the most intruiging, and not answering simple questions without a barrage of total nonsense leads me to the conclusion RW is just another timewaster.

It must have been people like ["Raptor Witness"] who made the ["JREF"] decide to end the challenge in two years.
I think I'd get fed up with listening to this crap day in day out too.
 
RW, welcome to the Forum!

I want to chime in, really just to repeat something everyone else has said:

Your demonstration can't require judgement or interpretation.

Prophesies are BAD CHOICES for the MDC unless you're incredibly specific. A short line of verse with a vague statement in it won't cut it. It has to be something like "At 11:20 am Eastern Standard Time, there will be an earthquake in Boston, MA that registers 6.7 on the Richter scale."

Open-ended prophesies don't cut it. 'Cause if there's no "deadline", so to speak, then the claim is not falsifiable -- you could simply claim that the event you predicted hasn't happened yet.

A review:

o Prophesies can't be subject to interpretation. They have to be cut and dry, yes and no, it happened or it didn't happen
o Prophesies must have an end-date.
o Prophesies must be specific (to satisfy the requirement for /no interpretation needed/).

Do you understand?
 
It has to be something like "At 11:20 am Eastern Standard Time, there will be an earthquake in Boston, MA that registers 6.7 on the Richter scale."


11:20, Boston, 6.7. I imagine it would be sufficient to just correctly predict two out of those three.


Hence, my latest prediction: At some point tomorrow morning, it will be 11:20 a.m. in Boston.
 
Last edited:
Hay. That is a game that two can play.

At 11:20 am Eastern Standard Time (give or take 120 hours), there will be an earthquake that registers 6.7 on the Richter scale
 
RW, welcome to the Forum!

I want to chime in, really just to repeat something everyone else has said:

Your demonstration can't require judgement or interpretation.

Prophesies are BAD CHOICES for the MDC unless you're incredibly specific. A short line of verse with a vague statement in it won't cut it. It has to be something like "At 11:20 am Eastern Standard Time, there will be an earthquake in Boston, MA that registers 6.7 on the Richter scale."

Open-ended prophesies don't cut it. 'Cause if there's no "deadline", so to speak, then the claim is not falsifiable -- you could simply claim that the event you predicted hasn't happened yet.

A review:

o Prophesies can't be subject to interpretation. They have to be cut and dry, yes and no, it happened or it didn't happen
o Prophesies must have an end-date.
o Prophesies must be specific (to satisfy the requirement for /no interpretation needed/).

Do you understand?
In [post #5,] I demonstrated that I could pick two hurricanes, and correctly select the lowest pressure in a region and greatest damage in a geographical area. That's a lot better than Dr. Gray of Colorado State University, who makes the news every time he spits out his broad assertions. Then, after carefully explaining why I picked the numbers 4 and 8 to begin with, and afterwards complaining that no one was paying me any attention, I switched to sports, specifically football. Out of 33 bowl games, I just happened to select the winner and winning score of the Fiesta Bowl, which turned out to be 48.

You know what I think? I think that anything less than the plagues of Egypt, would fall of deaf ears here. Then after the death of the first born, you would still ride out into the desert and drown.

I'm not here to juggle for you, or pull rabbits out of hats. I'm here to win. Not for the money, but because I [can.]
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom