A skeptic tests psychic ability

It is a plastic water bottle. It is not ceramic, not white and is almost devoid of vertical lines.

Please describe the water bottle. Did it have water in it. What ever I sensed felt cool.

I assume the bottle was not a ball. Most bottles have a curvy neck at the top, 2 vertical lines that makeup the bottle wall, and a kind of curved bottom. Does that sound like yours.

What colors are on the bottle. What brand?
 
...cool have been another material that felt cool.

Vertical line felt like a outside edge of the object, like it had a flat or flat like edge.

That fits a water bottle with water in it. Not very good I admit. It is like first shot down the firing range. Just trying to see if I can get in the rings.
 
Sorry guys gotta go. LL, we are looking forward to your post. I will check in later this eve. Bye.
 
Last edited:
Here is a direct quote from the MDC application.



On the surface this seems reasonable, however, their is a clause missing in that statement.

... the results are self-evident to _____ (who)
what does self-evident mean? Yes I know what it means, but if you were in a court of law.

... For example, what if I said it was self-evident to my 3 year old child who was going to decide is that ok? What if I said it was self evident to a extreme religious zealot who thinks all things unexplainable are evil.

Who declares that self-evident is met. What if 20 people in the room feel that self-evident was met, but not JR. What if 100 people feel that it was met but not JR.

Maybe self-evident should be decided by a panel, so that no one person holds all the power. It has to be self-evident to a committee.

That to me is reasonable.

No, but wait .... Lets leave it. When I take the test, I am going to assign my 3 year old to be the self-evident decision maker. That is my plan. The agreement does not say I can't do that, I will put that in my protocol.

You misunderstand entirely. The results must be self-evident, and not judged by anyone. No panels, no committees, no judges. Please look at protocols that have been accepted in the past.

One way to get around the issue you're dealing with is the way they handle readings or astrology profiles (or whatever they're called): the test can be set up so that the psychic gives written readings for a certain number of people (with no opportunity for cold reading or back and forth or anything), and then those subjects attempt to recognize which reading suits them. (With obvious identifying stuff removed, such as names, genders, any reference to unique features that are discernible through ordinary means.)

For the remote receiving thing you're sort of doing now (an exercise in retrofitting), you could do the following:

Several subjects (or the same subject several times) holds an object at a certain time and you write down your "reading". You send the readings to a neutral (and silent) observer. Only after all the readings are done, the identities of the objects are sent from the subject to the neutral observer. That person mixes up the order of objects (perhaps using the roll of a die), then sends the identities on to you. You then attempt to match which reading goes with which object. Your claim is to do significantly better than chance.

Do you understand how this differs from a protocol where you're allowed to make judgments after the fact as to what counts as a hit? Now we know what a hit is--either you matched the reading with the corresponding object (first reading with first object, etc.--we really don't care about the words you used in this format) or you didn't. It is self-evident.

I leave it to people with better statistics knowledge than I have to figure out how many trials is reasonable and how many matches would be required to rule out chance with a given level of confidence.
 
Please describe the water bottle. Did it have water in it. What ever I sensed felt cool.

I assume the bottle was not a ball. Most bottles have a curvy neck at the top, 2 vertical lines that makeup the bottle wall, and a kind of curved bottom. Does that sound like yours.

What colors are on the bottle. What brand?


I find your above post extremely insulting. First, you make a postdiction that the object felt "cool." You did not mention this before I told you what the object was. You said "ceramic," "white" and "vertical line." I asked you specifically and you said that was all that you were getting. You cannot honestly expect anyone to be impressed that you come back after I told you what the object was and add that it felt "cool."

Furthermore, you ask all sorts of additional questions about the object. This is despite the fact that you somehow got "nasal bulb" perfectly. By asking for additional information, you are seeking to increase the pool of data from which you can fish. With "plastic water bottle," you cannot do much. However, if I give you all sorts of additional information, you hope to somehow find something about it that was white or vertical. This is exactly the type of judgment call that makes your experiments worthless and impossible to ever classify as science.

For the record, the watter bottle was Nestle Pure Life exactly the same as [URL="http://www.flickr.com/photos/sirwwoods/1107098000/"]this one[/URL] except for one detail: it had the label torn off. I chose the water bottle specifically because the lack of a label made it very uniform and simple in shape and color.

There is nothing about the bottle that is ceramic.

There is nothing about the bottle that is white.

Although the bottle rises into the air with an average vertical direction, there are no real vertical surfaces on the bottle. It is made up of curved ribs and a rounded top and bottom. In fact, the most striking feature of the bottle is the series of horizontal lines created by the ribs.

And it's not even cool. Although full of water, the bottle has been wedged under my couch for several weeks. It's room temperature. which, in my house, is a blistering seventy-four degrees.

I count zero hits. Other readers are free to interpret the results as they like as the results are already meaningless.
 
Last edited:
That fits a water bottle with water in it. Not very good I admit. It is like first shot down the firing range. Just trying to see if I can get in the rings.

No. It's just retrofitting.

If you allow that as a hit (or even a "near miss") then there is almost nothing that wouldn't be able to be wrenched into fitting and counting as a hit.

That's the inherent problem with this method of testing paranormal abilities.

I know you're only in the calibration stage (or tuning in or whatever). Once you have accomplished that, I encourage you to look at the protocol I just suggested.

One refinement I'd add is that you shouldn't be allowed to hedge your guesses. For example, in a test with just 2 trials, there's a 1:2 probability of you getting them both right by chance alone. That is, you either get them both right or both wrong, unless you're allowed to hedge your guesses by matching both readings to just one object. In that case, you're guaranteed to get one right and one wrong.
 
Last edited:
This is despite the fact that you somehow got "nasal bulb" perfectly.

I don't get the part about that nasal bulb. The only thing I can find in this thread is a post by you where it is mentioned. Was this a PM thingy or am I missing something?
 
I find your above post extremely insulting. First, you make a postdiction that the object felt "cool." You did not mention this before I told you what the object was. You said "ceramic," "white" and "vertical line." I asked you specifically and you said that was all that you were getting. You cannot honestly expect anyone to be impressed that you come back after I told you what the object was and add that it felt "cool."

For the record, he did say "cool" before the identity of the object was revealed. This is the sum of what he said ahead of time:

I had ceramic, white, vertical line
Ceramic felt cool, cool have been another material that felt cool. Wood, leather, plastic would be a miss.

Vertical line felt like a outside edge of the object, like it had a flat or flat like edge. Balls would not work. Coffee cup would be ok.

I agree that it's a complete miss. There's no such thing as almost a miss or a near miss if the goal was to identify the object. He failed to identify the water bottle. (He seems to have identified a ceramic coffee mug, and he mentioned a few of the infinity of materials and objects that it isn't. Odds are pretty good you can do that.)

This whole set-up is wrong though because it is nothing more than a test of his retrofitting skills and pretty much everyone else's patience.

Martinv (and everyone else), can you look at the protocol I suggested above and offer any objections, criticisms or proposals for changing it? (Also, anyone know the necessary stats to work out the numbers?)
 
Last edited:
I don't get the part about that nasal bulb. The only thing I can find in this thread is a post by you where it is mentioned. Was this a PM thingy or am I missing something?

Ditto. Did I miss something?

I took that to be an "open" test--like when the dowsers get to see the water and we ask if there's any reason their abilities won't work here and now.

If he came up with "I picked up the bulb shape, light color -blue or white, and rings/bands" before being told what it was and seeing a picture of it, I'd be impressed (although he still didn't say "a light blue baby's nasal bulb"). But he didn't, right? LL revealed what it was at the same time as asking the question (in the same post where LL told him his location).
 
I agree that it's a complete miss. There's no such thing as almost a miss or a near miss if the goal was to identify the object. He failed to identify the water bottle. (He seems to have identified a ceramic coffee mug, and he mentioned a few of the infinity of materials and objects that it isn't. Odds are pretty good you can do that.)

This whole set-up is wrong though because it is nothing more than a test of his retrofitting skills and pretty much everyone else's patience.

Yep. I think we've just seen a demonstration of how people fool themselves into thinking they have a paranormal ability: Vagueness, retrofitting, excuses beforehand ("It is not about accuracy of test"). This shows why so many people think paranormal abilities are real, without actually being able to demonstrate them.
 
Last edited:
Since you've already decided that psychics exist, I don't exactly see your claim of wanting test for psychic ability to be credible.
If you thought you were a psychic, wouldn't you want to try to find a way to prove it?

...

Anyway, I think that by removing certain shapes, the chance to answer correctly may increase as there are less options.
 
Why not run a series of tests? Pick 10 clearly different objects in advance and then randomly select one of those for each run.

e.g. I have around me now
- screw driver (metal and plastic, empty or full)
- plastic or glass bottle
- paper (single sheets, magazines, newspapers, money notes)
- a crayon (wooden)
- electric iron
- CDs, DVDs
- a rubber stamp (with my address, mostly plastic)
- wii controllers, the remote for my TV, a cordless or mobile phone
- coins (German, either a single coin or a handful of them) or other 'shrapnel' like screws, etc.
- an electric cable (live or dead)
- a can of baked beans (I have a few other options, but not that many right now. and I might want to eat my beans ;))
- eggs
- a pair of socks (or other clothes)
- a bit of salt (or a lot, if i am allowed to keep it in the mill)
- a stone (vulcanic lava or whatever i can pick up outside)

... well, you get the idea. I've tried to list a few items that are very distinct one way or another in size, shape, material, purpose, weight, organic vs unorganic etc.

Many of the items I listed can be arranged with specific colours, too, to distinguish them further.

Even if what the psychic can see is relatively vague it should be possible for them to distinguish the items since they would know the list in advance.
 
Last edited:
I don't get the part about that nasal bulb. The only thing I can find in this thread is a post by you where it is mentioned. Was this a PM thingy or am I missing something?


It was part of the open test that Martinv asked for to "calibrate" his abilities to me:


At 1:46 I will try to tune in and find you. I need you to both tell me a question (with an visible object) and the answer. I want you to hold both those in your mind until 1:48. I will try to see if I can pick you up with that question and answer. I also want you to send me another question without an answer. Hold that question in your mind from 1:50 to 1:53.

I need:
1. your city,state
2. a question
3. answer to #2
4. another question
The question is: What is the object I am holding?
The answer is: A light blue baby's nasal bulb.


I then posted a picture of the nasal bulb. Martinv answered that he had received the nasal bulb well. He wished I hadn't posted a picture because he could have told us that he'd received "light color" and "rings/bands." He said this after I had posted the picture.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the explanation, LL. Seems like JoeTheJuggler and me didn't understand why you would answer your own question within the same post.
 
Last edited:
Well does not look like I missed much.... I find this (from the calibration test with LL) interesting:

We need to fix q2. I will get stuff like soft, tan, person, stuff like that. Maybe movie. That is not going to work for me. Nasal bulb was perfect.
So I gather you can't give definitive answers to things such as LLs question (which would be very clearly right or wrong), just vague answers that would fit most things?

Being a skeptic yourself, you see the flaw here right? Then again, this is perhaps why you believe you have paranormal abilities as with open ended/vague statements you really can't miss much.

Anyway...if you need anything from me, let me know; otherwise I'm gonna be quiet until noon Monday.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the explanation, LL. Seems like JoeTheJuggler and me didn't understand why you would answer your own question within the same post.

To give the psychic a fighting chance of getting it right? :duck:
 
Why not run a series of tests? Pick 10 clearly different objects in advance and then randomly select one of those for each run.

e.g. I have around me now
- screw driver (metal and plastic, empty or full)
- plastic or glass bottle
- paper (single sheets, magazines, newspapers, money notes)
- a crayon (wooden)
- electric iron
- CDs, DVDs
- a rubber stamp (with my address, mostly plastic)
- wii controllers, the remote for my TV, a cordless or mobile phone
- coins (German, either a single coin or a handful of them) or other 'shrapnel' like screws, etc.
- an electric cable (live or dead)
- a can of baked beans (I have a few other options, but not that many right now. and I might want to eat my beans ;))
- eggs
- a pair of socks (or other clothes)
- a bit of salt (or a lot, if i am allowed to keep it in the mill)
- a stone (vulcanic lava or whatever i can pick up outside)

... well, you get the idea. I've tried to list a few items that are very distinct one way or another in size, shape, material, purpose, weight, organic vs unorganic etc.

Many of the items I listed can be arranged with specific colours, too, to distinguish them further.

Even if what the psychic can see is relatively vague it should be possible for them to distinguish the items since they would know the list in advance.
This works for me.

In a way, though, it's the same as mine. He does his vague reading first ("round, light colored, not a Prussian soldier, not an albino rattlesnake"), then has to match that to one of the known objects.

His claim would be to get more correct than would be probable due to chance with some degree of confidence.

What do you think, martinv? Either of these tests with self-evident outcomes appeal to you?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom