madurobob
Philosopher
Wow - 140 posts on a late Friday/Saturday. You guys are dedicated!
Martin - I read through your site and your posts here and had many comments. But they were already well covered in responses in this thread. The meat of the matter as I see it lies in this quote from your site:
That little paragraph is very telling and perfectly illustrated in this thread. When confined to narrow possibilities with clear right or wrong answers you fail. What allows you to feel you succeed - confirmation bias, if you will - is the "richer dataset" of photographs that allows you to offer something vague like "orange" and "curve" and then search the photo for anything that might be orange-ish or have a curve. As has been pointed out here already, any test protocol must have simple, known items that cannot be confused with each other and for which there is but one correct answer. If you cannot do it with Zener cards you cannot do it with anything else.
As an aside, I notice in one of the links form your site that you post of photo of yourself with the caption "cool photo... orbs floating around me". Would you care to offer an explanation of these "orbs"? Are they at all related to your abilities?
As a further aside: I note you are the founder of Everytrust, described here as "a trillion dollar non-profit organization that provides health, education, food, housing, and employment benefits to all 6.6 billion people of the world, with 950 offices in 250 countries". I would love to have an in depth discussion with you regarding everytrust over in the business section. Would that be amenable to you?
Martin - I read through your site and your posts here and had many comments. But they were already well covered in responses in this thread. The meat of the matter as I see it lies in this quote from your site:
ZENER CARDS
Last week we tried to do a little telepathic development work with zener type cards (not true zener but close enough). What we found very interesting in discussion and results that almost everyone was doing very poorly (ie statistical results).
Most people in our group personally said they also had a history of doing poorly with these tests. We decided we want to try with a richer dataset such as photographs, etc.
That little paragraph is very telling and perfectly illustrated in this thread. When confined to narrow possibilities with clear right or wrong answers you fail. What allows you to feel you succeed - confirmation bias, if you will - is the "richer dataset" of photographs that allows you to offer something vague like "orange" and "curve" and then search the photo for anything that might be orange-ish or have a curve. As has been pointed out here already, any test protocol must have simple, known items that cannot be confused with each other and for which there is but one correct answer. If you cannot do it with Zener cards you cannot do it with anything else.
As an aside, I notice in one of the links form your site that you post of photo of yourself with the caption "cool photo... orbs floating around me". Would you care to offer an explanation of these "orbs"? Are they at all related to your abilities?
As a further aside: I note you are the founder of Everytrust, described here as "a trillion dollar non-profit organization that provides health, education, food, housing, and employment benefits to all 6.6 billion people of the world, with 950 offices in 250 countries". I would love to have an in depth discussion with you regarding everytrust over in the business section. Would that be amenable to you?
